Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is average commute to work for mothers?

110 replies

user1461609321 · 30/12/2021 19:01

Hi

Just curious about how long most of you would commute to and from work each day if you have primary/ early secondary age school children?

Just curious about the norms particularly in London and whether this has posed any problems for you?

I currently leave home at 7.30 each morning then back at 6.30pm, eldest in secondary from September, youngest will be yr5, just trying to see how to manage commute/ school runs and ensure adequate supervision of kids before and after school

So my questions;

  1. What time are you leaving home in the morning?
  1. Who oversees your kids getting ready for school,
  1. how old are they and do they get to school on their own?
  1. How far is the child's secondary school? How do they get there? How long does it take them?
  1. At the end of the school day? Are kids home alone? What time do you get back?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1461609321 · 31/12/2021 19:26

Hi

We find out school allocations on 1st March so until then not sure of which school it will be, but first 2 options are generally the same journey but 1 stop apart

OP posts:
LawnFever · 31/12/2021 10:18

I think I have PFB syndrome, child never been left home alone or travelled independently so this will be a big transition for us all

It’s ok to recognise this Smile What’s great is you have until Sep to start building up the independence your DC needs, and do some test runs of the journey with them at weekends etc to get them (and you) used to it.

Plus build up some time with them being used to being at home alone, and doing other things alone too like nipping to a shop etc?

I bet some friends will be doing the same journey who they’ll be able travel with too - do you know yet if anyone who lives near you are likely to be going to the same school?

Babdoc · 31/12/2021 10:16

My two are adults now, but I used to leave home at about 8.20, as soon as the nanny arrived, have a 30 minute commute to work, leave work variably between 4 and 6pm (depending on when my operating theatre list finished, or whether I could hand over to an on call colleague), and get home anywhere between 4.30 and 6.30, to relieve the nanny.
As a widowed single parent I didn't have the option of not working - I was sole breadwinner - and as a doctor, I couldn't work from home. So I would still have done it, however long the commute.

Sowhatifiam · 31/12/2021 10:15
  1. What time are you leaving home in the morning? 7:30
  1. Who oversees your kids getting ready for school, me till I leave
  1. how old are they and do they get to school on their own? secondary, one walks, the other two use school bus
  1. How far is the child's secondary school? How do they get there? How long does it take them? college is about a mile and a half, school is just over 3 miles
  1. At the end of the school day? Are kids home alone? What time do you get back? yes, home alone, I get in between 5 and 6
badspella · 31/12/2021 10:07

@jessie75 I can really empathise. The reason I had to give up going out to work was due to school refusal (anxiety related). I was fortunate insomuch as I could work from home. I realise that not everyone has this option. I hope things get better for you.

Jessie75 · 31/12/2021 09:51

@badspella my current dilemma is child taking itself to school 5 days out of 10 knowing it wont go or a £20,000 pay cut or private school next to my office if theyll have them.

Mofomo · 31/12/2021 09:45

I've never like a commute longer than 30 minutes

badspella · 31/12/2021 09:44

@jessie75 I would not say that work is impossible. On reflection, I should have started working from home much sooner than I did, or I should have found something a little more local. I think there is a balance to be struck. The fact that I spent so many hours away from home, had a detrimental effect on my children.

motherofawhirlwind · 31/12/2021 09:14

It's varied alot over the years as I worked interim roles, but I always said that I would be within an hour of home.

Primary School - she went to breakfast club that opened at 7:30am but mostly my OH dropped her off about 8am before continuing into his local job. After school club until about 5:30/5:45pm, or later if I was collecting.

Secondary - 4 miles away. She gets the bus about 7:30am and then we leave just after (OH now works further afield also). Was a council run service but now public. She gets home about 4:45pm and lets herself in. Pre Covid - he's usually home by 6pm and worse case scenario I'll be home at 7pm (I do condensed hours now, so one day a week I take her and collect her). Now we're wfh again and so we're here when she gets home.

Jessie75 · 31/12/2021 09:08

So reading this I have concluded that pretty much working is impossible funny don’t have a darling husband or family to help to support you I mean I knew this because I lived it for years but it was nice to see it written down this kind of confirmation.

GiraffeDancer · 31/12/2021 09:03

Leave home at 7.20 and drop toddler DC at childminder at 7.30, then at work (1 hr commute) by 8.30.
I usually get the older DC (year 1 and year 5) dressed and sort their stuff ready for school, and then DH gives them breakfast and takes them to before school club at 8am.
I finish work at 2pm (work 21 hours a week over 4 days) then get back in time to pick up DC from school, then childminder, and do all the after school care.
Obviously they are not old enough to be home alone yet, and won’t be for a while. When the eldest go to secondary school, it’s a 10 minute walk away and they will probably walk themselves (or walk part way with DH and other child, as it’s along partly the same route as primary school). They will either walk home and have maybe half an hour alone, or else walk to primary school (also 10 mins away) and meet me there.

rifling · 31/12/2021 08:55
  1. Depends on the day - earliest is 7.15
  2. Mostly me but dh on early start days
3/4. All are at secondary school level which makes things so much easier! They all walk or bike. It takes ds17 about 10 minutes by bike and the younger two have a 15 minute walk.
  1. Depends on my timetable but sometimes ds17 is in charge for a few hours.
BiddyPop · 31/12/2021 08:47

Ok, for primary-
7.30
DH or au pair, changed to neighbour we paid for final 2 years.
She walked or cycled with au pair, often walked with DH or got a lift occasionally, neighbour drove as had bad back
She went to after school club in primary until 6th class, when she went home alone after ECAs every afternoon in school (and we had built up to that before bullying issues in the after school had forced our hand - it started in 4th class with her leaving afterschool but walking when I collected her, and I drove, and building up to letting her leave at 5:30 when I was due home at 5:45 from my train so we'd arrive roughly the same time, and had pushed back to her leaving at 5pm before she needed to leave the club permanently - so she was used to the walk, unlocking the door, ringing me to say she was home, safely using the kettle for a drink, getting herself a snack, and getting started on any homework left to do, and she had a phone for the purpose of that walk and the walk that she made with a group In her class (about 8 of them) for the school senior hockey afterschool group to a different local school once a week about a mile the other direction).

She's now secondary, occasionally walks or cycles but as a hockey goalie, has a very (very) large bag of gear as well as sports uniform and books to carry. So usually is driven, it's about 1.5 miles.
(And yes, gear needs to travel as she has club or province training a few nights per week outside of school).

cliffdiver · 31/12/2021 08:42
  1. 7.30am-7.45am, with DC
  1. Me
  1. Y3 and Y5. No, I drop them to breakfast club
  1. Both in Primary, but about a 15/20min walk. Their primary is on the way to the secondary school, so when DD1 moves up, I'll probably drop them both to the primary and DD1 will walk with friends from there. Or I'll drop her to school
  1. No, DH was able to change his working day to facilitate pick up. I'm usually home between 4pm-4.30pm
SmallElephant · 31/12/2021 08:26

He'll be fine OP Smile they grow up a lot after starting secondary.

I grew up in London and was a latchkey kid.

MintJulia · 31/12/2021 08:03

7.30
Me
13. No I drop them at the school bus stop
20 miles so no, they can't get there alone. The bus takes 30 mins
School bus drops off at 5.30 and I collect them from the bus stop.

I wfh 3 days a week, commute into London on the other two, but leave at 3.40 to get back in time, and then make the extra hours up in the evening.

I used to work locally and share school runs with another mum, which worked quite well.

Darbs76 · 31/12/2021 08:01

I commuted an hour when mine were in primary. I got them ready and they went to wrap around care, getting home around 6-6.30pm. Secondary they got the bus. I am grateful now that no childcare needed. I work at home now and generally drive my daughter to school as she goes through a woods, but she gets the bus back (lots of children in woods at same time)

SmallElephant · 31/12/2021 07:58

My three DC are at secondary school. My commute is 35-50 minutes by car (depending on traffic - occasionally longer). We all leave home at 7.45, I drop them at the bus stop and get to work around 8.30.

Evenings vary a little, but typically I leave work at 4pm and drive to school to pick them up at 5pm (it's slightly further from work to school than from work to home). They can get the bus home if they finish at normal time, but if they do an after school club then the timings don't work (it's a public bus not a school bus).

I work 0.7 FTE, which for me means I do four slightly shorter days and have Friday off.

badspella · 31/12/2021 07:47

Before I started working from home ( five years ago), my routine was as follows:

Leave the house between 5.30 and 6 am.

Take a bus, two trains and (regularly but not always) another bus to work. - 2.5 - 3 hour commute.

Work

Return (2.5 - 3 hours commute).

Husband looked after children and it was an enormous strain on him because they had SEN.

The commute would have been 1.5 hours each was (possibly 2) if I could drive.

On the commute, I prepared for work, answered e-mails or studied.

Simonjt · 31/12/2021 06:54

Dad, North London

  1. What time are you leaving home in the morning? 8:15 to walk to school
  1. Who oversees your kids getting ready for school? Me
  1. how old are they and do they get to school on their own? Six, so I walk him most days, sometimes my husband his step dad walks him.
  1. How far is the child's secondary school? How do they get there? How long does it take them? Primary school is a 15 minute walk, his secondary school when the time comes will be a 15 minite walk in the opposite direction.
  1. At the end of the school day? Are kids home alone? What time do you get back? Monday my husband picks him up at 3:30, Tuesday to Thursday he is at after school club until 4pm, on Friday I pick him up at 3:30.
liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 06:44

DH will be home after school, I was more anxious about a newly 11yr old who has never traveled without us going on 2 different trains in London even though for very short journey.

Plenty time to get him used to this. Dd is lucky enough to have a short walk but plenty of her friends have to get busses (although generally only if they are out of catchment - Scotland so most go to their local school as as we are in a city centre the catchment isn't huge). Growing up though I lived quite rurally and had a long journey via public transport to school and round here many of the private school kids often get themselves there via busses from quite a young age. Definitely pre secondary. Does he have friends he can travel with?

liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 06:34

To add primary and high are next to each other about a 10 minute walk. Dd1 used to collect dd2 but the timings for that no longer work so I had to check he my hours. Dd1 walks and is quite capable of coming home and being alone although not needed as I have to collect her sister anyway. Dd2 gets thrown out the car on my way the send breakfast club opens its doors and is usually the last child collected as I desperately find somewhere to park and leg it to the school gate Blush

liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 06:31

I can't leave for work before 8 as that's when breakfast club opens so I'm quite restricted as it's an area with heavy traffic. I work part time so finish at 3 but full time would be tricky as no after school club opens past 5.45 round here and again traffic is likely to be problematic and would limit work to a very small radius.

Dd2 is 8 so I've got a couple more years of restrictions on that yet. Dd1 doesn't need to leave til 8.15 so leaves after us, locks up etc she's been doing this since just before her 11th birthday although we have neighbours with a dc the same age who wfh on hand if there is any problems (there hasn't been and she's 12 now)

noideabutstilltrying · 31/12/2021 06:05

I have two teens. The council recently did away with school bus travel if you didn't use the closest school.

This means that I leave the house at 8. Drop the youngest at 8:20 and the eldest at 8:30 to the 6th form campus.

I would then (pre Covid) go straight onto appointments or drive into the office for 9.

On appointment days the lady who runs my diary ensures that I am back for my son at 3:15 and pick my daughter up at 3:30.

Home at 4 to work on laptop for several hours.

Lone parent and no contact with my parents and in law.

You will find a way to make it all work 🙂

Rosebel · 31/12/2021 00:04

Since secondary school age my children have been responsible for getting themselves up, ready for school and getting themselves to school.
We don't live in London, but still in a large city. Where we are virtually all the kids get themselves to school either bus, bike or walking.
I have changed my hours so I'm at home after school but before that they were home alone for about 1 and a half hours.