Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bossy woman at work - bullying

82 replies

LibbyVonTrap · 31/12/2021 04:00

I’m a HCA on a hospital ward. Early this year a student nurse joined the ward and she was bossy as hell, ordered all the HCAs and patients around and even tried to boss the qualified nurses around. She continuously wrote incident reports/Datix about people and tried to change various aspects of the way the ward was run. She was a 2nd year. She drove us all mad and one of the other HCAs complained about her in the end to the charge nurse. Charge nurse had a word with her and she promptly reported charge nurse and the HCA to HR. She was an absolute nightmare.
Anyway, her placement finished thankfully and she left. However she has now returned as a HCA!!! She immediately tried to boss everyone around again as soon as she came back and one of the HCAs snapped at her and said “you bossed me around as a student, you’re not bossing me around as a HCA”. Naturally she immediately reported her.

Since then charge nurse has spoken to everyone saying the situation is difficult but we just have to learn to get along with her as she technically isn’t doing anything wrong. One of the male nurses pointed out that she looks like Sid from Ice Age and this has become her nickname. I was bullied as a child and I’m uncomfortable with this. I have spoken to charge nurse who snapped at me and said she’s sick to death of complaints both from and about this woman.
For Christmas one of the nurses bought her a mug with Sid on it. She doesn’t know this is her nickname so she’s proudly using it every day at work and doesn’t appear to have noticed the sniggering etc.

The whole thing is driving me mad!! If I tell her all hell with break loose. If I don’t I feel guilty and on edge.

AIBU to turn a blind eye and tell myself she kind of brought it on herself? It’s making me want to leave my job.

OP posts:
DukkaTheHallsWithBoughsOfHolly · 31/12/2021 07:28

Well the ward should have gone to the university with their complaints, they haven’t helped themselves there.

This is why you have to have a clear pathway in their paperwork if they’re failing (and attitude is part of it), else the university make it very very hard to fail them. Goodness knows they make it impossible enough.

HelloDulling · 31/12/2021 07:28

Put the mug in the bin.

Continue to go to the charge nurse and ask them to confirm if your should be doing XYZ that the HCA is telling you to do. They may be sick of dealing with issues around this HCA, but that is their job.

Perhaps go to HR yourself and tell them the HCA is overstepping and trying to manage you. If you get in first with HR, then if she does go and complain they will already have spoken to you.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/12/2021 07:27

Don't join in with the bullying but don't feel the need to whistleblow it to nightmare woman either.

As for the rest, surely a nurse would answer her 'order' with 'you're not my manager', rather than 'scuttle off' and do as she suggests. Why are people following the 'instructions' of a junior staff member? That is just plain weird.

MichelleScarn · 31/12/2021 07:27

She tells patients that it’s our job to promote their independence not babysit them etc!!
Well the initial part of that's right. Maybe not the delivery! We are meant to promote independence where safe. You must know about 'pyjama paralysis' etc

LibbyVonTrap · 31/12/2021 07:23

@DukkaTheHallsWithBoughsOfHolly

Why when she was on placement did the nurse in charge not go through the university?

What happened to her being a nurse if she’s got a job as an hca?

The student (as she was then) reported the ward to the university as she had concerns regarding practice!! So in a sense she got in there first and I would imagine any report about her after that would have come across as malicious
OP posts:
SilverPeacock · 31/12/2021 07:21

She sounds like an absolute nightmare. But the bullying mug is horrible. And a completely stupid thing to do if it is uncovered. They could get into serious trouble. At least you have raised it OP. But the manager who has failed to deal with it could lose their job. We have recently had something similar in my workplace which has lead to mass suspensions. I would be having a word with them myself and warn them to stop it but I understand that this could be difficult.

MichelleScarn · 31/12/2021 07:18

Some students go on the bank as hcas for some extra money and more experience. Although she may have left the course too!

DukkaTheHallsWithBoughsOfHolly · 31/12/2021 07:14

Why when she was on placement did the nurse in charge not go through the university?

What happened to her being a nurse if she’s got a job as an hca?

LibbyVonTrap · 31/12/2021 07:13

She’s taking a year out for personal reasons apparently

OP posts:
kateluvscats · 31/12/2021 07:09

@MichelleScarn

So none of the behaviour was brought up in her feedback and she was passed by the CN her mentor and offered a job as an hca? Of course she'll think she's done it well. (Or is she related to someone!)
It sounds like she has failed her nurse training if she's returned as a HCA.
RedHelenB · 31/12/2021 07:03

@LibbyVonTrap

The thing is she can be quite nice but she’s just so bloody bossy! I can’t help but feel sorry for her, I’m just so sensitive to bullying I think and I don’t believe she sets out to upset people. We were once chatting at lunch (a few of us) about how some wards can be bitchy and she said “well at the end of the day we don’t come to work to make friends” to which another staff member said “well that’s good in your case then!” And everyone laughed. She laughed along (nervously) too but I could tell she was hurt by that. Her old nickname was matron when she was a student but the staff did actually start calling her that to her face.
Sometimes the truth does hurt. She doesn't seem ro mind upsetting anyone else though so from your post I wouldn't waste your sympathy.
LibbyVonTrap · 31/12/2021 07:03

@meteoric

"we just have to learn to get along with her as she technically isn’t doing anything wrong"

When you say she isn't doing anything technically wrong - is the stuff she's "bossy" over actually her trying to make people do everything by the book, and totally correctly?

Yeah kind of. An example being … lunch time a load of staff members gather around the kitchen waiting to take meals to patients. This woman marched up and told a qualified nurse to go and do her lunch time meds rather than handing out meals. The nurse scuttled off and did as she was told. To be fair to her she was just thinking about making the best use of skill set but it’s not her job to manage staff and it gets people’s backs up.

Another example first thing in a morning she’ll stand at the foot of a bay telling all the HCAs where she wants them etc - some of us have been working here for more than 10 years, we don’t need her ordering us around. She tells patients that it’s our job to promote their independence not babysit them etc!! And she told me off last week for helping a man get washed. She came marching up saying “Percy can manage that on his own!! Can’t you Percy!!” Made me feel bloody stupid (name changed)

OP posts:
AlDanvers · 31/12/2021 07:02

Either she os making loads or complaints that are unfounded or her complaints are being taken seriously.

If its the first, then something can be done.

If its the second, sounds like she is just trying to do her job correctly.

The incident reports? Why hasn't anyone told her she shouldn't be writing them Pointlessly and there's other work to do?

Or is she actually right and they aren't pointless?

This is an issue with your management.

Tiani4 · 31/12/2021 06:58

You can't tell her about the mug . She'll report the whole team to HR regardless of whether everyone was involved. It'd be cruel to let her know. It'll lose its power over time and may settle into a nice nickname people forget where how it arose. Teen boys often have these type nicknames for each other!

As far as she knows she likes her mug and if she overhears, her nickname Sid it's because she uses a Sid mug all the time.

You can go to HR that she's making everyone miserable as she's a bully in how she talks to people, which may decimate the team as people will want to start leaving, but you think it's something she can learn to change if someone in management can talk to her.

To her, I'd reply 'don't bully, speak to me politely and with respect. Do you want to start again?'

Might as well reframe her bossiness for something she will hear.

meteoric · 31/12/2021 06:43

Anyway, it it were me and upsetting me so much, I'd say to the others that I don't like the Sid thing as it feels too much like bullying so please don't, probably bin the mug somewhere and get her a new nondescript one, and then ignore the lot of all.

meteoric · 31/12/2021 06:40

"we just have to learn to get along with her as she technically isn’t doing anything wrong"

When you say she isn't doing anything technically wrong - is the stuff she's "bossy" over actually her trying to make people do everything by the book, and totally correctly?

MichelleScarn · 31/12/2021 06:30

So none of the behaviour was brought up in her feedback and she was passed by the CN her mentor and offered a job as an hca?
Of course she'll think she's done it well. (Or is she related to someone!)

LibbyVonTrap · 31/12/2021 06:21

The thing is she can be quite nice but she’s just so bloody bossy! I can’t help but feel sorry for her, I’m just so sensitive to bullying I think and I don’t believe she sets out to upset people. We were once chatting at lunch (a few of us) about how some wards can be bitchy and she said “well at the end of the day we don’t come to work to make friends” to which another staff member said “well that’s good in your case then!” And everyone laughed. She laughed along (nervously) too but I could tell she was hurt by that. Her old nickname was matron when she was a student but the staff did actually start calling her that to her face.

OP posts:
Mybalconyiscracking · 31/12/2021 06:11

Well, start by “losing” or “breaking” the mug for a start?

PWYP76 · 31/12/2021 06:07

She sounds horrendous but the sid mug is quite identifying, imo. If she saw this thread, she'd hit the roof.

Unrealnotunrealistic · 31/12/2021 05:29

LibbyVonTrapp, I feel for you in this horrible situation but this person will always know better. Than everyone. You have no respect for your boss so apply to other jobs. I’m so sorry this person rocked your work world.

violetbunny · 31/12/2021 05:24

It sounds like a nightmare, but I would just keep well clear of it. If she bosses you personally around, just say "I will not be doing that", or "I do not take instructions from you as I report to X, if you think Y needs doing then please speak to them". Keep it factual and polite. I would just ignore your childish colleagues making fun of her, it's not on but I really would just leave them all to it.

FurryAntiWaxer · 31/12/2021 05:15

Turn a blind eye. Your colleagues are immature but they are building an emotional barricade against her bullying. Sometimes you do what you can to get by.

undertheglassceiling · 31/12/2021 05:10

Oh yeah, but about the mug. That’s really off. She may be a nightmare but it’s really bad for your workmates to have a private joke about her. Nasty, malicious, high school stuff. That being said, I wouldn’t tell her. Stay out of it but don’t join in the backstabbing either.

sjxoxo · 31/12/2021 05:08

If ignore her as much as possible and don’t get dragged in to it. The mug is unprofessional but just ignore it & play no part. If your life becomes unbearable and no one steps in, I’d consider leaving and citing clearly the honest reasons why xx