Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To advise friend to ditch baby bottles, pushchair and nappies?

189 replies

feelinghappy · 29/12/2021 22:42

My friend's children who are 4 and 6 drink squash from baby bottles (during the day at home - not at school - and take bottles of squash to bed with them), wear nappies in the car (not at night) and use a Phil and Ted pushchair if we go anywhere. My son was in pullups at night until 8 so I know the battle of accidents when they sleep - it's just seeing them get ready for driving home by lying on the floor to have nappies put on felt strange. Both children have speech problems (6 year old is seeing speech and language specialist) and neither have been to a dentist. I tried to encourage them to walk today but after a few steps they were both too tired and climbed back in the buggy. The nappies and buggy do not affect their health so much as the bottles - I wonder if she'll say to me in the future 'why didn't you say I shouldn't use bottles so long?' Or should I just mind my own business?

OP posts:
massiveblob · 30/12/2021 10:21

OP a friend of mine had similar. They used a method where he had to drink gallons in the day & train his bladder / brain reaction. He bed wet lots until age 9. Really hard going. I think it's more common in boys

x2boys · 30/12/2021 10:20

@massiveblob

At our v large primary a few years back one mum used a pushchair for reception child. Never seen anyone else do it as catchment is less than 3/4 mile. She did it to stop him moaning on the ten minute walk home. Everyone used to comment behind her back that it was very odd. Might be wrong but it's true. The child is older now but never ever plays out and is the most unsporty child ever & has no coordination / balance. All prob linked. People do judge.
That's very unpleasentbif the other parents ,did it ever occur to any of you there might have been a reason ,why the child could only walk short distances and is now unsporty , uncoordinated etc?
viques · 30/12/2021 10:19

@Cheeeeislifenow

You should mind your business unless she asks for your opinion.
It could be that your friend is your friend because she feels comfortable in your company because you havent given her unasked for advice or commented on the way she parents her children. I am pretty sure that other people will have made remarks, raised eyebrows, whispered behind her back etc etc. Unless she lives in a vacuum she will be aware of the way children develop and will be aware that hers are not making the expected progress in many areas. Just carry on being her friend until she asks you to be her advisor.
Newyearnewme2022 · 30/12/2021 10:19

My dd did the school run in a buggy until she was 6, we lived remotely and school was a 30 minute walk away through country lanes.
I would keep out of it, if services are involved the nappies, bottles and buggy will be brought up.
Contrary to the poster saying buggy use is linked to being uncoordinated my now adult dd is a professional sportswoman.

massiveblob · 30/12/2021 10:12

At our v large primary a few years back one mum used a pushchair for reception child. Never seen anyone else do it as catchment is less than 3/4 mile. She did it to stop him moaning on the ten minute walk home. Everyone used to comment behind her back that it was very odd. Might be wrong but it's true. The child is older now but never ever plays out and is the most unsporty child ever & has no coordination / balance. All prob linked.
People do judge.

feelinghappy · 30/12/2021 10:08

I'm glad my other friend gave me advice but as others have pointed out I sought that advice so it wasn't judgemental. I don't believe the children are neglected or in danger of harm. There were just moments yesterday when I thought to myself should I say anything? I made them drinks with lunch in cups which they drank but when they started to get upset (later that afternoon - arguing with each other) they were given bottles of juice so it is being used as a comforter. But she has never mentioned it being difficult moving them from a bottle so it has never come up in conversation.

OP posts:
KeyWorker · 30/12/2021 10:06

I think of the 6 year old has a general developmental delay then I can see why she’d be treating the 4 year old the same. She may not know what is usual development and what is part of the delay.
The fact that she doesn’t send baby bottles to school indicates that she is well aware it’s not usual for children of that age to use them. Using a baby bottle should be stopped at 12-18 months.

feelinghappy · 30/12/2021 09:53

The children's teeth seem fine. School made a s&l referral. The children are clean and well looked after and clearly adore their mum. I mentioned my son as it was tough on him wearing a pull up at night (he hated them) but he wet the bed every night until he was 10. I sought help from HV from when he was 5 but they kept saying not to worry 'it happens to lots of children' - the sheets were soaked through every morning. Then on advice from a friend (not this one) tried a bed alarm which eventually worked - it was exhausting but we got there. The bottles are cleaned but now discoloured from the juice in them - my friend has aways said 'they love their juice just like me' - the eldest used to take two bottles with her to bed to have at night but now only has one in the evening. So it is getting better. Neither of my children had bottles and yet one of them has always had problems with his teeth whereas the other has been fine plus we've just had to pay for braces 😬. Watching your child have a filling is awful 😖

OP posts:
SpellBounds · 30/12/2021 09:42

@Cheeseycheeseycheesecheese

I don't think she'd blame you for not passing comment in the future. Everyone does something others find odd.

I did think bottles were supposed to go by 18 months and be replaced by cups. is this true though? Sorry to derail slightly, ds is 2.5 and still has a bottle of milk at bedtime and a bottle when he wakes up. Cups all day otherwise, should I be stopping this?

2.5? Yes its bad for their teeth and isn't necessary. He could have a sippy cup of milk instead. Or normal cup better still.
GoodPrincessWenceslas · 30/12/2021 09:27

How can you say they have no SEN when one is already being seen by a speech and language specialist? It really is quite difficult to get referrals to them, you know.

RoyalFamilyFan · 30/12/2021 09:19

@DeepaBeesKit

I was amazed at the number of parents at our school taking reception children home in a pushchair after a 3 hour morning at the start of term. Cooing "oh they're so tired and they're just babies really aren't they"Hmm. We live in a village where all the children live within a ten minute walk of the school!! These kids are 4 and 5, they are not babies. It's not true that all kids will insist on walking at 4 & 6. Plenty can't be bothered to walk and will happily sit bone idle in a pram if given the choice.
This!! Some kids are still treated like babies when they are not babies.
DeepaBeesKit · 30/12/2021 09:04

To the outside world dd is a perfectly fit and healthy 8 year old. However due to complex health issues and meds she suggested painful muscle fatigue. She cannot play out for hours or walk miles without it causing crippling pain. Therefore if it has been bad or she has done lots of exercise then I still use a pushchair for her. She has recently had covid. It has left her with chronic fatigue. We went to a local attraction on Monday. She sat in the pushchair most of the day.

I'm quite surprised whatever health professional your daughter is under hasnt suggested/provided a wheel chair. A friend had similar with their child & the occupational therapists said a wheelchair was important in terms of her peers not perceiving her as a baby etc.

DeepaBeesKit · 30/12/2021 08:57

I was amazed at the number of parents at our school taking reception children home in a pushchair after a 3 hour morning at the start of term. Cooing "oh they're so tired and they're just babies really aren't they"Hmm. We live in a village where all the children live within a ten minute walk of the school!! These kids are 4 and 5, they are not babies. It's not true that all kids will insist on walking at 4 & 6. Plenty can't be bothered to walk and will happily sit bone idle in a pram if given the choice.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 30/12/2021 08:53

FWIW my dd2 was still having drinks out of bottles at 3, and her adult teeth (she’s long grown up) were always perfect. She used a dummy until well after 3, too.

Emerald5hamrock · 30/12/2021 08:48

You know your friend and have a better idea of the set-up.
Is the house chaos? Is she drinking or on drugs? Are the DC receiving regular a regular meal in a warm home? Are they hygienically looked after.
If you feel there's more than SN then talk to her about their milestones gentle.

Blueeilidh · 30/12/2021 08:39

If the children are only out in nappies to go in the car, this would suggest they have been taught to use the toilet but the car is an issue. This could potentially just be laziness in not wanting to stop but it could also point to a medical issue. My daughter frequently wets in the car. She has problems with muscle control and delayed speech means she doesn't tell us if she needs the toilet or is wet in the car and possibly the vibrations and movement of the car stimulate peeing.

Starlightstarbright1 · 30/12/2021 05:31

Are they in nappies at school? Do they drink out of cups at school?

I would be tempted if wanted to intervene by a disney or other style cup with a straw.

We don't know enough to know Sn or bad parenting.

HappyMeal564 · 30/12/2021 05:20

Not shaming you but you have said your 8 year old was in pull ups, some would find this a bit old but that's where you and your child were, this is where she is with her kids right now. She's getting external help and they will be able to identify anythingthat the children need extra help with, I don't think it's your responsibility to say what she should do with her kids or to try make them walk, and if she blames you for not telling her she's a bit of a cop out.

Tableto · 30/12/2021 02:54

@RoyalFamilyFan

But on MN everything is down to SEN and neglect/poor parenting can never be a reason.
Yep, and mind your business, but then on other threads why did no one say something Hmm
Rangoon · 30/12/2021 02:54

Mine had bottles for far longer than a year. They are both at university now - ones a postgraduate - so I don't think it was particularly crucial. They never had a bottle in the cot with them and they always had water in the bottle before bed to rinse out any residual milk. If they had fruit juice in a bottle, that too was followed up with water to get rid of the acid on their teeth. They never ever had squash though. Do you think she ever cleans their teeth? Mind you, you should probably not clean immediately after squash as the tooth will not have mineralised back at that point.

OutIsay · 30/12/2021 02:43

I would just encourage her to sign them up to a dentist. They will then advise against the juice in bottles.
Phrase it as getting them in with an NHS dentist when they are young and then they are on the list (it can be really hard to get one as an adult). Mention that child dental treatment is free.

Londonr · 30/12/2021 01:58

@Jobseeker19

But the children don't wear nappies in school or use a bottle. So how is this the same as a child with additional needs?
It could be because it's a different setting. My son is scared of the toilet at school. But he's started to use it now. Just when there's not many other children. He used to hold his wee all day. He will only wee in the toilet at home but you can see He's scared . He has a potty for older children for when he needs to poo as he won't sit on the proper toilet . It could be possible the child is not drinking at school.
greenteafiend · 30/12/2021 01:53

MNers do seem to be a bit addicted to "minding their own business" even with what are supposed to be close friends.

Generally speaking, I ignore parenting styles that are different from mine, but some of what the OP describes is actually really bad, especially letting the kids drink squash out of bottles all day.

If these are friends, the OP would surely be aware if there were special needs?

I would broach the subject tactfully, giving room for the friend to explain if there is a special reason why these things are done. A friend should surely be OK with explaining to another friend if there are SNs.

By the way, I used to take a buggy with us until our daughter was about 4.5, but that is because we do not have a car and our days out require insane amounts of walking. She still did plenty of walking. It does not sound like this is the OP's friend's situation.

ASandwichNamedKevin · 30/12/2021 01:42

I disagree with the mind your own business remarks, but would firstly offer support if the person is actually a friend, and report concerns if not and leave it to the professionals to offer support, as they'll be privy to more information.

If children are being neglected they need someone to speak up for them. Never having been to the dentist is neglectful.
The rest you don't know the full story but I'd not just do nothing.

Jobseeker19 · 30/12/2021 01:38

But the children don't wear nappies in school or use a bottle. So how is this the same as a child with additional needs?