Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To advise friend to ditch baby bottles, pushchair and nappies?

189 replies

feelinghappy · 29/12/2021 22:42

My friend's children who are 4 and 6 drink squash from baby bottles (during the day at home - not at school - and take bottles of squash to bed with them), wear nappies in the car (not at night) and use a Phil and Ted pushchair if we go anywhere. My son was in pullups at night until 8 so I know the battle of accidents when they sleep - it's just seeing them get ready for driving home by lying on the floor to have nappies put on felt strange. Both children have speech problems (6 year old is seeing speech and language specialist) and neither have been to a dentist. I tried to encourage them to walk today but after a few steps they were both too tired and climbed back in the buggy. The nappies and buggy do not affect their health so much as the bottles - I wonder if she'll say to me in the future 'why didn't you say I shouldn't use bottles so long?' Or should I just mind my own business?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 30/12/2021 11:42

I wonder if she'll say to me in the future 'why didn't you say I shouldn't use bottles so long?'

Of course you don’t actually wonder this.

Butt out.

piney07 · 30/12/2021 11:42

It’a completely baffling that after everyone saying that people need to speak out, if they see something say something, that OP is being told to mind her own business. Confused

OP surely you can ask about the bottles and buggy in a curious way that doesn’t feel like criticism, just to get some more understanding about whether there are genuine reasons or whether she needs more support?

Hospedia · 30/12/2021 11:42

I work in an ARB with teenagers with SEND and there’s a few students that don’t need to be there but their parents are convinced that they need to be.

If they have a place then they have met the qualifying criteria for it and so do need to be there, LA won't fund specialist places for children who don't need specialist placement (and usually won't fund them for children who do either). I hope none of your pupils know how dismissive you are of their difficulties.

Qwertykeys · 30/12/2021 11:38

Next time you are with her maybe just ask her , just casually why the need for the nappies and buggy. There may be Sen issues or she's just not letting them grow up.

GrandmasCat · 30/12/2021 11:37

Honestly, I cannot imagine 4-6 year olds being able to climb on a normal size buggy unless it is one made to carry disabled children, especially in school years when kids want not to be seen as “babies”.

From what you say, it looks like these kids are disabled but your friends has not disclosed the full extent of their disability to you.
Besides, you wouldn’t be breaking any news to her, I’m sure the school is already on the case.

RoyalFamilyFan · 30/12/2021 11:35

@panicpidgeon

My five year old would happily go in a buggy if we let him so not sure about all the comments about normal four year olds not wanting that!
I totally agree.
KCee30 · 30/12/2021 11:34

I think you should stay out of it and mind your own business. It's easy for someone to judge from the outside.

RoyalFamilyFan · 30/12/2021 11:34

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER yes there can be a snob element. But dentists say clearly that bottles and dummies beyond a certain age, especially bottles at night or with juice in, increases the risk of dental decay. This does not mean every child will get it. Just as every child raised by parents smoking heavily on the house do not develop asthma. But it increases the risks and should be avoided.

panicpidgeon · 30/12/2021 11:32

My five year old would happily go in a buggy if we let him so not sure about all the comments about normal four year olds not wanting that!

RoyalFamilyFan · 30/12/2021 11:29

I agree that not all young kids want to walk. For every toddler who wants to walk really slowly rather than sit in a buggy, there are kids who never want to walk and just sit in the buggy. Some parents do not encourage their child to move onto the next stage.
A referral to SALT could be because of an underlying SN. It also could be because of deleted speech due to sucking from bottles far beyond a normal age.
I think the suggestion to let the safeguarding lead at school know, is a good one.

guardiansofthegalaxychocs · 30/12/2021 11:29

My son was in a buggy until fairly late because he is hyper mobile and easily tired. They didn’t diagnose it for ages though. All I knew was he couldn’t do it.
That age is peak “somethings different but we don’t have diagnosis age”. I’d assume it’s SEN or disability and wouldn’t say anything.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 30/12/2021 11:26

[quote toomuchlaundry]@londonrach do you clean her teeth afterwards. The problem with bottles I think is that the liquid pools round the teeth and can damage them.[/quote]
And does it not ‘pool’ if they use a cup? A lot of children have a habit of swilling whatever it is rounds their mouths anyway.

I’m old enough to remember when dummies were very much frowned upon in many circles - regarded as very much a ‘common’ or lower class thing. IMO the same probably applied/still applies to bottles for toddlers or older children.
When I had my two (long ago now) the advice was to stop bottles by 9 months and wean on to a cup. I dare say there was a ‘snob’ element to that, too.

As per my pp, a dd (now,long grown up) was still having drinks in a bottle - often (shock horror!) Ribena, at 3, and her teeth have always been perfect.

TreeLawney · 30/12/2021 11:25

Treating children in a developmentally inappropriate way is a form of abuse.

Of course if the dc do have sn then despite their chronological ages they may be being treated in a way that is perfectly appropriate for their development.

But just going from their age, they aren’t.

Personally I may contact their school and ask to talk to safeguarding lead. They may not be aware of pushchair, bottles etc if it all happens at home not school. It could be useful information for them and they will be able to decide what (if any) further support is required for the family.

ddl1 · 30/12/2021 11:25

It's not true that all kids will insist on walking at 4 & 6. Plenty can't be bothered to walk and will happily sit bone idle in a pram if given the choice.

Are they active at home? Some children will run around for hours at home, barefoot or in socks, but dislike walking outdoors in shoes. In some cases it's because the shoes are uncomfortable or not an ideal fit; in other cases it may be that the children are just not used to spending much time outdoors, especially if they spent a lot of time at home during lockdown.

If they aren't active anywhere at all, then it's more worrying.

Gonnagetgoing · 30/12/2021 11:21

Lots of parents do these and more for various reasons. My nephew at 3.5 still sleeps with his DM a lot (probably because she’s put him in nursery every day 8-5) and when they go on walks he prefers to be carried or piggy backed but then he is a threenager. Would never dare to say anything! Their child their choices.

ddl1 · 30/12/2021 11:18

If you are close to her, I think that you could perhaps suggest that they need to see a dentist (especially the 6-year-old, who will be beginning to get their permanent teeth) and that taking squash bottles to bed is probably not great for their teeth; could the squash be replaced by water?

For the rest, I think it's not really your business. I suspect that they do have some sort of special needs - after all, they wouldn't be getting SALT for no reason - and that she may not be telling you everything about it, or may not have a full diagnosis yet. It is NOT typical for children this age to become tired after walking a few steps. If they don't have special needs, then they'll soon solve the problem themselves by rebelling - what school-age child actually wants to be pushed around in a buggy in front of everyone, if they can manage the walk? - and you need do nothing..

toomuchlaundry · 30/12/2021 11:06

@londonrach do you clean her teeth afterwards. The problem with bottles I think is that the liquid pools round the teeth and can damage them.

appleturnovers · 30/12/2021 11:03

Mention ONCE that drinking juice from a bottle is much worse for their teeth than drinking it from an open cup.

Then she's got the information and she can decide what to do with it. She might not know, and might be grateful for the heads up. But if you kept on about it then she probably wouldn't want to be your friend anymore...

Marvellousmadness · 30/12/2021 11:01

Madness

Yeah. Do point it out! These poor kids!!!

And if she doesnt listen .... and....lets face it.. she wont...then you need to let it go. Or find different friends.

She sounds like she needs some help

londonrach · 30/12/2021 10:57

@Cheeseycheeseycheesecheese. My daughter is five and still has a bottle of milk at night. She drinks out of a cup all day. I've spoken to my friends and all their children same age has bottle at night. Saying that I'm on the verge of throwing them as we forgetting them so forcing her to drink out of a cup. My daughter teeth is perfect and no problems with her speech and she very bright five year old.

Sally872 · 30/12/2021 10:52

Is your friend especially sheltered or unobservant? If not she must know most children don't use bottles, nappies and buggies at this age.

Is she an attentive mum generally? Then I wouldn't expect the nappies to be to avoid cleaning up an accident. It doesn't really seem like a lazy option anyway as must be some job pushing children of that age in buggy.

Speech and language can be first step on path to diagnosing sen. I suspect there may be more going on than you realise.

Emerald5hamrock · 30/12/2021 10:44

The children's teeth seem fine. School made a s&l referral. The children are clean and well looked after and clearly adore their mum.
Then they're not being neglected, possibly delayed due too babyish upbringing, then again most DC want walks and a runaround I suspect they're not reaching milestones because there is a problem not their DM.

WonderfulYou · 30/12/2021 10:32

Like some others on here, I'm astounded at the responses "mind your own business". So many asumptions that the children have SEN or autism.

Is that the get out of jail card? Just make that assumption and you will absolve yourself of any responsibilities.

Unfortunately this is more common than people realise. I work in an ARB with teenagers with SEND and there’s a few students that don’t need to be there but their parents are convinced that they need to be.

One family in particular had their children strapped in wheelchairs saying they couldn’t walk. It was only when the school got hold of their medical records they found that this wasn’t true and now as teens they’ve come to us but their years in the wheelchair means they struggle to walk very far.

Over the last few months there have been plenty of threads discussing why if people have concerns they don’t report them yet most people on here have said to mind their business.

As they’re at school I don’t think they need reporting as I’m sure school would do that but they absolutely should be kept a close eye on by OP.

massiveblob · 30/12/2021 10:25

@x2boys she told everyone she couldn't be bothered making him walk. Her elder one walked the journey: he's 4 years older. The child has no SN and is very bright

bobsholi · 30/12/2021 10:23

It might be worth talking to her about it and finding out what's going on. Maybe she needs some support as the longer this goes on the harder it will be to stop. I had a friend who put her 6 year old in nappies because she couldn't be bothered to take him to the toilet when we went out! Our friendship ended because I couldn't keep my mouth shut about it, but I don't regret trying to stand up for that poor child.