Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

tricky family medical (genetic) matter

311 replies

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 12:42

Have NC for this. I wondered if anyone has any thoughts on something that caused a family argument this Xmas. It is a medical matter. I will just give the essential info, not to make it too specific and technical, or long. Basically:

I have a DH, who has two adult daughters, my DSDs. We also have a 12yo DS together. Not long ago DH and the DSDs found out from family that DH's sister (from whom he is estranged) has been diagnosed as having a genetic condition. The condition does not affect everyday life in any way but does mean that the sufferer needs to make doctors aware of it if they have a general anaesthetic.The condition can be potentially fatal if you have a general anaesthetic using certain agents, but if the doctors know about it, alternative agents can be used and all is fine.

It is of course possible to just tell doctors about the possibility of the condition at the time of an anaesthetic, and they can use the alternative agent just in case (this happened recently when DS had to have a GA). However, the concern would be if the person is not in a position to give this history, in an accident and unconscious, say, with no family around in time (also DS is only 12 and is autistic and probably unlikely to give the history correctly even if he is conscious). So I certainly want to know if DS has it, and the DSDs want to know if they have it. If they do they would then wear a medic alert tag.

The catch is that. although some degree of genetic testing can be done, the only definitive test is a muscle biopsy, which a fairly invasive and, I believe, quite painful, test. Now, the way the conditiion is inherited, if DH was to test negative, the kids could not have it and so would be spared the testing and any further concern. So the obvious first step is for DH to see a doctor and ask for testing.

The problem is that DH is refusing. He says he will see a doctor to discuss the situation but no way will he have the biopsy. This means that 12yo DS is going to have to have the test (as even if the DSDs test and are negtaive. DS could still have it).

DH became verbally abusive and started shouting at the dining table at Christmas when i suggested he was being selfish. This was in front of the DSDs boyfriends, one of whom we only know a little and one of whom we were meeting for the first time. This was very embarrassing for me. And we are no further forward with finding out the genetic status of any of them.

I dont think IABU (unless you think I should just solve it by getting everyone medic alert tags anyway, but I don't see why DS should have to wear one if he does not have the condition).

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 29/12/2021 16:28

I am a little confused - if dsd’s not having it doesn’t mean your ds doesn’t have it - isn’t it the same for your DH? Ie if he had it - it would still not mean your ds definately has it? He still might not have it and will have to do a test anyway? I am guessing if he has it you would want him down on some sort of register - but he will surely only be put on a register if it’s confirmed he has it?
Granted your dh sounds mean because if he doesn’t have it you won’t need to get your ds son tested. But it sounds like if he does have it you would need to get him tested anyway.

GabriellaMontez · 29/12/2021 16:23

Have I got this right? You havent even seen the specialist yet? And not actually had a recommendation about how to proceed?

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:23

sorry about the weird @ and bold

OP posts:
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:22

@we do all that on Xmas eve. This was at the Xmas day lunch, so after.

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2021 16:21

Was the discussion about genetic testing before or after you pulled the Christmas crackers, put on silly hats and read out the jokes?

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:16

@also, in some genetic conditions there can be a thing called partial penetration ie a less severe version or one thst maifests differently, buyt I don't know enough about this condition. That is one thing I will need to ask the specialist at the appointment.

OP posts:
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:14

@Magnited that is certainly something to think about. DH already has life insurance, but the girls need to think about this before they test, I guess, as they do not have any yet. In further discusions I will highlight this to them so they can make decisions.

OP posts:
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:12

@AlternativePerspective the other condition is breast cancer. Through Ancestry DNA and building a family tree of his family we have found that multiple female members of his family died very young of this, which he had no idea about until last week. The DSDs obviously need genetic testing.

OP posts:
Magnited · 29/12/2021 16:12

@questionandanswer

This is all very interesting. One question - if the condition is inherited, but a person tests negative, is it the case the condition cannot manifest in any remoter issue at any stage? I assume that argument is not true, but if true the implications are for remoter issue to always have to test.

Has your DH considered the financial effects of not getting the test? For example, with life insurance not being able to answer any known family history questions correctly. His children may find it more expensive to get life insurance because it may be health-rated or it may not pay out at all. This will impact on their ability to organise their finances in coming years.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/12/2021 16:12

@BookFiend4Life

I agree it's selfish. I noticed you said it autosomal dominant and therefore he can't be a carrier? That was not my understanding. Our family is going through some testing right now so I was just curious about that if you care to elaborate!
Simplistically, if you have an autosomal dominant characteristic, you won't be a carrier because the characteristic will be evident.

You get one copy of each gene from your father and one from your mother (apart from on the X and Y chromosomes). If you have one dominant gene, it will - as the name suggests - dominate.

So, if the gene for loving MN is AD, and the gene for loving Netmums is autosomal recessive, everyone with the MN gene will love MN. But, because the Netmums gene is recessive, only people with two Netmum genes will love Netmums. People with one MN gene (AD) and one Netmums gene (AR) will love MN but be Netmums carriers.

In practice, it's more complicated than that because of variable penetrance and expression of genes. But that's the outline.

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:10

@CoedenNadolig I would not have DS tested "regardless", if DH tested and was negative, then none of the three children would have to test at all. If DH does not test, then they all have to and they will.

Of course I won't force DH and I will "leave him alone" if he does not agree to the test. I just feel it is selfish of him, that is all, and I said as much at the dinner, once he started being all adamany about not hving it (he could have just said we'll talk about the appointment in the new year or something and then discussed it more privately with me). I of course should not have called him selfish, in hindsight, not under those circumstances. It was a highly charged situation, it was Christmas, we had all not seen each other in two years, we had all had some wine...certainly a mistake by DSD and me to even seek to discuss it then. It just came up fairly casually in the context of discussing other testing as in "oh yes, these are things we all need to start arranging after new year".

Re the previous surgeries: As I have explained, with this condition you can be fine multiple times (as in fact they all have been with GAs) and then unpredicably have a potentially fatal reaction.

Autosomal dominant means that if you have one of the genes you have the condition, You therefore cannot be a carrier. You either have it or not.

@Ilove the only place to have this investigated here is at Cork Universoity Hospital, and DH has agreed to have a consultation there. At that meeting I will discuss what is to be done about DS. I know that you have to be at least 12 to have the biopsy ) which is why I have not pushed this too hard with DH the last two years, DS is only 12 now).

Whatever happens we have to know if DS has the condition. He is never going to be able to reliably speak up about it if we are not around, even in adulthood, so all carers will always need to know about it, especially when we are no longer here to advocate for him (and his sisters are also a great deal older than him so will also potentially not always be around for him).

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 29/12/2021 16:09

DH was not excluded from the discussion, he was very much part of it (there is another, potentially way more serious, genetic condition in his family which the girls have to be tested for, which we very recently, as in last week, found out about, and he was taking part in that discussion just fine, we were all planning how and when they were going to come back to Ireland for the testing, one of the girls then just mentioned bye the bye that his appointment needed to be planned too. Everyone was surprised by his reaction). and here we have it. There is a serious genetic condition in the family, which he may have, and which his children may have, presumably your DS will need to be tested as well. And the discussion about this less serious condition (let’s be honest it’s only serious if you have to have a GA, so isn’t life altering) was dropped in during the discussion about the more serious one.

I suspect his reaction, apart from feeling railroaded in front of his daughters’ partners,was more of a response to the serious condition he potentially has, but got caught in the discussion over the lesser condition.

What is the serious condition? Is it life altering?

It’s like piling things on top of one another. Having a discussion about building an extension on to a house, which is really stressful, and then throwing into the middle of the conversation that “you need to ring the plumber about fixing the dodgy flush on the toilet, I’m going to ring them tomorrow, by not ringing them you’re being selfish,” The plumber is largely irrelevant in relation to the wider discussion, but because it’s thrown into the middle of the stresses of the other discussion that’s the thing that the respondent focuses on.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/12/2021 16:01

@TeacupDrama

you all cornered him looks like 5 to 1 in a subject that you probably understand better but you look like a bunch of bullies I am a retired HCP and I think the way you called your DH selfish in fromt of the rest of the family is incredibly poor behaviour undermining your DH and acting like senior parent no wonder he was cross you humiliated him too "I know what I'm talking about you don't" is the gist of it No adult and especially no spouse likes to be put down shamed or bossed around in public ( to him it could feel like public as he barely knew boyfriends) your continual medical talk when he is present might actually be increasing his phobia not decreasing it , maybe you should just stop talking medicine as a family when one person is essentially out of conversation, it can't be pleasant feeling like an interloper at the doctor's mess as dentist I deal with a lot of phobic and anxious patients it would not have helped even one of my patients deal with their anxiety by listening to a bunch of dentists discussing dentistry
Agree. If the OP had deliberately set out to entrench her DH's refusal, she couldn't have done it better. You do not overcome someone's fears or incorrect health beliefs by shaming them, especially in front of their family.
Merryoldgoat · 29/12/2021 16:01

@BookFiend4Life

Carrier is generally used to refer to someone who does not have a condition but can pass it along. So technically yes, if you have the condition you ‘carry’ it but carrier isn’t the correct description as they are an affected party where a carrier isn’t.

Merryoldgoat · 29/12/2021 15:59

@BookFiend4Life

I agree it's selfish. I noticed you said it autosomal dominant and therefore he can't be a carrier? That was not my understanding. Our family is going through some testing right now so I was just curious about that if you care to elaborate!
@BookFiend4Life

All of your cells have half of their genetic material from your mother and half from your father.

In autosomal dominant conditions the simple presence of the gene means that the condition will occur. You could have one affected gene from one parent and one unaffected gene from the other but you will still have the condition as the condition only needs one instance to express itself. Huntington’s is an example of this.

In autosomal recessive conditions you need to inherit the gene from both parents to have the condition. If you only inherit it from one person you are a carrier.

Sickle cell anaemia is an example of these.

I’ve used the words genes in place of alleles for ease of communication in case anyone is about to jump on me

Ilove · 29/12/2021 15:54

MH (malignant hyperpyrexia) is able to be avoided .

Any anaesthetic that can be local or a nerve block is fine

A GA that needs muscle relaxing agents needs to be done by a consultant anaesthetist using a vapour free circuit and a “clean machine”. They cannot use a machine that has had a normal anaesthetic gas put through it as the pipe work carries remnants of it.

You need an appointment with your son and the MH department at your local big hospital.

Feel free to PM me if you would like to talk further. I have reacted to anaesthetics as has my mother, and my kids are all now aware too.

They possibly cannot do the muscle biopsy on your 12 year old as the muscle mass won’t be there to do it, however it IS manageable.

TeacupDrama · 29/12/2021 15:52

you all cornered him looks like 5 to 1 in a subject that you probably understand better but you look like a bunch of bullies I am a retired HCP and I think the way you called your DH selfish in fromt of the rest of the family is incredibly poor behaviour undermining your DH and acting like senior parent no wonder he was cross you humiliated him too "I know what I'm talking about you don't" is the gist of it No adult and especially no spouse likes to be put down shamed or bossed around in public ( to him it could feel like public as he barely knew boyfriends)
your continual medical talk when he is present might actually be increasing his phobia not decreasing it , maybe you should just stop talking medicine as a family when one person is essentially out of conversation, it can't be pleasant feeling like an interloper at the doctor's mess
as dentist I deal with a lot of phobic and anxious patients it would not have helped even one of my patients deal with their anxiety by listening to a bunch of dentists discussing dentistry

BookFiend4Life · 29/12/2021 15:51

I agree it's selfish. I noticed you said it autosomal dominant and therefore he can't be a carrier? That was not my understanding. Our family is going through some testing right now so I was just curious about that if you care to elaborate!

QueeniesCroft · 29/12/2021 15:46

My experience is of chromosomal abnormality rather than this kind of condition (a balanced translocation which was discovered after a stillbirth, but not related to it). But the thing which links them is the sense of shame that many people can feel.

I think your husband is wrong and I hope I would behave differently, but he may have felt especially humiliated having this topic brought up in front of strangers, and lashed out because of his sense of shame that he might be the carrier of a potentially fatal condition. Hopefully, he will calm down and change his mind.

Gingernaut · 29/12/2021 15:45

Your DH is no 'father' if he's not prepared to spare his children the pain of this relatively minor operation.

If you're capable of giving birth to his children, then he's more than capable of doing this for them.

www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/treatment-tests-and-therapies/muscle-biopsy

CoedenNadolig · 29/12/2021 15:44

Hang on your DH has had operations under GA already has he, was there no adverse reaction to this or did he say he might have it and they just adjusted accordingly?

If you plan to have DS tested regardless then just drop this with DH in its entirety? He's a grown man, he can make risk assessments leave him be. If he doesn't want to know, then that's up to him. More fool him we may think, but he has capacity so it's his gamble to take.

I'm confused as to why this is such a big issue now as you plan to test DS regardless and all the daughters seem to be aware and willing to be tested.

Leave the man alone. It's up to him

HoppingPavlova · 29/12/2021 15:43

Not understanding the pushing him into a corner. If surgery is planned then surely all involved just mention this prior as a possibility so surgeon and anaesthetist is aware. If you do have it, and someone has an accident and is unconscious, they are not going to be able to say anything irrespective whether it has or has not been confirmed, so medical bracelet. So essentially, by forcing your DH into something he doesn’t to do, what is it going to achieve. Get your DS a bracelet. If your DS is having planned surgery/procedures, then you mention it. If your DS has emergency surgery then they will note the bracelet. For all those saying bracelets are not foolproof, how do you think it works with people who have had it confirmed but can’t communicate prior to surgery/ don’t have ID on them at the time etc!

Gribbie · 29/12/2021 15:42

I have a muscle problem that is on the same gene at MH. I had 2 muscle biopsys 30 years ago to get my diagnosic. They didn't check for MH as they didn't know what the problem was at the time so were looking for the muscle issue. I just wear a band and carry a card. I could get another biopsy but cba - I have 2 scars already and don't want a 3rd. Feel free to PM me if you want any info.

HillsBesideTheSea · 29/12/2021 15:39

It was unclear in your post where you say he ended up with wife and 2 dds that were doctor

but you are still forcing him to face his best before. Some people just can't do that. So people have no choice, and some people chose to die rather than face it. At the end of the day it is something that really should be dealt with by counsellors. And tbh if you go forwards with getting ds tested it is likely they will want dh to be part of the process of discussing it and then there will hopefully bea less confrontational approach.

Knowing you might have, and knowing you actually have is two very separate issues. And despite the fact that I am comfortable with it, there are a lot of people (noticeably with english style upbringing) where you just do not talk about this stuff EVER, and definitely not with other people because it is not seen as the appropriate thing.

I know this as we have a genetic (several in fact) conditions in the family that you can trace multi generational. And NONE of my cousins even had a clue until one family do and i was talking to a wife and i drop the bombshell, oh yes that comes down from X and typically has this comorbidity. It is just not done to talk about it even within family, and has never been done since. I just quietly keep the logs and tracking from the small snippets that come through.

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 15:35

@PurpleFrost that is very interesting. Maybe a medic alert band in any case then. Well, not for DH, he won't wear it, it will be put in a drawer and never seen again. But for DS. The elder DSD has had an odd recation to a GA in the past, although not hyperthermic, and we did wonder if there was a relationship. She does already wear a medic alert band.

OP posts: