Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She was 42?! I’m 44

336 replies

AmIoldbutdontrealiseit · 29/12/2021 22:42

Shirley Valentine. Sat watching it on Channel 5, obviously seen it before but when very young so it didn’t have quite the same impact.
Cannot believe she was 42, I’ve just turned 44 and whilst I don’t feel young, I’m surely not frumpy and middle aged, pretty as she was, if you know what I mean?
The anorak wearing, egg and chip making and very mumsy, almost grandma feel?
I realise it was set in the 80’s but is it that we look/act younger now, or that we’re really middle aged and frumpy but don’t realise it 😬
In comparison, I have a 3 year old Dd, a career, live abroad, have longer hair, wear converse, parka and Gucci bag (just example today’s outfit) use Instagram, have many interests. My life is mainly centred around Dd so isn’t wild as in before, clubbing, festivals, travelling etc…but..is this what my age is really like inside?

Hope that made sense 🤣

OP posts:
Loudestcat14 · 30/12/2021 08:00

I think this every time I watch SV! I think it’s the clothes and hair. Women in their 40s in the Seventies/Eighties generally didn’t wear their hair long or wear jeans - it was all set perms and elasticated waists! I actually shuddered when I saw in the Sunday Times Style section this week that Eighties’ thin eyebrows are making a comeback - they’re SO ageing!

JinglingHellsBells · 30/12/2021 07:59

I think you have to blame the author of the play - Willy Russell.

She wasn't typical of most women in their 40s, in the early 80s.

In that era, I was roughly 10 years younger than she was in the film.

I cam assure you that the way she was portrayed as a 42 year old was not typical.

You need to focus on the 'message' of the film (it was originally a stage play) and ignore the fashions. It's more about a 2nd chance in midlife and a woman worn down by a boring husband, who wants to live a little. She could be any age. Russell just happened to make her 42 (and that says more about his attitude to women than anything.)

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/12/2021 07:57

i dont get your point op,
your life is different from shirley valentine
shock horror you have a 3 year old and wear converse trainers.

judge yourself perhaps in 20 years
she had a boring life, married to a boring man - age is irrelevant

gogohm · 30/12/2021 07:55

I'm almost 50 and live a very different lifestyle! My kids have left home (well back for university holidays) and we definitely are middle aged as far as age is concerned (complete with increasingly creaking joints) but I've never made egg and chips in my life and there's nothing staid in the bedroom department Grin

GrandmasCat · 30/12/2021 07:49

Everybody looked older in the 80s. But obviously, we didn’t realise about that until 20 years later.

The clothes and hairstyles were not exactly flattering.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 30/12/2021 07:44

It’s not just about age. All of Willy Russell’s major plays (Shirley Valentine, Blood Brothers and Educating Rita) examine the major theme of working-class women trapped in, and prematurely aged by, a life of drudgery. There’s a line in Blood Brothers where Mrs Johnstone says ‘by the time that I was twenty-five I looked like forty-two’ because she’s had seven children already.

If you enjoyed SV then I highly recommend Educating Rita. She has a lot of the same frustrations as Shirley but is only twenty-six.

userxx · 30/12/2021 07:29

Just a cotton picking minute !

I've never heard anyone use that term except my mum!

OhGiveUp · 30/12/2021 07:28

When you look at your parents family photos is when you see how old not just the women, but the men look too.
When I look at my parents wedding photos with my grandparents on them, I never fail to be shocked at how old my grandparents look, even though they would only have been in their early forties then.
If I'm honest, one of my grandmother's on the photo looked exactly the same when she died some forty years later to me.
Different lifestyle and expectations I think. To be fair to my grandmother, she did have fourteen kids, which will have aged her.
I look at photos of myself and my siblings taken in the eighties and I think blimey, I look almost as old as my mother with my poodle perm and heavy make up. ( Although obviously at the time, I thought I looked the height of sophistication. Haha )
I love the Shirley valentine film. Him poking his finger into the egg yolks makes me laugh every time.

Youngstreet · 30/12/2021 07:25

In the late 70’s I had a work colleague who was about 22 and imo dressed like an old woman and had a granny perm.
She’s on fb now and is exactly the same.
Still looks older than other women her age.
She’s very happy, married, adult dc and enjoys her life.
But to my shame I shudder at how she looks and dresses. It makes me really shallow doesn’t it?

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 30/12/2021 07:25

I don't get your point @BoudecaBains? I'm also 43. But we weren't 43 in the 80s, and probably would've looked and acted very differently if we had been.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/12/2021 07:11

isnt it her husband, who is boring and set in his ways?

WTF99 · 30/12/2021 06:56

Can you all please stop saying egg and chips! Grin That isnt what she says

And isn't the whole point that she's supposed to look dowdy bored and old before her time? If she was glamourous and fulfilled there wouldn't be much a story would there!

sansucre · 30/12/2021 06:36

I walk past the hotel where Shirley bumps into Marjorie on few times a week, so often think of this film, and Shirley.

I recall watching this with my mother, she would have been the same age as Shirley, and now, I am the same age as Shirley. Her married life was similar to Shirley's and can recognise how bored my mother must have been - she was trapped in suburban hell as a SAHM with little interest in any of it, or any respite/escape. (My father was much like Joe, not sociable. As my mother has spent most of her 20s in the US, she had few friends, and no real way of making any.)

In terms of her looks and dress sense, she was miles away from Shirley, definitely more of a Marjorie/Joanna Lumley type albeit better looking and far better dressed. I think this only adds to the frustration of how she must have felt being trapped at home. I'm sad that she didn't have more of a life or the opportunities to live her life differently. She was deeply unhappy with her life, and unlike Shirley, didn't have an outlet to facilitate any changes.

But, I must admit that the 80s seems like an easier, less stressful time. Growing up, our meals were somewhat regimented and we always ate the same things on certain days of the week. I rather miss this! These things aside, am glad life is different now, particularly how many more options there are for women to live (and dress) in ways that serves them.

BoudecaBains · 30/12/2021 02:53

@GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal

Just different times, wasn't it? Women married younger, had children younger...and got older younger.
Just a cotton picking minute !. I'm 43. My eldest is 19, the other two are 16 and 15, and I still look good in what my mother gave me. I've got all my hair and teeth, no celulite and could probably still fit into my wedding dress. So forgive me if I pass on the "got older younger" bit.
Kanaloa · 30/12/2021 02:53

I’m in my twenties and regularly make egg and chips 😂 it’s an easy and filling family meal that everyone likes. We call it a ‘busy day’ tea. If everyone had activities and we don’t have much time after school and clubs etc then egg, chips & beans. Everyone’s got a full belly and happy!

I do kind of get what you mean though - sometimes on telly you’ll see someone in their 30s being brought across like they’re old/past it or ‘mumsy.’

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 30/12/2021 02:29

The stereotype fit my mum at that age (42 in the 80s). I was 19 by then (oldest child) and mum was a frumpy, middle aged woman who was overweight and wore "comfy" shoes.

I, on the other hand, had a 2yo at 42 and hadn't descended into "middle age" at that point. Just hitting it now, it seems like, as DS1 becomes a teenager.

KickAssAngel · 30/12/2021 02:13

As someone who remembers the 80s,I think there were a few things that made her appear older than we expect a42 year old to appear now.
She was from a working class background and probably left school at 16, married by 18 and kids soon after. Being a mum does often make women Mumsey. That's part of her discontent, she realizes that there were other options so she starts going to college.

Then, there was the expectation that past a certain age you were expected to dress like an adult. When I was a student my mum once refused to take me to a nice pub as I wasn't dressed appropriately. Even for a pub lunch your best Laura Ashley was expected, jeans wouldn't do.

There would have been a lot of raised eyebrows if she'd turned up at the school gates in jeans. I remember my mum having to change it of her gardening or housework clothes to fetch my sister from school.

Generally, we're less formal now, and it's OK to be a mum without having to wear floral pleated skirts.

SleepingStandingUp · 30/12/2021 01:38

The actress was 49 when the movie was made though, so hence she might have looked good but she didn't look 42.

Thickasmincepie · 30/12/2021 01:37

I've never, ever been asked for ID. Even as a 15 yr old. Don't even get a second look in supermarkets.i used to read all the 'I get id'd all the time' posts on here and think I must look ancient. But I'm tall and have an authoritative air, so people barely even glance at me.

Change123today · 30/12/2021 01:36

I do think it was the clothes/fashion of the time.
My Mum had me young and both Grandmas would have been 42/44 and when I look at photos of them with me they dress quite old looking - with hair cuts to match!
I look at photos of my Mum in the early 80s and she dressed so frumpy and had another bad haircut - short it really ages her!
But now my Mum 63 I would say dresses very well and has her haircut to suit her face (mid length!) she restarted her career in her mid twenty’s ditched the frumpy clothes (she love princess Diana - so copied a few styles) grew her hair again. She looked amazing - not that I thought that at 14 …she would arrive to parents evening from work and I thought her skirt was too short. I was mortified (it wasn’t) but she was 32 with amazing figure against all what I thought I could see was mum types (I was wrong)

MissMaple82 · 30/12/2021 01:32

People always feel and think they look younger than they actually do !!!!!

nordica · 30/12/2021 01:31

Some people just look older though, and I say that as someone who wishes I did too. I think SV just has that older face.

I'm nearly 40 and was just thinking about a favourite teacher I had in my teens and realised she was younger then than I am now, and yet she looked a lot older. Just somehow very grown up in sensible clothes and hair but also her skin and general features, even her voice. Like no one would have IDd her buying a bottle of wine with the food shop and I was nearly refused a box of matches a year or two ago for not looking old enough.

Momijin · 30/12/2021 01:29

I'm in my 50s and have had to shove my mask down when buying alcohol many times during the pandemic. I dress relatively simply and have longish natural looking hair.

One of my local friends looked frumpish when she was in her 30s. She's 10 years older now but her hair is longer and she wears more flattering clothes so looks younger than her years.

EleonorBronte · 30/12/2021 01:20

i will take the bait, she was working class.
uuurgh Grin

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 30/12/2021 01:20

@DukeofEarlGrey

People used to look older when they were younger. You only need to watch Grease to see that Wink
😂
Swipe left for the next trending thread