Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have handled it this way re DS and DIL?

469 replies

MagnifyingGlasses · 29/12/2021 13:01

A year and a half ago my DS wanted to leave his wife and 2 young DC. We never got to the bottom of why he did, he just said he was unhappy and wanted to be on his own. DIL was very upset and I found out about this because she called me up to tell me he was leaving and was worried about him. DS didn't tell us himself.

After this we tried to support DS and both DH and I and his siblings gave him support by offering him a place to stay and bring the DC etc. It didn't get to this stage though as DS decided he wanted to stay with his family and DIL.

Since then I feel my relationship, and that of DH and my other DC, has deteriorated drastically with DIL. We all used to spend a lot of time together such as meals out, go away for the weekend together, days out and even holidays together. A lot of it organised by her and DS with their DC, my only DGC.

We are not NC with them, we do still see them, but not on the scale we used to. She no longer offers to organise things for us all to do, and we are no longer invited on any days out, trips etc. She is welcoming and friendly when we do see them, or when they are at our house, but it feels strained and she no longer opens up around us.

I do think I did some things wrong when they were separated, which was for about 3 months. During that time I thought their relationship was over, so I didn't contact her and I didn't speak to my DGC. Also, my DD's gave him a lot of support, helping him to find somewhere to live and other things and also never spoke to DIL or DGC either. I think my DIL is hurt and no longer trusts us. At the end of the day though, he is my son and family and so I don't know what else I could have done.

Could this be repairable? WWYD?

OP posts:
BellyDancer124 · 29/12/2021 16:16

@PotatoOfTheNight

I think if she's being pleasant and polite when you do see her, I'd be happy with that.

You aren't going to ever get back to where you were before.

I agree with this. It's sad that you didn't contact her at all. If my MIL did that to me I'd be gutted. Perhaps you should try and make amends by organising some things for you all to do instead of waiting for her to do so.
CanofCant · 29/12/2021 16:16

@ESGdance

I am interested at the timing of your post - 18 months after the break-up - is it because you were all excluded from Christmas celebrations with your DGCs?
This is a very good point. The bottom line is that you weren't interested in supporting her or your grandchildren when there was nothing in it for you. Now, only when it affects you and you feel uncomfortable do you regret your actions. I really hope she leaves him. I wouldn't trust him after his behaviour and I bet he was either cheating or hoping to.
Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 29/12/2021 16:16

@GatoradeMeBitch

Indeed - "disposable", so sad isnt it. This poor woman. Sad

Yes I agree whole heartedly OP should profusly apologise but not to make things better for herself but just to be truly sorry - which it doesnt sound like she is - because shes missing out now shes sorry.

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2021 16:15

A couple of years ago DH and I went through a bad patch. He seemed to withdraw into himself and I was really worried about him. Then he said he wanted to live by himself . He couldn't explain why but just kept saying he was unhappy.

We had always been very close to PIL and his siblings- holidays together, days out, Christmas, meeting up for dinner etc. I thought of my MIL almost as another mum really and believed she cared for all 4 of us. I confided in her how worried I was about DH and our marriage. I couldn't really believe he wanted to leave me and our two small DC.

I never heard from her or any of his family after that. She and FIL and his siblings offered him places to live and, although DH and I got back together quite quickly- after about 3 months- and we are fine now, not one of his parents or siblings contacted me to ask how I was doing and how our DC were. They never saw our DC either. There was not even a phone call or asking if I fancied a coffee or needed any help. It was such a difficult time but we managed and got through it as a couple.
TBH I felt they made it easy for DH to leave us and they showed no concern for me and the children at all. My DC were really confused and sad at the time about their dad and about not seeing the GPs and aunts.

I am struggling to have the relationship I had with them before. For DH and the DC's sake I maintain a polite, friendly relationship. I ask them to the house and visit theirs but I can not do more. I still feel very let down by them. I think that if our marriage had ended that would have suited them in some ways and can not understand why the children and I mattered so little to them. I don't think I will ever trust them again, especially my MIL.
Now she has said I am to go and see her 'for a long talk' . I have told DH I am not going and he understands why. I don't want to hear her 'side' of it- it is too late for excuses and I have no desire to have any closer relationship than we now have. I prefer to maintain some distance. TBH I would have no problem if I never saw any of them again but in the interests of DH and DC that would not be reasonable. AIBU?

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 29/12/2021 16:13

@WhatScratch

I would suggest with dil and mil strained relations it might be common to dump the dil and the GC like a hot potoato when he says " I cant do this anymore" and wants to move out.

Most sensible people and those who see dil as family "may" become more strained later on AFTER a divorce, especially if a new partner comes on the scene. But not many would literally treat a dil this way when he makes noises about moving out then actually doesnt.

I also know of plenty of situations where actually the dils in laws have been supportive and kind throughout a break up - realising the shame of a feckless son - whilst still loving that feckless son.

GatoradeMeBitch · 29/12/2021 16:12

12 weeks of silence after your DIL had made so much effort to include you in her family life. You treated her like she was disposable. You certainly showed that you don't see her as family. No wonder she stopped going the extra mile for you. And I don't think you'd have reflected on your behaviour for a second if she'd gone back to prioritizing you. You really fucked up a good thing.

You absolutely should apologize. But you should also accept it if the dynamic is permanently altered. You showed her loud and clear where she - and her children - stand in the pecking order. Perhaps golden boy should start organizing some things, and not leave everything to his wife?

ESGdance · 29/12/2021 16:10

Why is your DIL 100% responsible for arranging stuff for you all to do as an extended family?

Does your DS step up to make plans?

Do you and your family invite and host?

3peassuit · 29/12/2021 16:10

Be prepared to grovel, what you did to your grandchildren would be unforgivable to most. You’re lucky that the DIL is still civil to you.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 29/12/2021 16:08

Poor dil, so many of us - do all the organising and never get a shred of thought or thanks for it.

You thought the relationship was over so you didnt speak to her. She tried to reach out to you! She must have been distraught and she trusted you

Op, do you like her? I do not believe if you liked or at least valued her you would have been so ready to ignore her during that time .

I am not sure it would be repairable because you have made it very clear which mast your colours are nailed too and this is one occasion I cant see how you could rapair the damage because she knows damn well you would still be igoring her if they were still apart.

I feel so sorry for dils I really do....the extra effort, planning, running around etc and dropped like a hot potatoe when a feckless naughty son says - fuck it I am leaving.

WhatScratch · 29/12/2021 16:08

Again, not that unusual. If the father has contact with the DC then that’s when the DC see that side of the family.

I’m not saying it’s acceptable or desirable that people behave in that way but it seems to be incredibly common. It’s like the DIL, the family home and that (usually much more than) 50% of the DC’s lives just cease to exist for them.

ESGdance · 29/12/2021 16:07

I am interested at the timing of your post - 18 months after the break-up - is it because you were all excluded from Christmas celebrations with your DGCs?

itsgoodtobehome · 29/12/2021 16:07

I would be devastated if my MIL did this to me and my DC. I would understand her looking out for DS, but if she cut off me and DC that easily, there would be no going back.

Earwigworries · 29/12/2021 16:04

You let her know she wasn’t family , now you want her to treat you like family . It isn’t going to work OP … I don’t think a long chat is going to help much either … I’d imagine she will see any apology on your part as self serving too

JustLyra · 29/12/2021 16:02

@WhatScratch

It’s pretty common for ILs to cut off a DIL in this situation. There are plenty of DILs who thought that they were friends with their sister-in-laws and got on well with their MIL only for them to be dropped by their ILs the second the marriage breaks down.

Look on the relationships board for posters who OHs had affairs, moved out of the family home and were having cosy Sunday lunches at his parents’ house with the OW within weeks.

It tends to come down to blood family. Even if their DS has been a total dick, he’s still their DS, he’s not going to be the one written out of the family.

I don’t think the OP did anything that unusual but now her DIL has been made aware of how her ILs really view her, why would she put herself out for them?

The OP - and her daughters - didn’t just cut the DIL out though, they dropped the grandchildren as well.
TooBigForMyBoots · 29/12/2021 16:01

You showed her how insignificant she and her children are to you @MagnifyingGlasses. Why the fuck would she arrange nice things for you? You abandoned her at a devastating time.Xmas Hmm

WhatScratch · 29/12/2021 16:00

It’s pretty common for ILs to cut off a DIL in this situation. There are plenty of DILs who thought that they were friends with their sister-in-laws and got on well with their MIL only for them to be dropped by their ILs the second the marriage breaks down.

Look on the relationships board for posters who OHs had affairs, moved out of the family home and were having cosy Sunday lunches at his parents’ house with the OW within weeks.

It tends to come down to blood family. Even if their DS has been a total dick, he’s still their DS, he’s not going to be the one written out of the family.

I don’t think the OP did anything that unusual but now her DIL has been made aware of how her ILs really view her, why would she put herself out for them?

Luredbyapomegranate · 29/12/2021 15:58

All you can do is apologise to her - with bells on, because you treated her and your grandchildren very very badly indeed.

TBH if she is welcoming and friendly to you, that’s big of her. She is the mother of your grandchildren, you absolutely could have been in touch with her and them, without discussing or being disloyal to your son. Her husband left with no explanation, and you all cut her off - and even worse cut the kids off.

An apology is long overdue, but at least you are doing it now. A walk is fair enough, but don’t put her in a position where she has to walk with you for an hour after you bring it up - she may find it upsetting, or she may brush it off because she simply doesn’t want to get into it.

Before you talk to her really try and figure out why you behaved so badly, so she has some kind of explanation. You also need to own what you did - your post is very much focused on your feelings and not hers, despite the fact that you are the wrongdoer.

I hope things improve, but they will be different. She’s not likely to return to feeling like a full member of your family, so will probably always maintain more distance than before - partly for self protection but partly to make sure she builds up her life elsewhere. Be appreciate of any improvement and make sure you meet and match efforts made by her.

Dogscanteatonions · 29/12/2021 15:57

I WAS the DIL in the same situation nearly 15 years ago now when exh left. He left for 'no reason' except he was actually shagging one of his employees.

I was so close to my PIL especially my. MIL as we used to share a hobby and spent loads of great times together. I was hurt beyond measure when I was dumped like this and when I reached out for help when I was desperate and they could have helped me and the kids so much.

We got back together briefly but the relationship with PIL was ruined.

Be lucky sure is so nice to you. You don't deserve more.

SockFluffInTheBath · 29/12/2021 15:57

So she asked you for support when your DS was trying to decide if he could be bothered being a husband and father anymore, and you offered him a way out. Now you’re surprised she’s not fussing round you? I can see where your DS gets his relationship skills.

Ps you’re in DIL-land on MN. If you want tea and sympathy about the nasty DIL you’d probably go better on Gransnet, though I suspect even there you’ll be told you’re an insensitive, selfish idiot.

DepressionIsAMonster · 29/12/2021 15:57

My MiL could have written this. I initiated a separation - temporary, as it transpired, but I didn’t know at the time - with DH as I simply couldn’t handle his significant MH issues, a f/T job as breadwinner and parenting our one year old.

She called, once, and I missed it, and then didn’t call again. For years I had bought every present and card for her and FiL, encouraged DH to make a proper effort with them, facilitated days out and holidays with DC. When I needed an ounce of compassion (let alone support with DC) she was entirely absent.

You said yourself your DS is family and your actions have proved conclusively to your DiL that she is not. Therefore, she will no longer consider you family. My MiL is my husband’s mother; I’m courteous to her but I will never again trust her or put any effort into making her feel part of my family. All the long talks in the world couldn’t make up for how excluded and isolated her actions made me feel.

Sowhatifiam · 29/12/2021 15:57

During that time I thought their relationship was over, so I didn't contact her and I didn't speak to my DGC

why? I don't understand why you would do this. It doesn't make sense. You could have supported your DIL without betraying your son and vice versa. Do you see the children as some kind of extension of your DIL only?

we are no longer invited on any days out, trips etc. She is welcoming and friendly when we do see them, or when they are at our house

So what you've discovered there is that your DIL worked hard at maintaining a relationship with you and including you as wider family in family-related activities. Women's work. Mental load. You seem surprised that it doesn't happen in quite the same way as it did. Why? Why would she bother with you now when you showed her not one ounce of support when she probably needed some?

Tuttiflutey · 29/12/2021 15:56

@PotatoOfTheNight

I think if she's being pleasant and polite when you do see her, I'd be happy with that.

You aren't going to ever get back to where you were before.

… but you could write to her with an apology, saying that you regret the way you handled things (… but do make it a straight apology - don’t try and excuse or justify).
Nousernameforme · 29/12/2021 15:48

You can imagine the aibu from the Dil aibu to just step back and do the minimum after 'd'ps family blanked us or 3 months when we temporarily split. I know that I used to do all the organising when it came to his side but after seeing how they treated me and my children I can't bring myself to be more than civil.

Honestly @MagnifyingGlasses leave the poor woman alone she owes you nothing and I think if you push your luck she might just not bother with you anymore

TheGrinchsDog · 29/12/2021 15:48

@Lndnmummy

So I was reflecting some more on this. Actually, the worst bit is you STILL only seem to be sorry for YOU. You seem only troubled by the fact that you are no longer included in the family outings (wonder why...) and not that you have deeply hurt your DIL. Its extremy self centered.
This ^ also I'm quite Shock at the casual cruelty and subsequent thoughtlessness - quick gloss over what I did, I miss my days out Confused
Totalwasteofpaper · 29/12/2021 15:48

@MagnifyingGlasses

Gosh, I'm scared to come back.

I do know that I didn't handle it right, resulting in this and I am sorry about it.

Regarding the 3 months. DS stayed in the marital home for a while at the beginning, then I was away on holiday for 3 weeks. They don't live close to us and we don't see them that often. I did speak to DS about the DGC and asked after them to make sure they were all right. I know that is not ideal. I definitely would not have not seen them again. I was just waiting to see what was going to happen long term and see what structures would be put in place.

I think I am going to ask DIL to come for a long talk with me and see if we can heal any of this.

Thanks for all the comments.

Christ almighty you have a breath taking lack of self awareness.

She has mentally been through the wringer and prob has no mental bandwidth thanks to your delight of a son... you offered little to no support when he was being a turd....

AND NOW... you... YOU are sad Sad because the fun train she ran for your pleasure has stopped. You are misisng all the fun stuff she kindly and thoughtfully planned and included you in like meals out, go away for the weekend together, days out and even holidays together

Maybe you could now after several years of letting her carry the load for you and your lazy son you could carry the relationship a bit yourself and plan a few nice trips for her although secretly it is still all for and about you ????

Swipe left for the next trending thread