Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex DBiL attitude to food - is this acceptable?

94 replies

6079SmithW · 29/12/2021 15:05

Disclaimer: I have posted about this before (when I thought it was a one off) but now it has happened again I don't know if I should do something?

ExDH took DC to DBiL for Christmas. We have two DD primary school age but think upper years. When the girls got back they told me this happened (I asked ExDH and he confirmed it).

I bought all the Christmas presents, and included in the girls' stockings a box each of trashy American breakfast cereal that they always ask for but are never allowed to eat usually. When the girls opened them DBiL wrote 'BAD' and 'Unhealthy' on the boxes and lectured them about the amount of sugar etc.

DBiL has form for this kind of behaviour. On a previous visit he made them do star jumps before they were allowed a piece of birthday cake. He only seems to do it where the girls are concerned (he didn't make the adults do star jumps or go around writing 'bad' on the adults chocolates or booze for example).

ExDH seems to think his brother's behaviour is totally acceptable and refuses to do anything about it. AIBU to worry that this is fat shaming and could lead to body issues/eating disorders?

FWIW I am overweight so I believe that's why DBiL behaves like this, but having struggled with weight my entire life, no one wants the girls to not become overweight more than me.

OP posts:
CheshireSplat · 29/12/2021 17:53

I agree this is a problem. Sadly the first thing the chocolate bar and star jumps made me think of was a school friend who was anorexic. She'd go for a long run for every chocolate bar she ate.

That has made me uber sensitive to linking exercise to "balance" out food and girls particularly are so prone to eating disorders.

BoredZelda · 29/12/2021 17:48

I don't agree that it's fat-shaming and unacceptable to point out that junk food is junk food.

On a kids Christmas present? How is the view up there from that high horse?

SheikhMaraca · 29/12/2021 17:46

It’s a difficult one. I do think we tiptoe around weight for fear of causing eating disorders, but we need to bear in mind that we are on track to have pretty much the whole population either overweight or obese in the near future.

This can be Contrasted with the fact that approx 8% of the population have an eating disorder (only 0.6% having anorexia).

I think the conclusion has to be that your ExBIL INU, your DDs are at far more risk of obesity than an eating disorder, so he is in the right to draw attention to this.

Snowsaurus · 29/12/2021 17:40

Give the kids a marker and tell them to write BAD on his forehead.

WonderfulYou · 29/12/2021 17:39

My DDs dad is like this.
It can absolutely lead to eating disorders. They say you should never label food as bad or good as your brain associates it with punishment which leads to emotional eating and then an eating disorder.

I would just try and make fun of him to your girls and tell them how silly he is. Ask them to try and get him and their dad to join in with the exercise.

Excitedforthefuture · 29/12/2021 17:36

@OhGiveUp

I would be tearing strips off both the ex husband and his brother! No way would I let my kids anywhere near him again! Star jumps indeed!!
You’re not divorced are you?

Sadly this simply isn’t realistic.

OP, nothing is better than ridiculing. When the girls are back with you, ridicule their uncle for his views (and anything and everything else), scorn him, laugh at him. Don’t make out you’re upset. Make out it’s so laughably stupid that you won’t dignify it with any response other than taking the piss

OhGiveUp · 29/12/2021 17:34

I would be tearing strips off both the ex husband and his brother!
No way would I let my kids anywhere near him again!
Star jumps indeed!!

2020nymph · 29/12/2021 17:31

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

We've just had a similar conversation. SIL is a SW lifer and spoke a few times about how bread/cheese/something else were bad foods on Christmas Day. When she saw DS filling his plate with fruit and veg at Christmas buffet she told him that was healthy and the other food was not.

It sounds like she does that every day when she gets a little platform anyway, but she reminds me of all the joy sponges who wring their hands in despair and urgently warn you that the average person eats X-thousands of calories on Christmas Day, which is dreadful as the daily calorie requirement is only half/a quarter/a tenth of that.

I don't know if they also notice that most people spend far more than 1/365th of their annual income on Christmas Day as well. It's almost as if it's some kind of only-one-day-a-year special feast and celebration day....

Every time we see her!!

2020nymph · 29/12/2021 17:30

@ANameChangeAgain

Don't you just love a pious sl lifer, should have read. My Internet is crap today!

Every conversation I have with them!!!

TheOriginalEmu · 29/12/2021 17:29

@RandomLondoner

I don't agree that it's fat-shaming and unacceptable to point out that junk food is junk food.
Well if that’s what he’s done I’d agree. But he didn’t he wrote BAD and UNHEALTHLY on a child’s gift.
QueeniesCroft · 29/12/2021 17:11

He's awful! Is this something he only does to young girls, or is it all children? The star jumps thing is all kinds of creepy too!

mathanxiety · 29/12/2021 17:11

And if your exH is too much of a wimp to stick up for his daughters when they are being bullied in front of his own eyes, then I would hesitate to let them stay with him.

mathanxiety · 29/12/2021 17:09

@6079SmithW

Why are they never allowed the offending cereal, and it's only a Christmas treat?

Either it's ok to eat or it is not.

I agree your former BIL is all kinds of wrong on this one, and I hinestly think your DDs should write BAD on bottles of wine, and even verbally question it every time a glass is poured or a chocolate is chosen from a box at BIL's house if they're ever there again, but examine what you yourself are saying to your daughters when you turn certain items into forbidden fruit.

Excitedforthefuture · 29/12/2021 17:05

You did the children’s stockings
For them to open at your ex husband’s?

BillMasheen · 29/12/2021 17:05

Go,and write ‘pollution hazard‘ on his car

(Joking btw)

appleturnovers · 29/12/2021 17:05

It's awful.

Labelling certain foods as "naughty" and shameful can lead to unhealthy relationships with food that can conversely lead to disordered eating.

That's not to say you shouldn't tell children that some foods are healthier than others, but it's not "bad" or naughty or shameful to eat cake and certain sugary American cereals, it's just that we need to make sure we don't eat too much of them and mostly eat nutritious food.

It's Christmas for god's sake, can't children enjoy some tasty food once in a while? (This is aimed at all the virtue-signalling PPs saying it's "junk food". So bloody what? It's not like that's all they ever eat, is it?)

Make sure the children know he's a bit of a nutter, let them know they do NOT have to do star jumps for cake, even if Uncle Nutter says they do, and also I agree with the PP who said the kids should put labels on Uncle Nutter's alcohol bottles.

almondcaramelcoconut · 29/12/2021 17:02

What kind of jerk thinks it's acceptable to write on someone else's gift from their mother?!

If I were you, I'd make my opinion known to the girls. They're old enough to probably realise on their own that he's a controlling fun-sponge, but I'd want to be sure they know that he's being ridiculous and rude. They don't have to tell him that (unless they want to), but they need to be confident enough to brush off his creepy behaviour and know that he's not a trusted adult or someone they should look to for guidance because he's a stupid jerk.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 29/12/2021 16:57

I think you are in danger of taking this too seriously due to your own weight issues

Er no. She's taking it seriously because it is horrible bullying behaviour towards two young primary school children on the part of creepy uncle, who has form for behaving like this.
Why shouldn't this be taken seriously?

MichelleScarn · 29/12/2021 16:45

I actually called him a creepy twat, but spell check like the uncle seems to have gone all pious!

PoshPyjamas · 29/12/2021 16:43

I would just laugh at him - and encourage your DDs to do the same. I think you are in danger of taking this too seriously due to your own weight issues.

heldinadream · 29/12/2021 16:38

How old are your girls? That's waaaaay out of order. I'm not sure what you can do without some ruckus but perhaps encourage them to tell him to do one. Never too young for them to stand up to a bullying nutcase. Why does your ex-dh think this is in any way ok?

Keep the cereal for at home perhaps. But also let your girls know he's a twat.

MintJulia · 29/12/2021 16:36

So your ex-bil has just made himself look boring and joyless in front of his nieces....

I'm sure your dds think you are a cool mum to let them have it. My ds has pain au chocolat for Xmas breakfasts and thinks they are the ultimate in sophistication Smile

Beautiful3 · 29/12/2021 16:36

Thats really bad. I wouldn't alloa them to ho again, without me. He's going to trigger eating disorders.

GrandmasCat · 29/12/2021 16:36

You have an ExH problem, not a ExBIL problem.

Thankfully your kids are at the end of primary school so they can’t be forced to keep in touch with nasty extended family members for much longer. That’s the beauty of teenage in some cases, they step back from unpleasant social interactions by choosing to spend more time with people that makes them feel good and valued, the friends they chose themselves.

VillanellesOrangeCoat · 29/12/2021 16:32

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

I don't agree that it's fat-shaming and unacceptable to point out that junk food is junk food.

So you don't think the fact they're clearly told throughout the year that they can't have it, but only as a special Christmas treat, conveys the message very clearly?

Also, it's bad enough for irritating, boorish people to pass judgment on what you choose to eat - but they hadn't gone and chosen this: it was a present that they just opened. His actions clearly undermined the girls' parents.

Moreover, I know the cereal boxes were destined to become recycling eventually, but how horrible to seize and deface a present that somebody else has just received.

I'm sure he would be furious if he'd received a much-wanted book on golf or fishing and they had scribbled over it 'boring' or 'waste of time hobby - should get another weekend job'.

All he needed to say, to convey his intended mansplaining message, was "Oh, what a lovely very special treat - just because it's Christmas!!!" - but he didn't: instead, he went super weird and totally unacceptable.

This with bells on!! And WTF at the star jumps?!! He’s a bullying fuckwit.