Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel conned by 'luxury' handbags?

163 replies

realhousewifeofmodor · 29/12/2021 22:35

Have been fortunate enough to have had a bit more disposable income recently,and have found myself lusting after bags from certain well known middle-high end brands, such as Mulberry, Aspinal, Strathberry, Demellier etc.

Have bought a couple, and although they're nice bags, I can't now help but feel that I was conned into buying them from people on Instagram and I only ever really liked them for the name printed on the front. I can't afford the likes of Hermes etc so it's not even super high end, but do feel a bit disgusted with myself that I've spent so money on branded goods when that money could have done so much good.

Anyone else splurge a bit and then get buyers remorse? Or is it possible (or indeed OK) to own a plethora of such handbags etc and to not feel an ounce of guilt/shame about it? Or to truly believe people buy these items because they genuinely love them, not because of the brand name abs therefore status attached to them?

OP posts:
Omicrone · 30/12/2021 14:38

@saleorbouy

As a bloke I'm at a loss firstly as to why you need to lug a bag of "stuff" about with you and secondly how the exorbitant cost can even be justified. It seems to me the more expensive the handbag the more garish, chavvy and hideous the look. When I see someone strutting about with one I just think "gullible".
It's to carry around all the stuff you are expected to in order to 'woman' properly. So that's makeup, hair stuff etc in order to fulfil the role of 'looking good' and then stuff like tissues, wet wipes, nappies, plasters, toys, hand sanitizer in order to fulfil the role of 'support human who has all the things that everyone else needs'.

But 'as a bloke' I wouldn't expect you to understand that.

zingally · 30/12/2021 14:36

I enjoy a nice bag as well, but mine are more of the Kate Spade/Coach level.

I use a Kate Spade backpack for work, which still looks as good as the day I bought it. I also have a Kate Spade purse, which is at least 5 years old, but still looks like new!

Saying that, my current day-to-day handbag came from Wish.com, and cost about £7!

Omicrone · 30/12/2021 14:34

@Tabbacus

A Chanel/Hermes isn't going to give a better 'handbag' experience than a Coach/Osprey or even nice leather Zara, apart from knowing its a high end brand.

Not sure on Hermes as I have only ever seen one in the wild, but Chanel bags are definitely better quality than Zara etc. Whether they're worth that much more £££ wise is debatable, but absolutely they are (or were at least) exceptionally well made and last and last.

I don't doubt the quality of the bags (although from what I have heard, the quality of Chanel, Mulberry etc is going downhill, almost in direct correlation to the price hikes!). I just think you can get just as good quality from bags that are literally 3 or 4% of the price of a Chanel.
onlychildhamster · 30/12/2021 14:06

@saleorbouy you could say that about clothes too. Why do I buy dresses from joules and Gudrun sjoden with floral prints that I find pretty? I could get a basic t shirt and jeans/black trousers and it would do the exact same job of getting me clothed. Even for work in my office job, a simple black dress would suffice. People do want to look nice and I am more willing to spend on a backpack that I can carry for years at a time rather than a dress that I might possibly not be able to fit into when I get pregnant and have a baby. I carry my backpack daily, I wear a favourite dress maybe once a fortnight.

mariebaby3 · 30/12/2021 14:04

I went through a bit of a phase a while ago of enjoying more expensive bags.

I’ve got a few Coach bags, 2 x Kate Spade, mulberry Bayswater and my biggest spend was on an LV. I ended up selling the mulberry and LV because they were so expensive I felt like I couldn’t enjoy them - also they require a surprising amount of upkeep! The quality on the LV hardware wasnt amazing either.

My favourite bags now are Coach. Expensive but not so expensive that I feel like I need to baby it, and I find their leather and hardware excellent.

PegasusReturns · 30/12/2021 13:46

When I see someone strutting about with one I just think "gullible"

I’ll be sure to bear your opinion in mind next time I’m being complimented on my fabulous accessorising.

Woodlandwater · 30/12/2021 13:42

@saleorbouy

As a bloke I'm at a loss firstly as to why you need to lug a bag of "stuff" about with you and secondly how the exorbitant cost can even be justified. It seems to me the more expensive the handbag the more garish, chavvy and hideous the look. When I see someone strutting about with one I just think "gullible".
As a bloke you probably won't have realised that most women's clothing doesn't have pockets, and even if you think they do they are often fake pockets, or they're too small to be functional. Women are also often relied upon to cater for the family's needs when out and about, which can mean nappies, wipes, change of clothes, something to keep kids entertained if stuck waiting somewhere, snacks, umbrella in case it rains, change for the trolley, tissues, hair bands, plasters etc.
saleorbouy · 30/12/2021 13:37

onlychildhamster
I have a work backpack too for a laptop, note book diary and PPE, I don't class that as a fashion item worthy of ££££ expenditure.

I just find it strange to put a phone, purse, etc in an expensive fashion accessory that then makes it more attractive for others to covet and perhaps try to relieve you of the bag and it's contents.

I get people need bags but these are just attracting attention and seem so unnecessary ostentatious and most are pretty ugly. (In my opinion)

onlychildhamster · 30/12/2021 13:29

@saleorbouy I carry a convertible backpack and it carries my work laptop. Also my makeup. And grocery bags. But in some settings backpack isn't suitable like in a museum or glassware shop so I wear it crossbody style.

Working women/mums have a lot of things to carry! And city women often can't drive around so they need bags to carry their stuff for the day.. I don't do small bags though! I can't walk in heels so for a long time, I needed a bag big enough to carry an extra pair of shoes. I still insist on wearing heels for formal occasions cos I am five foot tall! I don't understand small bags though and many expensive handbags fall into that category..I have no use for a bag smaller than 35 cm which is why I switched to backpack as it's kinder on the shoulders. I have a clutch for weddings.

Lucyccfc68 · 30/12/2021 13:22

I have a mix of bags. Some very expensive and some pretty cheap. OP - buy what you like and not because an influencer (idiot) has put pictures on Instagram of a freebie they have been given and are advertising.

If you really can afford a particular bag and love it then buy it because you love it.

saleorbouy · 30/12/2021 13:21

As a bloke I'm at a loss firstly as to why you need to lug a bag of "stuff" about with you and secondly how the exorbitant cost can even be justified.
It seems to me the more expensive the handbag the more garish, chavvy and hideous the look.
When I see someone strutting about with one I just think "gullible".

Tabbacus · 30/12/2021 13:17

A Chanel/Hermes isn't going to give a better 'handbag' experience than a Coach/Osprey or even nice leather Zara, apart from knowing its a high end brand.

Not sure on Hermes as I have only ever seen one in the wild, but Chanel bags are definitely better quality than Zara etc. Whether they're worth that much more £££ wise is debatable, but absolutely they are (or were at least) exceptionally well made and last and last.

toconclude · 30/12/2021 13:16

And a con which, judging from comments, too many people buy into. Their loss, in more ways than one 🤷

pinkgin85 · 30/12/2021 13:13

"A Chanel/Hermes isn't going to give a better 'handbag' experience than a Coach/Osprey or even nice leather Zara, apart from knowing its a high end brand."

@Omicrone but that's your subjective opinion isn't it? I get a lot of joy when I use my Chanel flap. I have some Coach bags too for daily use and I love them too but it's a different feel when I take my Chanel out. And a Toyota can give just as nice of a driving experience as a BMW, I have a hybrid Toyota because as long as my car is comfortable, reliable, and functional I don't care what brand it is, but some people do and that's okay.

CrimbleCrumble1 · 30/12/2021 13:13

Chanel/Hermes isn't going to give a better 'handbag' experience than a Coach/Osprey or even nice leather Zara, apart from knowing its a high end brand it does for me, i feel great with my bags, they make my outfits look lovely, I enjoy looking at them and using them, I’m worth it.

toconclude · 30/12/2021 13:12

YANBU to feel conned because they are a con. Simple.

Omicrone · 30/12/2021 13:08

@saturning

My point exactly about cars - you could buy a cheap runaround like a Kia or Ford Focus - why go for a BMW 5 series? Of course its about being in the "i can afford better" gang!!!! Cars are acceptable but more traditionally female things like bags are not.
It's not though? Those cars are more comfortable to drive, have smoother engines, better acceleration, have better interior options such as climate control, adaptive cruise control etc. And once you get to Ferarri/Aston Martin territory the driving experience is completely different, you can't really compare to a Kia at all.

Yes there are 'luxury cars' that are pretty shit (looking at you Range Rover) but generally more expensive cars are nicer to drive.

A Chanel/Hermes isn't going to give a better 'handbag' experience than a Coach/Osprey or even nice leather Zara, apart from knowing its a high end brand.

CrimbleCrumble1 · 30/12/2021 13:06

OP what would good would you have done with the money if you had not bought the bags? Do you generally feel guilty spending money on yourself or only on bags?

pinkgin85 · 30/12/2021 13:02

Why are luxury bags always picked on? People spend on fine food and wine, nice expensive cars, expensive holidays, get their nails done, or spend on expensive hobbies and no one judges that?
I don't do any of the above but I do like nice bags.
I recently had the chance to meet some of artisan creators at Dior and they do everything by hand (unlike what some PP claimed). They train for years and years at their craft so Ofcourse it's going to cost most. And bags ARE an investment. I bought my small lady dior in 2015 for £1850 and now it's £3050.
Ofcourse don't buy something just for the sake of a name though, if you're going to feel disgust with yourself then it's clearly not something you get joy from.

CrimbleCrumble1 · 30/12/2021 13:01

realhousewifeofmodor

CrimbleCrumble1
I have a few Dior bags and would rather save up for one of these than spend on the £500 bags.
I also have quite a few under £40 bags that I enjoy using, it’s the middle price range I’m not keen on.

I prefer them, I don’t really go for the £1500 ones either. My bags are more than double that.
It’s no different to preferring an Audi to a Citroen.

saturning · 30/12/2021 12:58

My point exactly about cars - you could buy a cheap runaround like a Kia or Ford Focus - why go for a BMW 5 series? Of course its about being in the "i can afford better" gang!!!! Cars are acceptable but more traditionally female things like bags are not.

Omicrone · 30/12/2021 12:56

To be fair, although there will still be a mark up with expensive cars, there is much more of an element of 'you get what you pay for' with cars. The difference between a Ferarri, a Mercedes and a Hyundai is huge in terms of engine, interior spec etc and much bigger than the difference between a New Look, a Mulberry and a Hermes bag. There is just no way that a single handbag can be worth 20 grand, or even a thousand pounds really, even when you factor in materials and labour.

The ridiculous price hikes of Chanel bags in the last 3 or 4 years have shown that its all total bullshit.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 30/12/2021 12:56

@ShinyHappyPoster

I think posters who say it's only about the label, can't imagine people just buying something they like ... which is sad. There are also issues of materials, workmanship, whether staff are paid a living wage ... plus the design element. This is reminding me of a thread from a few weeks ago. Handbags aren't 'valued' because they are associated with women and viewed as 'frivolous' purchases. Watches and cars are viewed as serious 'investments' because they're traditionally associated with the male market. In the last year, handbags have outstripped watches, cars and property on investment returns. And yet women are constantly asked to 'justify' their frivolity. It's not frivolity when it's the most sound investment on the market. Handbags and jewellery are both good ways for women to have access to valuable items that can be carried easily and converted to money if need be.
I think you are ascribing views to people without evidence. I think a man who buys an ugly watch to show off the maker, or has a car he can't get in and out of properly but is a high end brand, is a tit.

Again, as I said for bags - buy what you like, and enjoy using it. Buying anything because you think the brand is impressive is vacuous.

ShinyHappyPoster · 30/12/2021 12:46

I think posters who say it's only about the label, can't imagine people just buying something they like ... which is sad.
There are also issues of materials, workmanship, whether staff are paid a living wage ... plus the design element.
This is reminding me of a thread from a few weeks ago. Handbags aren't 'valued' because they are associated with women and viewed as 'frivolous' purchases. Watches and cars are viewed as serious 'investments' because they're traditionally associated with the male market.
In the last year, handbags have outstripped watches, cars and property on investment returns. And yet women are constantly asked to 'justify' their frivolity. It's not frivolity when it's the most sound investment on the market. Handbags and jewellery are both good ways for women to have access to valuable items that can be carried easily and converted to money if need be.

UserBot99 · 30/12/2021 12:43

My hunt for a beautiful bag that I could fall in love with came from a brand-ignorant starting place. I was looking around with big eyes and the ones I LOVED weren't cheap.

Then I started noticing patterns, I tend to like Loewe bags. I don't seem to like Chanel bags. So my tastes were a bit champagne on a ginger beer budget but they were still genuine.

I'm not carrying around a framed bank draft on a strap and it's interesting that some people who don't love bags can reduce a love of bags to pure materialisms and nothing else. No space to allow an appreciation for the design or the quality at all.

The bag I bought for my 50th, if I'd seen a similar bag for half the price I would have bought it but there's nothing out there remotely similar and I do appreciate the quality and the design being unusual.

I have brought it to work, on the bus, out to family events and I wouldn't think that most people know well that was not from m&s.