Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She was 42?! I’m 44

336 replies

AmIoldbutdontrealiseit · 29/12/2021 22:42

Shirley Valentine. Sat watching it on Channel 5, obviously seen it before but when very young so it didn’t have quite the same impact.
Cannot believe she was 42, I’ve just turned 44 and whilst I don’t feel young, I’m surely not frumpy and middle aged, pretty as she was, if you know what I mean?
The anorak wearing, egg and chip making and very mumsy, almost grandma feel?
I realise it was set in the 80’s but is it that we look/act younger now, or that we’re really middle aged and frumpy but don’t realise it 😬
In comparison, I have a 3 year old Dd, a career, live abroad, have longer hair, wear converse, parka and Gucci bag (just example today’s outfit) use Instagram, have many interests. My life is mainly centred around Dd so isn’t wild as in before, clubbing, festivals, travelling etc…but..is this what my age is really like inside?

Hope that made sense 🤣

OP posts:
billy1966 · 30/12/2021 10:07

Loved that movie.

"Educating Rita" is another movie around that time, similar theme, really enjoyable, though very of its time.

CounsellorTroi · 30/12/2021 10:06

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry

Remember we’ve only really been big on spf for the last couple of decades or so. sun ageing will be a big factor in how much older people looked in years gone by.
And most people don’t smoke any more. In the past everybody did and it is ageing and bad for your skin.
sashh · 30/12/2021 10:03

I think a lot of women did age early.

For most you lefts school, got a job, found a mate, married, gave up work to look after the house, husband and children.

I can remember looking through a clothes catalogue and my mum saying, "oh that would be nice, for someone young, not for me"

This would have been in the 80s so she might have been early 40s.

I remember her telling a friend that she hadn't been in touch with for a while that she spent her 40th birthday crying.

I spent my 40th in London, having fun and drinking far too much.

My mother also used to talk about my grandmother being a '10 shilling widow', my grandmother was widowed before she was 40 (or maybe 50) so didn't get a full 'widow's pension' so had to work, my mother thought this was scandalous.

SFisnotsimple · 30/12/2021 10:01

[quote ravenmum]en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dad_bod[/quote]
Yea fair point but not as common parlance as slagging off middle aged women.

ravenmum · 30/12/2021 10:00

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dad_bod

SFisnotsimple · 30/12/2021 09:54

@namechanged221

Apparently converse are the new 'mum boots'

I learned this on a S&B thread!

That's not a good thing btw

I know this is meant well but this sort of thing really pisses me off.

So fed up of older women/mums being looked down on. The whole Karen thing, side swipes at looking "mumsy" etc is so damaging to women. Men aren't criticised for looking "dadsy".

Bluntness100 · 30/12/2021 09:51

The whole point of the story is she was old and frumpy, before her time, hemmed in, the put upon wife.

In forty years folks will think forty year olds look old. Because the look today will become dated.

I recall my step grandmother, tall slim woman, very lady like dressing like hyacinth, short bouffant styled grey hair, I now know she was only in her forties at that stage, she looked more like a woman in her seventies now.

However my own grandmother kept her hair dyed brown till she died in her eighties, wore hairpieces to thicken it that were undetectable, wore pencil skirts and chiffon or silk blouses, did she look younger, I don’t think she did, as a child or teenager we think anyone over the age of forty looks ancient.

senorafridgidaire · 30/12/2021 09:49

I think times are different now - my DM retired just after 50, and acted like and referred to herself as an 'old lady' from then on. I'm pretty much the same age now and struggle to even consider myself middle aged, I still feel young even though I know my colleagues in their 20s don't think I am!

Jessie75 · 30/12/2021 09:45

@Gloriagayn

Perms are to blame for me. Everyone had one
This is deeply concerning to me as I have naturally curly hair and I do get the reaction whenever I have it straightened at the hairdressers that I look 10 years younger it’s very upsetting
BlondeDogLady · 30/12/2021 09:45

godmum56 Thu 30-Dec-21 09:38:05

I don't know anybody who has botox

I suspect that you do, it's just that most people won't offer up that information! I was having a drink recently with 2 neighbours and one commented how we were all looking quite good for our age (for context, I am 52, they are 46 & 42), so I just said "well, I have botox", and then they both said "so do I". No one has ever mentioned this before and we have been neighbours for years. It's not obvious either, because it's been done really well.

Gloriagayn · 30/12/2021 09:44

Perms are to blame for me. Everyone had one

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 30/12/2021 09:44

Converse parka you say?

OK, case closed.

EdenFlower · 30/12/2021 09:41

The thing is, Pauline Collins was almost 50 in 1989 when she filmed Shirley Valentine, not 42! She's a very attractive woman, but she looks her age, not 42!

BarkminsterBlue · 30/12/2021 09:40

@BlondeDogLady

Let's not forget Botox is rife now, but it wasn't available back then. Me and almost all of the women I know have Botox.
You aren't typical. Far more widespread are fewer people smoking and more people wearing SPF.
nineteensixy · 30/12/2021 09:38

Maybe we were just less superficial back then? I don't think people dressed for 'image' as much in those days. One of the big changes of the last 20 years is that many of us now spend an inordinate amount of time and energy wondering how we look to other people, and seeing ourselves through a camera lens, because social media means we could be photographed almost any time. If women from previous generations look 'frumpy', maybe they just spent less of their time worry about what others thought about their appearance.

godmum56 · 30/12/2021 09:38

@BlondeDogLady

Let's not forget Botox is rife now, but it wasn't available back then. Me and almost all of the women I know have Botox.
I don't know anybody who has botox
godmum56 · 30/12/2021 09:37

excuse me everybody but its CHIPS AND EGG

BlondeDogLady · 30/12/2021 09:37

Let's not forget Botox is rife now, but it wasn't available back then. Me and almost all of the women I know have Botox.

ravenmum · 30/12/2021 09:37

@cansu

I think lots of you are kidding yourselves. There are still many women trapped in unhappy marriages. It may not be about cooking for husbands but many stay home rather than go out with friends. Many are responsible for all the housework and childcare. They still carry the mental load of wife work. Yes more women work outside the home and but themselves nice stuff but the fundamental imbalance in domestic relationships is alive and kicking.
I agree. I didn't feel trapped in an unhappy marriage at the time, but I was responsible for all the housework and childcare, and it was hard for me to go out for many years as my exh worked away during the week - or came home when the kids were already in bed. I did other things which meant I didn't feel bored. By the time I was ready to date again after breaking up with my exh, the children were in their late teens so I could go out in the evening. I didn't go overboard, but it was definitely an amazing feeling to be out having fun like in my 20s :) I couldn't have done that at 42; just not possible.
BadSpellaSpellaSpella · 30/12/2021 09:34

I watched a tiktok once where a young women did her hair in an older style (short and used curlers) and she looked about 20 years older, think alot of it is style and fashion.

DillonPanthersTexas · 30/12/2021 09:31

I’m 46 and still having amazing sex with 36-year-old man with abs

Quality humble brag

JinglingHellsBells · 30/12/2021 09:30

@Buddywoo

I am the same age as Pauline Collins and remember thinking she was frumpy in the film the first time I watched it. She was meant to be and then she blossomed.

Each generation thinks previous generations looked old and were frumpy. It will happen to you.

Exactly. She was meant to look like that.

If you take away the frumpy clothes, her situation is one which still exists.

There are women in unhappy marriages, women who married too young, without pursuing an education or gaining qualifications (as with Educating Rita) women who are trapped and can't see any way to escape.

The clothes she wore were only there to emphasise her circumstances. Clearly that worked hence the OP's thread!

Pegasussnail · 30/12/2021 09:28

I watched this last night.
I took the ending to mean she was gokmg home (she said to Costos her husband was coming to collect her to bring her home)
Great film ! Her daughter being so cheeky to expect to move back in annoyed me Confused

JinglingHellsBells · 30/12/2021 09:26

Some things have changed that can't be denied.

For a start, some women these days take more care of their skin and hair and therefore look younger than women the same age did 40 years ago. They often spent a lot of time in the sun and didn't know of or use facial sunblock, for one thing.

There was also an expectation that at a certain age, you wore some 'good' brands, like Country Casuals, Jaegar, Alexon etc as your 'best' clothes.

To be honest, there wasn't as much choice as there is now. If you are relatively young, you won't appreciate this! There was a big gap in the market between very young high-fashion and what we'd now see as middle aged clothes. None of the high st names like Fat Face, White Stuff, Mint Velvet, New Look, Mango, All Saints, etc existed. It was Dotty Perkins, Etam , Wallace or M&S.

There really was very little choice. I find it much easier now to buy clothes than I did in my 30s and early 40s when everything was for the very young or the very old. Now, me and my DDs buy the same things and even swap clothes.

Short hair was a fashion, not necessarily a statement of being older.

But even today, we all know women who dress older than their years, don't take much care of their appearance and are modern day Shirleys!

cansu · 30/12/2021 09:20

I think lots of you are kidding yourselves. There are still many women trapped in unhappy marriages. It may not be about cooking for husbands but many stay home rather than go out with friends. Many are responsible for all the housework and childcare. They still carry the mental load of wife work. Yes more women work outside the home and but themselves nice stuff but the fundamental imbalance in domestic relationships is alive and kicking.