Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel conned by 'luxury' handbags?

163 replies

realhousewifeofmodor · 29/12/2021 22:35

Have been fortunate enough to have had a bit more disposable income recently,and have found myself lusting after bags from certain well known middle-high end brands, such as Mulberry, Aspinal, Strathberry, Demellier etc.

Have bought a couple, and although they're nice bags, I can't now help but feel that I was conned into buying them from people on Instagram and I only ever really liked them for the name printed on the front. I can't afford the likes of Hermes etc so it's not even super high end, but do feel a bit disgusted with myself that I've spent so money on branded goods when that money could have done so much good.

Anyone else splurge a bit and then get buyers remorse? Or is it possible (or indeed OK) to own a plethora of such handbags etc and to not feel an ounce of guilt/shame about it? Or to truly believe people buy these items because they genuinely love them, not because of the brand name abs therefore status attached to them?

OP posts:
CharSiu · 30/12/2021 12:24

I have known two women who buy high end bags, both are from poor backgrounds. One has most definitely made it and herself and her DH are millionaires a couple of times over. The other still lives in pretty grim circumstance and really scrimps to afford the couple of bags she has. I suppose it makes them feel good.

I just spent 1k on a full size arcade video game machine, I absolutely love it and pootle about in public with a rucksack that’s cost about £20. Each to their own I suppose.

When it comes to items that people want it’s only an issue if they can’t afford them. Capitalism relies on people wasting money :)

Bluebluemoon · 30/12/2021 12:16

I think a good quality bag and shoes are good buys - so long as you can afford it. I would never get into debt to buy one and I buy what I like personally, I don't look at Instagram etc. I have a few but use one mulberry and one LV handbag most of the time so I certainly get my monies worth. I agree you could buy a leather bag from Tk maxx or somewhere much cheaper which would be just as good quality. But having "nice" bags and shoes etc give me a little boost and I can afford them.

It's all about the overall look though. There's a fine line between looking classy or overdone. I usually assume people with things like Chanel and those little black Gucci shoulder bags are fakes as so many young girls have them and don't look like they can actually afford the real thing, but perhaps that's just me being a snob. There are so many good fakes around though - there was a man selling all manner of fakes on a stall in Dublin recently and I was astounded at how real they looked. I wouldn't buy one though as I would know it was fake and I'd feel like a fraud!

onlychildhamster · 30/12/2021 12:09

@Cocomarine for new look, you need to take it back within 30 days..never bought coach but I wouldn't be surprised if they accepted even after 30 days had lapsed. My bag has a lifetime guarantee- repairs all free. This isn't exclusive to luxury but generally only brands who have an emphasis on quality i.e. not new look would do that.

Mankyfruitbowl · 30/12/2021 12:08

Looking at it from a different angle, how much do you think somebody should be paid to create a leather handbag? Think about all the people along the supply chain, from the leather tanners/ processors, the designers, people cutting it out, sewing it together, producing all the metal hardware bits etc. I don't know the answer to this question, but I suspect it would be higher than we all expect - not sure why it's seen as virtuous to spend as little as possible.

I don't have the budget right now, but if I'm ever in a position to spend a few hundred on a bag, I'd happily spend it if I felt it was ethically produced and great quality. I realise that a higher price tag doesn't always guarantee either of these things (and have no idea about the brands you mentioned) but I'd be researching small producers making beautiful products - possibly even buying direct from them.

Dreamstate · 30/12/2021 12:08

The most I've spent is £180 and it was on a dkny bag, I actually made myself walk around Bluewater to see if I still wanted to spend that much. I did buy it in the end and I loved it. I should of bought two because I loved the design and always got compliments on it but as I used it ao much it wore out. Shame they don't sell that dssign anymore.

Maybe ou bought too many at once and thats also contributing to your feeling.

onlychildhamster · 30/12/2021 11:58

@justasking111 they buy for family because European luxury goods are heavily taxed in China. There is a growing wealthy class in China. International students are mostly well off, we have to have to be as mostly our parents fund our studies and the home office checks our finances before giving us a visa. My dad had to put £200k in an accessible bank account as proof of finances as I was studying in London.and in Asia, luxury goods are often a sign of conformity with peer group rather than 'luxury'. Like I know in Singapore, I have heard people who worked in sales who said they felt pressured to carry luxury bags as their clients assumed they were not good at their job/had no clients if not carrying a Chanel or Prada. It is much cheaper to buy those brands in UK so naturally they do buy those brands when holidaying in the UK...

Also I have always felt that people from China/HK/Singapore buy luxury consumer goods because a very high percentage of the population live in apartments/condos including the rich so there is less they can do to improve it even if they own it. I speak as someone who owns a London apartment. How many times can you redecorate the interiors? Conversely , I feel home improvements are where rich British people spend the most money as outside of prime central London, most rich British people live in houses. That and private school and expensive holidays.

Cocomarine · 30/12/2021 11:49

@PrincessNutella

My husband bought me a Coach bag. The zipper broke, and we took it back to the store to get it fixed. They couldn't fix it, so they gave me a new one for free. I have to say, that really impressed me. I felt as if they really stood behind the product they made and had a certain kind of pride about it.
Why did that impress you? New Look would do that! Well, with it he trying to fix first. Replacing a faulty product is a legal obligation.
user1493494961 · 30/12/2021 11:47

I buy my bags from charity shops, never had buyer's remorse.

cobblers123 · 30/12/2021 11:45

I have got two M&S Cross body bags, both really nice, most expensive one was £65, had both about four years and still in excellent condition.

Also have a Bally bag bought in the 90s, still looks good and occasionally get it out and give it an airing if I go out at night and only need a very small bag. Smile

harriethoyle · 30/12/2021 11:43

I absolutely adore the strathberry bags @realhousewifeofmodor - I think the closing is so elegant. Have also got a lovely cream leather Kate Spade which I adore. On the other hand I'm sick of seeing Louis Vuitton bags and wouldn't thank you for one! So for me it's the design not the label that is most important. Try the outnet too if you want a bargain-- some great bits on there.

Charliesgotachocolatefactory · 30/12/2021 11:39

@realhousewifeofmodor I have a couple from Dunmore Scotland. I’ve had one of their leather saddlebags for years and it’s probably the bag I use most day to day. I like a cross-body bag and my finger is currently hovering over their green leather satchel as there’s a really good sale on at the moment. I really don’t need another bag, but when’s that ever stopped anyone? 🤣

Thepineapplemystery · 30/12/2021 11:33

I can, but don't buy designer shoes or bags. I have in the past and have regretted it. Mainly because my style and tastes change and I stop loving them. But if you can afford it and you like it, then why not!

TillyTopper · 30/12/2021 11:29

I have bought one label (Ted Baker - so not really high end) that I liked. But honestly I feel the price for a label is what DH calls a "stupid tax". I love the bag I've got now - it's a large heavy canvas one and I've "pimped" it with a floral star and a tassel in the same colour. Plus I can get everything in it!

cobblers123 · 30/12/2021 11:27

I bought a Coach bag this month, it was £400, the most I've ever paid for a bag but it does exactly what I wanted it for, looks really nice and I'm pleased with it.

I'd buy another but not right now. I also have Kate Spade bag I bought in the summer, not as expensive as the Coach bag but I will be using it next summer, I really love it.

Omicrone · 30/12/2021 11:26

Anything over about £200 you are just paying for the label.

Some companies sell very good dupes (not fakes) of designer handbags. So they are in the same style as certain handbags and have most of the same features, but a couple of features to differentiate from the real thing and obviously no branding on them. Around the £150 mark. I have a couple and they are really beautifully made leather bags and I can't see how a 'real' handbag could be better in terms of quality tbh. Obviously some people would think that was totally tacky and sad and if you can't afford the real thing then don't bother at all, but I don't really give a shit!

Totalwasteofpaper · 30/12/2021 11:21

@montysma1

For the life of me I cannot understand what anybody gets out of this. Actually anything with a name on the front makes me snigger at the owner.
you must spend a lot of time "sniggering"... Confused

I see numerous people with branded clothing (everything from adidas and nike to Boss & Ralph Lauren) everytime i walk down the high street.

How loudly do you laugh when you see people "showing off" carrying their visibly branded reusable Waitrose/M&S freezer bags at the shops????

NameChangeCity123 · 30/12/2021 11:20

@MaybeHeIsMyCat

I really like coach bags. I have the two attached (and you can see the price I paid as I'm a bargain hunter!!!) They feel nice, look good and seem to be hard wearing - but I don't think I would pay full price
These are beautiful!
batmanladybird · 30/12/2021 11:18

Good thing about a bag is that it fits however fat or thin you are. Unlike designer clothes

batmanladybird · 30/12/2021 11:17

@PrincessNutella

My husband bought me a Coach bag. The zipper broke, and we took it back to the store to get it fixed. They couldn't fix it, so they gave me a new one for free. I have to say, that really impressed me. I felt as if they really stood behind the product they made and had a certain kind of pride about it.
It can't be good quality if it broke and can't be fixed 😳
PinkWednesdays · 30/12/2021 11:10

@montysma1

For the life of me I cannot understand what anybody gets out of this. Actually anything with a name on the front makes me snigger at the owner.
You don’t actually come across well with that comment…
Elphame · 30/12/2021 11:10

Yes - Mulberry is no longer the brand it was.

I have a vast collection of them but stopped buying about 10 years ago when the prices rocketed and the quality fell. They used to be timeless understated designs but now they are far too flashy and that huge rose gold buckle they seem to love is just tacky.

BerthaBlythe · 30/12/2021 11:06

I bought a moderately priced bag £400 and returned it the next day. I know what you mean about feeling tricked into thinking I wanted one. It’s marketing, I suppose. It was only when I got it home and the shop glamour faded a bit that I recognised that it didn’t align with my values at all.

I don’t mind spending money on long lasting, good quality, clothing because cost per wear makes sense. But having a status symbol on my arm was just not me.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 30/12/2021 11:05

@montysma1

For the life of me I cannot understand what anybody gets out of this. Actually anything with a name on the front makes me snigger at the owner.
Do you laugh at people who buy expensive cars too?
VestaTilley · 30/12/2021 11:00

I wouldn’t feel guilt as it’s your money, but I’ve never understood why people spend a lot on bags or shoes - nobody notices them anyway and I don’t think they look special.

But I’ve never seen the appeal of designer goods anyway, so I’m not the right person to ask!

montysma1 · 30/12/2021 10:54

For the life of me I cannot understand what anybody gets out of this.
Actually anything with a name on the front makes me snigger at the owner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread