Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL gone to panto when waiting for PCR result - oh yes she did!

533 replies

anotherannoyngSIL · 30/12/2021 14:47

Name changed as I’ve been slated on here before for not allowing my SIL to do as she pleases.

Today I thought we’d made a positive turn as she has taken my older son and hers to the pantomime as I’ve got a broken leg (though she has made a big thing about helping out).

Unfortunately she’s just text me to say “BTW I’ve had a positive lateral and waiting on my PCR but decided to take the boys anyway as xxx (her son) was looking forward to it, I’m sure that’s fine”.

In which universe is that fine?? She’s risking not just my son, but the others she’s gone with and the whole audience!! She is very jealous if people do social things without her but surely there comes a time when sense is more important than FOMO?? I’m assuming she waited till she was there to tell me so I couldn’t do anything.

Husband says I’m being unreasonable for being annoyed as the rules aren’t clear cut and she hasn’t had the PCR test back.

AIBU for wanting to ban her as she’s so irresponsible and only really cares about herself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
gogohm · 31/12/2021 10:25

@kitcat15

Exactly, we decided at work to stop testing twice a week, everyone is vaccinated and boosted, we wear masks for visitors

gogohm · 31/12/2021 10:23

It's irresponsible that she went knowingly but I won't pretend that I would have taken a lft - I would have gone.

PurpleDaisies · 31/12/2021 10:22

What about people still waiting for cancer treatments, for eye surgeries, for physiotherapy to help eat, for speech therapy, for hearing assessments. The list goes on.

Those will be delayed if the staff are off with long covid, covid or the hospitals are too busy with covid patients.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 10:18

@BonnesVacances but most people recover from long Covid. For most people it's a temporary thing.

What about people still waiting for cancer treatments, for eye surgeries, for physiotherapy to help eat, for speech therapy, for hearing assessments. The list goes on.

Everyone waiting on the longest lists known to the NHS are waiting for life changing interventions. Their conditions may be longer lasting than long Covid.

To me, it seems you're fixating on one condition (understandably because it affects you and your family) but you're ignoring the millions of others still sitting waiting for letters to come through the post with offers of medical help. Caused mostly by isolation.

chaosrabbitland · 31/12/2021 10:18

[quote frazzledali]@chaosrabbitland you can't see how it's goady to say things like "running around like a hysteric"? Then I think you are proving my point.[/quote]
no its the truth , i have to deal with these people day in and day out working on a healthcare counter , the long awaited flow tests came in yesterday and we had to ration them to 1 per person instead of 2 , they ran out in about an hour , we have posters up saying they are out of stock , but it still does not stop the whingy when are you getting more , do you now where i can get them qustions followed by despairing sighing , like they are in search of the ark of the covenent instead of an unreliable test which then has to be followed up by a reliable one to confirm a positive result and all for a varient which is proving to be mild in the vast majority of people , christ how have people let themselves get to this !! its not being goady its speaking the truth

Covidworries · 31/12/2021 10:14

@marianne1234

Having to wear a seatbelt is a retriction. Havingnto make a child with sensory issues wear a seat belt reduces the amount of journeys we can do and i dont like seeing the disapointment on their face when they have to go in car but that life sometimes.
Not downing a bottle of wine before driving is a restriction.
Not speeding at 50 through a 30 zone is a restriction.
Life is full of restrictions some restrictions like staying home when covid postive are not forever but currently needed now else they would have been stopped already the experts still see the need in not going out to public places while covid positive.

The idea of testing and isolating if positive is that it keeps cases as low as possible at any given time. So that the utility companies may have a couple of staff off but can hopefully limp on to ensure emergencies are dealt with and we keep our utilities functioning. Every memeber of staff off at the same time is going to cause disruptions. Ditto the lorry drivers, ditto the supermarkey staff, ditto the school staff, and most importantly ditto the NHS.

Hospitilasations are currently higher and quicker than the worse case predictions at a time when staffing iis dropping. Good luck to anyone needing medical care for any reason in the next few weeks

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 10:11

@WhatAHexIGotInto

I was all for Covid restrictions whilst the virus presented a real risk to people.

But the pros of isolating no longer outweigh the cons.

@FriendshipsAreHardForMe can I ask, genuinely, not in an inflammatory way, does that mean that you don't believe that people should isolate if they have CoVID?

Having read and listened to what I have in recent days about the evidence of Omicron...

I think policy should change. My personal views are; mask wearing for those who can should stay (because it's not hard for most people to wear a mask and it has no ill effect). But isolating, if symptoms are mild should end.

In the rare occasions symptoms aren't mild then people should stay at home whilst symptomatic, as you'd hope with any virus. But if asymptomatic or if it's presenting as a cold, then yes, I think people shouldn't isolate.

Education and healthcare isn't sustainable if people isolate for cold like symptoms.

BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 10:09

@NameChanged15729

Friendshipsarehardforme you have pretty much summarised how I feel about it all.

At the end of the day continuing this madness might be somewhat protecting the cev but it’s at a cost to so many other people. Children with disabilities, people feeling isolated with poor mental health, people losing there jobs... not being able to survive on repeated statutory sick pay. It’s not ok to just sweep it all under ‘the pandemic doesn’t end because people have had enough Hmm’. It won’t end. Covid isn’t going anywhere and it’s always going to be a threat to vulnerable people. Unfortunately those vulnerable people do not trump the rights of everybody else.

I do agree it can't go on forever. But I don't think it's ongoing now to 'somewhat protect the CEV'. It's to protect the health service for everyone who might need it, Covid-related or not. The government is also prioritising the majority and doesn't care about the CEV either. It has its head in the sand over Long Covid and is kicking that can down the road.

The latter has also caused "children with disabilities, people feeling isolated with poor mental health, people losing there jobs... not being able to survive on repeated statutory sick pay". For months though (18 months in our case), not 7-10 days at a time. I've lost my job to look after DD and there's no SSP for me. My DD is self harming and there is no NHS healthcare because everyone else with Long Covid wants to see the same consultants.

Letting Covid pass at will and infect at the rates it's doing will increase Long Covid numbers and affect people far far more than 7-10 days of isolation. But I do realise this is hard for people to relate to and that getting Long Covid feels like low odds (even though they aren't) and that they'd rather take their chances and have some semblance of a normal life again. I often wonder on these threads how people would cope with Long Covid though, when the minor mitigations in place now are such a struggle for them.

Marianne1234 · 31/12/2021 09:59

But when’s that going to happen Hex? Is there a point at which this will not be dangerous for the CEV? I mean what’s the solution to this?

frazzledali · 31/12/2021 09:56

@chaosrabbitland you can't see how it's goady to say things like "running around like a hysteric"? Then I think you are proving my point.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 31/12/2021 09:56

@Marianne1234 isn't that what everyone wishes for though? Don't we all, even those with differing views at the moment, want CoVID to go away and for lives to return to normal?

WhatAHexIGotInto · 31/12/2021 09:55

I was all for Covid restrictions whilst the virus presented a real risk to people.

But the pros of isolating no longer outweigh the cons.

@FriendshipsAreHardForMe can I ask, genuinely, not in an inflammatory way, does that mean that you don't believe that people should isolate if they have CoVID?

Marianne1234 · 31/12/2021 09:53

It’s entirely normal for people to want their lives to go back to normal. It’s not selfish to want that. I wouldn’t do what the SIL has done but it’s not right to demonise people for wishing things could go back to normal. That’s what I’m trying to say.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 09:50

@NameChanged15729

Friendshipsarehardforme you have pretty much summarised how I feel about it all.

At the end of the day continuing this madness might be somewhat protecting the cev but it’s at a cost to so many other people. Children with disabilities, people feeling isolated with poor mental health, people losing there jobs... not being able to survive on repeated statutory sick pay. It’s not ok to just sweep it all under ‘the pandemic doesn’t end because people have had enough Hmm’. It won’t end. Covid isn’t going anywhere and it’s always going to be a threat to vulnerable people. Unfortunately those vulnerable people do not trump the rights of everybody else.

Yep. My child has a developmental delay. We are getting zero help for it, partly due to Covid restrictions.

I was all for Covid restrictions whilst the virus presented a real risk to people.

But the pros of isolating no longer outweigh the cons.

People need to rethink WHY we are doing something. Not just go along with the status quo.

People are saying "wait until we know more". Why?!?! We have the data. It's from credible sources. What are we now waiting for?!

whereismumhiding3 · 31/12/2021 09:49

@Marianne1234

Fuck right off with the selfish chat. It has been two years. We have sacrificed plenty. It’s not selfish to want to carry on with your life. It’s entirely normal and understandable. Stop trying to demonise people for this.
But it is selfish to go out contagious with covid symptoms, positive LFT waiting for PCR test result.

People should get on with their lives but not deliberately infect others with contagious disease by failing to follow public health guidance. In this instance, I hope police fine this woman as I doubt it'd be hard to get proof she attended theatre whilst waiting for PCR result.

NameChanged15729 · 31/12/2021 09:43

Friendshipsarehardforme you have pretty much summarised how I feel about it all.

At the end of the day continuing this madness might be somewhat protecting the cev but it’s at a cost to so many other people. Children with disabilities, people feeling isolated with poor mental health, people losing there jobs... not being able to survive on repeated statutory sick pay. It’s not ok to just sweep it all under ‘the pandemic doesn’t end because people have had enough Hmm’. It won’t end. Covid isn’t going anywhere and it’s always going to be a threat to vulnerable people. Unfortunately those vulnerable people do not trump the rights of everybody else.

Marianne1234 · 31/12/2021 09:43

Having to change your plans at the last minute because you have asymptomatic covid is a restriction though. It means you can never truly plan anything. It means absolutely everything you plan is subject to cancellation at the last minute. I don’t want to live like that forever. I don’t want that to be my children’s childhoods.

I wouldn’t have done what the SIL did. I follow the law. But I don’t want this to be the law forever.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 31/12/2021 09:40

Genuinely cannot fathom this. I'd like people to act responsibly and with consideration so everyone has a chance at staying safe. But you'd rather they didn't have to do that and as a result those at risk have nothing at all or take their chances. Have I understood that right? Is that your position?

I find this very difficult to understand too @BonnesVacances. So many people willfully 'misunderstanding' posts and declaring that you must want eternal restrictions and lockdowns if you say that it's a reasonable expectation for people to continue to be cautious for now, while cases are rising again, (not lockdowns etc) for the benefit of others. No one actually wants this shit to carry on, but it's easier to try to make you sound unreasonable and hysterical rather than show any kind of empathy.

Some of the comments on this thread show that there are some people who genuinely do not give a shit about anyone else and unfortunately, that won't change.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 09:40

@BonnesVacances

I'm not sure, from reading your posts, that you are up to date with your knowledge on Omicron (which is now the dominant variant in UK and lots of other countries and will be around the world soon).

It's endemic. That means, it's staying for a long while. It's highly contagious but shown to be very mild.

There IS a cost to isolating. Good luck getting non-urgent operations. Enjoy remote GP appointments. Events and bookings are being cancelled last minute due to staff isolating. The quality of schooling will be lowered due to isolating teachers.

It can't continue. Not while the risk to most people, including the vulnerable, is very low. We have vaccines and we thankfully have a safer variant. Now I was my NHS back, schooling to be back and life for everyone to return to normal.

chaosrabbitland · 31/12/2021 09:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ as it quotes a deleted post

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 09:34

If Omicron was avoidable, I'd say your SIL was totally irresponsible.

Unfortunately, for those children and adults who are immunocompromised, it WILL be a case of either shielding indefinitely or accepting a level of risk.

I appreciate and sympathise that it's a very difficult position to be in. It's not fair. Not is it something anyone would want for themselves or their family.

But that doesn't change the facts. Which is; Omicron is unavoidable. It is circulating and is becoming endemic. Overall, this is positive as it's far safer than Delta. But yes, it's still not ideal.

Getting people to isolate for 7-10 days isn't justifiable anymore. It won't stop the spread.

The sooner everyone gets it, the sooner people can build up Tcell immunity and be more assured that it won't cause serious harm.

Yes, some MAY get long Covid, but that's not anyone's fault. And there are no viable ways of containing the virus so we HAVE to live with it.

It's not an ideal scenario but nor is isolation and the effects that has on healthcare, education, employment etc.

BellaChagall · 31/12/2021 09:32

I can't believe that you didn't even bother to speak to her when she dropped off your DS. So she didn't bother to tell you when she picked him up, she then texted you, and didn't come to the door when she she dropped him off. By not telling her what you think you are condoning her behaviour. You really should be telling her how outraged you are, not us! I hope your DS is ok.

BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 09:28

@NameChanged15729

BonnesVacances no that is not my position. I have stated a few times now that my household had Covid early December and we all isolated. All double/triple vaxxed apart from the children because they are too young. They will be when allowed though. We wear masks and do what we can to stop the spread.

What I’m asking is where does it end? You don’t want restrictions forever but how much longer? What needs to change for life to carry on? Personally it feels like the majority of people have followed the rules but if anything things seem to be going backwards. I’m in Wales. Nightclubs are closed, the rule of six is back, queuing and one way systems are back in supermarkets. I’m now living in fear that my children’s school will close next. It’s easy to say restrictions won’t last forever but there needs to be a plan in place to get us out of them now because following the rules doesn’t seem to be working!

Where does it end? Who knows? But the exit plan isn't we've had enough now, so let's just stop and get on with it and back in your box if you're CEV. Hospital outcomes are improving, but we still don't have a functioning health care system due to overload, both from hospital admissions and the demand for secondary care from Long Covid, which will continue to increase as more people are infected.

NameChanged15729 · 31/12/2021 09:01

BonnesVacances no that is not my position. I have stated a few times now that my household had Covid early December and we all isolated. All double/triple vaxxed apart from the children because they are too young. They will be when allowed though. We wear masks and do what we can to stop the spread.

What I’m asking is where does it end? You don’t want restrictions forever but how much longer? What needs to change for life to carry on? Personally it feels like the majority of people have followed the rules but if anything things seem to be going backwards. I’m in Wales. Nightclubs are closed, the rule of six is back, queuing and one way systems are back in supermarkets. I’m now living in fear that my children’s school will close next. It’s easy to say restrictions won’t last forever but there needs to be a plan in place to get us out of them now because following the rules doesn’t seem to be working!

BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 08:47

@NameChanged15729

Bonnesvacances

I’ve read everyone of your posts and while I do feel sympathy for your daughters health struggles, I also feel your being just as selfish as the people arguing for no restrictions.

Your argument is she feels unable to go out after contracting severe Covid and in return you want restrictions lasting forever? Is that not selfish? Your asking people to curtail there lives for the sake of your dd. What about my children? They need to physically be at school for the sake of there mental health. They deserve to have happy childhoods without plans being cancelled because of Covid. It’s extremely difficult to explain to children with asd why plans they are excited for have to change with short notice.
The problem with the isolation rules is that it’s just dragging this out when it’s inevitable that it has to end eventually. So yes, I find what your asking just as selfish. Your dd’s needs do not trump my dc’s needs. We are all selfish in this and looking for what’s best for our own nearest and dearest.

Excuse me? Where have I said I want restrictions lasting forever? Quite the leap to infer that I want to stop children from attending school just so mine can live.Confused

Agree, my child's needs don't trump yours. But if still wearing a mask, testing and following the law by not going to an indoor space while positive with Covid allows mine to have any life at all, instead of no life, why would you be against that? Is that what you mean by restrictions? And that my wanting people to not wilfully and knowingly transmit Covid is wanting restrictions to last forever?

Genuinely cannot fathom this. I'd like people to act responsibly and with consideration so everyone has a chance at staying safe. But you'd rather they didn't have to do that and as a result those at risk have nothing at all or take their chances. Have I understood that right? Is that your position?