Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She was 42?! I’m 44

336 replies

AmIoldbutdontrealiseit · 29/12/2021 22:42

Shirley Valentine. Sat watching it on Channel 5, obviously seen it before but when very young so it didn’t have quite the same impact.
Cannot believe she was 42, I’ve just turned 44 and whilst I don’t feel young, I’m surely not frumpy and middle aged, pretty as she was, if you know what I mean?
The anorak wearing, egg and chip making and very mumsy, almost grandma feel?
I realise it was set in the 80’s but is it that we look/act younger now, or that we’re really middle aged and frumpy but don’t realise it 😬
In comparison, I have a 3 year old Dd, a career, live abroad, have longer hair, wear converse, parka and Gucci bag (just example today’s outfit) use Instagram, have many interests. My life is mainly centred around Dd so isn’t wild as in before, clubbing, festivals, travelling etc…but..is this what my age is really like inside?

Hope that made sense 🤣

OP posts:
Thewiseoneincognito · 30/12/2021 11:24

There’s plenty of mid 30s on my FB who look older than Shirley Valentine ever did thanks to too much drinking, drugs, having kids and smoking, ageing can be self inflicted or a byproduct of lifestyle and circumstances.

Let’s not forget the film intentionally over portrays her as downtrodden and frumpy but had you mentioned it to me without saying her age I would have said mid 50s from memory.

PartyPrawnRingGames · 30/12/2021 11:24

And most people don’t smoke any more. In the past everybody did and it is ageing and bad for your skin
My DH used to work in a factory with a lot of Eastern European workers and he said a lot of them looked much older than him and were surprised that he was the same age. A lot of them smoked and drank quite heavily, plus their food may not have been as good when they were younger if they came from a poorer area.

CSJobseeker · 30/12/2021 11:16

No fucking WAY does anyone of 42-43 look under 25. They just don't. If this has genuinely happened to someone in their 40s it's not that they look 20 years younger, it's because the person serving is shit at guessing ages, or your mask is covering your face, so it's hard to tell. You still look your age.

I agree with this. I know people in their 40s who say they get ID'd (and I have been too). They look good, but they do not look under 25 by a very long shot. I think masks make it particularly hard for staff to tell someone's age, so they err on the side of caution.

Siameasy · 30/12/2021 11:15

I agree. Im 40s and I wear clothes that my teenage nieces would probably also wear and even my 6 year old sometimes wears stuff that I think oooh I’d wear that.
When my mum was my age she had a certain look and the Lady Di hair do.

Gwenhwyfar · 30/12/2021 11:14

@SleepingStandingUp

The actress was 49 when the movie was made though, so hence she might have looked good but she didn't look 42.
48 apparently, but I think this explains the whole thread. She was closer to 50 than 40.
appleturnovers · 30/12/2021 11:10

I saw a fascinating TikTok video the other day where a young-looking, fashionable 40 year old did her hair and makeup the way 40 year-olds in the 80s did theirs, and poof! Suddenly she went from looking young-ish and trendy and vibrant to looking like an old lady!

My mum was told when she turned 30 (back in the 90s) by several people "oh, you'll have to stop wearing jeans/high heels/cut your hair short now". Our ideas of when people are supposed to get "old" have changed so much.

LizzieSiddal · 30/12/2021 11:07

Thanks for the correction BarkMinster. I had no idea it was so recent!

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 11:05

@SleepingStandingUp

The actress was 49 when the movie was made though, so hence she might have looked good but she didn't look 42.
This. ^ Most people don't look more than 5 or 6 years younger than their age, and Pauline Collins, although she is pretty and looked good, did look older than 42. More like 46/47.

As I mentioned before, the 'I get ID'd for booze/ciggies/matches even though I am in my early 40s' brigade make me laugh. I can believe a 42-43 y.o. could pass for 35/36, but not under 25. (Even though you only have to be over 18 to buy this stuff, you have to look over 25 if you have no I.D. So that is the target age. You need to look over 25.)

No fucking WAY does anyone of 42-43 look under 25. They just don't . If this has genuinely happened to someone in their 40s it's not that they look 20 years younger, it's because the person serving is shit at guessing ages, or your mask is covering your face, so it's hard to tell. You still look your age.

I am in my mid 50s, and like a few others here, I have never EVER been asked for I.D. for age, and right up to my late 40s, I looked 5 to 8 years younger all of my adult life (you know, a believable, realistic amount of years younger,) and I have NEVER been asked for I.D.

In my mid 50s now, I look my age, and I am happy with that. Why are so many people (women mostly) SO desperate to be thought of as looking younger?

OneTC · 30/12/2021 11:04

I'm 44.

I think there's definitely a different approach to maturity between then and now.

I think people assume the same or similar level of responsibility as previous generations but there has been a shift towards more enjoyment of what's available.

I also think that as society has approached maturity differently we have also approached emotional maturity differently

I blame coldplay

BarkminsterBlue · 30/12/2021 11:03

Her husband could have raped her and because she was married, it was not a crime until the 1980s

1991, by persuasive precedent from the House of Lords. Not explicitly written into statute until the Sexual Offences Act of 2003. Such recent history.

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 11:01

What struck me was when Shirley was talking about her husband, and said 'I planned on leaving him when the kids leave home. But now they've left, there's nowhere for me to go.'

That speaks volumes. There really IS nowhere to go for most ordinary women.

SO many posters come onto threads where a woman is complaining about their husband for some reason, and the 'leave the bastard' comments come on in droves. Followed by the 'I left mine when I was 53, and have never been happier.' OP says 'but I'm 57, it's too late for me to start over.'

Along come a bunch of posters with the usual predictable bollux - like 'I have a friend who left her husband when she was 60, retrained for a fabulous new career, and she's now on £75K a year, and she has a wonderful new life with a new bunch of friends, and men half her age are falling over themselves to date her.'

Of course, this only happens in the fantasy world of mumsnet. This would never happen to an ordinary 60 year old woman. And despite the bizarre cries of 'I look 20 years younger than I am and am frequently ID'd for alcohol, knives, batteries etc,' the vast majority of people do look their age, and the vast vast majority of 60 y.o.s look their age. Some look older, very few look younger.

In reality, what the F is a 60 y.o. woman going to get if she leaves her husband? A life in a grim one bed flat, no surplus income, and no spare time as she will be working so many hours to make ends meet. OR she will be on benefits, scraping the pennies from the back of the sofa for a loaf of bread. THAT will be the reality for most.

Also, what kind of man will she get? A man in his 60s that's what. She is not going to get a hot, fit man in his late 30s or early 40s, because no fucking WAY is a man like that going to go for a 60 y.o. woman. The only way that would happen is if she had a lot of money, and that would be the only reason. And as soon as he got his claws in it he'd be off.

The parallel world of mumsnet is quite hilarious sometimes.

LizzieSiddal · 30/12/2021 10:57

A bit of history and context…
In the 1980s a woman in her 40s would have been born and brought up during or after WW2 Her parents would so have been almost Victorian!

She would not have had the right to get a mortgage on her own until the 1970s
Her husband could have raped her and because she was married, it was not a crime until the 1980s
She was not entitled to equal pay until the 1970s
Ere etc etc

A lot of younger women don’t realise how much has changed over the very recent past and women had to fight tooth and nail to get equal rights. Which is why many older women are angry at the erosion of woman's rights which is happening right now.

Gwenhwyfar · 30/12/2021 10:55

"whereas now a 40something just looks like a 20something with a few more laugh lines."

Err.. I'm not going around wearing a crop top, leggings as trousers and massive trainers.

Bollocks2Covid · 30/12/2021 10:54

There was something about everyday 80’s fashion that made women look so frumpy and old before their time. Even teenagers looked frumpy. It’s still probably the worst decade for fashion.

DeepaBeesKit · 30/12/2021 10:52

People will think the same about you in 40 years

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/12/2021 10:51

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas

Egg and chip making 😂😂🍳🍳.

I 44 and I made ham egg abs chips tonight, for dd!”

Really, really want ham, egg and chips now Grin

(Or “chips and egg”, which SV said: always thought that was a bit weird)

bozzabollix · 30/12/2021 10:49

I’m 46 and watched it with my teenage son last night who was appalled at Shirley’s treatment. Didn’t see her as being anything like my age. I think it’s her life, the fact she’s downtrodden and the drudgery of the set. It ends when she looks almost unrecognisable.

I don’t think our generation are anything like but you do get certain people who are almost born middle aged. Generation X I think found it hard to grow up!

ShampooDoodle · 30/12/2021 10:48

That’s the 80s for you. My mother was in her 40s in the mid 80s and she wore exactly the same old woman clothes Shirley does, permed hair

snapsieplopp · 30/12/2021 10:45

I’ve basically not changed what I wear since I was younger and pre mum, so yep

I'm guilty of this too but think this can age us.

evilharpy · 30/12/2021 10:39

I love this film but haven't seen it in years - just checked and it's on Sky/Now TV if anyone wants to watch it (or Channel 5 with ads). I'm a year younger than Shirley, unbelievable.

My mum was 40 when I was born and looked older than Shirley. She had the short helmet perm, as did all her sisters, which I think was incredibly ageing. And also Deirdre Barlow glasses. She is in her 80s now and she and all her friends still have the same helmet perm. I'm assuming that it'll die out with her generation. She dresses younger now though than she did in the 80s and has much better glasses!

AmIoldbutdontrealiseit · 30/12/2021 10:39

@daimbarsatemydogsbone Converse *and parka, not fur lined

Here’s the bitchy comment 🤣at least explain yourself, yes I *am old and frumpy then? I’ve basically not changed what I wear since I was younger and pre mum, so yep

OP posts:
CSJobseeker · 30/12/2021 10:37

@3scape

Insta is just the 2020s version of some middle aged housewife magazine though. All perfect houses and housekeeping and bragging about life whilst battling some addiction to shopping or such. Boredom is boredom
Very true!
snapsieplopp · 30/12/2021 10:37

I don't think people looked actually older eg wrinkles, sagging I think it was the styling & make up.

peaceanddove · 30/12/2021 10:30

I'm 51. When I first met MIL she was only 48. She had already firmly embraced a hard perm, M&S Classic clothes and Footglove shoes. She easily looked 60.

But I have always believed that people are either born middle aged, or they're not. Sometimes DH can drive me up the wall, but I love the fact he is still very boyish at heart. My Auntie is pushing 80 but is still a party girl - last week we were practicing French skipping in her kitchen. I love a bit of frivolity and spontaneity - and will never understand people who just seem to be existing rather than actually living.

ancientgran · 30/12/2021 10:16

@Jessie75

I’m 46 and still having amazing sex with 36-year-old man with abs, have no interest whatsoever in an old fella with a moustache ! I do obviously still eat eggs and chips though we mix it up a bit and have beans on toast occasionally as well. I should say I’m also single !
You could go mad and have egg and chips with beans. I love my chips dipped in the beans sauce and egg yolk. I'm living the high life.

Having said that I'm nearly 70, still working, bringing up teenage grandson, regularly doing a 400 mile round trip to visit relative in care home and have to do it in a day as I'm DHs carer.

I probably look like a bag of rubbish some days, frumpy might be an improvement but I've got good skin.

Swipe left for the next trending thread