Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex DIL leaving 8 year old in house alone

183 replies

billybobhonking · 30/12/2021 13:05

Over the Christmas period I have found out my ex DIL has been leaving my 8 year old granddaughter alone in the house while she 'nips' to the shops. However, she can be gone for around about an hour.

When I brought up my concern to my son he said that he was fine with it, granddaughter is quite mature for her age I suppose. He said that ex DIL had spoken to her about what to do in an emergency/ to not answer the door etc. She has a snib on the door so whilst granddaughter is locked in she can very easily gets out. Ex DIL phoned her to check in.

It just doesn't sit right with me, I can't imagine leaving any of my boys alone at that age. Maybe in the car to nip into a shop quickly but nothing more than that. But since my son says he's fine about it I feel like there isn't much I can do. Other than look for reassurance that this is ok?

We are in Scotland and so there are no specific laws on this, it's up to the parents discretion but she just turned 8 in October. I feel it is far too young.

I could possibly speak to ex DILs mum to have a word but don't want to upset anyone.

AIBU to be concerned about this? I mean what about a fire? My son says she knows what to do but she 8 years old! Of course she doesn't know what to do!!

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 30/12/2021 16:40

There's not much you can do about it really.

I think 8 is too young to be left alone though no matter how mature the child seems. I have an 8 year old and wouldn't dream of doing it, I am a single parent so that is not an excuse. I think it is neglectful personally.

liveforsummer · 30/12/2021 16:39

[quote FatBettyintheCoop]@liveforsummer

At our primary school, all children are collected by an adult at the school gate or they catch the school bus. No child is allowed to leave unaccompanied.
The school bus drops the child off to a waiting adult rather than leaves them to walk home alone. It could be a half mile walk up a quiet road/boreen.

I think the issue about leaving children at home also depends on whereabouts you live. I have to drive about 7 miles to the nearest supermarket so it's not a five minute trot to the corner shop. Doing a 'quick shop' is likely to take me at least 30-60mins door to door. I wouldn't drive all the way there just to buy some bread and milk.

Where I grew up, we all knew our immediate neighbours so if you had a problem, you could run round to get 'Aunty' Doreen from number 15 to come and help. When I cut myself badly aged about 8, one of my neighbours with a car drove me to the hospital to get it stitched. Mum didn't drive and we didn't have a phone either.

Many people on mumsnet don't appear to know their neighbours very well which seems very weird to me.

[/quote]
Ah ok. That's different to your previous statement. Are you saying they don't let dc walk home at any age?

liveforsummer · 30/12/2021 16:38

If it's too much trouble for the Dil to take her daughter out with her when she pops to the shops, I doubt that she could be bothered to pick up the phone, call her mil and then wait for her to arrive.

Seeing it's no actual trouble to take an average 8 year old out - they can put on their coat and shoes while you get your own, not like getting a toddler out the door - I'd assume it's more because the 8 year old wishes to stay

HugeAckmansWife · 30/12/2021 16:36

As a pp said, comparing your dil with your son isn't fair. If she has the child 90% of the time she has far less opportunity to nip out for child free errands etc than your son. She has made a parenting decusion that she and he are fine with. It's entirely irrelevant how it 'sits' with you. From the response on here, it's a judgement call based on the individual child and circumstances. In some, 8 is fine, in others not. There are some 14 year olds I teach who I doubt are left alone as they have zero common sense.

liveforsummer · 30/12/2021 16:35

@Wineandroses3

Icedcoffee and why have you decided that 8 is old enough to be left home alone? Some 6 year olds i know are more responsible that some 8 year olds - is 6 ok aswell then??? 8 years old is just a child for God’s sake.
I'd guess because both parents have separately judged her as such and the OP admits she is mature
VividImaginationAgain · 30/12/2021 16:35

I think it’s far too young to be left alone but, if both her parents are happy with it, I don’t really see what you can do. If you speak to the DIL or her mother you risk jeopardising your relationship with them and therefore your GGD.

I risk assess for my children and would not be happy with anyone interfering.

Hugoslavia · 30/12/2021 16:34

@TheOriginalEmu

What an unkind and uncalled for comment! Very judgemental. The OP is perfectly within her rights to be concerned. Concern is vastly different from judging someone! The Dil is only popping out for short periods and has said that she believes this to be fine. That is vastly different to being extremely desperate for childcare. If it's too much trouble for the Dil to take her daughter out with her when she pops to the shops, I doubt that she could be bothered to pick up the phone, call her mil and then wait for her to arrive.

DisforDarkChocolate · 30/12/2021 16:34

Where I live most eight-year-olds start walking home alone or with friends as they start middle school next year most parents don't drop off at the school.

Hospedia · 30/12/2021 16:33

In my opinion it depends on the child

It really does.

My 10yo I'd happily leave alone as they're very sensible, mature, and capable, very able to follow basic ground rules and can be trusted to behave. They've been stayed alonenfor short periods since atound the age of 8. I could not have left my 12yo at that age as they were a liability, weren't very sensible, and wouldn't have followed the rules. They can now so have started to stay home for short periods. You risk assess based on the individual child.

FatBettyintheCoop · 30/12/2021 16:33

@liveforsummer

At our primary school, all children are collected by an adult at the school gate or they catch the school bus. No child is allowed to leave unaccompanied.
The school bus drops the child off to a waiting adult rather than leaves them to walk home alone. It could be a half mile walk up a quiet road/boreen.

I think the issue about leaving children at home also depends on whereabouts you live. I have to drive about 7 miles to the nearest supermarket so it's not a five minute trot to the corner shop. Doing a 'quick shop' is likely to take me at least 30-60mins door to door. I wouldn't drive all the way there just to buy some bread and milk.

Where I grew up, we all knew our immediate neighbours so if you had a problem, you could run round to get 'Aunty' Doreen from number 15 to come and help. When I cut myself badly aged about 8, one of my neighbours with a car drove me to the hospital to get it stitched. Mum didn't drive and we didn't have a phone either.

Many people on mumsnet don't appear to know their neighbours very well which seems very weird to me.

Wineandroses3 · 30/12/2021 16:30

Icedcoffee and why have you decided that 8 is old enough to be left home alone? Some 6 year olds i know are more responsible that some 8 year olds - is 6 ok aswell then???
8 years old is just a child for God’s sake.

ThirdElephant · 30/12/2021 16:29

Just turned 8, you say? So the Scottish equivalent to Year 3? Legal or not, as a teacher I'd be expected to report it from a safeguarding perspective if I knew about a kid in year 3 being left home alone. As to what you do as her grandparent, I don't know. Maybe mention to your son that the kid's school would likely be concerned if they knew?

DisforDarkChocolate · 30/12/2021 16:27

You have expressed your concerns to your son. He is happy with it, he probably doing the same.

Leave it alone unless your grandchild told you they felt uncomfortable with it.

ldontWanna · 30/12/2021 16:25
  • This is really irresponsible!

Yes houses can erupt into flames. My old tumble dryer suddenly started smoking. Luckily I was in the room and was able to unplug it instantly. What would have happened if I'd been out?

Similarly, my lodger's hairdryer, which she was using with a converter from European to UK plugs, suddenly started smoking. Again I was in the room at the time - what if I hadn't been?*

By that logic a parent can never take a long bath, put the laundry outside, take the bins out, get or deliver a package to a neighbour and maybe even chat for a bit just in case a random fire starts when they're not in the same room.

In my opinion it depends on the child and if 1.they are sensible and trained what to do AND 2.if they are comfortable being left alone. DD (10) for example, is super sensible and has been for a while and she literally wouldn't move from the sofa with her ipad but doesn't like it so I don't it.

Hugoslavia · 30/12/2021 16:24

It wouldn't sot right with me at all. I would try to impress this upon your son.

Hospedia · 30/12/2021 16:21

All those people saying it’s none of your business - ignore them they’re talking absolute crap of course it’s your business it’s your grand daughter

It's really not OP's business, it is a parenting decision and she is not the parent.

The law does not specify at what age a child can be left alone only that it should not be for overly long periods or overnight and that parent should use their judgement on how mature their child is before deciding to leave them alone.

It sounds like her parents have done this.

icedcoffees · 30/12/2021 16:20

I left a 11 yr old for 10 mins and came back to a smashed window where he'd been playing bouncy ball with the dog in the sitting room.

Most 11yo should know not to play with balls inside the house, surely?

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 30/12/2021 16:17

I left a 11 yr old for 10 mins and came back to a smashed window where he'd been playing bouncy ball with the dog in the sitting room. Victorian glass is brittle and breaks easily. I'd not have foreseen that happening.

But then that could happen just as easily while you were upstairs or in the garden. I think most parents would have a fair idea of whether their child was or was not prone to taking stupid risks.

icedcoffees · 30/12/2021 16:16

@Wineandroses3

All those people saying it’s none of your business - ignore them they’re talking absolute crap of course it’s your business it’s your grand daughter. 8 IS too young to be left home alone, what if something did happen to her? Would all these people saying it’s none of your business be saying the same thing then? No they wouldn’t it would be the same people saying the grandmother knew and did nothing! You need to speak to your son - I’d start with him
Why have you decided eight is too young, though? The law doesn't give a minimum appropriate age for a reason - because it varies so much between individual children and their circumstances.

If something happened, the police would weigh up all sorts of things before deciding whether the parents were responsible. It's a parents' job to weigh up whether the risks outweigh the benefits or vice versa.

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 30/12/2021 16:15

Because my son doesn't leave her alone when she is at his house but ex DIL does.

How much time per week does she spend with your son, as compared with the time she spends with your DIL? If it's only a relatively short time, that doesn't really make it a valid comparison because he can presumably organise matters so that he doesn't need to make an extra shopping trip. And do you help your son out with that?

liveforsummer · 30/12/2021 16:14

I left a 11 yr old for 10 mins and came back to a smashed window where he'd been playing bouncy ball with the dog in the sitting room.
Victorian glass is brittle and breaks easily. I'd not have foreseen that happening.

My 8 year old knows no tot play with balls in the hoist and why as that is absolutely something I could foresee happening

Yes houses can erupt into flames. My old tumble dryer suddenly started smoking. Luckily I was in the room and was able to unplug it instantly. What would have happened if I'd been out?

I always unplug my tumble dryer when not in use, and I'd never leave the house with it on. Risks can be mitigated

FortniteBoysMum · 30/12/2021 16:14

In some ways it's safer than in the car. Car could be hit by another vehicle, broken into and stolen etc. If the child is mature enough it comes down to parental choice. At that age I did leave my boys to pop to the shop. However the shop was opposite our house so I could see the front door almost the entire time as was only a corner shop. I was also only gone for 5 minutes at most as it would usually be we needed milk. An hour is a long time but that's her parents choice to make and if dad is OK with it not much you can do.

christmascharade · 30/12/2021 16:09

@Warblerinwinter

I mean what about a fire? My son says she knows what to do but she 8 years old! Of course she doesn't know what to do!!

Do you? The only things you need to know about a fire is

  1. Mitigate risks of having a fire in first place- an 8 year old is perfectly capable of understanding not to play with fire, light candles, or start a bonfire in the same way as I am. They get taught this at school, at home, and pretty much rammed down their throats
  2. If there is a fire, get out. Do not attempt to put it out, get out. Then call 999. Most kids a lot younger than 8 know to get out. It is crazy adults that think that are capable of trying to put fires out and put their lives at risk
I have a relative who is a fireman. He says unless you live in deprived areas with poor housing conditions, smoke, or light chip pans, or overload electrical sockets the risk of house fire in tiny. Houses simply do not spontaneously irrupt into flames.

Stop helicoptering. Educate your grandchild to be independent and self reliant for goodness sake.

This is really irresponsible!

Yes houses can erupt into flames. My old tumble dryer suddenly started smoking. Luckily I was in the room and was able to unplug it instantly. What would have happened if I'd been out?

Similarly, my lodger's hairdryer, which she was using with a converter from European to UK plugs, suddenly started smoking. Again I was in the room at the time - what if I hadn't been?

At the time, I thought it was because both items were old, but now I wonder if it was the wiring in that house.

liveforsummer · 30/12/2021 16:08

@JaninaDuszejko

and also potentially returning to any empty house

Our primary school won't let children walk home alone if there's no adult at home.

How on earth could a primary school know or police this?
Wineandroses3 · 30/12/2021 16:04

All those people saying it’s none of your business - ignore them they’re talking absolute crap of course it’s your business it’s your grand daughter. 8 IS too young to be left home alone, what if something did happen to her? Would all these people saying it’s none of your business be saying the same thing then? No they wouldn’t it would be the same people saying the grandmother knew and did nothing! You need to speak to your son - I’d start with him

Swipe left for the next trending thread