Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

MN and their approach to autism

510 replies

HypocrisyHere · 30/12/2021 10:22

I have attached two screenshots. One showing the two threads I’m watching, the other the deletion message from the first watched thread which was deleted.

The subjects of the two threads are

(1) Any ‘positive’ autism stories?
(2) Married to someone with Asperger’s: support thread 5

My confusion is that the first was deleted because “the title was not in spirit of the site” Yet thread 2 - which has (IMO) a deeply offensive as it implies all people with Asperger’s are a problem in a relationship (leaving aside the ghastly ableism within the thread) is absolutely fine?

Thread 1 was from a concerned parent who may have used clunky wording but was looking for support - yet she has been deleted. Thread 2 is for concerned partners who can blame every poor behaviour of their partners on autism and that’s all fine?

As an autistic person this makes no sense to me at all and highlights not only ableism within MNHQ but also a deeply inconsistent approach to moderation?

(Have name changed as I’m a coward)

MN and their approach to autism
OP posts:
christmascharade · 31/12/2021 11:46

@Itsnotover

Most NT people can balance theirs and other peoples needs better. They do so millions of time a day. Sometimes they might choose to put their needs first, sometimes they put others first. It's a ongoing balance often unconscious.

Autistic people are not inherently selfish. Selfishness is not a part of the condition. Our behaviours can appear unusual but many of us are kind and empathetic and actually are people pleasers.

Lacking empathy is not the same thing as being selfish, although it can look like being selfish.

Lacking empathy IS a common autistic trait.
Are you trying to say it isn't?

My mother, partner and DS all find it hard to impossible to put themselves in other people's shoes or predict or understand the consequences of their actions on others.

Should I stop giving them leeway as I think it's their autism making empathy difficult for them, and instead assume they are just selfish people?

Camperbann · 31/12/2021 11:45

I agree people should leave if they aren't happy, which many on the thread are in the process of doing. I suspect like any other relationship many have tried to talk about it, but really someone saying I can't change y because I have autism whilst true doesn't really solve anything for the partner does it? It really just pushes the idea that people should put up with it because the person can't help it which isn't fair. And yes, I don't see the issue on an Internet forum for someone to be able to post about how a loved ones situation is affecting them, in the 'real world' its often not seen as acceptable to do so and so these spaces provide a much needed place often.

HereticFanjo · 31/12/2021 11:43

@Itsnotover

The problem I have with the threads is that they reduce people to their diagnosis when autistic people are all very different from each other. The threads here reinforce stereotypes and ignorance about autism by assuming we're all the same.
I'm going by what I'm observing on this thread to be honest with you. But while people with autism are all very different - just as we all are very different- there are sometimes observable behaviour patterns and thinking processes. This is probably what people find enlightening on the other thread. If anything I suspect it may help people understand their partners better.
Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:42

If you want to be discriminating and ableist then you have the right to do that behind closed doors or in private Facebook groups but not on a public forum where we all have to see it and where it will hurt the feelings of people who have a disability that they never asked for.

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:40

Yes I agree with you but can you see how demanding a support thread be shut down might appear selfish? It's literally self-centring to force people not to discuss their needs and feelings because their needs and feelings offend you.

If it's ableist then yes it should be shut down. There is nothing self centred about not wanting to be discriminated against.

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:38

The problem I have with the threads is that they reduce people to their diagnosis when autistic people are all very different from each other. The threads here reinforce stereotypes and ignorance about autism by assuming we're all the same.

HereticFanjo · 31/12/2021 11:38

@Itsnotover

Most NT people can balance theirs and other peoples needs better. They do so millions of time a day. Sometimes they might choose to put their needs first, sometimes they put others first. It's a ongoing balance often unconscious.

Autistic people are not inherently selfish. Selfishness is not a part of the condition. Our behaviours can appear unusual but many of us are kind and empathetic and actually are people pleasers.

Yes I agree with you but can you see how demanding a support thread be shut down might appear selfish? It's literally self-centring to force people not to discuss their needs and feelings because their needs and feelings offend you.
Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:35

Most NT people can balance theirs and other peoples needs better. They do so millions of time a day. Sometimes they might choose to put their needs first, sometimes they put others first. It's a ongoing balance often unconscious.

Autistic people are not inherently selfish. Selfishness is not a part of the condition. Our behaviours can appear unusual but many of us are kind and empathetic and actually are people pleasers.

Justrealised · 31/12/2021 11:35

@Caramellatteplease

Very true, this is why most threads involving autism end in a row

It's why living with autism can be highly conflictual too

To give a real lived example DS might want to cross a road, I dont want him too. He might not see why my need outweighs his. The fact theres an oncoming car isnt relevant to him he needs to get to his destination...

Most NT people can balance theirs and other peoples needs better. They do so millions of time a day. Sometimes they might choose to put their needs first, sometimes they put others first. It's a ongoing balance often unconscious.

But you can guarantee they definitely would put their need to cross a road above some one wanting them to stop them. They are way less likely to end up in front of a moving car as a result.

I understand every interaction is a negotion and a compromise.things that would be normal are already a compromise to DS. If he could be sat alone playing computer with food arriving 3 times a day and me somewhere in the house he is utterly happy in life, everything else (except for disney and theme park visits) are a compromise . Given the need to compromise so much, there is little understanding as to when to "compromise" and when to not. If he is in a dentist chair, why is his need for painkillers more important than the dentists need to get on with it. It's easier to say nothing despite the increased pain (Yes weve been there too).

One day I might be arguing with DS why he shouldn't walk in front of a car the other why he might want to tell the Dentist hes in pain and pause the filling...

And on the whole I'm dealing with these obvious compromises, as you become an adult the compromises become more challenging and complex, especially when they involve money or your own slightly fragile sense of self.

OP you may not see why these "negative" threads need to exist. They do not support you and cause you pain. Why should you compromise your needs and pain for others needs and pain?

That is totally part of autism and ironically why such threads are necessary

This is very well written.

The threads I have been involved in about autism usually end up in heated discussion/ rows around there being different levels of need or impact cause by autism. Caramellatte's post is exactly the problem I usually encounter in these discussions.

HereticFanjo · 31/12/2021 11:32

Of course it's not about othering their partners. It's about exploring their own relationships with neurodiverse partners and finding support from people who are in the same situation and possibly experiencing similar behaviours. It's giving them a space to vent and be supported.

Honestly it's really clear on this thread that those opposed to the support thread think only the feelings of the autistic partners matter. They must take front and centre! Everyone else must adapt and bend around them.

Except they are free to start their own threads! Give those on the support thread their space to be supported.

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:31

[quote Camperbann]@Itsnotover so instead or responding to one of the many points the poster has raised, you instead just ask what about x as a gotcha? This is the bigger problem on these boards to be honest, people being minimised who also have experience of it but obviously not the right type of experience. A cancer support thread sounds like a great idea as it goes, it is really hard knowing how to best support someone whilst keeping day to day family life going- and there is a woeful lack of in person support and it can be hard for people to feel comfortable about talking to family and friends who directly know the person. An anonymous forum sounds like an ideal place someone can be honest and seek support.[/quote]

You're sidestepping the point I am making.

If the person with cancer was behaving differently because of their cancer (for example if it was affecting their brain) I really don't think that it would be seen as reasonable to be posting about how hard done by the partner was.

Here's a thought, if NT people find it hard living with an autistic person, why don't you try talking to them instead of moaning about them on the internet to other NT people ? Why don't you try to understand their disability better? If you don't want to do this then maybe you don't love them and you should leave?

I have had many NT partners who ask why I do something, I explain it to them. Then 2 weeks later they ask the same thing! They cannot be bothered to understand or even remember yet we're the ones with no empathy and poor communication?

Caramellatteplease · 31/12/2021 11:24

Very true, this is why most threads involving autism end in a row

It's why living with autism can be highly conflictual too

To give a real lived example DS might want to cross a road, I dont want him too. He might not see why my need outweighs his. The fact theres an oncoming car isnt relevant to him he needs to get to his destination...

Most NT people can balance theirs and other peoples needs better. They do so millions of time a day. Sometimes they might choose to put their needs first, sometimes they put others first. It's a ongoing balance often unconscious.

But you can guarantee they definitely would put their need to cross a road above some one wanting them to stop them. They are way less likely to end up in front of a moving car as a result.

I understand every interaction is a negotion and a compromise.things that would be normal are already a compromise to DS. If he could be sat alone playing computer with food arriving 3 times a day and me somewhere in the house he is utterly happy in life, everything else (except for disney and theme park visits) are a compromise . Given the need to compromise so much, there is little understanding as to when to "compromise" and when to not. If he is in a dentist chair, why is his need for painkillers more important than the dentists need to get on with it. It's easier to say nothing despite the increased pain (Yes weve been there too).

One day I might be arguing with DS why he shouldn't walk in front of a car the other why he might want to tell the Dentist hes in pain and pause the filling...

And on the whole I'm dealing with these obvious compromises, as you become an adult the compromises become more challenging and complex, especially when they involve money or your own slightly fragile sense of self.

OP you may not see why these "negative" threads need to exist. They do not support you and cause you pain. Why should you compromise your needs and pain for others needs and pain?

That is totally part of autism and ironically why such threads are necessary

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:22

@HereticFanjo

I really dislike seeing people attempt to shut down that support thread. It clearly gives people a safe space to talk about their lives and concerns. It's eye opening for many people.

A safe space? Or is it really encouraging them to 'other' their partner?

Camperbann · 31/12/2021 11:17

Another one who thinks autistic people are selfish and incapable of empathy. Brilliant

Where have they said that? Oh they haven't and you are misinterpreting and projecting!

HereticFanjo · 31/12/2021 11:15

OP there are some really helpful posts here. People have been extremely generous and patient at explaining other perspectives here. I hope you can attempt to take them on board.

psydrive · 31/12/2021 11:13

@Caramellatteplease

I was not in validating you because of your autism.

I was saying you were invalidating other people's needs because they were in conflict with your own.

You do not want anyone to discuss negative lived experience of autism because you find it upsetting and invalidating to your sense of self.

Essentially they are not allowed to have feelings in conflict with your own needs.

Yes. That is very much a problem I've found with many people with autism. The theory of mind is not there to appreciate why they have those feelings and why they might be as important as your own.

That doesn't mean it invalidated either party's feelings, but that it is a problem of living with autism. But I'm not allowed to discuss that right?

Another one who thinks autistic people are selfish and incapable of empathy. Brilliant.
TractorAndHeadphones · 31/12/2021 11:08

@Fiftythreepercent

I have a son who has Aspergers and it infuriates me that the go to for a thread about an arse of a husband is 'is he possibly on the spectrum?

The worst thing about these posters is that the OP invariably pounces on this as the explanation for the behaviour because it then gives it a label rather than just poor behaviour. Hence the cycle continues with everyone a diagnostic expert

I personally think the partner with autism support threads are acceptable provided they are strongly moderated

Yes don’t accept any self diagnosis or armchair diagnosis nonsense
TractorAndHeadphones · 31/12/2021 11:04

@Caramellatteplease

I was not in validating you because of your autism.

I was saying you were invalidating other people's needs because they were in conflict with your own.

You do not want anyone to discuss negative lived experience of autism because you find it upsetting and invalidating to your sense of self.

Essentially they are not allowed to have feelings in conflict with your own needs.

Yes. That is very much a problem I've found with many people with autism. The theory of mind is not there to appreciate why they have those feelings and why they might be as important as your own.

That doesn't mean it invalidated either party's feelings, but that it is a problem of living with autism. But I'm not allowed to discuss that right?

Very true, this is why most threads involving autism end in a row
Fiftythreepercent · 31/12/2021 11:01

I have a son who has Aspergers and it infuriates me that the go to for a thread about an arse of a husband is 'is he possibly on the spectrum?

The worst thing about these posters is that the OP invariably pounces on this as the explanation for the behaviour because it then gives it a label rather than just poor behaviour. Hence the cycle continues with everyone a diagnostic expert

I personally think the partner with autism support threads are acceptable provided they are strongly moderated

Deisogn · 31/12/2021 10:55

I have a son and a husband who are both autistic. Those support threads were invaluable to me. Some of DH's behaviour sure can look like arsehole if you don't know he's autistic. There's no malice behind it and it comes from his inability to have theory of mind and each situation needs to be hard coded in if that makes sense. Before we had kids I just thought he was 'quirky'. Once we had kids it all started to fall apart and it was a very dark time as he really was unable to support me. It was also hugely confusing. Only when DS got his diagnosis and the paediatrician asked us to take a questionnaire did it all start to make sense.

Caramellatteplease · 31/12/2021 10:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

HypocrisyHere · 31/12/2021 10:38

@Caramellatteplease I refer you to my previous post. And stop misrepresenting what I’m saying to suit your narrative

I think your snide and patronising remark about theory of min and autism is despicable- attempting to use someone’s disability as a way to invalidate them. I’m glad it amuses you - but it absolutely minimises the every day lived experience of autistic people living in a neurotypical world.

OP posts:
Camperbann · 31/12/2021 10:36

Also I agree about ignorant comments being unacceptable, but the threads you reference aren't full of that.

Camperbann · 31/12/2021 10:35

@HypocrisyHere

What you mean is that you'd like anything referencing autism to be deleted unless it meets the self proclaimed gate keepers approval?

Trying to twist what I’ve said and come up with ridiculous comments like this is a bit pathetic.

In fact go back to my opening post where I say

Thread 1 was from a concerned parent who may have used clunky wording but was looking for support - yet she has been deleted

I would simply like to get to a stage where people are more informed about autism, it’s nuances, it’s impact on the autistic person and that they realise it’s not appropriate to talk about us in such a negative way. But equally we need to listen too.

(And btw I have been rightfully criticised for my lack of knowledge on OCD - for which I have apologised - so I am on a learning journey too. I was aghast that I’d offended people with my ignorance - I would simply like the same courtesy extended to autistic people after people make unfair and incorrect and sometimes downright offensive comments about autism)

Yes I get that and agree, but the impact on others around them is also important, and that's what you are seemingly against being discussed when actually a forum like this is one of the only spaces people feel they can. What you want is people with autism to be fully centred and anyone who offers a different perspective to be shut down unless its deemed acceptable, whatever that means. As you know autism is a wide spectrum and absolutely there isn't a one size fits all definition which is partly why it's challenging to inform people comprehensively.
HypocrisyHere · 31/12/2021 10:32

What you mean is that you'd like anything referencing autism to be deleted unless it meets the self proclaimed gate keepers approval?

Trying to twist what I’ve said and come up with ridiculous comments like this is a bit pathetic.

In fact go back to my opening post where I say

Thread 1 was from a concerned parent who may have used clunky wording but was looking for support - yet she has been deleted

I would simply like to get to a stage where people are more informed about autism, it’s nuances, it’s impact on the autistic person and that they realise it’s not appropriate to talk about us in such a negative way. But equally we need to listen too.

(And btw I have been rightfully criticised for my lack of knowledge on OCD - for which I have apologised - so I am on a learning journey too. I was aghast that I’d offended people with my ignorance - I would simply like the same courtesy extended to autistic people after people make unfair and incorrect and sometimes downright offensive comments about autism)

OP posts: