Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you decided on a guardian for your will (disagreement with DH)

59 replies

ToInverness · 29/12/2021 21:05

Just that really, I'd love to hear how you decided who to name as guardian in your will, particularly if you disagreed with your partner. I'm in a situation where I want my sister, DH wants his sister, and I've no idea where we go from here or how we resolve it. I've not helped myself because I initially agreed to his sister, but having seen over Christmas how she interacts with our LO v how my sister does, I am desperate to switch!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ToykotoLosAngeles · 30/12/2021 17:29

Closest upbringing to the one we would have given him, which is my mum and dad. DH was in full agreement having been raised by helicopter parents.

Retrievemysanity · 30/12/2021 17:11

We chose my best friend. All my family are dead, PIL wouldn’t cope and BIL and family live too far away so it would mean a complete upheaval for the DDs. Best friend has no children of her own and is probably unlikely to and she’s godmother to my eldest. We spoke about it and she’s happy to do it although I think she hopes DH and I have a very long life Grin

Toddlerandthecat · 30/12/2021 17:03

We chose my BIL & his partner (child free by choice). My DB has 2 children so he wouldn't be able to prioritise my DS the way I would want (nor would I expect him to). BIL also lives very close to us so would be no issues with school etc, and has very similar opinions & values to myself.

Classicblunder · 30/12/2021 14:32

Have you actually asked your sisters about this? One of them might say no and make the decision for you

logsonlogsoff · 30/12/2021 14:27

Re inheritance, you can have more than one trustee for the money which we have. DW mother is joint with my DSis.

logsonlogsoff · 30/12/2021 14:25

We chose my sister because I have no doubt that she would put the kids needs above hers and can be entirely trusted with the large amount of money they’ll inherit.
DSIL on the other hand is motivated by money, and always thinks her way is the only way and her kids are entitled brats So it made the decision easy.

MrsToothyBitch · 30/12/2021 14:12

We've only discussed this hypothetically atm but we did discuss it when SiL named us & FiL for DNiece.

ATM it's FiL then my cousin who has DC already and I know his parents would help, too. My parents are 87 and 71 so they're not a practical solution although would want them involved. My other BiLs are still young and getting eatablished atm so we wouldn't put them down until they're more settled, really.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 30/12/2021 14:06

We have this same issue - can’t agree on which sister (mine or his) and as a result we’ve just shelved the topic and not made a will!
Really need to sort this out.

In reality I think if we both died they’d live with my ILs who are in their 70s so maybe that’s the answer but I’d definitely want both sisters involved and my sister to manage their finances, we have some family money on my side so she’d be best for that.

TerribleCustomerCervix · 30/12/2021 14:03

My sister and her DH.

They have a child close in age, same parenting values and live ten mins away, so the kids can stay at the same school.

DH was a bit put out, but his family, although lovely, do things very differently from us and that’s not how I want to raise my kids.

His eldest sister and mine are joint trustees, so his side will still be very involved.

Liverbird77 · 30/12/2021 13:54

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Justkeeppedaling · 30/12/2021 11:32

You can name more than one Guardian. And the guardian doesn't have to be the person the child lives with.

We agreed with friends that if they died, their DD (my DDs best friend) could live with us so she could continue at the same school. Her two much older siblings (by about 15 years, so adults at the time of the agreement) would be the child's guardians, so the major decision makers in everything.

User124689 · 30/12/2021 11:20

We were advised to not choose parents unless they were “young”. And we have three sets because mine are divorced/remarried.

5 years ago when we made the wills (DC were 2 and 5 at that point) all parents were in good health. Since then, so much has changed in terms of health and our relationship with them, I’m so glad we didn’t choose them.

In the end we chose my brother and DSIL.

Swonderful · 30/12/2021 11:10

I think the biggest issue is if they could cope with bringing up someone else's kids. Saying you'll do it in theory and actually managing if something awful happened are 2 different things. I know some friends who were appointed guardians and did it for a few years when both the kids parents died. But they also had 3 kids of their own and couldn't cope. The kids went to some other relatives in the end.

Peccary · 30/12/2021 10:48

Just glad this was one of our easier decisions in life, DH's sister, no contest. She's willing, is a sahm, has room and DD adores her.

Kbyodjs · 30/12/2021 10:25

Our decision came down to finances and practicalities in the end; I wanted my sister but then she’d have 4 children under 5 (with mine and hers combined) and they’d have to use a huge amount of our life insurance to buy a bigger house as well as putting them in childcare to be able to work which generally is fine but not for two recently bereaved children whereas DHs parents have a big enough home already and are retired. Once kids and grandparents are are older we’d rethink.

Boysnme · 30/12/2021 10:19

We chose my brother as guardian, not because we particularly wanted the kids to live with him but because he was the only one I trusted at the time to make the right decision for my children.

We are now in a position to know where the kids would go, my BIL is much more settled, lives nearer us kids see a lot of him and would take them in a heart beat. We’re not going to bother changing our wills though as I know my brother would agree that BIL is the right person to have our kids.

It was quite easy for us though as at the time of doing our wills we’d never have picked my DHs brother and my brother was the only option.

Ghostofchristmaspasty · 30/12/2021 09:45

We chose friends with similar aged children who have the same parenting style as us. We both named the same couple and we are thier guardians in return.

We both have siblings - neither have/want children so it didn't feel right to name them. Parents too old/infirm, not really involved with kids. I really hope we don't die, but I feel we have made the right decision and as the years have passed it's confirmed this.

WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 30/12/2021 08:54

We chose someone child free who could and would put our DC front and centre in their lives in the same way we would. They're friends, not family, and would understand much better what choices we would make and also live in the same city we do so DC could go to the same school. They could also offer a good standard of living and the kind of experiences we would want our DC to have. Family guardians would involve moving to a new area, changing schools and having to slot in to an existing family, so while loved I think would always be a bit of a spare part.

We have discussed it with potential guardian but not our families. It would only cause upset for them about something we hope would never happen. Potential guardian knows this and is comfortable in having to deal with the fallout should the worse happen!

housecoat1968 · 30/12/2021 08:51

It's been a while since we had to do this and ours are all adults now, but when discussing with the solicitor they advised that the Guardians appointed were there to make decisions about the best care for the children, not necessarily to have them.
Ultimately social services would decide with input from the guardians and any other instructions left in the will.
We therefore named my parents and my brother.

Aurorie11 · 30/12/2021 08:49

We have my sister and husbands sister.
Logic was if the worst was to happen we wouldn’t know who would be at the best stage of their lives to care for our children. Guardian for us is about making the right decision when the time comes not necessarily being the care giver.
As it happens I think when we made the wills about 10 years ago SIL would have been the choice as carer now I think due to changing circumstances it’s my sister.
Hopefully there will never be a need for guardians

Bohemond · 30/12/2021 08:46

Neither of our siblings is suitable so we have chosen my cousin and her husband. They do not have children at home but they live rurally unlike any of my close friends which is what we chose for our child. He will have a trust with three trustees - my cousin and two of my close friends - who will advocate/advise him in all matters until he is 25.

JeremiahObadiahJackanoryJonez · 30/12/2021 08:45

We have my brother and dh’s sister.

Our logic was/is that the guardian isn’t necessarily the one who does the day to day caring, but they are representing our children and making the best decisions for them at the time.

It meant both families would be involved as well. We are fortunate to get on well with both sides.

HoboSexualOnslow · 30/12/2021 08:43

[quote EnterFunnyNameHere]**@Liverbird77 & @Jennifer2r that's absolutely fascinating (to me).

I don't have kids (by choice) - even though I know my friends/family think I would make a great parent I know that I really wouldn't, because how could I be good at something I really don't want to do?

@Liverbird77, if you don't mind me asking, how did your friend respond when you told him you'd selected him for guardianship?

Sorry if I'm being weird, I'd just never thought about the issue from this perspective and find it really interesting! I don't even understand why people think it's logical to ask me to babysit for them giving I blatantly have no idea what I'm doing having no experience Grin[/quote]
Same! I do love my nieces and nephews but I would not want to be their guardian. I don't want children at any stage of life, especially ones traumatised by their parents death.

Heruka · 30/12/2021 08:38

We have put off making a will for years because we can’t decide on this! Know that’s daft. But we don’t really feel comfy with any of the options for various reasons. At the moment I’d prefer my best friend and have joked about it but feels a big ask when her kids are also wee! But she’d be most aligned to our values. Let’s just hope we don’t both die.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 30/12/2021 08:38

[quote Mrsgordonselfridge]@EnterFunnyNameHere I agree with you…however, everyone in our families think that’s what we’d do and should do…Confused And because my narcissistic mother tells anyone who’ll listen that my Golden child Dsis ‘can’t have children’ when that is not actually the case… so obviously in the event of death I’d be giving her mine… Err righto.[/quote]
Yikes, that sounds difficult to manage (for a whole host of reasons). Although we thankfully don't have to navigate that kind of dynamic, I actually could imagine some family members thinking I would be the obvious choice if my DB were to pass away (and have kids!), you know - youngest female relative bound to be ideal candidate for maternal action and all that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread