Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you if our dentist can strike off husband from their nhs patient list without telling us?

121 replies

Teefteefteef · 30/12/2021 17:10

So posting here for traffic:
Husband lost half of a filled tooth last night. The tooth is more filling than actual tooth. It looks very much like it needs to either be removed or crowned. Not in pain yet but only half the tooth is remaining. He called our nhs dentist to book an appointment. Was told that seeing as he hasn’t had an appointment over the last 3 years that they now consider him a new patient and he would have to pay full private fees because, (surprise surprise,) they aren’t taking on nhs patients at the moment. Does anybody know if there is a code of conduct I can reference? To see if they are actually allowed to just strike people off? We think this may be a bit unfair seeing as they weren’t actually seeing anything other than emergency patients the majority of the time for the first huge chunk of covid. Any insight would be very helpful.

OP posts:
LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 20:36

@AnotherMansCause

This happened to us too. They had always sent us letters to say "your next checkup is due, please phone to make an appointment". Then they stopped sending them but didn't bother telling any of the NHS patients they were changing their booking system. When I phoned up to make appointments for us it turned out we'd gone overdue as they'd cancelled our appointments due to the pandemic, I'd been trying for months to rebook but we were now no longer on their books. I looked on their website & there were a lot of complaints from people in a similar position. They did try to get us to re-register as private patients but I told them that we were only with them as they were NHS, & why would we travel an hour each way by bus to them to spend a fortune on private dentistry when we could walk to a dentist in our home town. The receptionist got quite unpleasant with me & said I should have realised we'd gone overdue & it was irrelevant that they'd changed their booking procedure without giving notice... I'm afraid I wasn't very polite. I don't usually swear. It's costing us over £45 a month now for insurance that covers checkups & hygienist work only, no fillings etc but it's with a local dentist, not those scam artists that didn't even do a good job with DH's teeth anyway. Majority of the cost is for DH's cover.

It took us about a year to get registered with a new dentist as they were all closed, DH lost 2 teeth due to poor dental hygiene & a fall in the meantime. The very first things I bought at the start of the pandemic were oil of cloves, cocodamol, & an emergency filling kit from Boots.

That's bloody dreadful. Flowers
RightOnTheEdge · 30/12/2021 20:31

My dentist sent all their NHS patients letters last year informing us all that they no longer do NHS not even for children so everyone who wanted to stay had to pay for private treatment.
Most people had been with them for years.
We live in a small market town so now half the town have been trying to find a new dentist in the surrounding areas and we are all being told that there is either a waiting list of more than a thousand or they aren't taking on new clients.
I am so worried about it especially for my children because there is no way I can afford to pay private fees. We had been going since they were babies and all we got was Sorry, thanks for your years of loyalty Hmm

So I think YABU because your dh was lucky to have an NHS dentist and should have been going for his check ups.

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 20:28

[quote TeacupDrama]@LittleRoundRobin no that is not correct and has't been ever
the NHS have a set fee for crowns a band 3 treatment in England the patient pays the band 3 fee and the NHS pays an extra percentage but it is still band 3 The NHS have a standard set of fees with fixed patient contributions
a private crown is not the same price without NHS contribution the private crown fee will be what the dentist decides a private dentist will have a fee scale but it won't be the same as dentist down the road, the fee list will vary depending on type of crown whether it has a post whether it is ceramic composite or gold it will be more than NHS by some way as often use better colours more translucent porcelain with more shading etc though the accuracy of fit should be no different

the system is different in Scotland where different tyopes of crown have different fees on NHS and pt pays 80% unless exempt up to a maximum so in England it is a band 3 payment whether you have 1 crown or 3, in Scotland it would be a fee for each crown[/quote]
@TeacupDrama

I must be getting tired, because I can't make head nor tail of that post. ^ Confused

AnotherMansCause · 30/12/2021 20:25

This happened to us too. They had always sent us letters to say "your next checkup is due, please phone to make an appointment". Then they stopped sending them but didn't bother telling any of the NHS patients they were changing their booking system. When I phoned up to make appointments for us it turned out we'd gone overdue as they'd cancelled our appointments due to the pandemic, I'd been trying for months to rebook but we were now no longer on their books. I looked on their website & there were a lot of complaints from people in a similar position. They did try to get us to re-register as private patients but I told them that we were only with them as they were NHS, & why would we travel an hour each way by bus to them to spend a fortune on private dentistry when we could walk to a dentist in our home town. The receptionist got quite unpleasant with me & said I should have realised we'd gone overdue & it was irrelevant that they'd changed their booking procedure without giving notice... I'm afraid I wasn't very polite. I don't usually swear. It's costing us over £45 a month now for insurance that covers checkups & hygienist work only, no fillings etc but it's with a local dentist, not those scam artists that didn't even do a good job with DH's teeth anyway. Majority of the cost is for DH's cover.

It took us about a year to get registered with a new dentist as they were all closed, DH lost 2 teeth due to poor dental hygiene & a fall in the meantime. The very first things I bought at the start of the pandemic were oil of cloves, cocodamol, & an emergency filling kit from Boots.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 30/12/2021 20:21

@TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross

Yes, they can - our dental practice is very clear on that: if we don’t make regular appointments for check-ups, we lose our place on their books. Not surprising - why should they keep you on as patients if you’re not using them?
That's ok if you can use them! I was due a check up at the start of lockdown in March 2020 which obviously didn't happen. Despite being able to open from June 2020 they remained closed for two more months while they decorated the surgery. I phoned when they finally reopened in August and they refused to make me an appointment as I had to wait to be contacted and not to call them again unless I had a problem. Guess what, I never heard from them.

I found a new dentist who is actually far better but it's annoying that they can pretty much do what they like. I can't help thinking if I'd asked to see them as a private patient they would have seen me but I wouldn't do it on principle.

Whitewolf2 · 30/12/2021 20:10

Exactly the same thing happened to us, my husband hadn’t been in 3 years, called up to make an appointment and was told he’d been struck off. Neither of us had any idea this was a ‘thing’ and felt really annoyed the dentist hadn’t informed us as of course then we would have gone more regularly, but now from this thread it seems like this is common knowledge that somehow we’d just never heard of!

donquixotedelamancha · 30/12/2021 20:02

Yes they can BUT the last two years have not been normal times and many dentists have not been offering check ups.

Actually, for much of that time they have mostly/only been doing check ups. It's drilling that creates the risk and requires massive extra precautions.

I do agree with WonderfulYou though, that they really should have cut people some slack with us having covid. Maybe give people an extra year.

It's nothing to do with Covid, the DH hasn't been in touch for 3+ years.

NHS dentists have a contract which requires them to do preventative dental care- there simply aren't enough slots for surgery to keep people on their books who don't have check-ups.

ImFree2doasiwant · 30/12/2021 20:00

Our dentist cancelled DS1s appointment and told me they would send another one. They didn't, I called them, and was told he was off their books as he'd missed his last appointment. He was 2.

godmum56 · 30/12/2021 19:59

@LittleRoundRobin

I don't understand the comments people are making about dentists booting people off so they can get private. They make the same money whether the patient is NHS or private don't they? As the NHS patients have a portion of their costs paid (by the NHS.) So if they did 2 crowns (for example,) that cost £1200 for the two, the NHS patient would pay the tier 3 amount (£282,) and the NHS would fork out the rest for the dentist.

Happy to be corrected. But I am pretty sure this is what happens.

Many private dental fees - especially for crowns/bridges/dentures/veneers can run into the low 4 figures. I don't understand why people don't keep up their dental checks. You need a tooth crowned - max £282 NHS, as much as £700-£800 privately. Sometimes more.

My dentist who retired recently stopped taking new NHS patients but kept on his existing ones quite a few years ago now. He said that dealing with NHS bureaucracy was driving him crazy and he had to chase to get paid every single time. He said that the amount that he could be paid by the NHS was capped which meant he had to dial his treatment back to what the NHS would cover and not what might be best for the patient. He said that it wasn't the thing about being able to fit more private patients into treament time but about having to do much less admin for the private patients.
TeacupDrama · 30/12/2021 19:56

@LittleRoundRobin no that is not correct and has't been ever
the NHS have a set fee for crowns a band 3 treatment in England the patient pays the band 3 fee and the NHS pays an extra percentage but it is still band 3 The NHS have a standard set of fees with fixed patient contributions
a private crown is not the same price without NHS contribution the private crown fee will be what the dentist decides a private dentist will have a fee scale but it won't be the same as dentist down the road, the fee list will vary depending on type of crown whether it has a post whether it is ceramic composite or gold it will be more than NHS by some way as often use better colours more translucent porcelain with more shading etc though the accuracy of fit should be no different

the system is different in Scotland where different tyopes of crown have different fees on NHS and pt pays 80% unless exempt up to a maximum so in England it is a band 3 payment whether you have 1 crown or 3, in Scotland it would be a fee for each crown

anon12345678901 · 30/12/2021 19:54

Yeah they do, it happened to my friend and she had to go to my private dentist in the end. I've been private for years now as my dentist changed from NHS to private when they opened their own surgery so I followed them. I did tell my friend if she found an NHS dentist to make sure she sees them even if there's nothing wrong, to keep her on the books.

Thatswhathappens · 30/12/2021 19:53

The same thing happened to me and all I can say is good luck finding a new dentist! I called in excess of 50 and couldn’t find one accepting nhs patients, I called nhs England who told me they had a duty to find me a dentist but could be anywhere in the country! My dentist is now 57 miles away 🤷‍♀️

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 19:50

@Riapia

I book my next appointment when paying for my check up. My dentist receptionist rings the day before my appointment to remind me.
Same here. That's why I can't fathom really how people can go/have gone 3 years.
LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 19:49

@DahliaMacNamara

My dentist has only been seeing emergency patients for most of the time during Covid, and even now their website says that routine examination appointments are 'limited'. I'm not even sure what that means. DH has been seen recently for emergency treatment, which was probably more extensive than it would have been had he been able to have the usual check-ups in the interim. Our last actual check-ups were just before the first lockdown, but subsequent ones were cancelled. I'd be mightily pissed off to be removed from their NHS list just because they couldn't see me.
I wouldn't have thought they would tbh. Not if you're making the effort, and they are saying that they are limiting appointments.

I am with an NHS dentist, and had to have 2 crowns in August/September, one new one (as an old filling broken away,) and one replacement one. Would have cost some £1100 - £1300, but cost £282. As I said, the private fees are limitless. There is no 'cap' and you could end up paying thousands.

I would still touch base with your dentist @DahliaMacNamara to double check when your next appointment is, and to make sure you're not de-registered! Shock

Newmummyinlockdown · 30/12/2021 19:45

Yes. Why would they keep your husband registered under the NHS scheme when he is not using the NHS service as it is designed? It removes the opportunity for someone who wants to look after their oral health, with regular check ups, to utilise the service appropriately.

Riapia · 30/12/2021 19:42

I book my next appointment when paying for my check up.
My dentist receptionist rings the day before my appointment to remind me.

sageandbasil · 30/12/2021 19:38

This is standard practice in NHS practices. They need to strike people off to allow for new patients

Fretfulmum · 30/12/2021 19:37

There is no patient registration for NHS dental patients since 2006. It’s not like your GP, where you are registered at a practice. A NHS dental practice doesn’t “register” anyone so they have no obligation to see a patient unless they are currently in the middle of a course of dental treatment with them.

DahliaMacNamara · 30/12/2021 19:36

My dentist has only been seeing emergency patients for most of the time during Covid, and even now their website says that routine examination appointments are 'limited'. I'm not even sure what that means. DH has been seen recently for emergency treatment, which was probably more extensive than it would have been had he been able to have the usual check-ups in the interim. Our last actual check-ups were just before the first lockdown, but subsequent ones were cancelled. I'd be mightily pissed off to be removed from their NHS list just because they couldn't see me.

LittleroundRobin · 30/12/2021 19:30

@Looneytune253

What?!? This is crazy. I had regular appointments with my dentist but it's probably been close to 3 years now thru Covid etc and would be disappointed if I was struck off
I would ring them tomorrow, the chances are high that you have been struck off. I hope not, but I expect you have. Covid has been around for 1 year and 10 months, and most dentists have been open for more than half of that time. You can't use that as an excuse. They definitely won't buy it.

I do agree with @WonderfulYou though, that they really should have cut people some slack with us having covid. Maybe give people an extra year. Of course, with my friend's sister, the OP's DH, and @Looneytune253 who I just quoted, they would still be booted off, as they have hit 3 years, and my friend's sister and the OP's DH are only contacting them because they NEED them now.

I still feel for them though, because as I said, some dental fees are hella expensive. I wouldn't wish being booted off the NHS dental practice on anyone. It's very upsetting, because everyone knows that the fees are limitless. Sad Like vet bills. (Not having a go a dentists OR vets by the way, I am just saying... ) Smile

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 19:29

I don't understand the comments people are making about dentists booting people off so they can get private. They make the same money whether the patient is NHS or private don't they? As the NHS patients have a portion of their costs paid (by the NHS.) So if they did 2 crowns (for example,) that cost £1200 for the two, the NHS patient would pay the tier 3 amount (£282,) and the NHS would fork out the rest for the dentist.

Happy to be corrected. But I am pretty sure this is what happens.

Many private dental fees - especially for crowns/bridges/dentures/veneers can run into the low 4 figures. I don't understand why people don't keep up their dental checks. You need a tooth crowned - max £282 NHS, as much as £700-£800 privately. Sometimes more.

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 19:29

@Teefteefteef I do sympathise massively, and this exact same thing has just happened to my friend's sister who is 30. She had a filling come out too (on Christmas Eve, typical!) and when she rang her regular NHS dentist on 28th December, she was told she had been struck off the list. She was really upset.

She complained 'yeah but Covid' and so on, but like your husband, she had not been for 3 years. (Last time Nov 2018!) Covid didn't start til March 2020, so that's not a great excuse really... She was meant to have gone for a check up in May 2019, (6 months after her last one,) and cancelled it because she couldn't be arsed to go, and didn't need to.

The dentist was closed because of covid from March 2020, but reopened in late July 2020 until November 2020. So she had a full 5 months to rebook her check up. But she didn't.

They said they wrote to her, (May 2021,) and gave her 3 weeks to contact them, or they would de-register her. But she moved house in October 2019, and never gave the dentist her forwarding address, so it's not really their fault.

She complained that they could have rung her, as she has had the same mobile phone number since 2015. But as has been said, they are a business, and will drop non-attending/poor-attending patients for regular ones, at the drop of a hat. So, whilst it is shit for this to happen, this young woman, and your husband, need to take responsibility themselves for being dropped.

It is common courtesy to let someone know they are about to be struck off, but as other posters have said, they don't have to. It's not law. It sucks that this happens, as you wouldn't be struck off the GP list for not attending for 3 years, nor would it happen at the opticians, but everyone knows what dentists are like, they are really stringent, and you do have to keep up the visits.

Hope he manages to get re-registered with another NHS dentist @Teefteefteef but I doubt he will anytime soon.

Good news though, this young woman I know has an appointment at a private dentist on 7th January, and it's only just over 50% more than the NHS. So the NHS price would be £65 for the treatment, and new private dentist is £103. The only time there would be an issue/huge costs would be if she needed crowns, or bridges.

phlebasconsidered · 30/12/2021 19:29

Mine removed me because I hadn't been for a year. Despite my trying to get appointments through all the lockdowns. Makes them hit their targets for registering nhs patients.

I haven't been able to find another dentist in 50 miles. It's a scandal.

Anjo2011 · 30/12/2021 19:21

Yes, if you haven’t been for two years you will be removed and next person in the waiting list ( if they have one) will be offered a place. The best way to keep a place is to go regularly and book the next appointment as you go.

WonderfulYou · 30/12/2021 19:17

Yes this is normal, although due to covid I would have thought they would have disregarded the past two years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread