Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL gone to panto when waiting for PCR result - oh yes she did!

533 replies

anotherannoyngSIL · 30/12/2021 14:47

Name changed as I’ve been slated on here before for not allowing my SIL to do as she pleases.

Today I thought we’d made a positive turn as she has taken my older son and hers to the pantomime as I’ve got a broken leg (though she has made a big thing about helping out).

Unfortunately she’s just text me to say “BTW I’ve had a positive lateral and waiting on my PCR but decided to take the boys anyway as xxx (her son) was looking forward to it, I’m sure that’s fine”.

In which universe is that fine?? She’s risking not just my son, but the others she’s gone with and the whole audience!! She is very jealous if people do social things without her but surely there comes a time when sense is more important than FOMO?? I’m assuming she waited till she was there to tell me so I couldn’t do anything.

Husband says I’m being unreasonable for being annoyed as the rules aren’t clear cut and she hasn’t had the PCR test back.

AIBU for wanting to ban her as she’s so irresponsible and only really cares about herself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Covidworries · 31/12/2021 12:00

@humdingle

So if the 2 links id already added and the link added by the other person you tagged asking for links werent enough, im not sure what is going to be enough for you Grin

Keep living in la la land

WhatAHexIGotInto · 31/12/2021 11:53

The mental health of the vulnerable is just as important as those who are healthy

100% agree. So much talk of 'this doesn't trump that'. It's frightening that some refuse to see vulnerable people as important members of society too.

CalishataFolkart · 31/12/2021 11:52

@Marianne1234

Of course they’re urging caution but if they were seriously worried there would be restrictions on mixing surely. I know many people wouldn’t comply but many would.
Why are they urging caution if it’s something we can and should live with? If it’s not a problem? If it’s “just a head cold”?

They did advise restrictions. Boris chose not to implement them. This was framed as the scientists being “gloomy.”

Sugarplumfairy65 · 31/12/2021 11:50

@DappledOliveGroves

I'm afraid I couldn't get het up about this. If one-third of all people are asymptomatic and merrily spreading it, then what difference does it make if someone may be aware that they may test positive? If isolation worked, why do we have close to 200,000 cases a day?

Frankly, it's so contagious that if you don't want to catch it then don't go anywhere. Mind you, I've always felt that the onus should be on those not wanting to catch it to stay home, rather than others having to curtail their freedom in case someone catches it.

The vulnerable have spent nearly 2 years staying at home. Don't you think they should be allowed out occasionally and be able to rely on others sticking to the rules? Even if someone was asymptomatic, they should be testing regularly anyway. The mental health of the vulnerable is just as important as those who are healthy
humdingle · 31/12/2021 11:45

[quote Covidworries]@humdingle

Are you incapable of googling?
Do you really need us to find you links?
Or would you rather pretend its a made up figure?[/quote]
Yes I am incapable of googling and finding this because it's made up. Prove that it's not! Or can't you?

Marianne1234 · 31/12/2021 11:38

Of course they’re urging caution but if they were seriously worried there would be restrictions on mixing surely. I know many people wouldn’t comply but many would.

CalishataFolkart · 31/12/2021 11:35

This up to date information and data - is that the same data the scientists advising the government are privy to or is there some MN data they haven’t seen? Just finding it hard to work out why they would be urging caution for “just a head cold” or people spreading “sore throats.”

I’m looking forward to the briefing where Chris Witty announces, “Most people will be fine, we’ve just got to get on with it now. Sick of it.”

Notonthestairs · 31/12/2021 11:23

"How do you come to that conclusion when they've acknowledged that the vast majority of hospital admissions with Covid are incidental. Ie they are in for other reasons and happen to test positive in hospital."

Sorry, could you point me to where this has been stated? Things obviously are changing but the last thing I read suggested 70% were being treated primarily for Covid

amp.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/29/how-can-we-measure-the-true-scale-of-uk-covid-hospital-admissions

It's also important to point that regardless covid patients will need to be isolated from others and that does have an impact of staff and resources. Covid may also complicate any ongoing treatment they are receiving for ongoing conditions.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 31/12/2021 11:20

There's a certain irony in seeing a particular poster now complaining about being misrepresented 🤔

whynotwhatknot · 31/12/2021 11:18

What did your dh say op to her result being positive

WhatAHexIGotInto · 31/12/2021 11:16

@Marianne1234 thank you, I understand your position on this now. While I do agree with much of what you say, I still feel very conflicted about isolation. What may be a bad cold to me, may make someone else very ill and I would hate to be the person to cause someone else to become very unwell.

The last thing I, and I think most people, want is any more lockdowns. I wouldn't even pretend to know what the solution to this is, but I do still think that we should exercise some degree of caution I suppose. I think we would all agree that we've all had enough of covid now, but I do find the 'I just don't care' attitudes of some of the posters on this thread hard to stomach, it just smacks of seeing other people as collateral damage as long as it doesn't affect them.

ilovesooty · 31/12/2021 11:13

@Marianne1234

But some people aren't even prepared to take mitigating measures while this is with us, like wearing a mask if they can or precautionary testing before mixing with others

For the record I am not this person. I’ve always worn my mask. I did my pre-Christmas day testing. I’m fully vaccinated. I’ve complied with the rules from day one.

But this is a head cold and it’s too much now.

I didn't say that you were that person. Another poster admitted to being that person though, and there are loads more like her around.
Covidworries · 31/12/2021 11:11

Attachment fail

SIL gone to panto when waiting for PCR result - oh yes she did!
Covidworries · 31/12/2021 11:10

@friendshipsarehardforme

Children hospitalisations are rising.

The data from nhs England states that 71% of covid addmissions are because if covid

Scottishskifun · 31/12/2021 11:02

@Marianne1234

I’m sure I read that teachers in Scotland have been advised they can work if they are asymptomatic. Maybe I’ve picked that up wrong.
Nope! Teachers in Scotland can voluntarily leave isolation if negative we have Whole household isolation for 10 days regardless of vaccination and negative test results.
FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 11:00

@Covidworries

It still hospitalises a % if 100 people had delta and 1 got hosptalised and omicon hospitalises 2/3 less often if we have 300 cases the hospital are dealing with the same number of cases. If of the 300 people 70 are too ill too work for a week and 10 are too ill to work for a month till doesnt seem bad untill you realise we have a daily cases of close to 300k (estimated based in lack of tests) which means daily hospitalisations are going to be pushing 1000 and approx week long absences from the work place of 70000 extra every day.

Do you see that the potential for problems is quite high?

How do you come to that conclusion when they've acknowledged that the vast majority of hospital admissions with Covid are incidental. Ie they are in for other reasons and happen to test positive in hospital.

Look at South Africa. They've had Omicron longer, with fewer vaccinated and evidence is positive with regards to hospitalisations DUE to Covid.

The hospital issues are more compounded by people isolating than it is by people needing treatment for Covid.

I feel people are reluctant to update their views on Covid. Why won't you acknowledge up to date data? It's all very well quoting figures but you need to look into what it's showing and isn't showing. They're incidental findings.

Marianne1234 · 31/12/2021 10:51

But some people aren't even prepared to take mitigating measures while this is with us, like wearing a mask if they can or precautionary testing before mixing with others

For the record I am not this person. I’ve always worn my mask. I did my pre-Christmas day testing. I’m fully vaccinated. I’ve complied with the rules from day one.

But this is a head cold and it’s too much now.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 10:48

@bonnesvacances

You aren't educating yourself with up to date information. You're taking as though it's Delta.

I'm sorry, but until you acknowledge that Omicron is causing extremely mild symptoms there's no point you discussing Covid. It doesn't matter if people are spreading sore throats. It does matter if people can't access healthcare.

Covidworries · 31/12/2021 10:47

It still hospitalises a % if 100 people had delta and 1 got hosptalised and omicon hospitalises 2/3 less often if we have 300 cases the hospital are dealing with the same number of cases.
If of the 300 people 70 are too ill too work for a week and 10 are too ill to work for a month till doesnt seem bad untill you realise we have a daily cases of close to 300k (estimated based in lack of tests) which means daily hospitalisations are going to be pushing 1000 and approx week long absences from the work place of 70000 extra every day.

Do you see that the potential for problems is quite high?

Marianne1234 · 31/12/2021 10:46

I’m sure I read that teachers in Scotland have been advised they can work if they are asymptomatic. Maybe I’ve picked that up wrong.

BonnesVacances · 31/12/2021 10:44

[quote FriendshipsAreHardForMe]**@BonnesVacances* but most people recover from long Covid. For most* people it's a temporary thing.

What about people still waiting for cancer treatments, for eye surgeries, for physiotherapy to help eat, for speech therapy, for hearing assessments. The list goes on.

Everyone waiting on the longest lists known to the NHS are waiting for life changing interventions. Their conditions may be longer lasting than long Covid.

To me, it seems you're fixating on one condition (understandably because it affects you and your family) but you're ignoring the millions of others still sitting waiting for letters to come through the post with offers of medical help. Caused mostly by isolation.[/quote]

I don't agree it's caused mostly by isolation rules. How does allowing people with Covid to pass it on to healthcare staff improve the situation and help patients with other conditions to receive treatment? Confused Who's delivering these appointments, operations, services to while they're temporarily off with sickness or longer with Long Covid?

Who's teaching the kids when teachers are off sick with actual Covid illness? Do you think people coming into work or socialising with Covid would result in less time off and an increase in the delivery of treatment or services than when people are (unnecessarily) isolating with it?

ilovesooty · 31/12/2021 10:40

[quote frazzledali]@chaosrabbitland you can't see how it's goady to say things like "running around like a hysteric"? Then I think you are proving my point.[/quote]
She knows it's goady. She doesn't care.

ilovesooty · 31/12/2021 10:37

[quote WhatAHexIGotInto]@Marianne1234 isn't that what everyone wishes for though? Don't we all, even those with differing views at the moment, want CoVID to go away and for lives to return to normal?[/quote]
Of course we do
But some people aren't even prepared to take mitigating measures while this is with us, like wearing a mask if they can or precautionary testing before mixing with others.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 31/12/2021 10:36

@purpledaisies

Why would they be off with Covid? Most cases of Omicron are now sore throats. If people are off work due to sore throats then I'd question their work ethic.

The hospitals won't be too busy with Covid patients. Stats are showing Omicron isn't causing hospitalisations like Delta and previous variants did. It's mild. And data is also showing most hospitalisations with covid are incidental - people were in hospital for other reasons and happened to test positive for Covid whilst there (which isn't surprising given how contagious Omicron is).

Start reading the evidence coming out about Omicron. It's not the same as Delta.

ilovesooty · 31/12/2021 10:33

@NameChanged15729

Bonnesvacances

I’ve read everyone of your posts and while I do feel sympathy for your daughters health struggles, I also feel your being just as selfish as the people arguing for no restrictions.

Your argument is she feels unable to go out after contracting severe Covid and in return you want restrictions lasting forever? Is that not selfish? Your asking people to curtail there lives for the sake of your dd. What about my children? They need to physically be at school for the sake of there mental health. They deserve to have happy childhoods without plans being cancelled because of Covid. It’s extremely difficult to explain to children with asd why plans they are excited for have to change with short notice.
The problem with the isolation rules is that it’s just dragging this out when it’s inevitable that it has to end eventually. So yes, I find what your asking just as selfish. Your dd’s needs do not trump my dc’s needs. We are all selfish in this and looking for what’s best for our own nearest and dearest.

Where did @BonnesVacances suggest children didn't attend school?