Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you decided on a guardian for your will (disagreement with DH)

59 replies

ToInverness · 29/12/2021 21:05

Just that really, I'd love to hear how you decided who to name as guardian in your will, particularly if you disagreed with your partner. I'm in a situation where I want my sister, DH wants his sister, and I've no idea where we go from here or how we resolve it. I've not helped myself because I initially agreed to his sister, but having seen over Christmas how she interacts with our LO v how my sister does, I am desperate to switch!

OP posts:
LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 30/12/2021 07:00

You can agree to disagree on this. You make separate wills. The appointment of a guardian only takes effect in the event that both of you are dead. You appoint your sister, he appoints his. In the event you were both to tragically die together in circumstances where it is not possible to say which of you died first, then the younger is deemed to have died last.

Your DH cannot compel you to name his sister as guardian in your will, any more than you can compel him to name yours.

Alternatively you can both name both of them. Usually if 2 people are named they are a couple. But not exclusively so. This does raise the chance for conflict later on though.

Mrsgordonselfridge · 30/12/2021 06:59

I’d choose the person who will best serve your child’s interests if anything happens to both of you. For us, this included following our beliefs/standards etc about raising children, education, nurturing etc. does either sibling have children? Plan to have children? FWIW my Dsis lives with a controlling arsehole who thought it was funny to allow by DD to watch him play COD when she was 5.. so no to them even though they are childless by choice so maybe would be seen as the ‘natural’ choice. However I know they would not see the ‘value’ in education/choosing the right schools and frankly live in a shitty area. Any inheritance my DD received I would not have trusted them to give to her without taking some form of rent/payback etc (a whole other thread). my DH’s sister on the other hand favours some sort of free-range parenting which means her kids have no boundaries, no manners and are a complete nightmare but who do live in a hip area but are still a no…so That left us with the godmothers and her godfather (friends for both of us for nearly 40years) who we spend the most time with, and trust implicitly to ensure my DD would be well-loved, receive the best education, support, finance and also could tell my DD the most about me, my DH etc if anything were to happen. One is named as her legal guardian, one to manage her inheritance and one to provide moral support and is the next named guardian if anything happens to the first. I don’t think you can exclusively include or exclude siblings unless you are certain about all aspects of care and I don’t think either of our siblings would’ve wanted to be the legal guardian either really!

Monday55 · 30/12/2021 06:45

Surely you're meant to ask the person/people before naming them as a guardian as it's a pretty big role and most likely a burden for someone who might not want any/anymore kids.

MrsTerryPratchett · 30/12/2021 06:43

No idea. We have DH's sister (under sufferance) and I'm just praying we don't die.

girlmom21 · 30/12/2021 06:42

Have you spoken to both sisters and asked if it's something they'd actually be willing to do?

RedRobin100 · 30/12/2021 06:38

F - interested jn this, not because of an argument, but how to choose..

GoodnightGrandma · 30/12/2021 06:36

What happens if you both put your choices, then the person who lives longest gets their way ?

Flickflak · 30/12/2021 06:34

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lochmaree · 29/12/2021 21:10

my DHs family are dysfunctional and his parents abusive and there was no way we would put any of them as guardians. DH agreed luckily! but that was the thing that decided it for us. within my family, it would be whoever had the capacity at the time should it ever occur. not one named person.

Swipe left for the next trending thread