Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

tricky family medical (genetic) matter

311 replies

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 12:42

Have NC for this. I wondered if anyone has any thoughts on something that caused a family argument this Xmas. It is a medical matter. I will just give the essential info, not to make it too specific and technical, or long. Basically:

I have a DH, who has two adult daughters, my DSDs. We also have a 12yo DS together. Not long ago DH and the DSDs found out from family that DH's sister (from whom he is estranged) has been diagnosed as having a genetic condition. The condition does not affect everyday life in any way but does mean that the sufferer needs to make doctors aware of it if they have a general anaesthetic.The condition can be potentially fatal if you have a general anaesthetic using certain agents, but if the doctors know about it, alternative agents can be used and all is fine.

It is of course possible to just tell doctors about the possibility of the condition at the time of an anaesthetic, and they can use the alternative agent just in case (this happened recently when DS had to have a GA). However, the concern would be if the person is not in a position to give this history, in an accident and unconscious, say, with no family around in time (also DS is only 12 and is autistic and probably unlikely to give the history correctly even if he is conscious). So I certainly want to know if DS has it, and the DSDs want to know if they have it. If they do they would then wear a medic alert tag.

The catch is that. although some degree of genetic testing can be done, the only definitive test is a muscle biopsy, which a fairly invasive and, I believe, quite painful, test. Now, the way the conditiion is inherited, if DH was to test negative, the kids could not have it and so would be spared the testing and any further concern. So the obvious first step is for DH to see a doctor and ask for testing.

The problem is that DH is refusing. He says he will see a doctor to discuss the situation but no way will he have the biopsy. This means that 12yo DS is going to have to have the test (as even if the DSDs test and are negtaive. DS could still have it).

DH became verbally abusive and started shouting at the dining table at Christmas when i suggested he was being selfish. This was in front of the DSDs boyfriends, one of whom we only know a little and one of whom we were meeting for the first time. This was very embarrassing for me. And we are no further forward with finding out the genetic status of any of them.

I dont think IABU (unless you think I should just solve it by getting everyone medic alert tags anyway, but I don't see why DS should have to wear one if he does not have the condition).

OP posts:
UniversalAunt · 29/12/2021 14:54

@questionandanswer You sound eminently sensible & looking for practical ways to get things done.

Sometimes we realise things about ourselves when our children & immediate family are diagnosed with health or psychological conditions, & it can take some time & iterations to get to the point where we may accept that we are made of the very same stuff. This may involve also giving up some of the ‘constructed’ self that we have build to distance ourselves from the ‘others’ in our lives. This new information binds him back to his sister & all that has gone before.

So to the point, Christmas & any table sat round at that time is a minefield, any subject raised can escalate into open warfare. Let this skirmish go…have dust settle & give OH time to breathe & reflect. He knows what may need to be done & may need time to figure himself out to regroup.

No-one can make him do it. We are living in times where pundits & others speak of compulsory vaccinations with very hard sanctions for the non-compliant. Everyday conversations are becoming tribal & heated. With this as the background music, being expected to face up to a new medical condition, & agree to a possibly painful test may take some people some time to step up. Of course (to me & others) he would have the test - whenever NHS resources are available for this - & why not? Because not everyone is me.

By my choice, I choose to live within my own determined & informed levels of risk & I can articulate that very effectively to medical professionals. Not everyone is like me, they may be overwhelmed by calculating risk, not assimilate information & data comfortably, or articulate effectively when feeling vulnerable, so their default response may be NO with an adrenaline fight/flight response. I would not call that person out as selfish.

What next? Ease off about his taking the test for the whole team, update GP/hospital records as required & bulk order Medicalert bracelet/neck tags.

ancientgran · 29/12/2021 14:54

@Strictlyfanoftenyears

So ok, if your child is positive (and u dont know), is wearing a bracelet (not foolproof) and is unconscious therefore, cannot warn a dr if needs a GA. Therefore his/her life is at risk, if he/she has an accident is it not? Therefore your DHs actions do have a bearing........ So your children will have to be tested to be sure? What sort of parent puts their child through any tests if they dont have to?
If the father is positive then the child may or may not choose to have the test, he may have to wait till he's 18. If he's positive what happens then? There isn't a cure he will still be relying on the not foolproof bracelet. This isn't something where the father is preventing the child having lifesaving treatments.
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 14:53

@Strictlyfanoftenyears I fully intend to find out whether DS is positive or not, whatever DH decides to do. So he is not putting his son's life at risk. The risk will be exactly the same whatever he does.

@Onehotmessiah his sister is his twin. She cannot have been adopted.

@elfycat he has had approximately two years to think it through. The girls and I think it is now time to get this sorted. Well, he did agree now to see the specialist, so we will take it from there.

OP posts:
TomsPrisonConsultant · 29/12/2021 14:51

I agree strongly with @MissLucyEyelesbarrow and @elfycat - please don't underestimate the emotional challenges that surround genetic testing

TomsPrisonConsultant · 29/12/2021 14:49

@Strictlyfanoftenyears I believe the way these things are managed is that if the risk is known then a person who hasn't yet been tested should be treated exactly as if they were positive. Which might be unnecessary but no one is put at risk because they haven't been tested (through choice or opportunity) once the risk is known. So the DH is not putting anyone's life in danger.

SocialConnection · 29/12/2021 14:47

Maybe the Christmas dinner table with non family members present wasn't the place to bring it up.

Embarrassment can be a strong trigger.

So can the fear of pain, which I absolutely get (and why I'm being so silly about calling the dentist).

It needs a private conversation when nobody's on show, with compassion for fear of the pain. And some research into how that pain could be managed in advance.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 29/12/2021 14:46

I am trying desperately to think of any scenario where I would put my child through a test if I could have it for them.

tara66 · 29/12/2021 14:46

I suppose all who are concerned that need this painful test should find a sympathetic doctor who can sedate them enough to dull the pain (if the drug used is not the same as for a general anaesthetic). Otherwise leave books about the condition scattered about the house. It seems DH has to decide for himself what he will do.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/12/2021 14:46

@elfycat

We've been through genetic testing since DSis had breast cancer and was found to have the BRCA1 gene. My other DSis and I do not have it, but the pre-screening question was all about how I would feel (including survivor guilt if I did not have it - BTW DSis is fine after her surgery/chemo), what I would do (take it all away please), and what I would do about my own DDs and testing (advise them to get mortgages and life insurance before testing...). DH was asked how he felt about me potentially finding I had the gene - he told them that he's an engineer and you need to know what the fault is before you can work on fixing it (there may be some autistic traits in that engineer). they also cover what if your DF turns out not to be genetically your parent - these things happen

You DH may be having some of that guilt thing. I know my DF is about the gene passing down through him and he feels that he 'gave' his DD cancer. I honestly think he might have rethought having children at all if this information had been available 50 years ago, and I might never have been born. That's the strength of the fear of unwittingly having damaged your children.

And that's before the unpleasant operation to find out.

He might need time to think his way through it all. And pushing him will only make him push back harder against the idea and become entrenched. And it is up to him, no one can force him to have this procedure. IMO you need to finish up pushing him on this with acceptance and say calmly that you'd like him to, for his own sake as much as you DC's, but you appreciate he needs to think about it. And them leave it - for months if needed and maybe revisit it in the summer with a mild question.

Agree. I suspect most PPs who don't see the issue have never been in this situation. Genetic testing throws up a load of complex emotional and ethical issues. It's not a decision that people take on a purely rational basis.

OP, if you are in the UK, make sure that you get this family history added to your DS' GP record.

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 14:44

@diddl we are all well aware he is needle/doctor phobic. But not to the extent that he wouldn't have surgery if he needed it, would not take vaccines etc. He does have essential procedures, vaccines and so on. He used to work in very far flung areas of the world and had lots of jabs because of that. He didn't like them but got on with them because he had to for work. We knew he was putting off this test because he avoids doctors if possible, but not that he would have that reaction.

OP posts:
Santahatesbraisedcabbage · 29/12/2021 14:42

Maybe he is worried how guilty he will feel if he is positive..

rocky1914 · 29/12/2021 14:42

He is scared of the pain, I think

Right. But he's not concerned with whether or not his 12yo DS would be scared of the pain? Got it.

Sounds like a real stand up guy.

Please don't let him talk to you like that again in front of family or anyone for that matter. I'm upset and offended for you. Disgusting, immature, unnecessary behaviour.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 29/12/2021 14:42

So ok, if your child is positive (and u dont know), is wearing a bracelet (not foolproof) and is unconscious therefore, cannot warn a dr if needs a GA. Therefore his/her life is at risk, if he/she has an accident is it not? Therefore your DHs actions do have a bearing........ So your children will have to be tested to be sure?
What sort of parent puts their child through any tests if they dont have to?

Onehotmessiah · 29/12/2021 14:39

Maybe he knows his sister was adopted and he wasn’t?!
I can’t think of any reason to be so adamant apart from maybe to protect another family member.

TomsPrisonConsultant · 29/12/2021 14:38

@questionandanswer
"Well, in fact he is forcing three people to take the test. But I am most concrened about DS obviously."

He isn't forcing anyone to take the test. There are other ways to manage this without taking the test, as you've said. He's putting them in the exact position they will be in if he is positive. You are deliberately framing this in a way which I think is quite unkind. No one is forcing anyone to do anything but you appear to be trying to guilt him into doing something he doesn't want to do. He can't cope with this at the moment, and like everyone he is allowed bodily autonomy, so other family members can proceed with the knowledge they have a 50% chance and test if they want. I would also seriously consider whether your son needs to be tested while he's a child or whether, given the balance of risks, it would be better to wait until he's an adult and can make all his own choices.

elfycat · 29/12/2021 14:38

We've been through genetic testing since DSis had breast cancer and was found to have the BRCA1 gene. My other DSis and I do not have it, but the pre-screening question was all about how I would feel (including survivor guilt if I did not have it - BTW DSis is fine after her surgery/chemo), what I would do (take it all away please), and what I would do about my own DDs and testing (advise them to get mortgages and life insurance before testing...). DH was asked how he felt about me potentially finding I had the gene - he told them that he's an engineer and you need to know what the fault is before you can work on fixing it (there may be some autistic traits in that engineer). they also cover what if your DF turns out not to be genetically your parent - these things happen

You DH may be having some of that guilt thing. I know my DF is about the gene passing down through him and he feels that he 'gave' his DD cancer. I honestly think he might have rethought having children at all if this information had been available 50 years ago, and I might never have been born. That's the strength of the fear of unwittingly having damaged your children.

And that's before the unpleasant operation to find out.

He might need time to think his way through it all. And pushing him will only make him push back harder against the idea and become entrenched. And it is up to him, no one can force him to have this procedure. IMO you need to finish up pushing him on this with acceptance and say calmly that you'd like him to, for his own sake as much as you DC's, but you appreciate he needs to think about it. And them leave it - for months if needed and maybe revisit it in the summer with a mild question.

godmum56 · 29/12/2021 14:37

[quote questionandanswer]@WonderfulYou it is autosomal dominant, you cannot be a carrier

@godmum56 I have already explained, there is no way he would ever make any medical appointment for himself.Too phobic, too dyslexic, too prine to ignore things. I have known this for 20 years. I have always sorted out his health care.[/quote]
and that's fine,. but to announce it publicly?

vivainsomnia · 29/12/2021 14:37

Discuss it with him when you're alone. Listen to him explain how scared he is. Only then offer support one step at a time. It needs to come from him so he feels in control and that you'll be with him supporting him all the way rather them telling him what to do and making him feel guilty.

In all likelihood he will do it when he doesn't feel watched and pressurised.

Alieninmybody · 29/12/2021 14:37

My dh found out as an adult his parent had HD. He knew it was in the family but his parent was given the all clear in middle age before the gene was discovered. They never went for testing after it was discovered as they were in their late 50s. A sibling of dh was later tested and positive. Up until this dh firmly believed he would've gone for testing straight away. When hit with the reality it was a very different story. We had young children and he knew for them at some stage he would be tested but he also knew at that time a positive result would stop him living a normal life long before the illness would start. We put it out of our minds until the kids were older and then for their sakes only he went for testing.
There is mandatory counselling involved and it took six months from first appt to result. The referral waiting period was quiet a few months too.
In the end he was very thankfully negative. He spared the kids the turmoil of going through testing and also freed himself of the unknown but he did it for them even though he fully expected to be positive or at best in the grey area and believed knowing would be detrimental to his own quality of life.
Time and a lot of thinking helped him get there. I don't think it's fair to judge anyone for been initially afraid and that conversation should never have happened as it did.

Singinghollybob · 29/12/2021 14:37

I agree he may have felt a bit ganged up on, but I would hope and expect once he's calmed down he would not be so selfish as to put his son through a test which was potentially unnecessary.

If he still refuses which means your son has to have the test, then I would look at him very differently and not in good way

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 14:36

@Summersnake yes I did go about it wrong. I agree. But it didn't start as a demand, it was part of a wider discussion about family health issues and medical appointments which needed to be made for various reasons. The DSD who mentioned the appointment (among other appointmens) needed to be made was shocked when he said no way as he going to have the biopsy. Before he had just made excuses about being too busy etc, never said he wouldn or was scared. I am afraid that when he loudly declared in front of the group that he would never have the biopsy, I did say I found it selfish. That led to him losing it. So I should not have done that. But equally, he could just have said oh yes we need to do that in the new year, and had a further discussion privately later.

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/12/2021 14:35

Sorry - 50% - brain not working.

gsaoej · 29/12/2021 14:34

Just get your ds the test.
As a child he’ll likely recover quickly.
Your dh will have to live with the fact that he’s not willing to take pain to spare his children pain.

RestingMurderousFace · 29/12/2021 14:34

@DreamerSeven

I think you’re massively under-estimating the impact that the thought of genetic testing can have on a person. Plus discussing it at Christmas in a group setting was a terrible thing to do, I’m not surprised he possibly felt ambushed and stormed out (not saying it was the right reaction, just that I can imagine how he may have felt).

It can be a total minefield to navigate through these things, cut him some slack and give him time to process it all.

Agree with all of the above ^
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/12/2021 14:34

@questionandanswer

Thanks for the input, and I am trying to see it from his point of view. He is an intelligent man but his knowldege of medical matters is very poor and he is very frightened of doctors. (Strange, he has a wife and two daughters who are all doctors!)
Can't you see how this made the situation so much worse, from his POV, and ramped up the pressure on him? I'm amazed that, as doctors, you and his DDs weren't more conscious of the sensitivities around genetic testing (I am also a doctor).

Also, as MH is autosomal dominant and his sister had it, there is (assuming it wasn't a spontaneous mutation in her) a 75% chance that your DH has it, meaning that there is a 75% chance that your DS will need to be tested anyway, regardless of whether your DH is tested.

Swipe left for the next trending thread