Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL gone to panto when waiting for PCR result - oh yes she did!

533 replies

anotherannoyngSIL · 30/12/2021 14:47

Name changed as I’ve been slated on here before for not allowing my SIL to do as she pleases.

Today I thought we’d made a positive turn as she has taken my older son and hers to the pantomime as I’ve got a broken leg (though she has made a big thing about helping out).

Unfortunately she’s just text me to say “BTW I’ve had a positive lateral and waiting on my PCR but decided to take the boys anyway as xxx (her son) was looking forward to it, I’m sure that’s fine”.

In which universe is that fine?? She’s risking not just my son, but the others she’s gone with and the whole audience!! She is very jealous if people do social things without her but surely there comes a time when sense is more important than FOMO?? I’m assuming she waited till she was there to tell me so I couldn’t do anything.

Husband says I’m being unreasonable for being annoyed as the rules aren’t clear cut and she hasn’t had the PCR test back.

AIBU for wanting to ban her as she’s so irresponsible and only really cares about herself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Covidworries · 31/12/2021 00:34

@gaolbhoalba

Can i just point out that CEV under 12 have had no vaccinations yet. Zilch, nadda, not one

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 00:32

@BonnesVacances

Perhaps, but being in an enclosed space will also raise the odds of catching it, even if only asymptomatic people attend.

I know it's the law to isolate. I agree with following the law.

BUT I don't think it should be law now. There's enough evidence in the UK and South Africa (where Omicron has been dominant for longest) to prove that Omicron is much milder and much less likely to result in severe illness.

All those nurses/docs having to isolate and non-urgent operations and appointments being cancelled and delayed. It's inexcusable now, there is simply no clinical reasonings to evidence the benefits of isolating outweigh the cons - to OTHERS as well as ourselves.

And kids missing schooling still. For what? Cold symptoms?

It's unsustainable and unfair. Covid has changed, our response to it needs to change now too.

humdingle · 31/12/2021 00:32

@Covidworries

I suggest you start with UCL and public health England
Prove it. Or can't you?
humdingle · 31/12/2021 00:31

@BonnesVacances "People keep going on about how CEV individuals should assess risk and decide themselves if it's safe to go somewhere. But that's impossible when they don't know what people are doing because they think their own needs are above the law."

Actually, I don't think it's impossible to risk assess just now. I think it's safe to assume you will probably encounter covid if you go to public indoor places right now. It couldn't be a more clear cut risk assessment as you call it. Covid is absolutely everywhere at the moment. That's with or without people knowingly going out while having covid. I personally wouldn't do it, but it's so widespread that you have to assume there will be multiple people in a venue like a theatre who have it unknowingly and yes sadly possibly knowingly too.

Covidworries · 31/12/2021 00:30

I suggest you start with UCL and public health England

willithappen · 31/12/2021 00:30

I'm from scotland and three friends got PCRs today and I was able to pick up two boxes of LFTs from chemist so you can get tests here

GaolBhoAlba · 31/12/2021 00:29

What a clusterfuck of a thread. So much division, and ensuing bile. In RL families and friends falling out. Awful.

Everyone eligible for booster will have had the opportunity by mid January (vulnerable groups already done). Everything points to omicron being milder. The picture is a positive one.

Hopefully gov has the bollocks to, shortly, scrap isolation completely.

Perime · 31/12/2021 00:26

@MrsBerthaRochester

In Scotland you cannot get a lft or pcr test at the moment. So should everyone just assume they are positive and stay at home?
Not true
BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 00:26

[quote FriendshipsAreHardForMe]@waitingpatientlyforspring

But will all respect, what about asymptomatic people?

Your aunt would have been taking a big risk going even if everyone there had no signs of covid. And tests aren't 100% accurate.

Anyone who is immunosuppressant should steer clear of large gatherings, irrespective of "trust".

And not just for Covid but also flu and all sorts of other viruses around in deep winter.[/quote]

But that's part of the risk assessment. People attending when they know they are positive isn't supposed to be part of that assessment, because they're not supposed to be there!

It's not binary. It's about odds and likelihood. The more people there with Covid, the more likely it will be to catch it. It's not about assuming there's no one there that's asymptomatic. If you include asymptomatic and symptomatic with a positive result the odds increase.

People keep going on about how CEV individuals should assess risk and decide themselves if it's safe to go somewhere. But that's impossible when they don't know what people are doing because they think their own needs are above the law.

humdingle · 31/12/2021 00:26

@Covidworries and @BonnesVacances if you are claiming as true a statistic that 1 in 7 children is suffering from long covid, please show exactly where you are getting this from. If you are unable to cite it accurately, then I am quite confidently calling bullshit on it.

Notonthestairs · 31/12/2021 00:24

To be honest arguing with anyone who'd refuse to test before a public event like the panto is pointless.

I'd suggest, given the shortages of LFTS and PCRS, the majority are thinking about avoiding (not eliminating 🙄) spread and we can take heart from that.

I'm at home with covid at the moment. I'm not going to be hospitalised. But if I had been working this week I'd have lost money. It's been a bit shit, but it's been worse for my 12 year old than me. I'd not want to spread my germs further and they'll be no Hogmanay for me this year.

Covidworries · 31/12/2021 00:22

Isolations if positive are still required through so obv these are still needed. If they are removed then yes positive people can go to the panto but currently they shouldnt

BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 00:21

@MrsBerthaRochester

1 in 7 kids are NOT suffering from long covid. Im reporting that post as its absolute bollocks scare mongering.

It's not bollocks. If you think it is to the extent that you consider it scaremongering, you obviously agree that those statistics would indeed be scary. And they are real statistics. If you haven't bothered to fact-check that yourself, and have instead resorted to reporting the post and putting your fingers in the ears, all your other posts are starting to make sense.

As someone who has been part of the long Covid community since May 2020 because DD has it, I think I'm more aware of the statistics and long term harm (not just deaths) that Covid can cause to people of all ages, including children. You are not. As you continue to talk about deaths and do not take into account any other adverse outcome from catching Covid. Including the effect having a long term debilitated DC who cannot attend school or see their friends has on their parents and siblings, which is immense.

TheRainbow · 31/12/2021 00:21

@MrsBerthaRochester

None of my comments have been deleted but some of the personal attacks have. I am entitled to a different view point without being subjected to abuse.
Referring to someone's aunt who has cancer as having 'health anxiety' because she can't 'trust' people to act responsibly is a personal attack.
FuckeryIsAfoot · 31/12/2021 00:21

@Marianne1234

I just can’t get excited about this any more.

If it’s as rife as the headlines are screaming about then what’s even the point 🤷🏻‍♀️

Sure. Let's go for a cool million a day and see how the NHS fare🤦
FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 00:19

[quote Covidworries]@friendshipsarehardforme

Can you not recognise there is a difference between someone going to an event not realising they are positive to someone choosing to go knowing they are positive. The outcome for people there may not be any different.
Just like the outcome for a child knocked down may be the same weather the driver had a genuine accident or decided to drive into the child because they thought children get knocked down anyway.

My child is CEV so we take alot more precautions but could still get infected, if we do an activity we accept there are risks (we currently arent dping anything). If this resulted in a positive that is like but if one of the people we trusted deliberately ignored their positive test result and put us at risk just because then that is an entirely different situation.
Alot of vunerable conditions are first identified when taken ill for something else. So some vunerable people do not know they are vunerable yet[/quote]
It is endemic. You can't avoid it with R rates of 5/6 like London has seen with Omicron.

It's unavoidable. It's in all schools. There is no longer a reason to isolate for 7-10 days, limiting people's income and freedom.

I'm sorry, but there's just no longer a clinical case for isolation or lockdowns.

Personally I think it's far better for people to get Omicron in school holidays and when many are on annual leave than disrupt schooling further and affect people's work/income.

friendlycat · 31/12/2021 00:15

What is so sad about this thread is that there are people who would do the same and knowingly go to a busy enclosed space having tested positive. All for a bloody Panto.

Of course the World is going to have to find a way of living with this until it runs its course, but common decency really should prevail that if you are positive you don’t then go and knowingly mingle with others like this when it’s avoidable. You just miss the sodding Panto.

Covidworries · 31/12/2021 00:10

@friendshipsarehardforme

Can you not recognise there is a difference between someone going to an event not realising they are positive to someone choosing to go knowing they are positive. The outcome for people there may not be any different.
Just like the outcome for a child knocked down may be the same weather the driver had a genuine accident or decided to drive into the child because they thought children get knocked down anyway.

My child is CEV so we take alot more precautions but could still get infected, if we do an activity we accept there are risks (we currently arent dping anything). If this resulted in a positive that is like but if one of the people we trusted deliberately ignored their positive test result and put us at risk just because then that is an entirely different situation.
Alot of vunerable conditions are first identified when taken ill for something else. So some vunerable people do not know they are vunerable yet

Pensieve · 31/12/2021 00:10

*ill

Pensieve · 31/12/2021 00:09

Thing is, it’s not just hospitalisations is it. It’s isolating and actually ‘being just I’ll enough’ that you can’t go to work and need a few days off. It’s creating chaos up and down the country. Post office was shut near me recently as no staff due to COVID, as an example.

MrsBerthaRochester · 31/12/2021 00:07

None of my comments have been deleted but some of the personal attacks have. I am entitled to a different view point without being subjected to abuse.

BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 00:06

[quote humdingle]@BrotherHelp "Long covid, like I said. Colleagues, healthy people who got covid pre vaccine, and some post. Loosing their jobs. Not anecdotal. Healthy people who did iron men, cycled miles every day, worked all the hours. Now nothing. No treatment as it’s all so new. But meh, it’s not individually in a paper for you."

If you know multiple people in your area who this has happened to, I have bad news for you, it's not just covid as that is not normal, something else is happening. I would be campaigning to get your water tested or something.

You are speaking about people (plural) who did iron men events and are completely incapacitated now and you are saying it's not anecdotal - so please, point me to the data that reports all these multiple former iron man participants who cannot function day to day (because if you can't do that then guess what - it's anecdotal! And probably an exaggeration)
[/quote]

You don't know what you're talking about, FACT. If you haven't come across real genuine heartbreaking stories of long term disability in long Covid in your echo chamber, don't dismiss other people's experiences. Get thee on Twitter and search the hashtag and educate yourself FFS. Instead of making snide and ignorant comments about contaminated water.Hmm

TheRainbow · 31/12/2021 00:04

@MrsBerthaRochester

1 in 7 kids are NOT suffering from long covid. Im reporting that post as its absolute bollocks scare mongering.
someone needs to report you!