Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

MN and their approach to autism

510 replies

HypocrisyHere · 30/12/2021 10:22

I have attached two screenshots. One showing the two threads I’m watching, the other the deletion message from the first watched thread which was deleted.

The subjects of the two threads are

(1) Any ‘positive’ autism stories?
(2) Married to someone with Asperger’s: support thread 5

My confusion is that the first was deleted because “the title was not in spirit of the site” Yet thread 2 - which has (IMO) a deeply offensive as it implies all people with Asperger’s are a problem in a relationship (leaving aside the ghastly ableism within the thread) is absolutely fine?

Thread 1 was from a concerned parent who may have used clunky wording but was looking for support - yet she has been deleted. Thread 2 is for concerned partners who can blame every poor behaviour of their partners on autism and that’s all fine?

As an autistic person this makes no sense to me at all and highlights not only ableism within MNHQ but also a deeply inconsistent approach to moderation?

(Have name changed as I’m a coward)

MN and their approach to autism
OP posts:
Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 12:46

@Innocenta

MNHQ is deeply ableist. I've raised this with them before by email and even made a formal complaint, but zero progress.

I have heard that MN has a vested interest in having threads of certain topics because they benefit from them financially. No idea if this is true.

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 12:44

Yes please! Adding to this, kindness to their care givers and their families.
Some of us dedicate our lives to providing care to our loved ones, some of whom have extremely complex and severe needs. I have no bitterness because adore I my child but my god, do I have sad and angry days. Our children matter too, so do we as carers

I agree. Autism is imo mostly genetic. Two of my 4 girls are on the spectrum. One of them has very high care needs and she doesn't like speaking. Like me, her autism affects her mental health. She could be aggressive and on occasion she attacked me whilst I was driving (which I didn't attempt to do again). I always felt more sad for her than for myself because I can see how much pain she's in. She never asked for her brain to be wired this way. She's 20 now and has in the last few days stopped eating and drinking because she's upset. She's in a specialist placement now and they've managed to get her out of it thankfully.

Gilead · 31/12/2021 12:40

I tried to put a stop to the ‘married to’ stuff years ago. I was hounded and harassed and had to name change.

Cherryblossoms85 · 31/12/2021 12:39

If you look for offence, you can find it absolutely anywhere.

Innocenta · 31/12/2021 12:36

MNHQ is deeply ableist. I've raised this with them before by email and even made a formal complaint, but zero progress.

HereticFanjo · 31/12/2021 12:35

[quote Itsnotover]@HereticFanjo

I'm not saying they should ban threads about having a ND partner but they certainly should delete ableist comments.[/quote]
I don't think anyone disagrees with you in principle but you may not agree with the moderator viewpoint on what ableism actually is.

Crashdoll · 31/12/2021 12:32

”Peace to you all, happy 2022 and I hope that MN can perhaps become a place that is a little less hostile to autistic people in the next year.“

Yes please! Adding to this, kindness to their care givers and their families.
Some of us dedicate our lives to providing care to our loved ones, some of whom have extremely complex and severe needs. I have no bitterness because adore I my child but my god, do I have sad and angry days. Our children matter too, so do we as carers.

Camperbann · 31/12/2021 12:29

@HypocrisyHere

Yes and here is why there will never be a kind place for autistic people on MN.

I have been told by a neurotypical person that I am wrong to feel offended by threads titled “support thread for people married to someone with Asperger’s (as the title was the purpose of this the read). The title in itself is offensive

  1. It suggest ALL relationships with an autistic person are difficult
  2. It suggest ALL of the problems are with the autistic person (and content backs this up)
  3. It states Asperger’s but several forms of autism are referred to

The content - which admittedly I have been dragged into on this thread which was not my intention - IS offensive to many a autistic people (telling me it’s not offensive is like a white personal telling a black person what’s racist and what’s not).

It is offensive as most partners are not diagnosed
It is offensive as every bad trait is blamed on autism
It is offensive as it portrays itself as representative of ALL marriages to autistic people (evidence - the number of times I’ve seen the threads referred to as a place someone can go and see what being married to an autistic person is like and also by the comment “hopefully someone is reading this and running”)
It is offensive as autistic people are not welcome on that thread.

And in response to @Caramellatteplease who is continually suggesting I’m trying to shut down all discussions which are not positive about autism. I’m really not and I find you continually trying to gaslight me by stating this, frankly Patronising and bullying. You are trying to suggest I cannot see things clearly because of “theory of mind” and that you are not invalidating me. You are - you absolutely are. Are you telling me how You’ve made me feel is not valid? That’s ironic don’t it? I absolutely don’t expect everything to be centred on me - I’ve assorted my entire life to try to fit in to a world designed for NTs - so how dare you suggest I’m trying to make this about me. It’s completely out of order.

What I personally would find acceptable is a thread which was titled “support thread for those in difficult NT/ND relationships”

Then I think the opening post should make the following statements

  1. All partners - NT and ND - are allowed to comment
  2. No generalisations of either neurotype
  3. This is not representative of NT/ND relationships as a whole - it is on an individual basis only
  4. All responses should be civil.
  5. There should be no repetition of autistic myths such as “no empathy”, cold and unfeeling, that there is no such thing as “mild autism” and that “very high functioning” makes no sense (HFA = IQ of over 70 - not that they breeze through life with no issues)
6 all responses should be based on personal experience - and no one should state the person is wrong in feeling a certain way.

I think if these caveats were made then though I know that the content would be mainly driven by unhappy self-diagnosed NT spouses, most people will have at least been given some context and it will not be seen as a definitive description of ALL autistic partners.

But it would also be a place where those needing support can get it. And as I’ve already said, yes we can be difficult so I understand the need for discussion. (But I think - agains as already stated - that NTs also behave unacceptably and that causes problems too)

Peace to you all, happy 2022 and I hope that MN can perhaps become a place that is a little less hostile to autistic people in the next year.

Alot of that are assumptions you're making though and how you're perceiving it. Whilst of course your perception is valid, where do we draw the line? It's intent is not to suggest everyone is the same and it's a key point on the moderation of the thread. By kind do you mean nothing that I might not like? Also surely by having a thread for difficult relationships it makes it harder for people who want to to avoid these discussions? Armchair or self diagnoses are wrong on both ends- it also happens on threads where someone seeks advice about something and people chime in and say you have to put up with it as the child might have autism. Of course that is an important consideration and it's not acceptable to barge in and say whatever, but it doesn't mean things can't be addressed and people should just be kind and put up with it.
Crashdoll · 31/12/2021 12:29

These threads always go the same way. Those who have a voice do not speak for everyone with an ASC. Those who have the cognitive and neurological skills to be able to use a social media forum and formulate coherent debates are not representative of everyone.
I’ve been criticised for speaking negatively about the challenges my family faces with autism, by other people who have autism.

Whitefire · 31/12/2021 12:26

Very true, this is why most threads involving autism end in a row

I tend to avoid them, I'm either a shit parent or I am not allowed to admit I struggle because it is all about ds and his autism. I have pretty much no support in RL and online support is often unhelpful due to the first part of my post.

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 12:15

@HypocrisyHere

Yes and here is why there will never be a kind place for autistic people on MN.

I have been told by a neurotypical person that I am wrong to feel offended by threads titled “support thread for people married to someone with Asperger’s (as the title was the purpose of this the read). The title in itself is offensive

  1. It suggest ALL relationships with an autistic person are difficult
  2. It suggest ALL of the problems are with the autistic person (and content backs this up)
  3. It states Asperger’s but several forms of autism are referred to

The content - which admittedly I have been dragged into on this thread which was not my intention - IS offensive to many a autistic people (telling me it’s not offensive is like a white personal telling a black person what’s racist and what’s not).

It is offensive as most partners are not diagnosed
It is offensive as every bad trait is blamed on autism
It is offensive as it portrays itself as representative of ALL marriages to autistic people (evidence - the number of times I’ve seen the threads referred to as a place someone can go and see what being married to an autistic person is like and also by the comment “hopefully someone is reading this and running”)
It is offensive as autistic people are not welcome on that thread.

And in response to @Caramellatteplease who is continually suggesting I’m trying to shut down all discussions which are not positive about autism. I’m really not and I find you continually trying to gaslight me by stating this, frankly Patronising and bullying. You are trying to suggest I cannot see things clearly because of “theory of mind” and that you are not invalidating me. You are - you absolutely are. Are you telling me how You’ve made me feel is not valid? That’s ironic don’t it? I absolutely don’t expect everything to be centred on me - I’ve assorted my entire life to try to fit in to a world designed for NTs - so how dare you suggest I’m trying to make this about me. It’s completely out of order.

What I personally would find acceptable is a thread which was titled “support thread for those in difficult NT/ND relationships”

Then I think the opening post should make the following statements

  1. All partners - NT and ND - are allowed to comment
  2. No generalisations of either neurotype
  3. This is not representative of NT/ND relationships as a whole - it is on an individual basis only
  4. All responses should be civil.
  5. There should be no repetition of autistic myths such as “no empathy”, cold and unfeeling, that there is no such thing as “mild autism” and that “very high functioning” makes no sense (HFA = IQ of over 70 - not that they breeze through life with no issues)
6 all responses should be based on personal experience - and no one should state the person is wrong in feeling a certain way.

I think if these caveats were made then though I know that the content would be mainly driven by unhappy self-diagnosed NT spouses, most people will have at least been given some context and it will not be seen as a definitive description of ALL autistic partners.

But it would also be a place where those needing support can get it. And as I’ve already said, yes we can be difficult so I understand the need for discussion. (But I think - agains as already stated - that NTs also behave unacceptably and that causes problems too)

Peace to you all, happy 2022 and I hope that MN can perhaps become a place that is a little less hostile to autistic people in the next year.

👏👏👏

I completely agree. Many of us have quite severe mental health issues after a lifetime of trying to fit in with NT people in an NT world. Then we have a cheek to ask people not to be ableist and discriminatory because that makes it all about us?!

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 12:11

@Mabelface

I do get fucked off when shitty behaviour gets lumped in with asd and blamed, often with no diagnosis. I have asd and I'm not a twat.

Yes this is what happens. Autism is a complex condition really. Some people are cold because they have attachment disorders which are a completely different thing.

HypocrisyHere · 31/12/2021 12:09

Yes and here is why there will never be a kind place for autistic people on MN.

I have been told by a neurotypical person that I am wrong to feel offended by threads titled “support thread for people married to someone with Asperger’s (as the title was the purpose of this the read). The title in itself is offensive

  1. It suggest ALL relationships with an autistic person are difficult
  2. It suggest ALL of the problems are with the autistic person (and content backs this up)
  3. It states Asperger’s but several forms of autism are referred to

The content - which admittedly I have been dragged into on this thread which was not my intention - IS offensive to many a autistic people (telling me it’s not offensive is like a white personal telling a black person what’s racist and what’s not).

It is offensive as most partners are not diagnosed
It is offensive as every bad trait is blamed on autism
It is offensive as it portrays itself as representative of ALL marriages to autistic people (evidence - the number of times I’ve seen the threads referred to as a place someone can go and see what being married to an autistic person is like and also by the comment “hopefully someone is reading this and running”)
It is offensive as autistic people are not welcome on that thread.

And in response to @Caramellatteplease who is continually suggesting I’m trying to shut down all discussions which are not positive about autism. I’m really not and I find you continually trying to gaslight me by stating this, frankly Patronising and bullying. You are trying to suggest I cannot see things clearly because of “theory of mind” and that you are not invalidating me. You are - you absolutely are. Are you telling me how You’ve made me feel is not valid? That’s ironic don’t it? I absolutely don’t expect everything to be centred on me - I’ve assorted my entire life to try to fit in to a world designed for NTs - so how dare you suggest I’m trying to make this about me. It’s completely out of order.

What I personally would find acceptable is a thread which was titled “support thread for those in difficult NT/ND relationships”

Then I think the opening post should make the following statements

  1. All partners - NT and ND - are allowed to comment
  2. No generalisations of either neurotype
  3. This is not representative of NT/ND relationships as a whole - it is on an individual basis only
  4. All responses should be civil.
  5. There should be no repetition of autistic myths such as “no empathy”, cold and unfeeling, that there is no such thing as “mild autism” and that “very high functioning” makes no sense (HFA = IQ of over 70 - not that they breeze through life with no issues)
6 all responses should be based on personal experience - and no one should state the person is wrong in feeling a certain way.

I think if these caveats were made then though I know that the content would be mainly driven by unhappy self-diagnosed NT spouses, most people will have at least been given some context and it will not be seen as a definitive description of ALL autistic partners.

But it would also be a place where those needing support can get it. And as I’ve already said, yes we can be difficult so I understand the need for discussion. (But I think - agains as already stated - that NTs also behave unacceptably and that causes problems too)

Peace to you all, happy 2022 and I hope that MN can perhaps become a place that is a little less hostile to autistic people in the next year.

OP posts:
Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 12:05

Another thing that annoys me about those threads is the way that autistic seems to have become an explanation for 'selfish man' which it isnt!

Often these people don't even have a diagnosis and their partner has armchair diagnosed them.

Camperbann · 31/12/2021 12:01

@Itsnotover

Personally I wouldn't find a relationship fulfilling if I had to tell a partner what I felt I wanted or needed. I wouldn't assume it's them lying or not caring, but the end outcome is the same ultimately.

So, what you do is you either don't marry that person in the first place or you leave. Instead of bitching about them on the internet?

Yes I would personally, but it's more complex than that isn't it. Some women feel they can change men, some men mask whilst dating and as things change ie having a child certain behaviours etc arise that are hard to live with, if someone is head over heels with the person perhaps they do want to seek support and advice from others who have been in the same position in the hope they can get through it, and some probably have spent years and years putting their own needs second to someone else and have finally reached their breaking point.
Caramellatteplease · 31/12/2021 12:00

Another one who thinks autistic people are selfish and incapable of empathy. Brilliant

Actually I think if you look at my examples you can see it's nothing to do with empathy or selfishness. Not getting painkillers at a dentist isnt selfish, walking in front of a car is not selfish. DS will be upset if I'm upset, he will be worried if someone cries in the house.

Another example. ExDP was determined to do something nice for me. He knew it was nice and would make me happy. However in his single minded determination to do the thing he inadvertently behaved completely thoughtlessly. To the extent that I was furious, thought correctly he was hiding something (I assumed bad) and wanted to split up. He was devastated utterly paralysed by my upset, he completely shut down unable to talk ended up ill. Most NT would be able to say "hang on, I was only doing this because...." but his need to give me this secret surprise was too important to do that. He had no idea what to do about my upset, he felt it, boy did he feel it, but he couldn't resolve it without ruining something else that was meant to be happy. He couldn't balance that We survived that time . 4 months later he had his big tadaa moment. The surprise was awesome caring and brilliant. He so pleased, as if it made everything ok. But for me as much as I plastered a smile on my face, it by no means made up for the initial trauma. It was the beginning of the end for me and ironically for him too. He knew I was still upset, but didnt get why, hed done a nice thing!!!. He no long felt he understood what made me happy, he stability had been completely removed. It was utterly heartbreaking.

Balancing needs isnt about selfishness. Autism is not about selfishness.

Emerald5hamrock · 31/12/2021 11:59

Yanbu.

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:58

Personally I wouldn't find a relationship fulfilling if I had to tell a partner what I felt I wanted or needed. I wouldn't assume it's them lying or not caring, but the end outcome is the same ultimately.

So, what you do is you either don't marry that person in the first place or you leave. Instead of bitching about them on the internet?

Camperbann · 31/12/2021 11:56

@Itsnotover they might be doing the same, in that scenario though it doesn't seem unreasonable. Personally I wouldn't find a relationship fulfilling if I had to tell a partner what I felt I wanted or needed. I wouldn't assume it's them lying or not caring, but the end outcome is the same ultimately. Other people though would find that conversation and way of living great and it would work for both of them. Just as ND people are all different, so are NT people.

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:55

@HereticFanjo

I'm not saying they should ban threads about having a ND partner but they certainly should delete ableist comments.

BishopBrennansArse · 31/12/2021 11:54

@Itsnotover

The problem I have with the threads is that they reduce people to their diagnosis when autistic people are all very different from each other. The threads here reinforce stereotypes and ignorance about autism by assuming we're all the same.
This x 100000
Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:54

My mother, partner and DS all find it hard to impossible to put themselves in other people's shoes or predict or understand the consequences of their actions on others.

I can definitely understand the consequences my actions might have on others and I'm very aware of it but I can't accurately predict how others might behave.

HereticFanjo · 31/12/2021 11:52

@Itsnotover

If you want to be discriminating and ableist then you have the right to do that behind closed doors or in private Facebook groups but not on a public forum where we all have to see it and where it will hurt the feelings of people who have a disability that they never asked for.
Actually I haven't observed the behaviour you are describing but I would probably in general recommend hiding the threads if they offend you. In the same way I could hide threads where people are salivating over meat because I'm vegetarian. I wouldn't demand MN removes all meat recipes from the site. I just accept that a thread called '100 ways to cook a steak' isn't going to be for me.

There are a great many threads that cause me offence in all sorts of ways (casual classism/racist threads / antivax bollocks / looking down on poverty etc) but I don't attempt to shut them down. I might eye roll a few posts and I would certainly report anything outrageous- MNHQ are generally very on the ball in my experience. I don't believe I have the right to avoid all offence in life. If I did my life would be much more upsetting.

Itsnotover · 31/12/2021 11:51

@Camperbann

I agree people should leave if they aren't happy, which many on the thread are in the process of doing. I suspect like any other relationship many have tried to talk about it, but really someone saying I can't change y because I have autism whilst true doesn't really solve anything for the partner does it? It really just pushes the idea that people should put up with it because the person can't help it which isn't fair. And yes, I don't see the issue on an Internet forum for someone to be able to post about how a loved ones situation is affecting them, in the 'real world' its often not seen as acceptable to do so and so these spaces provide a much needed place often.

I have had partners who complain that I don't seem to understand what they want from me.

As far as empathy goes, there is a difference between not knowing how someone feels and not caring. For me it would be the former.

I have explained to partners that if they want something from me they need to tell me and I'll provide it. But they often ignore me on that point and just assume I must be lying. And that I really do know what they want but I'm pretending to not know.

How do we know the NT partners on these threads are not doing the same thing?

Deisogn · 31/12/2021 11:47

I know a hell of a lot of high functioning autistic people who would take great offence at being called disabled....but I wouldn't nor would they ask for a thread to be deleted because someone else sees it that was.

Some autistic people are disabled and some aren't. The severity of the symptoms of autism vary to such a huge degree and some have a learning disability or other diagnosis alongside their autism. Most of the discussion on Mumsnet pertains to male high functioning heterosexual partners. They obviously don't represent all autistic people.