Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She was 42?! I’m 44

336 replies

AmIoldbutdontrealiseit · 29/12/2021 22:42

Shirley Valentine. Sat watching it on Channel 5, obviously seen it before but when very young so it didn’t have quite the same impact.
Cannot believe she was 42, I’ve just turned 44 and whilst I don’t feel young, I’m surely not frumpy and middle aged, pretty as she was, if you know what I mean?
The anorak wearing, egg and chip making and very mumsy, almost grandma feel?
I realise it was set in the 80’s but is it that we look/act younger now, or that we’re really middle aged and frumpy but don’t realise it 😬
In comparison, I have a 3 year old Dd, a career, live abroad, have longer hair, wear converse, parka and Gucci bag (just example today’s outfit) use Instagram, have many interests. My life is mainly centred around Dd so isn’t wild as in before, clubbing, festivals, travelling etc…but..is this what my age is really like inside?

Hope that made sense 🤣

OP posts:
Buddywoo · 30/12/2021 09:19

I am the same age as Pauline Collins and remember thinking she was frumpy in the film the first time I watched it. She was meant to be and then she blossomed.

Each generation thinks previous generations looked old and were frumpy. It will happen to you.

HaggisBurger · 30/12/2021 09:17

I watched it a few months ago with my new bf (I’m 46 and recently out of a 21 year marriage). I had the same reaction as you @AmIoldbutdontrealiseitwas I staggered she was that age - tho she did look great! (Once she got to Greece lol). I’d gone to Greece in the summer too recently single and has a few Shirley V comments from friends. The previous summer - also in Greece on my own with kids and not yet single but realising things were heading that way - I had an offer of a night swim with a lovely Greek waiter. Which made my teenage girls laugh. Passed by that SV moment sadly …
It’s a great movie I think.

BlondeDogLady · 30/12/2021 09:11

I’m now 51. I have a 10 year old and a teen and a full time job. And I drive about 250 miles a week. A very different time

It's all relative though, isn't it? I am just 52. My children are 24 & 23. I could retire in 3 years with a good works pension. But I certainly don't feel old. When me and DH retire we are going to travel loads.

snapsieplopp · 30/12/2021 09:09

Tbf 18 yr olds still probably think "we" look old.

Lovemusic33 · 30/12/2021 09:06

I can’t remember my grandmother not looking like a grandmother despite her being not much older than I am now when I was a small child, she was probably late 40’s when I can first remember going over there, she always wore typical granny clothes and blue rinsed permed hair, would wear a head scarf if we left the house and carry a beige granny bag. She’s now 96 and her fashion hasn’t changed much 🤣.

I’m 40 in a few weeks and closes myself as quite young looking, I go to the gym, I paddleboard and my wardrobe contains a mixture of trendy (and quirky) clothes. I do see some people my age and think “they look much older than me” but maybe I’m just blind and can’t see (or feel) that I’m getting old?

CharityDingle · 30/12/2021 09:05

Oh I so love Shirley Valentine! Went to see the play earlier this year, it was very good too.

bizboz · 30/12/2021 09:05

The fashions back then were really ageing! I look back at photos of my mother when she was my age (41) and she looks a lot older!

Agree. My Mum was in her late 30s/early 40s in the 80s. If you look at photos her face is very youthful and she has great skin but the hair and fashion is aging. Those layered perms that virtually every woman over 30 had. It also seemed to be normal to dress "older", especially if you have kids. My Mum thinks I dress too young for someone in my 40s (it's not like I'm going round in hotpants or crop tops!) and keeps buying me clothing that - to me anyway - looks frumpy.

JinglingHellsBells · 30/12/2021 09:02

@YippieKayakOtherBuckets We are saying the same thing.

Comedycook · 30/12/2021 08:59

I'm 40. I have a photo of mum at her 40th birthday party on my wall. My DC couldn't believe she was the same age as me in the picture. I think it was the hairstyle...she had short typical middle aged woman hair of the 1980s/90s...mine is long.

ravenmum · 30/12/2021 08:58

How would the film have worked if she'd felt young and fresh and had no need to be reminded that she was sexy by a dodgy Greek bloke?
I haven't seen this one - is it any good? - but recently watched "Bread and Tulips" with Bruno Ganz, which sounds like the same plot.

UserBot99 · 30/12/2021 08:57

It's true that generally women did accept ageing younger @BoudecaBains that's not an insult to you, none of us have seen you! But generally this was the case.

One example of this is the signals women send out. The ''rule'' was that you got your hair cut short after a certain age and women just won't do that now, if their hair looks good, they're not going to cut it. Or, if they don't think short hair would suit them any better, they don't do it.

Daisy38 · 30/12/2021 08:55

Bernard Hill as Joe was 45 back in 1989 and he seems much older than DH who will be 47 soon. I guess everyone just seemed older in their 40s back then whereas now there seems to be much less of a distinction between various ages and stages in life.

Latenightreader · 30/12/2021 08:46

A few years ago I reread the Railway Children and was horrified to discover that Perks the Porter celebrated his 30th birthday. I kept thinking 'I'm older than Perks!' but when I reached the film I was relieved to see that Bernard Cribbins' Perks was older - 40 maybe?

One of the shocks of being an adult: characters you think of as old (or older) turning out to be younger than me!

CaptainMyCaptain · 30/12/2021 08:41

@2022newname

In the 80’s even 20 year olds looked a bit frumpy thanks to the fashion. Also I believe that Pauline Collins was more like 48 when it was filmed.
All those frumpy rara skirts and big hair?

I think she was meant to look frumpy because of the life she'd been leading that's why going to Greece had such an effect on her and she realised what she'd been missing.

Stormbraver99 · 30/12/2021 08:39

I can see where you are coming from.
I'm 46 now, and think back to when my Mum was the same age (a scary thought in itself!). So I'd have been 17 when she was 46.
She had short permed hair. I have long straight hair.
That's probably about the only thing that stands out to be fair, but at the time I just saw her as older than I perceive myself to be now.
Difficult to explain really.

I also think back to teachers I had in primary school and realise they were actually a lot younger than I thought they were at the time. Most of them who I perceived then as "middle aged" were actually several years younger than I am now.

Plumedenom · 30/12/2021 08:38

To your kids, you look as old as her. Tough love.

queenofarles · 30/12/2021 08:34

I couldn’t believe that Sally Field and Dolly Parton both were 42-43 when they filmed steel Magnolias , they just looked so old compared to women in their 40s now .
And I remember watching twin peaks and thinking they can’t be teens, and then I did some search and it turns out they were all indeed 19 or 20, they just looked so old, the only person who looked young was Peggy Lipton who was 44 at that time, but didn’t have a heavy late 80s makeup or stiff aging hair cut ,
So it must be the fashion and makeup.
But I also think we generally look healthier and younger now due to our lifestyle.

ChessieFL · 30/12/2021 08:27

I’ve often though this watching 80s sitcoms. For example Ever Decreasing Circles - they’re all meant to be in their 40s but dress like they’re in their 60s.

Loudestcat14 · 30/12/2021 08:22

Jinglinghellsbells I very much was around and it’s how all the women in my family over the age of 40 dressed - and some younger too! My Nan was 45 then and had her hair set every week in her kitchen by a mobile hairdresser and her friends did the same.

jesuistot · 30/12/2021 08:15

People looked older in the past. There have been discussions about it on twitter and similar where people have shared photos of their grandparents in their 20s or 30s and they look so old.

Crackingowlsanctuary · 30/12/2021 08:09

I was just watching Seinfeld on Netflix yesterday and thinking how they all look older than they are meant to be (men and women!). I think they are supposed to be early/mid 30’s(?) but they look more like late 40s (or 40’s at least!)… it’s the fashion/hair/make-up I think.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 30/12/2021 08:08

@JinglingHellsBells

I think you have to blame the author of the play - Willy Russell.

She wasn't typical of most women in their 40s, in the early 80s.

In that era, I was roughly 10 years younger than she was in the film.

I cam assure you that the way she was portrayed as a 42 year old was not typical.

You need to focus on the 'message' of the film (it was originally a stage play) and ignore the fashions. It's more about a 2nd chance in midlife and a woman worn down by a boring husband, who wants to live a little. She could be any age. Russell just happened to make her 42 (and that says more about his attitude to women than anything.)

He made Rita twenty-six. Absolutely nothing to do with his 'attitude to women' and everything to do with his examination of the ways in which social expectations of working-class women left them trapped and unfulfilled. It's in absolutely everything he wrote, from Our Day Out onwards. Sometimes they get out (Shirley, Rita, possibly Linda from Stags & Hens) and sometimes they don't (Carol in Our Day Out, Mrs Johnstone and Linda in Blood Brothers).
PartyPrawnRingGames · 30/12/2021 08:03

www.distractify.com/p/aging-faster-in-past
People did age faster in the past, as well as the ageing effect of wearing what are old fashioned styles to us now.
I agree with a pp who said the whole point of the story was that she had fallen into a boring rut and grown old before her time and how she transformed. But there is also a change in how people are expected to look at a certain age and I think 40s is now seen as more youthful than it was in terms 1980s.

JinglingHellsBells · 30/12/2021 08:03

@Loudestcat14

I think this every time I watch SV! I think it’s the clothes and hair. Women in their 40s in the Seventies/Eighties generally didn’t wear their hair long or wear jeans - it was all set perms and elasticated waists! I actually shuddered when I saw in the Sunday Times Style section this week that Eighties’ thin eyebrows are making a comeback - they’re SO ageing!
Were you around at that time? I was and can assure you that women did wear jeans and didn't all have perms.

I think everyone has to take what is on a film with a large pinch of salt.
You need to accept that some aspects of life can be exaggerated on film to make a point.

They needed to make her dowdy to show how she was at the time in her marriage/ life and how she could change it all.

MichaelAndEagle · 30/12/2021 08:02

When my mum was 40, the age I am now, she and most of her friends had cut her hair off short.
I think the invention of ghds etc has made it much easier to maintain a longer but still 'grown up' hair do.
When I look back a generation further my grandparents look much much older in their early 40s than we do now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread