Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex DIL leaving 8 year old in house alone

183 replies

billybobhonking · 30/12/2021 13:05

Over the Christmas period I have found out my ex DIL has been leaving my 8 year old granddaughter alone in the house while she 'nips' to the shops. However, she can be gone for around about an hour.

When I brought up my concern to my son he said that he was fine with it, granddaughter is quite mature for her age I suppose. He said that ex DIL had spoken to her about what to do in an emergency/ to not answer the door etc. She has a snib on the door so whilst granddaughter is locked in she can very easily gets out. Ex DIL phoned her to check in.

It just doesn't sit right with me, I can't imagine leaving any of my boys alone at that age. Maybe in the car to nip into a shop quickly but nothing more than that. But since my son says he's fine about it I feel like there isn't much I can do. Other than look for reassurance that this is ok?

We are in Scotland and so there are no specific laws on this, it's up to the parents discretion but she just turned 8 in October. I feel it is far too young.

I could possibly speak to ex DILs mum to have a word but don't want to upset anyone.

AIBU to be concerned about this? I mean what about a fire? My son says she knows what to do but she 8 years old! Of course she doesn't know what to do!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KurtWilde · 05/01/2022 08:54

@Blue4YOU

If I’m right, she really wants to get this child away from her mother who has done absolutely nothing wrong (and her son is a waste of space)
Yeah I think it's that poster too.
JustLyra · 05/01/2022 06:04

@BungleandGeorge

I don’t know any schools who allow year 3 to walk home alone. The difference between just turned 8 and 11 is enormous. 8 is very young in terms of size, strength and maturity. If the child can get out so easily I’d be worried about someone getting in. People need to stop this ‘none of your business’ , if you truly believe the child to be at risk it’s your duty to do something about it. Only you know whether this is malicious or a genuine concern but I don’t think you’re alone having concerns with a child alone for an hour when it’s not particularly necessary. Perhaps first step would be to offer to take her for that time or go to her house and look after her? Possibly next step to chat with someone in safeguarding at school or LA to discuss your concerns and get their opinion?
Schools that “don’t allow” children to walk alone are relying on parents not pointing out that it’s their call when their child walks alone, not schools. In the 20 schools I’ve worked it over the years most had that policy, not one didn’t back down as soon as a parent pointed that out. The cannot refuse to release a child if the parent insists on this, all they can do if they genuinely think it’s unsafe is speak to SS (who will usually be totally uninterested in a child walking to or from school alone as it’s normally not an issue)

Are you the poster who posts every month or so about how awful a parent your DIL is but your son is blameless?

Sounds a bit like it. They also have form for speaking to the DIL’s mother iirc.

LadyPenelope68 · 05/01/2022 05:32

@lastqueenofscotland I think it is the same poster.

smsd33 · 05/01/2022 02:24

For goodness sake do not speak to her mother, she is a grown adult making choices for her own child that you disagree with.

My MIL once spoke to my mum about something I did that she disagreed with. It caused the breakdown of that relationship with repercussions in others

audweb · 05/01/2022 02:03

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

Dd would sometimes be home alone for a while at aged 10-11 so I see Id be wrong under Scottish law.
Except you wouldn’t - it’s ok as long as it’s not for long periods and the child can cope with the responsibility.
TyrannosaurusRights · 04/01/2022 23:11

@CazCaz0013

Children can be seriously harmed in just a few seconds. I work in child protection and we see it all the time. Please take the advice being offered. Do with it as you wish. I only came to this thread as I was horrified at how this story is being presented in The Sun online
Bollocks do you work in child protection.

Stop shovelling this fine rose fertiliser, no one here is buying it.

Anonymouseposter · 04/01/2022 23:09

OP, you have done what you can in mentioning it to your son. You have no option but to leave it now. You can make it clear that you're happy to babysit if needed.
How do you think speaking to the other grandparent or criticising your ex-DIL would help?
It wouldn't, believe me! It would just cause friction, not make the parents review their decision.
Eight years old is very borderline for leaving a child alone for short periods and it really is the parent's decision.

To those posters saying it might be different if she were three or four--it most definitely would be different, it would be neglect.
In the two recent tragic abuse cases the grandparents had raised concerns but weren't taken seriously enough. It's appropriate for extended family to look out for children.
In this case though it's a matter of personal judgment and there is nothing you can do other than offer support.

Rno3gfr · 04/01/2022 22:43

I may be an outlier, I actually think it’s a good thing that she’s teaching her daughter how to be alone and independent in short bursts. You can’t expect a child to go from never being alone to going straight to walking themselves to secondary school! Age appropriate independence fosters healthy secure children.

Blue4YOU · 04/01/2022 21:51

If I’m right, she really wants to get this child away from her mother who has done absolutely nothing wrong (and her son is a waste of space)

CriminalOrator · 04/01/2022 21:47

@Blue4YOU

People- this poster is no doubt the ex-Mil who harbour a great resentment to her former DIl, who did nothing to her.
I thought that.
Blue4YOU · 04/01/2022 21:47

People- this poster is no doubt the ex-Mil who harbour a great resentment to her former DIl, who did nothing to her.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/01/2022 21:31

Dd would sometimes be home alone for a while at aged 10-11 so I see Id be wrong under Scottish law.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/01/2022 21:29

My Ds is about to turn 8. I wouldn’t leave him at all, unless my teenage Dd is also there. And then not for as long as an hour - maybe 15-20 mins, as it’s too long for her to be responsible for him otherwise.

CriminalOrator · 04/01/2022 21:27

Are you that poster who periodically posts about her former daughter in law, under different names?

Flickflak · 04/01/2022 21:26

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

CazCaz0013 · 04/01/2022 21:16

Children can be seriously harmed in just a few seconds. I work in child protection and we see it all the time. Please take the advice being offered. Do with it as you wish. I only came to this thread as I was horrified at how this story is being presented in The Sun online

audweb · 04/01/2022 21:13

@CazCaz0013 it doesn’t actually make that clear. It’s a matter of risk assessing. No one is going to prosecute someone for leaving their perfectly competent 8 year old at home for fifteen minutes. Or their ten year old to walk to the shops, or to school.

CazCaz0013 · 04/01/2022 21:12

@Stormwhale

I think 8 is very much a borderline age for this. Some 8 year olds would be fine, others not. My dd is the exact same age as your granddaughter, and she definitely isn't ready to be left alone. Although she is mature and sensible most of the time she can be very impulsive and do stupid things that she knows aren't safe or sensible here and there. She would also be scared of every noise and would definitely panic in an emergency situation.

So my 8 year old girl? No way. Possibly someone else's 8 year old girl may handle it much better and be ready for it.

The facts are a child under 12 should not be left at home alone. While there is no law that says you cannot do so, you are 100% right to apply common sense. The Scottish Gov website makes it quite clear under 12 is too young. Should anything happen to a child left alone a parent risks being charged under s12 of the Children and Young People (Scot) Act 1937.
CazCaz0013 · 04/01/2022 21:10

[quote audweb]@CazCaz0013 that’s literally not true. A quick google shows that to be false, it just is for a long period of time - and that will depend on the circumstances, age of the child etc.

My 8 year old would be capable of being alone while I’m going to the shops in that she would just watch tv and chill, however she’s too scared to be alone. I hope once she’s ten/eleven we can work on her being alone, but I imagine other 8 year olds would be perfectly fine.[/quote]
The facts are a child under 12 should not be left at home alone. While there is no law that says you cannot do so, common sense applies and the Scottish Gov website makes it quite clear under 12 is too young. Should anything happen to a child left alone a parent risks being charged under s12 of the Children and Young People (Scot) Act 1937. You need to widen your Google search

Wrenna · 04/01/2022 21:02

If you have to speak with any one about it it should be your son. However I agree with you, it is worrying.

Stormwhale · 04/01/2022 21:01

I think 8 is very much a borderline age for this. Some 8 year olds would be fine, others not. My dd is the exact same age as your granddaughter, and she definitely isn't ready to be left alone. Although she is mature and sensible most of the time she can be very impulsive and do stupid things that she knows aren't safe or sensible here and there. She would also be scared of every noise and would definitely panic in an emergency situation.

So my 8 year old girl? No way. Possibly someone else's 8 year old girl may handle it much better and be ready for it.

audweb · 04/01/2022 20:57

FYI I went to high school in Scotland when I was eleven. You telling me that I shouldn’t have been left alone? That my parents had to accompany me? Maybe it’s not acceptable for every 8 year old, but we have to slowly give our children chances to try to be independent.

audweb · 04/01/2022 20:55

@CazCaz0013 that’s literally not true. A quick google shows that to be false, it just is for a long period of time - and that will depend on the circumstances, age of the child etc.

My 8 year old would be capable of being alone while I’m going to the shops in that she would just watch tv and chill, however she’s too scared to be alone. I hope once she’s ten/eleven we can work on her being alone, but I imagine other 8 year olds would be perfectly fine.

CazCaz0013 · 04/01/2022 20:55

@Waxonwaxoff0

There's not much you can do about it really.

I think 8 is too young to be left alone though no matter how mature the child seems. I have an 8 year old and wouldn't dream of doing it, I am a single parent so that is not an excuse. I think it is neglectful personally.

A sensible answer at last! Children should not be left home alone at such a young age. They could be charged under s12 of the Children & Young People (Scot) Act 1937
CazCaz0013 · 04/01/2022 20:53

@VividImaginationAgain

I think it’s far too young to be left alone but, if both her parents are happy with it, I don’t really see what you can do. If you speak to the DIL or her mother you risk jeopardising your relationship with them and therefore your GGD.

I risk assess for my children and would not be happy with anyone interfering.

Agreed. The rule is that under 12 is too high risk and children should not be left home alone. If anything happened the parent risks being charged in Scotland. Between 12-16yr they should be able to spend time at home alone as it part of their development moving towards adulthood
Swipe left for the next trending thread