Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we decide 'social class'?

133 replies

badspella · 31/12/2021 08:09

I have been reading one or two threads about 'social class', and it reminded me that I am really confused about the whole notion of social classification (the labels we use, rather than stratification itself).

For example, I know a family who are farmers. They own a good few acres of prime land, and live in a large listed house. However, the house is falling to pieces (holes in the roof, rotten floorboards and so on) and the grandfather left school before receiving any formal qualifications. The son (who now farms the land) completed secondary education. All the family speak with a strong regional accent. The farm is worth well over £1 million.

What class are they?

Then, there is one of my friends who has a masters degree and PhD, is a university lecturer. She was brought up in a large detached house, but, she lives in a rented council house.

What class is she?

I must state that I do not spend my time trying to fit people into little boxes, but I do wonder how 'class' is 'decided', especially when contexts are so complex.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RoyalFamilyFan · 01/01/2022 20:49

@PegasusReturns

Actually laughing at the nobody cares comment. MN is notoriously obsessed With class Grin

Key takeaways from every thread are:

  1. The class system and possession of “class” are two entirely different things - although on class obsessed MN there is a tendency to proclaim anyone upper class also has heaps of “class” (so kind to the villagers as they drive around in their battered Volvo wearing patched hands me downs).

This is bullshit. There’s as many aristo arseholes as anyone else.

  1. many MNers claim to be working class “because I work for a living” despite their working involving having a PhD and being educated privately. This is not how class is determined. I assume they think they’re being terribly witty but honestly they sound like pretentious dicks.
Totally agree with this.
CatsArePeople · 01/01/2022 18:44

It's true that migrants to new countries don't park their old prejudices. It does seem amazing to me that you would emigrate somewhere new and experience being looked down on at times or disadvantaged to some degree and then look down on somebody who was perceived to be slightly below you in the pecking order back in your home country!

As a migrant, its really irrelevant what class you were back at home. But with compatriots - context matters. Not British sense of class, its different. A lot of migrants, when they go home for a visit, act like they're lord and lady now, when in truth there is nothing glamourous.

RobertaFirmino · 01/01/2022 14:24

I suspect those who are concerned with 'class' like to believe they are somehow 'a cut above' others and use the word 'aspirational' a lot. A hideous way to live.

ivykaty44 · 01/01/2022 12:06

This is the problem with social mobility, I feel your pain

OldaRailer · 01/01/2022 12:06

Maybe it's birds of a feather or different parts of the UK but ime people really don't care in the way they are meant to.
So everyone I know thinks people like them in outlook are best. Healthy self esteem or , deluded 🤷 take your pick.
Imo a character like Hyacinth Bucket doesn't really make much sense anymore for example. A modern version would be someone on their social media profile living their best life.

PegasusReturns · 01/01/2022 11:59

Actually laughing at the nobody cares comment. MN is notoriously obsessed With class Grin

Key takeaways from every thread are:

  1. The class system and possession of “class” are two entirely different things - although on class obsessed MN there is a tendency to proclaim anyone upper class also has heaps of “class” (so kind to the villagers as they drive around in their battered Volvo wearing patched hands me downs).

This is bullshit. There’s as many aristo arseholes as anyone else.

  1. many MNers claim to be working class “because I work for a living” despite their working involving having a PhD and being educated privately. This is not how class is determined. I assume they think they’re being terribly witty but honestly they sound like pretentious dicks.
PWYP76 · 01/01/2022 11:35

MaryAndHerNet

Great analysis!

Tillsforthrills · 01/01/2022 11:23

If you were so interested and invested into knowing what class someone is, one way people do it is to look at their social circle and whether it includes mostly professionals.

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 10:45

It's true that migrants to new countries don't park their old prejudices. It does seem amazing to me that you would emigrate somewhere new and experience being looked down on at times or disadvantaged to some degree and then look down on somebody who was perceived to be slightly below you in the pecking order back in your home country! So you're on the receiving end of the same shit you're dishing out Confused I have seen it happen though. I work with an Indian girl (born in Delhi) and there is another woman from not too far from where she grew up and my friend is upset that this woman just blanks her. Same woman does not blank me. So it made me think ''what a b1tch''.

coochyboochy · 01/01/2022 08:38

You can be intelligent, eloquent and educated and still be working class and have a strong regional accent. They're not mutually exclusive. You can also be proudly working class (which I am) and have a desire to progress in your career (which I have). I also do not aspire to be middle class and would staunchly reject ever being classified as middle class. It can be deeply ingrained and cultural too. It's definitely how people identify themselves as well as how people judge you.

Malariahilaria · 01/01/2022 08:07

@DillonPanthersTexas

This thread is about the English class system. Nigeria, as every other country, will have its own way of identifying social status and standing, but it isn’t relevant to this thread.

Well other countries class systems (or lack of) have been discussed on here so far so not sure why you feel the need to shut debate down. Anyway, migrants to the UK don't just park their own prejudices at the border, they end up being fed into the general pecking order of the wider community class system.

Totally agree DillonPanthersTexas. Having lived in a few ex colonial territories I can vouch that the English class system is quite infectious. It just has far more grades in England and people are more likely to sniff at you if you don't have a boat in Salcombe whereas in other countries it tends to be more blunt - do you speak well, have money, go to a decent school
OhdearOhdearOhdearIndeed · 31/12/2021 23:19

@Magnited

Working Class - you and your ancestors had to work to live.

Middle Class - you use other people to provide your means of living. You can move down but not up.

Upper Class - your distant ancestors killed other people to amass capital so that neither you nor your more recent ancestors had to work for a living.

The way you describe this makes me glad I'm working class Grin
DillonPanthersTexas · 31/12/2021 18:04

This thread is about the English class system. Nigeria, as every other country, will have its own way of identifying social status and standing, but it isn’t relevant to this thread.

Well other countries class systems (or lack of) have been discussed on here so far so not sure why you feel the need to shut debate down. Anyway, migrants to the UK don't just park their own prejudices at the border, they end up being fed into the general pecking order of the wider community class system.

ComtesseDeSpair · 31/12/2021 17:07

@DillonPanthersTexas

To this end, class is very much a white preoccupation: people of colour know full well that their status and the way they’re perceived by others will always be impeded by their skin colour and cultural background. Class is an inherently racist model of ascribing value and position to people.

Guess you have never lived or worked in Nigeria then.

This thread is about the English class system. Nigeria, as every other country, will have its own way of identifying social status and standing, but it isn’t relevant to this thread.
DillonPanthersTexas · 31/12/2021 16:52

To this end, class is very much a white preoccupation: people of colour know full well that their status and the way they’re perceived by others will always be impeded by their skin colour and cultural background. Class is an inherently racist model of ascribing value and position to people.

Guess you have never lived or worked in Nigeria then.

DillonPanthersTexas · 31/12/2021 16:50

You cannot say The Guardian is “trash”.

While 'trash' maybe a strong description they have sadly fallen in quality over the years. They are still capable of some top notch journalism when they can be bothered but sadly they often come across as student protest rag, and often a hypocritical one at that.

Cam22 · 31/12/2021 16:41

@CatsArePeople

as a non-native, there are so many things that I still don't get. What's the big deal about cheese and olives? They posh? There's plenty in Lidl. And what is this about Guardian vs Daily Mail? They're both trash.
I love your username but you’re not making sense. You cannot say The Guardian is “trash”.
1Micem0use · 31/12/2021 16:34

Your farmer friends are impoverished landed gentry

TheGoogleMum · 31/12/2021 16:30

I thought nowadays working class and middle class was a less relevant to modern Britain. I feel like I'm probably working class as I need to work to live but then whatdoes it take to count as middle class? In the new 7 class system I was an emergent service worker back in those days but I'm a homeowner now so maybe I've gone up!

ComtesseDeSpair · 31/12/2021 16:21

@UserBot99

I could have expressed this better but social capital is the new class system imo and what matters now, class is real in Ireland and does exist, but it's just one aspect of social capital. Which also includes intelligence. Not just qualifications. Intelligence, dynamism, effort, youth, confidence, looks....... If you have all of that, it'd take some snob to close a door in your face.
I think this summary is good and concise, though also neglects to consider the impact of race and culture in class and social standing. I know plenty of people to whom all those adjectives would apply - but doors do regularly close in their faces because they are black and / or not UK born.

To this end, class is very much a white preoccupation: people of colour know full well that their status and the way they’re perceived by others will always be impeded by their skin colour and cultural background. Class is an inherently racist model of ascribing value and position to people.

UserBot99 · 31/12/2021 15:55

I could have expressed this better but social capital is the new class system imo and what matters now, class is real in Ireland and does exist, but it's just one aspect of social capital. Which also includes intelligence. Not just qualifications. Intelligence, dynamism, effort, youth, confidence, looks....... If you have all of that, it'd take some snob to close a door in your face.

UserBot99 · 31/12/2021 15:50

I agree with you @DillonPanthersTexas

I went to a private school in South Dublin which has been mentioned in Ross O'Carroll-Kelly books! and my class mates include a barrister, an author, even an actor. They were all very pleasant to me at the reunion but I'm out of their loop now. Neither my house nor its location would quite cut it. Although a genuine connection would trump this.

Now I'm a single parent with a very ordinary job, and even at work, despite my middle class start in life, piano lessons, Italian exchanges and ballet lessons, I am just a middle-aged single adult feeling a bit low status Jane Austen style, despite knowing that I'm ''middle-class''. I'm not boo-hooing, just observing!

I guess I have no social capital? Without a husband, I fall back down the board? Snakes and ladders style!

Class exists and there is an Establishment that I could have stumbled in to but I never made it in! Perhaps my daughter with her local accent will. Despite the accent I would have loved her to have tried to disguise a little, she got in to a good course at Trinity! So although she went to a state school and has an accent that makes her grandparents pour a bit more gin in to their tonic, she did what I couldn't do.

Class exists here for sure but I think it's like a cross between the UK and the USA here.

Money, youth, confidence, looks, walking the walk, they're all key here.

A nice middle-class accent opens some doors but it also closes some.

But it's not quite like the USA here either because accent still gives away a lot and saying ''I should have went '' will hurt some people's ears.

DillonPanthersTexas · 31/12/2021 15:14

I think in Ireland there is a sort of classification of people but it wouldn't be so much "working", "middle" and "upper", as whether or not some one is "rough" or from a "rough area", and even then, people don't seem to care about it so much so long as the person is sound and not "ignorant" nor behaves in an anti-social way nor is a criminal!

In Irish (although lived in London for a while) and while I kind of agree with the above I still believe there is a subtle class system in place. There might not be an aristocracy but there is most definitely an elite establishment class in Ireland. Have a look at who is in the big private hospitality marquees at the Galway or Leopardstown races. You can bet top dollar that the parents in the D4 Georgian house will still disapprove of their BlackRock and Trinity educated son dating the girl working at SuperValue. That Limerick based solicitor is unlikely to be best mates with the feller who runs the caravan park in Kilkee. Etc.

BlwyddynNewydd2022 · 31/12/2021 14:57

I always thought historically our class was based on your occupation and family more than what you owned till you get to upper class and titled.

Working class
Middle Class
Upper Class and Titled
Royalty.

Working class tend to be manual jobs or low paying.

Middle required a professional qualification or Management/Ownership of a business. Teachers, dentistry.

Upper was lord lady and wealth came from capital assets and not working

Royal explains itself.

Though it's far more fluid in the modern day I suppose which is why it no longer works and the media have just divided us by rich and poor.

coochyboochy · 31/12/2021 14:49

Should say *other areas of England. I can't type today!

Swipe left for the next trending thread