Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not a favourite, but my kids are?

38 replies

Jamdown123 · 30/12/2021 17:33

Is my position contradictory AND bad.

So, I was talking to a friend recently, explained this situation and thought it sounded awful as it left my lips.

My grant's favourite grandchild is my cousin. His mother was not great until very recently and he is 45! So my gran raised him, and he views her as his mum in many ways, definitely in his heart. I am not her favourite, but I'm up there. I havent felt the sharp end of being out of favour, but I know my other cousins have / do. Some feel shunned, some are still trying, some can't hide the resentment. The favourite will inherit her entire investment property which has no mortgage, for example. I don't care, others do.

Now, this cousin has no kids. My kids are actually coming in first place for my grabs favourites, and I feel bad about it, but OK at the same time. Knowing how it feels to not be a favourite, should I challenge this in my grandma?

This is not a life or death problem, but is my position of seeing and doing not much, OK? Would I be hurt if the favourite cousin had kids and mine were relegated? I don't know.

Favouritism stinks, I know! Am I part of the problem? Eeek

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KittensTeaAndCake · 30/12/2021 22:55

I think you should raise it too. It is one thing to have favourite grandchildren it is quite another to show it!

AliveAndSleeping · 30/12/2021 21:43

I think you should raise it. At least then you know that you have tried. She might not change though. I'm also not sure if it's favouritism. She seems to favour whoever she spends the most time with and that's kind of natural, isn't it? Apart from her inheritance what does her favouritism look like?

Jamdown123 · 30/12/2021 21:27

Grab is a typo. B is next to n the n a qwerty keyboard. I've already explained away any idea of grabbiness. Anyone still on that path wants to be!

Thanks for some time of the posts, I am encouraged to raise it with my gran.

OP posts:
DroopyClematis · 30/12/2021 21:19

I'm also a bit confused about ranking children and grandchildren.
You say that it doesn't bother you but the fact that you've raised the issue here and have suggested challenging your gran/grab , WHO's 85! Suggests that it does bother you.

BobMortimersPetOwl · 30/12/2021 21:12

I'm not really clear on what your question is.

But it's really weird to have a ranking of family members.

Jamdown123 · 30/12/2021 20:31

I give her money because I love her and she's helped me so much. No other reason. If I stopped it would probably make little difference to her. But she's my gran, I love to contribute. She knows, so she accepts, though every so often she insists I stop.

I probably should have put this in relatiinshios. I didn't because I was mostly concerned about being complicit. I might do that now.

OP posts:
Starcup · 30/12/2021 20:22

To add, it happened to my family and it’s torn it apart pretty much.

OzziePopPop · 30/12/2021 20:22

You said you give her money each month, why do you do that if she has a ‘mortgage free investment property portfolio’? It doesn’t sound like she needs money? If the property is willed to your cousin then surely you’re essentially giving him the money? I’d be stopping!

Starcup · 30/12/2021 20:21

I’ll never understand why people don’t make things equal upon their death because money causes more family rows and divisions that almost anything else, other than infidelity.

Leaving one child/grandchild… whatever, an entire estate and leaving the others nothing is a really shitty thing to do because it will likely cause all sorts of tensions between relationships.

It would be better if they left it to a charity or burnt it than done something that they know will cause resentment.

It’s a shitty thing to do and will never end well most of the time

3mealsaday · 30/12/2021 20:15

@Jamdown123

My cousin is the favourite. She cooks for him every Saturday. He lives near her. He's a 45 year old man and is often chilling with her. She calls him daily, always talking about him.

She calls my kids most, definitely, but then I bring them round a lot, I'm the eldest grand daughter so I find myself doing errands, cleaning, managing her property stuff! But it means my kids see her a lot, often ask to call her etc. She remembers each birthday, they get really lovely presents. It's clear.

OK, I'm putting kids to bed. I can see that I'm not being very well I derstiid, my fault. It is tricky to explain family and culture on these boards sometimes, I think I've failed not a little!!

I think I'm going to talk to my gran. I do not think it'll do much though!!!

It sounds like their relationship is more akin to a parent-child relationship. Your gran isn't going to have the same relationship with grandchildren she didn't have to effectively parent. I don't know why you think this is 'favouring' him. He didn't ask to have shit parents.
Puffalicious · 30/12/2021 20:10

Where did 200% Come from?Blush

Puffalicious · 30/12/2021 20:09

@Notimeforaname

How do you officially find out you're ''The Favourite '' or a ''close favourite'' ??? Is ther a ceremony? A star chart or what?? This doesn't sound real.

Can the 'chosen one' change weekly or can you lock down your No.1 position for a longer period of time ?
I must know the rules.

This 200% GrinGrinGrin
Jamdown123 · 30/12/2021 20:02

Is it so weird to have a culture of favourites in both sides of the family?

I really didn't think so. Maybe it is. The friend I spoke to had the same. She was her dad's clear favourite, but by word not her mums. We spoke about it at length.

I come from a close knit working class family who all live in same or neighboring towns. We're in each others lives and do a lot of talking, for sure!!

OP posts:
Jamdown123 · 30/12/2021 19:57

My cousin is the favourite. She cooks for him every Saturday. He lives near her. He's a 45 year old man and is often chilling with her. She calls him daily, always talking about him.

She calls my kids most, definitely, but then I bring them round a lot, I'm the eldest grand daughter so I find myself doing errands, cleaning, managing her property stuff! But it means my kids see her a lot, often ask to call her etc. She remembers each birthday, they get really lovely presents. It's clear.

OK, I'm putting kids to bed. I can see that I'm not being very well I derstiid, my fault. It is tricky to explain family and culture on these boards sometimes, I think I've failed not a little!!

I think I'm going to talk to my gran. I do not think it'll do much though!!!

OP posts:
Notimeforaname · 30/12/2021 19:56

Both of my parents are not favourites

My kids are absolutely not the favourite on their
dad's side

I am not her favourite, but I'm up there

My kids are actually coming in first place for my grabs favourites

My point is I'm not the favourite of my generation

It's all so bizarre??!Confused

UsernameInTheTown · 30/12/2021 19:55

My DF favours my DSis's DOG over mine. Really pisses me off. Thankfully I am the only one with a DC so she is default favorite and I've inherited early.

Notimeforaname · 30/12/2021 19:52

I dont understand..how every person ,in every generation in your family is talking about 'the favourite ' it's like a weird plot to an awful film

Notimeforaname · 30/12/2021 19:50

How do you officially find out you're ''The Favourite '' or a ''close favourite'' ???
Is ther a ceremony? A star chart or what?? This doesn't sound real.

Can the 'chosen one' change weekly or can you lock down your No.1 position for a longer period of time ?
I must know the rules.

Jamdown123 · 30/12/2021 19:45

Yes to some recent posts.

Both of my parents are not favourites, they felt it keenly and made it very clear to us, their children, that they love and care for us all equally. I'm raising my children that way.

I'm not really concerned about my adult cousins, no. They're adults. I do feel really bad for the little ones who aren't favourites on my maternal side. I feel bad for my own kids on their paternal side.

OP posts:
Jamdown123 · 30/12/2021 19:41

Part that I missed out which has just come to me. My kids are absolutely not the favourite on their dad's side. I HATE it. I truly do. They're too young to notice now, and I dread the day that it might become apparent to them.

I wish someone would challenge it on that side. So that's part of my conundrum. Sure its working out for us here, but not there, and in reality I wish it wasn't the case anywhere.

Maybe I'm the only one with this messed up family dynamics!

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 30/12/2021 19:40

Favouritism is damaging to both the favourites and the disfavoured. A positive relationship between your dc and their cousins is far more important than a relationship with a woman who is willing to be so cruel towards children.

When people have favourites, there is always a chance that they will change who is favoured at any time. You cannot trust this woman to act in your dc's best interests if you see she is willing to damage other dc in the family.

Personally I wouldn't be encouraging contact at all.

APerfectSky · 30/12/2021 19:40

Hmm, from the way you've worded it, it seems like you're happy with the status quo because it favours your kids, but deep down you're concerned that this may change in the future, so your "worry" only seems to come from a place of ensuring your kids remain favourites. Because "you feel bad, but you're also ok with it".

I wonder how you would feel if your kids were in the "relegated" camp. Differently I suspect.

Jamdown123 · 30/12/2021 19:37

Thanks. I think I should add context. In my culture people like to talk about their death, funeral plans, what they're leaving to whom. I really DON'T care but my gran trusts me and is forever going over her morbid plans with me! I'm doing OK financially, in no small part because of her loving support, and I've told my gran whatever she wants to leave to me please make it fair because I don't want the hassle and please consider leaving my portion to my kids. I'm not grabby at all, I'm fact I give my gran regular money every month and I send money back to more distant cousins abroad. I mentioned inheritance to emphasise my cousin is the favourite. If you're thinking about that part you're missing the point which is lost in cultural translation.

My point is I'm not the favourite of my generation. It doesn't bother me, it does bother some of my cousins, some VERY much. Now I see that my gran favours my children and I've largely been OK with it. I'm wondering do I challenge it? She's 85! It does make me feel awkward. I wonder how it will impact my kids' relationships with their cousins?

My gran can be a difficult woman! She talks about it reciprocally - she favours those who share their time and effort with her. I'm not sure it's so clear cut a case of chicken and egg!

Its really not a big deal, but when I explained it to my friend recently, it sounded awful!!

I just wondered about it and whether I'm part of a generational problem that I should be trying to stamp out!!!

OP posts:
greatape · 30/12/2021 19:29

My dh was far and away his grans favourite out of her 8 grandkids. He was the eldest and the quietest (and arguably the brightest) so my pil would send him over there to focus on the others and effectively he viewed his gran as more supportive than his parents - he's benignly distant from them now and our dcs have no real relationship with them.

My dad very much and obviously preferred one of my dds to the other and alienated my dh and my other dd quite a bit. He died when they were 10 and sadly the non favourite dd had blossomed a lot in confidence at her school work because she'd always felt second best. My dad did love second dd and me and my mum constantly raised it with him and he'd try to correct it but him and Dd1 had a super close bond. Sadly to the detriment of Dd2.

So do raise it, don't ignore it. It's damaging.

5keletor · 30/12/2021 19:27

If you don't care, forget about it, let her have her favourites, why does it matter?
No one is entitled to her investment property, she can give it to one person if she wishes, she could even leave it to charity - those who feel they're missing out on it through not being favourite sound awful and grabby.

Swipe left for the next trending thread