Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we decide 'social class'?

133 replies

badspella · 31/12/2021 08:09

I have been reading one or two threads about 'social class', and it reminded me that I am really confused about the whole notion of social classification (the labels we use, rather than stratification itself).

For example, I know a family who are farmers. They own a good few acres of prime land, and live in a large listed house. However, the house is falling to pieces (holes in the roof, rotten floorboards and so on) and the grandfather left school before receiving any formal qualifications. The son (who now farms the land) completed secondary education. All the family speak with a strong regional accent. The farm is worth well over £1 million.

What class are they?

Then, there is one of my friends who has a masters degree and PhD, is a university lecturer. She was brought up in a large detached house, but, she lives in a rented council house.

What class is she?

I must state that I do not spend my time trying to fit people into little boxes, but I do wonder how 'class' is 'decided', especially when contexts are so complex.

OP posts:
Justkeeppedaling · 31/12/2021 11:33

@girlmom21

People don't care about class anymore.

Oh they do! Even if they tell you they don't.

It's as much an approach to life as it is to do with job or income.

Iyf865rny · 31/12/2021 11:29

I live in London and am an academic. I feel that in some ways I should be middle class - parents also academics and have a lovely lovely three bed house in the centre. However, my wages are really low in comparison to all the other professions so I actually have no idea. A secretary could easily earn 60-70k in the city as would a senior lecturer. I would absolutely think of a senior lecturer as middle class - secretary perhaps less so but they would be on a higher wage than me.

I think that in London - class has now been replaced by hard cash, you either have it and can live a reasonably ok life or you dont. And how you've made that cash is not really all that relevant. So say professionals dont exactly look down on me - but they absolutely do laugh at the fact that we used the free 30hrs for our nursery because both my parents and i work in a university (we were absolutely the only couple we knew who were entitled to it). They look down on my husband because he is not on six figure sums despite being male and his three degrees etc.

VladmirsPoutine · 31/12/2021 11:25

I think this is one reason why the UK could never become a republic. Because it's so obsessed with class order that they delight in the existence of the ruling class. Subjugation is a sort of national kink.

Moomoo75 · 31/12/2021 11:20

Gosh this is a depressing topic. Another way for self depreciation. I hate labels.

BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 10:23

I think working class was once defined as receiving a wage, ie weekly pay based on hours worked. The middle class still worked but received a salary, paid monthly and was based on a contract of x hours a week with holiday pay.

It's all well and good rejecting the class system in the UK, but it's part of our culture, however daft it is. The thing to do is not take it to heart or define yourself by it and just see it as a quirk of this country.

badspella · 31/12/2021 10:19

'Where I live, farmers are at the top of the pecking order in terms of wealth. Everything goes through the business. Weddings are nearly always follows by a charity function for that purpose, for example.'

Yes, this was part of the old rural hierarchy. There was the aristocracy (usually the people who lived in the Hall or big house, and who owned the estate that was rented out to tenant farmers). Then there were the landowning farmers, who would employ farm labourers (and members of their own families), after that came the tenant farmers and finally the farm labourers. There was also an itinerant casual workforce.

The trades people and artisans such as the blacksmith (who later became the garage owner), the publican, the carpenter, butcher etc all came somewhere between skilled working and middle class, the doctor was definitely middle class and when teaching became professionalised, teachers also joined the MC. The vicar was usually related to the aristocracy.

It sounds like a system that died out years ago, but it is one I can recall in the small village where I grew up.

OP posts:
TerraNovaTwo · 31/12/2021 10:13

@MintJulia

For me, real class is a mix of good manners, value placed on education, tolerance and the ability to get on with almost anyone.

Some people obviously have a headstart depending on their family history but anyone can achieve it.

Definitely this. The British class system is not what it once was. It's no longer based purely on earnings and profession.
BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 10:13

@Malariahilaria

Read 'Watching the English' by Kate Fox. Very funny and explains it all perfectly. Essentially you're only upper class if you're really upper class, you know if you're working class and mostly proud of it, everyone else is middle class but some people want to be seen as more superior to others and tie themselves in knots buying the 'right' things and saying the 'right words'.

I grew up abroad so was totally confused when I got here at 18. I didn't realise that at first meeting people were asking certain questions to rank me. Now I see who's doing it and who can bugger off quite frankly 😊

Brilliant book! And good summary of class.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 31/12/2021 09:59

@IncompleteSenten

If you don't give a shit about class, you're probably working class.

If you live in a property/estate passed down through the generations and there are titles in some places on the family tree, you're probably upper class.

If you spend time analysing what class you are, all the ways in which class is determined and whether your job or your origins determine your class, you're probably middle class.
Grin

Agree! I don't agonise over it, but I can see there are nuances to it and I'm definitely not upper class. My dad was working class and my mum middle class. We grew up with a decent amount of money as my dad became very successful. However, I'm not and never will be upper class.
BitterTits · 31/12/2021 09:59

Where I live, farmers are at the top of the pecking order in terms of wealth. Everything goes through the business. Weddings are nearly always follows by a charity function for that purpose, for example.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 31/12/2021 09:58

I always think class is mainly determined by how you both (assuming couple) grew up and which side of the family you are closest too. For example I know a woman who grew up upper middle to upper class family and she married a working class man. They live nearer to and do more with the woman's family, so I tend to think of them and their kids as upper middle class. If they'd moved near the working class side of the family, I'd think of them as working class I think.

I don't think it's much to do with income tbh.

ElectraBlue · 31/12/2021 09:55

Who cares!

I am only interested in whether people are decent/interesting/worth spending time or if they are not. Those are the only two 'classes' I use...

IncompleteSenten · 31/12/2021 09:53

If you don't give a shit about class, you're probably working class.

If you live in a property/estate passed down through the generations and there are titles in some places on the family tree, you're probably upper class.

If you spend time analysing what class you are, all the ways in which class is determined and whether your job or your origins determine your class, you're probably middle class.
Grin

Meatshake · 31/12/2021 09:52

It's tribalism, all to do with your own prejudice and labelling and comfort.

You feel X class, you don't like Tracy because she calls you out on your shit so you consider her a Y class and ever so common. Let's maybe not take the kids over because we don't want her rubbing off on them, but she's fun for a night out.

Or you feel Y class and you feel like a shit mum because Laura pushes her kid into coding for clarinet level 4 classes and your kid still misses it's mouth when picking it's nose and eating it. So you have a handy "she's not like us" signifier when she shops at Waitrose and doesn't "get it".

Simple. So class is fluid, and doesn't actually exist except when we want to exclude someone or define ourselves. It mostly talks of our own insecurities of our own upbringings- either a lack of exposure ("chavs are scary!", "Snobs are snobby") or aspirations (working as product of a state school in a privately educated arena).

If it was universably definable there wouldn't be eleventy billion threads on the subject.

DrSbaitso · 31/12/2021 09:51

@badspella

Thank you. There is a really interesting range of opinions, so I am reassured that I am not alone in my confusion.

I think the MN 'obsession' with class may arise because this is an anonymous space.

There are anonymous spaces all over the internet. I've never seen one as utterly obsessed with social class as this one, or so full of self-declared experts.
FinallyHere · 31/12/2021 09:51

What is the purpose of the class system and how do we use it today?

The John Cleese / Ronnie Corbett / Ronnie Barker sketch on The Frost Report summed it up perfectly, as a way to look up and to look down.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 31/12/2021 09:49

Bedrooms

Beadrooms would make the house even bigger i expect

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 31/12/2021 09:49

Have discussed it once but I didn’t start the discussion

Someone was telling me how working class they were, i didnt agree especially as their ultimate reason for being working class was living in a two up two down

It had 4 beadrooms…

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 31/12/2021 09:47

@PodcastFunFair

Traditionally it was based on educational attainment and occupation but its much more layered and complex now. I personally think its quite fluid and decided by other peoples point of view. Depending on who was viewing me I could be very much working class or middle class.
This

I dont care what class someone is or what I am and I certainly don’t ask questions so I can ‘rank’ them but i do find the idea of how ‘fluid’ the definitions are fascinating

badspella · 31/12/2021 09:36

Thank you. There is a really interesting range of opinions, so I am reassured that I am not alone in my confusion.

I think the MN 'obsession' with class may arise because this is an anonymous space.

OP posts:
Countrydiary · 31/12/2021 09:36

I think there are many different ways of looking at it. In an economic sense you could say anyone who has to work for their living rather than off the work of others (ie family money/large landlords) are working class. However we don’t tend to think of it like that, it’s much more about cultural capital, and therefore gets complicated quickly, as the OP indicated.

I think what we think of as middle class is actually upper middle class (private schools, large houses, likes perhaps classical music etc) and is a very small percentage of the population. Only 7% of children go to private schools, and some of them will be upper class. The rest of us are between lower middle class and working class and actually it’s hard to tell as it’s all stereotypes really. Like the idea a working class person can’t like opera or a middle class person can’t like Love Island say, clearly a bit nonsensical.

MaryAndHerNet · 31/12/2021 09:35

There's some grey areas, but broadly if you imagine a company in a tower block.

Right at the top - upper class - The owner
Never comes in, doesn't really know the business, inherited it from her great great uncle, she's a distant cousin of Prince Edward and her family and the royals are connected. Hasn't ever really done any kind of work, handed education, handed businesses, handed houses etc.

Below her on the next floor down are the board members and CEO of the company. These folks went to the same expensive schools as the owner, they don't really understand the nuts and bolts of the business, but they enjoy golfing with the owner and feel like they should be upper class too, but they're not, not really, they're upper middle class...

Then the departmental managers who run the seperate divisions as they're very well educated in the sections they run like solicitors in legal, HR execs and accountants running accounting etc they know what the business as a whole actually does. The middle class, seek to get up the ladder, but often get overlooked as they lack connections as they were educated in state schools and The Universities Of ArseNowhereState or Coventry etc

Then comes the general office workers, receptionists, admin staff, data input, clerks etc The hands on machine workers manufacturing the product the company actually sells are here too, as are the drivers shipping the product, the janitorial staff and maintenance guys, the working class. Sometimes promoted up the tower, but always feel like they're still working class and often vocally champion that fact to anyone that will listen, even after 30 years of working their way up the company...

But....
then there's the people on the outside of the company, the homeless guy in the doorway starving in the cold, the unemployed person that's borrowed money to buy a short to interview for a job there.
The people unable to work there due to circumstances like sickness, disability, caring duties etc. These people are often also called working class. Sometimes they're referred to as the 'under class' channel 5 make programs about how cushy and comfortable life is relying on benefits, foodbanks and living in sink places that they're put. This class seemingly exist for the workers of our company to point at and ridicule but also to live in fear of becoming. Our imaginary company workers see the 'under class' and it's reinforced with poverty porn TV shows that they will end up like "Those people" if they don't tolerate any levels of abuse, pressure and workload. They're laughed at in the company, but feared in private as the wise people of our imagined company know that, should the company faulter and close, they're not too far from 'under class' themselves...

MasterGland · 31/12/2021 09:27

I agree with pp that people should reject the class system, by the way. It helps, therefore, to stand outside it and analyse it. You can reject it by then rejecting the behaviours it perpetuates. I refuse to ask anybody 'what do you do?' when I first meet them. My opening line is "what are you interested in, then?" or similar. I also couldn't give a stuff about what anyone thinks about my car or my name or my clothes. There's a great freedom in it. Human societies have organised by hierarchy for a long time though, so another system would probably rise to replace it, probably the simple American one where only money matters.

ChiefInspectorParker · 31/12/2021 09:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

StopStartStop · 31/12/2021 09:20

School. Employment if needed. Contacts. Housing.
Many people don't understand it. I recall a documentary where sub-culture women were describing themselves, confidently, as 'middle-class'. They had accommodation, so they thought they were 'somewhere in the middle' of society, hence middle class.