Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She was 42?! I’m 44

336 replies

AmIoldbutdontrealiseit · 29/12/2021 22:42

Shirley Valentine. Sat watching it on Channel 5, obviously seen it before but when very young so it didn’t have quite the same impact.
Cannot believe she was 42, I’ve just turned 44 and whilst I don’t feel young, I’m surely not frumpy and middle aged, pretty as she was, if you know what I mean?
The anorak wearing, egg and chip making and very mumsy, almost grandma feel?
I realise it was set in the 80’s but is it that we look/act younger now, or that we’re really middle aged and frumpy but don’t realise it 😬
In comparison, I have a 3 year old Dd, a career, live abroad, have longer hair, wear converse, parka and Gucci bag (just example today’s outfit) use Instagram, have many interests. My life is mainly centred around Dd so isn’t wild as in before, clubbing, festivals, travelling etc…but..is this what my age is really like inside?

Hope that made sense 🤣

OP posts:
ancientgran · 30/12/2021 13:04

@CSJobseeker

Let's remember too that even if the Shirleys of the 70s and 80s worked they would very likely have been making 'small stamp' reduced NI contributions and therefore didn't even have a full state pension in their futures.

I hadn't realised this, how depressing.

I worked in the 70s and 80s and so did all my female friends and relatives. Non of us paid the small stamp longterm (I did for 5 years when I needed the money but had enough years left to get a full pension) and have full pensions now. Honestly even as someone who left school at 15 and was a mum when still a teenager I knew about finances, some women chose to pay the small stamp because they needed the money.
endofbluenight · 30/12/2021 13:02

And women can do a lot to maintain and build their own financial security so that they are in a position to leave a shit DH, if they want to, and have a good life. Not necessarily a glamorous, career driven life. But a good, independent life
They can but many don't for many reasons. The burden of childcare still falls on women heavily, the cost of childcare is mentally usually calculated against the women's earnings alone so the decision of whether it is 'worth' the woman working does not look at family income as a whole. Women are far more likely than men to give up their own jobs and careers to follow their husband's career than vice versa, men are far less likely to reduce their work hours to balance domestic and childcare labour. Women still do more than their fair share of domestic and childcare labour making is physically and mentally harder for them to maintain the earning power of men. Its well documented that even working women's careers stagnate once they have children though men's do not.

Women are much more likely to be living in poverty after a relationship breakdown than men.

There are a lot of societal influences which massively disadvantage women in this area.

I wish there were some sort of pPubliic Health campaign in this so that young owomenn, and not so young ,could make more inforrmed decisionss.

BendicksBittermints4Breakfast · 30/12/2021 13:00

@Doingtheboxerbeat

Everyone seems to look super old in older films. I thought it was just me watching it through young eyes - but no, they still do. It's obviously the hair /makeup /eyebrows /fashion etc.
It was made in 1989 so I was 41 and I don't relate to her lifestyle although wish I'd had her skin! Williy Russell used to write about working class women in the same way, fairly down-trodden, remember Educating RIta, a similar period. they were not career women at all and lived pretty mundane lives, pandering to their husbands and children.
LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 12:57

@BarkminsterBlue

Let's remember too that even if the Shirleys of the 70s and 80s worked they would very likely have been making 'small stamp' reduced NI contributions and therefore didn't even have a full state pension in their futures.

This !!! ^ Depressing isn't it? Sad

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 12:56

@ZoeTheThornyDevil Just stop it FFS. Hmm You're embarrassing yourself now.

CSJobseeker · 30/12/2021 12:55

Let's remember too that even if the Shirleys of the 70s and 80s worked they would very likely have been making 'small stamp' reduced NI contributions and therefore didn't even have a full state pension in their futures.

I hadn't realised this, how depressing.

ZoeTheThornyDevil · 30/12/2021 12:51

I didn't say she had a great new career. She has the same career, because she slogged it out to hold onto it despite getting zero support. I also said that few women are going to be in her exact circumstance. But you're deliberately painting a cartoonish portrait of the joys women are allegedly promised if they leave a shit DH which is as unrealistic as the idea that they have no choice but to shut up and take it. Things have changed a lot for women in that situation. And women can do a lot to maintain and build their own financial security so that they are in a position to leave a shit DH, if they want to, and have a good life. Not necessarily a glamorous, career driven life. But a good, independent life.

BarkminsterBlue · 30/12/2021 12:50

[quote LittleRoundRobin]@ZoeTheThornyDevil

Now that I think about it, my boss, who is in her late fifties, left her shit husband when their kids flew the nest. She's glamorous, has a lovely flat, a great career, and a new partner, the same age, who has a great career and grown kids of his own.

Yes, not every woman can be my boss, and she's where she is because she hung on to her own job and career.

@endofbluenight

I think the issue is about the impact of financial independence. Your boss had clearly maintained hers through her life. Its about the difficulty of trying to basically start out from scratch in middle age, if you don't have financial independence. If you are trying to start a career you are 50 plus competing against 20 something graduates.

This exactly! I can't believe some people actually aren't getting this. The life of over-privilege from a few is stinking out this thread. Hmm[/quote]
Let's remember too that even if the Shirleys of the 70s and 80s worked they would very likely have been making 'small stamp' reduced NI contributions and therefore didn't even have a full state pension in their futures.

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 12:46

@ZoeTheThornyDevil

Why does a woman need a snazzy new career, much less a new man, though, to leave? Obviously the devil is in the details, but if you're miserable with a man, as long as you can support yourself wouldn't you be better off in a small flat, and who needs a new man, much less a younger one? Most women will finish their lives alone in any case as they're usually younger than male partners and live longer; why would you rather be stuck with a man you hate than be single?
I never SAID they need all that at all! ^

THIS is the fantasy scenario peddled by some mumsnetters, when in reality, what I and some others like @Jessie75 said, will be the more likely scenario.

^Most women who find themselves getting divorced at 40+ proceed to spend the rest of their lives in poverty sadly. I was lucky in that I got out at 37 I think if it had been left any later I would’ve been serious financial trouble."

The scenario you described about your clearly privileged and well-off ex-BOSS in her late 50s, having a wonderful shiny new life with a new partner and a 'great new career,' at almost 60 is FAR more rare than women struggling, and living in poverty after leaving their DH.

For every woman who leaves her DH at 50+, and has a wonderful illustrious new life full of wealth and happiness, and a fab new career, and men half her age falling over themselves to date her, there will be 50 women, whose life is just full of working a shit minimum pay job, struggling to make ends meet, and living in a shitty private-let one bedroom dump.

We're not living in some fucking Jackie Collins novel. MOST people live in the real world.

LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 12:46

@ZoeTheThornyDevil

Now that I think about it, my boss, who is in her late fifties, left her shit husband when their kids flew the nest. She's glamorous, has a lovely flat, a great career, and a new partner, the same age, who has a great career and grown kids of his own.

Yes, not every woman can be my boss, and she's where she is because she hung on to her own job and career.

@endofbluenight

I think the issue is about the impact of financial independence. Your boss had clearly maintained hers through her life. Its about the difficulty of trying to basically start out from scratch in middle age, if you don't have financial independence. If you are trying to start a career you are 50 plus competing against 20 something graduates.

This exactly! I can't believe some people actually aren't getting this. The life of over-privilege from a few is stinking out this thread. Hmm

RoyalFamilyFan · 30/12/2021 12:36

@Echobelly

I've been wanting to watch it, I looked at the trailer the other day (I am also 44) but I immediately thought it was just fascinating that 42 was kind of 'deep in middle age and past it' at that time. Someone like Shirley would likely be married for 20 years by then, whereas these days it's more likely someone her age would be married for less than 10 year, possibly not even 5.

Remember, as to 'looking older', we all tend to stick with the styles of our youth, so she's wearing a style that looks 'old' to us now. It's like when you watch old Top of the Pops from the 80s and all the teenagers in the audience have bouffant hair that you'd expect in someone 40 years older, because that's how they kept wearing their hair through life!

This is interesting. I am in my late fifties and got married at 25. That was later than many of my friends. I still think 42 is middle-aged as it is halfway through most peoples lives. But yes, if you have been married for 20 years in a shit marriage bringing up kids, its not surprising women reassess their lives once the kids have left home.
LittleRoundRobin · 30/12/2021 12:35

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

It was a different world. When I started primary school (70s), I had the oldest mother in the class. Mum was 26 🙀
And NOW, if mumsnet is to be believed, the average age of a mother when her first child starts school, is about 50. Wink
RoyalFamilyFan · 30/12/2021 12:33

There were women in their forties who back then looked professional or trendy in their dress. Just as there are women now who look frumpy in their forties. I was one except when on a night out, because I don't really care about clothes.
Shirley Valentine is about a woman in a shit marriage who is fed up of the drudgery and loneliness of each day in such a situation. There are still plenty of women in that situation. The only real difference is that divorce is much more common these days.

endofbluenight · 30/12/2021 12:33

@ZoeTheThornyDevil

Now that I think about it, my boss, who is in her late fifties, left her shit husband when their kids flew the nest. She's glamorous, has a lovely flat, a great career, and a new partner, the same age, who has a great career and grown kids of his own. Yes, not every woman can be my boss, and she's where she is because she hung on like grim death with no support to her own job and career when her DC were younger, but to suggest you just have to put up with whatever waste of space man you find yourself lumbered with when your kids leave home is just as unrealistic as the idea that you're going to waltz into a new career and a 20 years younger man at 60. As I recall from divorce stats, the most common scenario is a woman initiating divorce in midlife.
I think the issue is about the impact of financial independence. Your boss had clearly maintained hers through her life. Its about the difficulty of trying to basically start out from scratch in middle age, if you don't have financial independence. If you are trying to start a career you are 50plus competing against 20 something graduates.
Echobelly · 30/12/2021 12:30

I've been wanting to watch it, I looked at the trailer the other day (I am also 44) but I immediately thought it was just fascinating that 42 was kind of 'deep in middle age and past it' at that time. Someone like Shirley would likely be married for 20 years by then, whereas these days it's more likely someone her age would be married for less than 10 year, possibly not even 5.

Remember, as to 'looking older', we all tend to stick with the styles of our youth, so she's wearing a style that looks 'old' to us now. It's like when you watch old Top of the Pops from the 80s and all the teenagers in the audience have bouffant hair that you'd expect in someone 40 years older, because that's how they kept wearing their hair through life!

AmIoldbutdontrealiseit · 30/12/2021 12:30

@endofbluenight Great, it’s coming 😢

OP posts:
Jessie75 · 30/12/2021 12:30

@NotMyYear123

Have you seen the interviews of Princess Di just before she got married? She was 20. (Yes, seriously, 20!). She looked 40. Styles then were dreadfully frumpy.
The Duchess of Cambridge dresses like a 50-year-old always has
NotMyYear123 · 30/12/2021 12:23

Have you seen the interviews of Princess Di just before she got married? She was 20. (Yes, seriously, 20!). She looked 40. Styles then were dreadfully frumpy.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 30/12/2021 12:22

I don't think it's about people actually looking older essentially. I think it's just you associate the styles of then with people who were a lot older than you then or when you last saw the film

I think that's true to an extent but not entirely. My mum looked similar to me at my current age (early 50s), allowing for fashion changes, but my Dad at 50 looked more like a 65 year old of today. It's things like the cut of his hair, which was very different from how a 30 year old of the time would have worn it, whereas - these days - a 30 year old and 50 year old man would probably opt for similar styles.

ZoeTheThornyDevil · 30/12/2021 12:20

Now that I think about it, my boss, who is in her late fifties, left her shit husband when their kids flew the nest. She's glamorous, has a lovely flat, a great career, and a new partner, the same age, who has a great career and grown kids of his own. Yes, not every woman can be my boss, and she's where she is because she hung on like grim death with no support to her own job and career when her DC were younger, but to suggest you just have to put up with whatever waste of space man you find yourself lumbered with when your kids leave home is just as unrealistic as the idea that you're going to waltz into a new career and a 20 years younger man at 60. As I recall from divorce stats, the most common scenario is a woman initiating divorce in midlife.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 30/12/2021 12:17

It was a different world. When I started primary school (70s), I had the oldest mother in the class. Mum was 26 🙀

Dixiechickonhols · 30/12/2021 12:17

Glasses. There used to be so few styles certainly no designer frames everyone wore the same.
My Mum pretty much looked like this.
www.google.co.uk/search?q=deidre+barlow+80s+perm&client=safari&hl=en-gb&sxsrf=AOaemvKKylsZZkQ0kJX3dPCtDY2jIlbdEg%3A1640866206695&ei=nqHNYZbcKZCUxc8PyLqO0As&oq=deidre+barlow+80s+perm&gs_lcp=ChNtb2JpbGUtZ3dzLXdpei1zZXJwEAMyCAghEBYQHRAeOgcIABBHELADOgQIABAKOgQIABANOgcIIRAKEKABOgYIABAWEB5KBAhBGABQ7whY3SNgnCZoAXABeACAAZoBiAHFCJIBAzEuOJgBAKABAcgBCMABAQ&sclient=mobile-gws-wiz-serp#imgrc=S973iVZqoFNLbM
I’ve just dug out a photo of us on holiday my mum is only 43. Short perm, Deirdre Barlow glasses, unflattering cotton just past skirt in jaunty colours, baggy sweater and peep toes with cork wedge heel (all from M & S) All the mums in my suburban street looked like this.

runningfromtheoutlaws · 30/12/2021 12:15

Im 43, feel 83 often due to chronic ill healthBlush

CaptainMyCaptain · 30/12/2021 12:14

@BlondeDogLady

Let's not forget Botox is rife now, but it wasn't available back then. Me and almost all of the women I know have Botox.
I don't know anyone who has Botox.
senua · 30/12/2021 12:10

Shirley Valentine is one of my bugbears. As is Educating Rita. They are written by the same bloke, Willy Russell.
I always felt that they were mansplaining to me what women's oppression looked like.

It's fiction, it's not a documentary. It's what they think a "frumpy and middle aged" character looked like, especially when forced into that by life circumstance. That's the whole point of her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread