Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

tricky family medical (genetic) matter

311 replies

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 12:42

Have NC for this. I wondered if anyone has any thoughts on something that caused a family argument this Xmas. It is a medical matter. I will just give the essential info, not to make it too specific and technical, or long. Basically:

I have a DH, who has two adult daughters, my DSDs. We also have a 12yo DS together. Not long ago DH and the DSDs found out from family that DH's sister (from whom he is estranged) has been diagnosed as having a genetic condition. The condition does not affect everyday life in any way but does mean that the sufferer needs to make doctors aware of it if they have a general anaesthetic.The condition can be potentially fatal if you have a general anaesthetic using certain agents, but if the doctors know about it, alternative agents can be used and all is fine.

It is of course possible to just tell doctors about the possibility of the condition at the time of an anaesthetic, and they can use the alternative agent just in case (this happened recently when DS had to have a GA). However, the concern would be if the person is not in a position to give this history, in an accident and unconscious, say, with no family around in time (also DS is only 12 and is autistic and probably unlikely to give the history correctly even if he is conscious). So I certainly want to know if DS has it, and the DSDs want to know if they have it. If they do they would then wear a medic alert tag.

The catch is that. although some degree of genetic testing can be done, the only definitive test is a muscle biopsy, which a fairly invasive and, I believe, quite painful, test. Now, the way the conditiion is inherited, if DH was to test negative, the kids could not have it and so would be spared the testing and any further concern. So the obvious first step is for DH to see a doctor and ask for testing.

The problem is that DH is refusing. He says he will see a doctor to discuss the situation but no way will he have the biopsy. This means that 12yo DS is going to have to have the test (as even if the DSDs test and are negtaive. DS could still have it).

DH became verbally abusive and started shouting at the dining table at Christmas when i suggested he was being selfish. This was in front of the DSDs boyfriends, one of whom we only know a little and one of whom we were meeting for the first time. This was very embarrassing for me. And we are no further forward with finding out the genetic status of any of them.

I dont think IABU (unless you think I should just solve it by getting everyone medic alert tags anyway, but I don't see why DS should have to wear one if he does not have the condition).

OP posts:
ChateauxNeufDePoop · 29/12/2021 17:04

[quote questionandanswer]@Chewbecca thank you for that. I personally did not think it an unreasonable thing to discuss at the table, everyone present knew about the family history, the need for testing, the fact that we had all got rather a shock last week when we found out about the breast cancer and that we were trying to mitigate that by making practical arrangments asap. One DSD just dropped in the other genetic testing that is needed, while we were on the subect of making appointments. As a medical family we discuss medical issues at the table all the time, both in general and about our own health. DH is no stranger to that, he has lived with me for 18 years, and the DSDs have been in medicine for the past 6-7 years.

What I was wrong about was calling him selfish in front of everyone (even though I maintain he was being selfish, I won't say it again). And I think he was wrong to fly off the handle instead of just saying we'll talk about the arrangements later and then telling me privately that he has changed his mind about having the test.[/quote]
Nope - his reaction is his reaction to something completely unexpected and not as mundane as "we might go for a walk tomorrow", so no, he wasn't wrong.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 29/12/2021 17:02

@questionandanswer

The tests would be specific for this condition, which is not in any way damgerous outside of the situation of having a GA, and only dangerous in the situation if the doctors don't know about it. (So no chance of finding some devastating information like Huntingtons etc).

Unfortunately the genetic test, which indicative, is not definitive, and if the genetic test shows a possiblity of the condition, the muscle bx has to be done to be sure.

The matter was brought up over the Xmas table by the DSDs, as it was the only time were have all been together and we won't all see each other again for some time (the DSDs live in different countries from each other and from us). I then just said I would be making an appointment in the new year for DH to see a specialist in the condition, and that the testing could be discussed, and he hit the roof. I was completely taken aback.

YABVU massively to a) say that at all and to b) leave it out of the OP then drip it in later. How dare you.
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 17:00

@ancientgran good thing you weren't there for the preceding discussion, which was about the rise of right-wing ideaology in Europe, going on to a long discussion of fascism versus socialism! We are sometimes more interested in talking to each other about things we consider important, including our own health, rather than being "festive", especially after we have not all been together as a family for over 2 years. (We were plenty festive the night before and played charades till the wee hours though).

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 29/12/2021 16:58

Your husband has the right to say no.

If you carry on badgering him, you are actually being coercive and trying to force him under duress. That undermines the principle of free consent.

Whilst you might not like his choice, its his body and his right to refuse to find out - he's said he will discuss it with a doctor - so he's not completely hostile to discussing it completely.

I don't think he should be guilt tripped into this. It might well be selfish, but finding out also has implications which he might not want to look into. And crucially more than anything its not your decision to make.

This is about bodily autonomy. He should always retain the right to say no, even if those closest to him don't like it. They have the option to make free choices themselves.

It might suck, but thats just tough tbh. He needs to be able to make that choice himself.

Blossom64265 · 29/12/2021 16:57

Most parents would do anything to spare their children pain or illness. Your husband refusing to do something like this is really surprising. There are parents devastated they can’t donate kidneys or parts of livers and he doesn’t want to do a biopsy. You obviously will need to do what is necessary to protect your son medically as a first step. I’m not sure I could really just let this go and leave my relationship with my spouse undamaged. Our bond grew when we had our child and I witnessed the depth of his love and protection for her. It wasn’t always part of our relationship, but it is there now and having it tarnished would be difficult.

ancientgran · 29/12/2021 16:57

[quote HarrysChild]@TheCanyon testing for a terminal, life limiting, irreversible condition such as Huntington’s is complex and very difficult. Many people choose not to test, as is their right. To dismiss it as “selfish” is way too simplistic and ignorant of what a diagnosis of Huntington’s means for that person - being told they’re a living time bomb who will 100% develop this devastating condition is not something everyone can cope with. Nothing selfish about it.[/quote]
I used to work with someone who wanted the huntingtons tests as grandparent had it. Her father didn't want it and didn't want her to have it as if her test was positive it meant he had it and he felt it was unfair to force that knowledge on him. I don't know what happened in the end.

It is a very complicated issue.

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:55

@Chewbecca thank you for that. I personally did not think it an unreasonable thing to discuss at the table, everyone present knew about the family history, the need for testing, the fact that we had all got rather a shock last week when we found out about the breast cancer and that we were trying to mitigate that by making practical arrangments asap. One DSD just dropped in the other genetic testing that is needed, while we were on the subect of making appointments. As a medical family we discuss medical issues at the table all the time, both in general and about our own health. DH is no stranger to that, he has lived with me for 18 years, and the DSDs have been in medicine for the past 6-7 years.

What I was wrong about was calling him selfish in front of everyone (even though I maintain he was being selfish, I won't say it again). And I think he was wrong to fly off the handle instead of just saying we'll talk about the arrangements later and then telling me privately that he has changed his mind about having the test.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 29/12/2021 16:54

@Chewbecca

YANBU at all, of course he should test to a) ensure he has the facts and b) to save his DC potential testing.

I also don’t think you’re U to discuss at the dinner table, anything goes at ours.

Nothing quite so festive as discussing serious medical conditions at the Christmas dinner table.
GabriellaMontez · 29/12/2021 16:54

[quote questionandanswer]@GabriellaMontez regarding the appointment, I am not going to "ask him to come", this would be his appointment not mine. I will go with him to HIS appointment if he agrees to go. If he won't go then I would make an appt for my DS and go with him. None of these appts can be for me, I don't have the condition.

Yes we are all medical doctors apart from DH.[/quote]
Great. He can speak to his specialist at his appointment and make his decisions.

Nothing more to do until then except stop talking about him like a piece of meat.

CoedenNadolig · 29/12/2021 16:51

OP with all due respect, and it's probably because your all Dr's and Dr's have this matter of fact attitude generally about them, regarding health and "medical discussions", I don't think you are going to ever see this from your DH's point of view.

The man is scared, he's anxious, he's worried about his children's health, he is scared himself of medical procedures and he's getting cornered about it all.

Give him some space, talk to him with some empathy and understanding. This isn't just a "medical thing" for him, it's his children's health and his own panic and anxiety. Perhaps a softer bed side manner might help. He clearly doesn't view this as "routine" and some phone calls to be sorted and discussed. Your not making a patient referral here, he's your husband.

SleepWhenAmDead · 29/12/2021 16:51

Our family has a similar condition. It has always been fine. Fortunately, we have never had an emergency, but I have always put on all the school forms etc that they must inform staff if child needs medical assistance.
I think as long as you make the people in charge of the child aware of the family history of the condition so they can [pass on the info, that is all that you can do.

HarrysChild · 29/12/2021 16:50

@TheCanyon testing for a terminal, life limiting, irreversible condition such as Huntington’s is complex and very difficult. Many people choose not to test, as is their right. To dismiss it as “selfish” is way too simplistic and ignorant of what a diagnosis of Huntington’s means for that person - being told they’re a living time bomb who will 100% develop this devastating condition is not something everyone can cope with. Nothing selfish about it.

Chewbecca · 29/12/2021 16:47

YANBU at all, of course he should test to a) ensure he has the facts and b) to save his DC potential testing.

I also don’t think you’re U to discuss at the dinner table, anything goes at ours.

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:43

@CoedenNadolig the issue of making the appointment for the breast cancer testing was brought up in the context of discussing travel plans for the future: having to plan when each of them can get home again and so when I should book travel and medical appointments for them.

We told them about the family history on the phone last week, as soon as we found out, and they said then that they wanted to discuss the practical arrangements when they were home for Christmas, which they were. They were leaving again the next day.

OP posts:
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:38

@GabriellaMontez regarding the appointment, I am not going to "ask him to come", this would be his appointment not mine. I will go with him to HIS appointment if he agrees to go. If he won't go then I would make an appt for my DS and go with him. None of these appts can be for me, I don't have the condition.

Yes we are all medical doctors apart from DH.

OP posts:
gunnersgold · 29/12/2021 16:38

Me and dh had similar to see if dd could carry what ds has . He faints at needles and gets in a right state but still did it . It's his responsibility I'm afraid and he has to literally man up!

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2021 16:37

[quote questionandanswer]@we do all that on Xmas eve. This was at the Xmas day lunch, so after.[/quote]
😂

gogohm · 29/12/2021 16:37

He needs to talk to his gp, I suspect it's not as painful as his thinks. Of course if one of the dsd's goes ahead and has the test and does have the gene then you know you do need to test ds, though I would personally as he's a child simply subscribe to a medic alert bracelet anyway if you don't already and have it as a maybe along with the autism. My dd has one fir asd, gad, and epilepsy, think it was £60 for the first year (including a silver necklace and bracelet) then £30 subsequently

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:35

There is no "register" but his carers and healthcare professionals would need to be told, it would need to be on his medical and school records etc, and he would wear a bracelet. He could wear a bracelet anyway, as elder DSD already does, but he is not going to like that (autism and special needs) and it may be uneccessary. Of course as long as I have known about the possibility he may have it I have flagged it up as a possibliy when he has seen doctors, gone to hospital etc, and he recently had surgery under GA, with them treating him as though he has it, just in case.

OP posts:
CoedenNadolig · 29/12/2021 16:33

So you all sat around on Christmas day discussing the fact that a) all the women die young historically and you may have the gene for breast cancer and then followed by B) a conversation about booking DH in for an appointment for another "faulty gene" he may have passed on to his children.

Poor guy probably feels like shit and wondering what the hell have I passed on to the kids, and then he's called selfish infront of everyone.

Sounds like delightful dinner conversation.

Lucillesbigsister · 29/12/2021 16:33

YANBU to ask your DH to have the test. Makes absolute sense. I wouldn’t hesitate if I was him.

YABU to discuss at the Christmas dinner table especially as there were people there you don’t know well.

Magnited · 29/12/2021 16:32

[quote questionandanswer]@Magnited that is certainly something to think about. DH already has life insurance, but the girls need to think about this before they test, I guess, as they do not have any yet. In further discusions I will highlight this to them so they can make decisions.[/quote]
Hmm...not sure it would be right knowing they have a probability and getting life insurance without disclosing it as a medical condition 'in the family'. Best situation is for DH to get tested. Then, if they need life insurance in future they can cut their cloth accordingly but at least will be able to rely on whatever life insurance they have.

Having been in a similar situation in the past, there is no substitute for having full medical information at your disposal for so many life choices.

Your DH will be selfish if he does not come round to the biopsy. Have not read the full thread and do not intend to.

GabriellaMontez · 29/12/2021 16:31

Then I suggest you apologise to your dh for speaking about him at the dinner table in that manner. And assure him there will be no further discussion until you've seen the specialist. Ask him to come and be part of that conversation.

Discussing medical appointments/details of another adult with family members at the dinner table... Are you a medical Dr?

No wonder he was furious.

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:31

@ittakes2 If DH has not got it none of the children has it and do not have to test.

If DH has it, each child has 50% chance of having it and so they will all have to test. One, two, three or none of them could be positive, no way to tell without testing.

If the DSDs test and are posiotive, that means DH does not have to test as he must have it. DS would still have to test as he would have 50% chance.

OP posts:
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 16:28

No not yet. DH had not yet agreed to go to an appointment. The first step is obviously to see the specialist. But from my reading, the genetic testing can be done but the definitive test is usually the biopsy. DH's sister certainly had to have the biopsy and her daughters have also had it I believe (I don't know what the daughter's results were but the sister is definitely positive).

OP posts: