Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Class difference - if you're posh

413 replies

2022bebetter · 29/12/2021 20:48

Posh people of MN, help me!

I have married into a very posh family. Not titled posh, but public school. DH and his brothers all lovely.

Sister, MIL and SIL clearly look down on me.

I know I shouldn't care and it's their problem etc but I feel so embarrassed when I clearly get stuff 'wrong'.

SIL in particular, will never correct me but quite often say 'I could never do xx, so tacky / common' knowing full well it's something I do! Most recently I have learnt that I say garage 'wrong'.

Wherever we go, they always dress so similar and I get it 'wrong'.

Obviously the easiest tip is not to care, but any advice from posh MNetters would be so gratefully received.

OP posts:
ShirleyPhallus · 30/12/2021 15:01

@poissonrouge1

Get your grammar right.

It’s not “if I was you...” which I’ve seen written here. It’s “if I were you...”

To me, correct grammar sets people apart.

I think this is true when I see people saying “I made dinner for DH and I” thinking using “I” makes them sound smarter but is actually used incorrectly. Even worse, misuse of “myself”
footcushion · 30/12/2021 13:54

Completely agree. I’m taken aback by the extent of class deference on this thread. Always the same on MN - the "proper UCs" are seen by some as educated with impeccable grammar, manners, almost saintly in their modesty and anyone who professes to be UC and doesn't appear to be saintly in all things is clearly not really UC at all. Grin

poissonrouge1 · 30/12/2021 12:52

Get your grammar right.

It’s not “if I was you...” which I’ve seen written here. It’s “if I were you...”

To me, correct grammar sets people apart.

Donotgogentle · 30/12/2021 12:05

@TatianaBis

Fridafever

I think what I’m mainly getting from this thread is that most of mumsnet think it’s impossible for upper class people to be unpleasant. The forelock tugging is absolutely hilarious.

Ibane

Yup. UC people are just as likely to be a shower of bastards as anyone else, regardless of their fabled dog-hair-covered tweeds and battered estates.

I am genuinely astonished by the starstruck, forelock-tugging, feudalist idealism on this thread.

Some uc are lovely and some are complete counts (😉).

You can get nice and nasty, snobby and unsnobby within the same family. It depends on their personalities, values, intelligence level etc.

This quaint idea that real posh people have impeccable manners, put everyone at ease, don’t care about status is hogwash.

Some are super obsessed with class, money, privilege, elitism, knowing people who are people, and making people who are not people feel small. They care about class because it’s their social trump card.

Completely agree. I’m taken aback by the extent of class deference on this thread. It explains a lot about the state of politics in this country.
TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 30/12/2021 11:56

Being privately educated, pretentious and rude should not be conflated with being "posh".

TheTrinity · 30/12/2021 11:37

I totally understand how difficult this must be for you. As if unwelcoming in laws aren't enough in any family. I'm not posh but have experienced and seen examples of such petty behaviour. My conclusion is that you simply have to become more confident and be proudly and unapologetically yourself. Someone may know exactly which plate and fork to use but if they don't have good manners and behave graciously towards EVERYONE, there's no point. The treatment you're receiving shows poor manners at best. They are simply rude. Please don't ever feel the need to sink to that level. Just be yourself and you'll be accepted and loved for it.

If you want to learn about dinner table etiquette then read up on it and anything else you think will help you.

AwaitingJudy · 30/12/2021 11:28

The reality is that they are insecure, nouveau riche middle class with aspirations to being seen and accepted as upper-middle or 'U'.

Nothing particularly wrong with that in general (though it's ripe for comedy) but going about it in this nasty way is a) horrible and b) in fact completely counter-productive as it marks them out as exactly what they are in the eyes of everyone they'd want to fit in with.

Another reality is that they could very easily be made to feel the way they make you feel by the truly 'U', and I would enjoy seeing it.

I shouldn't try to change yourself to fit with them, not least because you will never achieve it. That isn't because you are incapable of studying the whole class system very hard and understanding ask the 'rules' (though it's very difficult and there will almost always remain little 'tells') but because they don't want you to and will never be satisfied and let you into the 'club'. They want you to be someone they can patronise and look down on in order to cement their own social standing in their own head. No matter how well you imitate them, they will always find or invent something to single out to make the point that you are different.

If you're interested in all this from an anthropological point of view (and it really is fascinating!) may I recommend 'Watching The English' by Kate Fox? If you want to learn enough that you don't feel wrong-footed by unknown common 'rules' (and I sympathise with that - like learning local customs when abroad just so you roughly know what's what) I'd start with old copies of Debretts guides.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 30/12/2021 11:27

DH is from an aristocratic family.

I’m from a normal middle class family.

I just ask him for tips and pointers eg place settings and meal etiquette. If we’re going to a family event I dress in a similar style to MIL, she’s always happy to help if asked. DH will discreetly remind me if I use the wrong plate. I try to read the room and copy.

Nobody has ever made me feel lower class than them though. Class is never mentioned. They should be pleased you make their DS happy, not obsessed with what school you went to or what class you’re from.

HelloDulling · 30/12/2021 11:25

@DixieSun

Start calling SIL Mrs Bucket or Hyacinth.

Every time. "Alright Mrs Bucket, yes Hyacinth"

Rugby is an odd choice for just girls btw.

Agree. Too thick for Cheltenham or too poor for Benenden?
millymae · 30/12/2021 11:19

My goodness try not to give the silly mares the time of day - they sound like snobs of the highest order. Women with money but not much class.

Carry on just being the person your husband married and ignore their ridiculous speech affectations. Just because they have money and had a private education doesn’t make them any better than you.

As a family we still have the occasional laugh about my sister’s experience at a meet the family dinner at her then boyfriend’s house. She arrived home, having dumped him on the way back, with steam almost coming out of her ears full of indignation that his mother before the food was served explained to her in almost words of one syllable which cutlery to use with each course, the implication being that she would be out of her depth with such an array of it on the table.

RosesAndHellebores · 30/12/2021 11:05

I know people.from the East End (would have been 20s/30s in the early 80s) who are natural gentlemen and ladies and people who attended Eton and St Mary's who are utterly vile and snobs to boot. And vice versa.

RosesAndHellebores · 30/12/2021 11:02

@Bollocks2Covid the SIL undoubtedly has room (a whole room) for a pony but would she know how to look after one with hooves and a tail.

TatianaBis · 30/12/2021 10:59

Fridafever

I think what I’m mainly getting from this thread is that most of mumsnet think it’s impossible for upper class people to be unpleasant. The forelock tugging is absolutely hilarious.

Ibane

Yup. UC people are just as likely to be a shower of bastards as anyone else, regardless of their fabled dog-hair-covered tweeds and battered estates.

I am genuinely astonished by the starstruck, forelock-tugging, feudalist idealism on this thread.

Some uc are lovely and some are complete counts (😉).

You can get nice and nasty, snobby and unsnobby within the same family. It depends on their personalities, values, intelligence level etc.

This quaint idea that real posh people have impeccable manners, put everyone at ease, don’t care about status is hogwash.

Some are super obsessed with class, money, privilege, elitism, knowing people who are people, and making people who are not people feel small. They care about class because it’s their social trump card.

agapanthus1979 · 30/12/2021 10:55

@XelaM
Wow. Your family might well be 'highly educated' but you all sound pretty ignorant. No wonder she stays away....

Bollocks2Covid · 30/12/2021 10:46

Does your SIL have a Mercedes’, sauna and room for a pony OP? Asking for a friend 😉

TheWatersofMarch · 30/12/2021 10:45

True good manners boil down to consideration of others. My truly posh friends are genuinely interested in other peoples views - they are secure in their poshness and engage with people on level terms and at face value, rather than looking down on them. These relatives of yours are just rude and uptight.

alphasox · 30/12/2021 10:30

They sound rude, not posh. The poshest landed titled person I know is as friendly to the street cleaner as they are to the aristos. Class = knowing how to behave in a way that makes everyone feel welcome, not sneering at or belittling people less fortunate.

catgirl1976 · 30/12/2021 09:55

I’m afraid they don’t sound “posh” to me given they are completely lacking in manners, class and etiquette. They sound on a level with Hyacinth Bucket

I would use the MN standard “did you mean to be so rude?” And ignore them

whatwasIgoingtosay · 30/12/2021 09:50

@foxgoosefinch brilliant poem, thanks!

ExConstance · 30/12/2021 09:42

The first rule of being proper posh is to make everyone feel at their ease when they are with you. The proper posh certainly wouldn't say anything about the way anyone spoke. As a child I lived on the estate of an Earl, my family were tenant farmers and my friends were the children of the butler and chauffeur. If any members of the "family" came across you they would be polite and friendly. As an adult I've noticed the main hallmark of most people educated at public school is a real social ease, polite and friendly with everyone.
In 2021 all accents are acceptable, indeed the BBC promotes regional accents and I do;n't think many people aspire to RP English now.
I don't think your in-laws are posh, I think they are just entitled and rude. Don't give them a second thought and just carry on as you are.

Tillymintpolo · 30/12/2021 09:24

Just say ‘thanks Hyacinth’ and roll your eyes. You need to stand up for yourself

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 30/12/2021 09:18

I’d have fun and each and every time I had such a comment I’d be saying, ‘oh I keep forgetting how aspirational you are! I’m just not used to it’. Ask if it’s tiring being aspiring, ask what she feels gets her noticed best etc

Abhannmor · 30/12/2021 09:12

@immersivereader

God I'd have to take the piss out of them, majorly.

'Spoken to Megan recently??'
'Is it a napkin or a serviette??'
'How does one hold this frigging fork??'

Etc etc

If we said 'napkin' they'd call it something else. It's all about gatekeeping.
Ibane · 30/12/2021 09:02

@Fridafever

I think what I’m mainly getting from this thread is that most of mumsnet think it’s impossible for upper class people to be unpleasant. The forelock tugging is absolutely hilarious.
Yup. UC people are just as likely to be a shower of bastards as anyone else, regardless of their fabled dog-hair-covered tweeds and battered estates.
DoubleTweenQueen · 30/12/2021 08:42

Quite right! - money can't buy class, in fact in many cases it's a positive hindrance - as my DM used to say.

And yes, they do sound rather vulgar and not quality people at all :D