Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Feel like my DP prefers his son to our baby

213 replies

Anonymous1238 · 29/12/2021 23:03

This is so hard to write but I just feel like my DP prefers his 10 year old son to our baby. My DP & his son have a close bond which I completely understand he’s his first born & I try so hard to be ok with it but since we had our baby 4 months ago I feel like he hasn’t really bonded with our baby and he would pick his son any day of the week over our baby. I do all the night feeds and do almost all of the looking after of our baby in the week and at the weekend. My SS stays every weekend and he sleeps in bed with his dad every weekend & I just feel like our baby gets none of her dads attention when he’s here. He’s very clingy to his dad and since we’ve had our baby together I just feel like my DP is barely interested. I was worried my SS would be jealous of the attention of our baby but it feels like the other way round I just feel sad our baby doesn’t get any attention when he’s here. They are glued to each other’s side & if I say anything I think it would cause huge offence to my DP. I know my DP loves our baby but it’s like in a different league to his son. His son often asks to stay extra nights and so more and more he would rather have his son than spend time with just me and our baby. I wouldn’t even mind as much I think if they didn’t share a bed, I miss my DP too but I just feel he would rather just be with his son. Am I wrong for feeling like this? Is there any advice any one can give?

OP posts:
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 30/12/2021 15:54

God a lot of you have very low standards for your husband's don't you. As if babies being boring is a good enough reason to opt out. Yikes.

What kind of relationship do you think the baby will have with him if this continues?

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 30/12/2021 15:51

[quote AsYouWishButtercup]@Getyourarseofffthequattro that’s why I said “that kind of attention” - as in days out, playing, long talks and presumably everything his DS gets. The baby will literally have no damage due to a lack of attention for her dad, the 10yo whose life has been turned upside down because of - and I’m just gonna say it - his selfish dad and stepmum, will be so damaged from the lack of attention[/quote]
She literally will if he carries on.... Duh

icedcoffees · 30/12/2021 15:35

@aSofaNearYou

Yes, and speaking I would agree with you - but surely you can see that this isn't like a nuclear family bringing a newborn home to care for.

That doesn't make it any more reasonable for him to leave everything to OP, if anything it makes it less.

Again, I didn't say he should do that.
Scrabblecrabapple · 30/12/2021 15:21

He was probably no help with his son when he was a baby, hence why he was single. It’s far easier to parent a ten year old playmate than a baby.

aSofaNearYou · 30/12/2021 15:14

Yes, and speaking I would agree with you - but surely you can see that this isn't like a nuclear family bringing a newborn home to care for.

That doesn't make it any more reasonable for him to leave everything to OP, if anything it makes it less.

aSofaNearYou · 30/12/2021 15:12

DP should be pulling his weight when DS isn't staying with them, but whilst he is there I do think prioritising him is fair enough given the intensity of his emotional needs. The baby isn't going to suffer emotional harm from having a more attentive mother than father in these very early months. A 10 year old in an ordinary family situation could quite happily wait a while for attention, but not in this scenario.

If he were pulling his weight the rest of the time there would at least be an argument for this, but even then... no not really. My DP made the decision to have another child, with me. He has a responsibility to me, along with his two children. If he thought his DS was going to be emotionally damaged by having to wait while he changed a dirty nappy, or settled DD while she cried, then he should not have made that choice. I'm not going to act like a lone parent when his son is around. Especially if it's every weekend and he works during the week - this would be pretty much all the time he is available to do any proper parenting.

It isn't a black and white situation and obviously there will be some compromises to be made, but expecting OP and those in her position to do it all so he can entirely focus on the SC is taking it way too far.

icedcoffees · 30/12/2021 15:12

First paragraph in that should be bolded, sorry!

icedcoffees · 30/12/2021 15:11

Generally speaking, though, it's not really reasonable for a parent to opt out of helping with a newborn in the night on the basis that they need to cosleep with a child of 10.*

Yes, and speaking I would agree with you - but surely you can see that this isn't like a nuclear family bringing a newborn home to care for.

Especially without massively compensating the rest of the time, when that child isn't around. This is something that should have been sorted out, but as it is, we just have a whole thread of people justifying this man opting out of his responsibilities as a father of a newborn baby.

I don't think anyone has said it's okay for him to opt out completely, they're just saying that it's understandable that he wants to spend extra time with him and reassure him.

The fact that he doesn't help the rest of the time is a separate issue IMO, and mixing the two problems together won't help anyone.

MabelsApron · 30/12/2021 15:02

I think the justification comes from the fact that the DS is clearly having some intense emotional issues right now - co-sleeping at 10 is unusual and bound to be related to the enormous upheaval in his life. DP should be pulling his weight when DS isn't staying with them, but whilst he is there I do think prioritising him is fair enough given the intensity of his emotional needs. The baby isn't going to suffer emotional harm from having a more attentive mother than father in these very early months. A 10 year old in an ordinary family situation could quite happily wait a while for attention, but not in this scenario.

If it were desirable to avoid this sort of situation then OP and DP needed to plan better (or at all). They didn't, and now this is the result. If the adults have to suffer a bit, and the baby has to go without both parents being available 24/7 until it's a little older, then so be it.

Needless to say I think the adults have behaved appallingly, with no consideration whatsoever for their existing children.

aSofaNearYou · 30/12/2021 14:51

IMO there's absolutely nothing wrong with a parent sleeping in with their 10yo to give them some reassurance, especially considering the circumstances OP has posted about.

This isn't the thing I primarily disagreed with about this post and the comments that have followed but I wouldn't say there's absolutely nothing wrong with it, especially on the night they return from hospital. But then I come from the perspective of a very long and complicated birth, so the idea of my DP not prioritising being there to help me through the night is just so callous and cruel. "Reassurance" paled in comparison to the needs of myself and DD.

Generally speaking, though, it's not really reasonable for a parent to opt out of helping with a newborn in the night on the basis that they need to cosleep with a child of 10. Especially without massively compensating the rest of the time, when that child isn't around. This is something that should have been sorted out, but as it is, we just have a whole thread of people justifying this man opting out of his responsibilities as a father of a newborn baby.

Justmebeingme245 · 30/12/2021 14:50

He should be focussing on both children and helping you out. If the 10 year old is feeling out of sorts, maybe include him in the baby care, do activities he will enjoy etc.
Also, he shouldn’t be sleeping in bed with a 10yo - there’s really no need for him to do so.
YANBU - in my opinion.

icedcoffees · 30/12/2021 14:44

[quote aSofaNearYou]@icedcoffees You've completely ignored the actual content of the comment I was quoting. All it said was "are you suggesting the three of you should sleep in one room the night you return from hospital while a 10 year old sleeps alone? How do you think that will make them feel?" Which is frankly just mind bogglingly odd. Of course both parents by default should sleep in the room with the baby while the 10 year old sibling sleeps in a different room, FFS.[/quote]
No, I'm not ignoring it at all. I actually think it's a very sensible comment.

IMO there's absolutely nothing wrong with a parent sleeping in with their 10yo to give them some reassurance, especially considering the circumstances OP has posted about.

aSofaNearYou · 30/12/2021 14:35

It’s right that he should focus his attention on his son in the very short period of time he spends with him every week.

If my DP thought it was acceptable to entirely focus on my DSS when he came over and ignore our DD, I'd have left him by now. His attention is , and should be, split between his two children when they are both present.

I don't know where this strange MN mentality that dad's "normally" focus entirely on the older child when a new baby is born came from, but I have never encountered any parents doing that, ever, and I'd think it very strange if I did. Sure, dad might take the older child out to do something babies make difficult now and then, but the rest of the time, both parents are involved in looking after the baby. Sometimes that might mean the older child waiting a bit for attention. All perfectly normal for a 10 year old.

aSofaNearYou · 30/12/2021 14:28

@icedcoffees You've completely ignored the actual content of the comment I was quoting. All it said was "are you suggesting the three of you should sleep in one room the night you return from hospital while a 10 year old sleeps alone? How do you think that will make them feel?" Which is frankly just mind bogglingly odd. Of course both parents by default should sleep in the room with the baby while the 10 year old sibling sleeps in a different room, FFS.

icedcoffees · 30/12/2021 14:24

What an absolutely bizarre thing to say. He's 10 years old, they usually sleep in their own rooms.

Yes, but 10 is still young enough to feel very unsettled by the arrival of a brand new baby, especially in the circumstances OP describes.

Meanwhile, it's perfectly normal for parents to sleep in the room with their newborn baby, so they can BOTH do their fair share of night wakes.

Again, you're correct, but in this scenario OP has had a baby with a relative stranger. It's totally understandable that the 10yo is unsettled and needs some extra reassurance from his dad. The situation with the 8yo isn't comparable as they live there full-time so won't feel as unsettled and pushed down.

Chasingaftermidnight · 30/12/2021 14:19

In most two-parent families, when a new baby arrives, the dad focusses his attention on the older child(ren) and the mum focusses her attention on the newborn. Your DP bedsharing with a ten year old isn’t ideal, but that’s clearly a result of the circumstances. It’s right that he should focus his attention on his son in the very short period of time he spends with him every week.

What IS unacceptable is your partner not supporting you enough with the baby during the other 5 days and nights of the week. I think you’re mentally pinning the blame for that on your stepson when it’s actually entirely your DP.

HacerSonarSusPasos · 30/12/2021 14:10

@Anonymous1238 had you known each other before you started dating? Was the baby planned?

aSofaNearYou · 30/12/2021 14:09

There are some really, really unhealthy mentalities on this thread, so many making weird excuses like "of course he finds babies boring compared to a 10 year old", "what does a baby need attention for".

This man is not a child, he is a father. He doesn't get to opt out because babies are boring compared to older kids, that's a shocking suggestion you would never, ever see outside of the context of the older child being a step child. Babies need attention because if neither parent gave it, they would literally die.

He should not be leaving everything up to OP during the week OR on the weekends when his son is there. I'm appalled by the volume of comments on this thread that seem to suggest that's totally fine.

XelaM · 30/12/2021 14:00

Any parent would prefer a 10-year-old over a baby! Babies are boring and dreadful company.

aSofaNearYou · 30/12/2021 13:57

@arethereanyleftatall

Op - are you saying you thought on the first night the three of you should have slept in one room, with your 10 yr old step son on his own in another room? How do you think that would have made him feel?
What an absolutely bizarre thing to say. He's 10 years old, they usually sleep in their own rooms. Meanwhile, it's perfectly normal for parents to sleep in the room with their newborn baby, so they can BOTH do their fair share of night wakes.

It's seriously, seriously weird to be shocked by that and turn it into an emotive thing for a 10 year old child.

SocialConnection · 30/12/2021 13:52

At ten, your DSS is on the edge of adolescence and needs his dad to help him through it as a role model especially as they don't live together.

And is it so odd that DH might actually have more in common, more fun, more communication with his growing boy than with a new baby?

It's not a competition. The baby has your full attention and DH showing his son that he's included and paid attention to is a sign of a great dad making him feel he hasn't been replaced.

Though I think nature is screaming at you to get all the attention for your baby as a survival urge, and another woman's child may feel like something of a threat to that.

Outlyingtrout · 30/12/2021 13:41

Some of the responses on here are ridiculous. A 10yo boy should not need to routinely sleep with his father and those boundaries should have been put in place from the start. A new baby is tough and dad should absolutely be helping out during the night, whether his son is there or not. He can spend plenty of time with his son 1:1 during the day. I get so fed up of the ridiculous pandering that goes on by parents who are terrified their DC will feel even a hint of rejection - if these situations are managed appropriately, they won't.

Well that’s the whole point, isn’t it? It hasn’t been managed appropriately at any stage and so people are commenting on the situation as it actually stands right now. Not how it would be had OP and her partner done things with the children’s well-being in mind. You sort of acknowledge all of this in the rest of your comment so I’m not sure why your opening line is that PPs are being ridiculous Hmm

If this couple had spent time getting to know each other, gradually developing their relationship, and slowly and cautiously introducing the children way before moving in together, and had then spent time working on blending their families together before planning a new addition - then perhaps it would be reasonable to take a stronger line with this child and place firm boundaries. But that’s not what has happened. He’s been flung into an overwhelming and unhealthy situation at lightning speed, with dad’s new girlfriend who doesn’t view him as an equal part of the family and surprise surprise both of the adults have different ideas about how to parent the kids through this mess. In the circumstances, if this little boy needs his dad to sleep with him to feel safe and secure then it’s the bloody least he can do. It’s rubbish that OP has to do the nights with the baby while the little boy is there but it’s a mess they’ve both made and what really matters is the children all having their needs met.

Flowers500 · 30/12/2021 13:32

You’ve both been incredibly irresponsible with the timelines, which means things will be more difficult for the children, and thus you’ll have to work far harder to keep things ok. It’s a result of the situation you both created.

SallyWD · 30/12/2021 13:27

My DH was much more interested in our older child when DC2 was born. He absolutely adored playing with the older child but had little interest in the baby. I understood because (to me anyway) babies are a bit boring! I think a lot of people, particularly men, bond with and enjoy their children once they're a little older. I didn't enjoy the baby stage.

Cindercat · 30/12/2021 13:26

Some of the responses on here are ridiculous. A 10yo boy should not need to routinely sleep with his father and those boundaries should have been put in place from the start. A new baby is tough and dad should absolutely be helping out during the night, whether his son is there or not. He can spend plenty of time with his son 1:1 during the day. I get so fed up of the ridiculous pandering that goes on by parents who are terrified their DC will feel even a hint of rejection - if these situations are managed appropriately, they won't. What isn't appropriate is to have a 10yo sleeping in bed with dad, especially since he doesn't do this at home with his mum. Boundaries need to be set that support all the children of the family and allow OP to feel supported by the father of her new baby. OP, I think you're in a difficult position as you don't feel able to address these parenting issues with your DP and therein lies the crux of the problem - you've had a baby with someone without talking about how parenting will work for all three of your children. It is a bit of a mess and you've both had nine months to prepare DSS for the arrival of his new sibling, help him to feel part of things and replace some unhealthy boundaries with healthier ones which will benefit DSS in the long run and ensure he feels included and supported. As it is, without having done this, you've made your lives way more difficult as PP are correct that it would be very hard on DSS to suddenly be removed from his normal sleeping arrangement and replaced by your new baby. However, I do think that you and DP need to come up together with a plan to move towards DSS sleeping in his own room. This needs to include plenty of 1:1 time with dad during the day, some family time for him to bond with his new sibling, a good bedtime routine with dad gradually withdrawing etc etc. Good luck.