Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Class difference - if you're posh

413 replies

2022bebetter · 29/12/2021 20:48

Posh people of MN, help me!

I have married into a very posh family. Not titled posh, but public school. DH and his brothers all lovely.

Sister, MIL and SIL clearly look down on me.

I know I shouldn't care and it's their problem etc but I feel so embarrassed when I clearly get stuff 'wrong'.

SIL in particular, will never correct me but quite often say 'I could never do xx, so tacky / common' knowing full well it's something I do! Most recently I have learnt that I say garage 'wrong'.

Wherever we go, they always dress so similar and I get it 'wrong'.

Obviously the easiest tip is not to care, but any advice from posh MNetters would be so gratefully received.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
georgarina · 31/12/2021 12:12

They don't actually sound posh. They sound snobby and aspirational ie Hyacinth Bucket.

If they were actually posh they wouldn't care and you shouldn't either - be yourself, don't try to fit in with them. They probably look and act ridiculous. Your ILs would be the ones making fools of themselves in front of actually 'posh' people.

HeronLanyon · 31/12/2021 11:57

Indeeeeed (big stress on second syllable thete !) 😹

TatianaBis · 31/12/2021 11:31

@HeronLanyon

tatiana whole continents/countries would disagree.
That’s rather the point.
Moomoo75 · 31/12/2021 11:07

The only one to worry about is your husband. He obviously loves you as you are don't change to fit in with his sisters. Your sisters in law themselves behave in cheap way. People with true class would never speak or act the way they do. So head up Gurl you are already a cut above them.Xmas Wink

Pensieve · 31/12/2021 10:31

OP there are a few of your ILs on this thread, who are obnoxiously trying to correct pronunciation for the word garage. Really? It’s like any historical institution that tries to exert power and influence by somehow differentiating itself from the masses.

How pathetic and so very last century.

HeronLanyon · 31/12/2021 10:04

tatiana whole continents/countries would disagree.

TatianaBis · 31/12/2021 10:01

Mirage can be either Mi rarge or Mi rarrrge.

But garage is ga rarge. Not ga rarrrge.

HeronLanyon · 31/12/2021 09:51

I’m afraid i was exposed to the norm of garaaaaaaaaaage with stress on second syllable when a child. Everyone in my life and all friends said it this way. Cue exposure to uk garridge. Confusions and it remains a bogey word for me.
We did actually have a carriage house during the garridge days and we called it ‘the workshop’ far far safer.
Love garridge music.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 31/12/2021 09:15

@daytriptovulcan

In essence you re just being abused and put down by egotistical people. Beyond that, all facets of poshness are pure fake. Do they live in a 5 million pound house, with holiday home(s) abroad? No? Their poshness is just bullshit. I ve meet oligarchs who are not posh. What you describe is unfriendliness, and probably just the difference between a working class and affluent middle class upbringing.
Since when does a 5 million pound house + holiday homes abroad equal what is seen as ‘posh’? You seem to be confusing it with ‘loaded’, which is not the same thing.
thisgardenlife · 31/12/2021 09:02

@Ericaequites

Garage rhymes with mirage, not carriage.
It depends where you come from. In Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and most of England, it rhymes with carriage.

Some people in the south of England say garage like mirage, but that does not make it right, or posh.

From Collins dictionary:

daisychain01 · 31/12/2021 09:01

@Ericaequites

Garage rhymes with mirage, not carriage.
Thanks, good to know,
BurnedToast · 31/12/2021 06:48

That's just your opinion.

Ericaequites · 31/12/2021 02:31

Garage rhymes with mirage, not carriage.

FlamingLama · 31/12/2021 02:07

Ive come across their kind before and I think you could dress like them, walk, talk and act like them and they will still look down on you unfortunately.

Better to be yourself and own it. You sound lovely by the way. I'd much rather a cuppa with you than them!

Bettysnow · 31/12/2021 02:02

They sound like a pack if oiks! Do not allow yourself to feel inferior to these rude morons!
I personally would wind them up as much as i could by deliberately using wrong cutlery whilst proclaiming my love of all things tacky, sit back and watch the pearl clutching! Grin

mathanxiety · 31/12/2021 01:45

For instance someone unthread said to be truly "posh" you should use the words napkin, sitting room, lunch and dinner. Every working class Irish peasant uses those terms

LOL, YYY to this.

The 'posh' thing is incredibly insular.

If I were you, OP, I would let it all wash right over me and treat it as a pathetic expression of insecurity on a personal level on the part of the ILs, which it is.

There is nothing real about the English class system. It only holds power over people because they are willing to let it. If you decide it doesn't exist, nobody can make you kow tow to the silly expectations.

In the words of Eleanor Roosevelt, “No one can make you feel inferior without your consent.”

Queenie6655 · 31/12/2021 00:44

@RingBinderInjury

Be happy in the knowledge that by uttering the words “so common” out loud and purposefully putting you down she has revealed her true nouveau riche self. How embarrassing for her.
Yes so very true

How ridiculous

thisgardenlife · 31/12/2021 00:28

You sound lovely, your in-laws sound appalling.

I had a posh upbringing (public school, a few titled friends with a butler, that sort of thing). I am not remotely posh now.

Nobody in the circles in which I grew up Grin would refer to anyone as 'common'. The only people in my experience who use that word (referring to people) are the worst sort of stuck-up, upwardly mobile, pretentious twats.

For a genuine mix of people all working together in harmony, treating each other with kindness and respect for everyone's glorious differences see Christmas at Holkam Hall - I think it was on Channel 4. It is a lovely example of how we all complement each other, regardless of our roots. Good manners and kindness are all that matters.

Just be yourself, and if you can, laugh inwardly at your in-laws ridiculous pretensions.

anotheronenow · 31/12/2021 00:21

+1 here for the fact that the genuinely posh (a) would not really notice or care how you pronounce something or how your behaviours might differ from theirs, e.g. cutlery at the table etc, and (b) even If they did, it's been drummed into them that you never, ever draw attention to anything that would make someone else feel uncomfortable. It's the essence of good manners.

So, SIL and MIL etc are in fact not genuinely posh. As has already been observed on this thread, they're snobs with money.

You need to find a way to let them know that, or you need to rise above it. Don't ever feel inferior to them, because quite clearly you're not. You were brought up to understand making people feel bad about themselves is awful.

"SIL, you know what you just said about how is pronounced, I know this wasn't how you meant it, but I actually pronounce it like that and I know you're a kind person with good manners but if someone else heard you say that they might think you were being bit snobby like Hyacinth Bucket? I think it's called 'new money' or something like that? Linguists agree that pronunciation is descriptive and people being prescriptive about how you should say something just don't understand how language works. I love language though, it's like a lovely garden, all the flowers can bloom, anyway, just to let you know, because I can imagine it could be embarrassing for you to be misinterpreted"

Or something.

catfunk · 31/12/2021 00:05

Shame they didn't learn any manners or grace in their public school isn't it. I'd be suggesting a refund to MIL.

Pensieve · 31/12/2021 00:02

OP - I’m in a similar situation to you re. class difference, except they’re not overtly snobby and disrespectful towards me. I have been ‘accepted’ perhaps on merit given I’ve done very well for myself and am a charming conversationalist and nice person Smile I would never let anyone make me feel inferior anyway so perhaps it’s how you carry yourself and this is a you not them problem per se. There are always dickheads in life.

Generally my IL/extended family are nice people although I often observe some of them need a reality check. Early on I once overheard and was then asked to comment on a conversation that a cousin was dating a plumber as if this was a very negative thing. “what do you think Pensieve”, at which point I loudly guffawed. Said my father was X tradesperson and quoted how much we (and they all) had had to pay for work in the house and had to wait months so I very much doubt they’d have financial concerns. Wink.

Luredbyapomegranate · 30/12/2021 23:56

@AuntieObnoxious

Rugby is odd choice for girls as it’s traditionally a boys school. I even remember when they started allowing girls, but I am in my 50s. Normally if brother/sister siblings don’t attend the same school then they attend schools that are known for traditionally favouring their gender e.g. girls go to a girls school; Cheltenham or Roedean etc. Girls who have been to Rugby usually tend to be a bit strange and lacking social skills in my experience.
@AuntieObnoxious

This is rubbish. Lots of girls whose brothers are at Eton/Winchester/Harrow are at Rugby/Marlborough/Oundle etc - it’s a perfectly normal choice if you want all your kids to have the advantages of the scale, resources and networking of the major originally-all-boys public schools.

Grumpysister · 30/12/2021 23:49

Ok I haven’t read every post on this thread but have looked at the OP’s - I am from what would be termed a pretty posh background (think titles, boarding school, country life style, land etc etc). Basically your in laws sound grim - and lacking in basic manners. I’m intrigued by the SIL who is the rudest but apparently according to herself the poshest. She is clearly very insecure and just all out rude. As others have said you really have a DH problem - he should have your back.
And I’m also confused by the comments about girls at Rugby. If you are looking at boarding schools you decide if you want co-ed or single sex, and then choose schools accordingly (ie in a pretty normal way) - no idea why you’d only send girls to a school that used to be a girls’ school Hmm.

AuntieObnoxious · 30/12/2021 23:37

Rugby is odd choice for girls as it’s traditionally a boys school. I even remember when they started allowing girls, but I am in my 50s.
Normally if brother/sister siblings don’t attend the same school then they attend schools that are known for traditionally favouring their gender e.g. girls go to a girls school; Cheltenham or Roedean etc. Girls who have been to Rugby usually tend to be a bit strange and lacking social skills in my experience.

footcushion · 30/12/2021 23:10

@WaitingForSunshineAndDaisies

I haven't RTFT but if no-one's pointed this out yet, true class is knowing the difference between etiquette and manners (etiquette - knowing what to do; manners - shelving that knowledge and doing whatever makes your guest feel comfortable)
No such thing as true class. Things matter because people expect it to - mostly it's about customs and normal behaviours and that will flux and change by geography and time..