Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

tricky family medical (genetic) matter

311 replies

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 12:42

Have NC for this. I wondered if anyone has any thoughts on something that caused a family argument this Xmas. It is a medical matter. I will just give the essential info, not to make it too specific and technical, or long. Basically:

I have a DH, who has two adult daughters, my DSDs. We also have a 12yo DS together. Not long ago DH and the DSDs found out from family that DH's sister (from whom he is estranged) has been diagnosed as having a genetic condition. The condition does not affect everyday life in any way but does mean that the sufferer needs to make doctors aware of it if they have a general anaesthetic.The condition can be potentially fatal if you have a general anaesthetic using certain agents, but if the doctors know about it, alternative agents can be used and all is fine.

It is of course possible to just tell doctors about the possibility of the condition at the time of an anaesthetic, and they can use the alternative agent just in case (this happened recently when DS had to have a GA). However, the concern would be if the person is not in a position to give this history, in an accident and unconscious, say, with no family around in time (also DS is only 12 and is autistic and probably unlikely to give the history correctly even if he is conscious). So I certainly want to know if DS has it, and the DSDs want to know if they have it. If they do they would then wear a medic alert tag.

The catch is that. although some degree of genetic testing can be done, the only definitive test is a muscle biopsy, which a fairly invasive and, I believe, quite painful, test. Now, the way the conditiion is inherited, if DH was to test negative, the kids could not have it and so would be spared the testing and any further concern. So the obvious first step is for DH to see a doctor and ask for testing.

The problem is that DH is refusing. He says he will see a doctor to discuss the situation but no way will he have the biopsy. This means that 12yo DS is going to have to have the test (as even if the DSDs test and are negtaive. DS could still have it).

DH became verbally abusive and started shouting at the dining table at Christmas when i suggested he was being selfish. This was in front of the DSDs boyfriends, one of whom we only know a little and one of whom we were meeting for the first time. This was very embarrassing for me. And we are no further forward with finding out the genetic status of any of them.

I dont think IABU (unless you think I should just solve it by getting everyone medic alert tags anyway, but I don't see why DS should have to wear one if he does not have the condition).

OP posts:
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 20:33

Oh no I certainly would not expect the GP to handle this, I am just going to ask advice about where to be referred to. @greenlynx thanks for understanding that some families might spend a little time at their second shared meal in 2 years talking about some family health issues rather than feeling pressure to be unremittingly "festive". (When everyone is dispersing again the following day).

OP posts:
nocoolnamesleft · 29/12/2021 20:30

Very odd. I've always found parents leapt at any opportunity to undergo tests themselves, rather than inflict them on their children. And it sounds perfectly normal to discuss it round the meal table, when most of those talking are doctors.

BookFiend4Life · 29/12/2021 20:18

[quote Merryoldgoat]@BookFiend4Life

Carrier is generally used to refer to someone who does not have a condition but can pass it along. So technically yes, if you have the condition you ‘carry’ it but carrier isn’t the correct description as they are an affected party where a carrier isn’t.[/quote]
Thank you for the clarification. My child has a very rare mutation on the AN05 gene and we haven't decided yet how to tell her about it. She's just a baby though so we have time to figure it out. It is autosomal dominant so she has the condition, I was hopeful for a minute there that she might not be a carrier! Silly of me. It's a lot to learn. Thanks again.

astrowars · 29/12/2021 20:15

The difficulty with testing your DH's children without him being tested is that if any of them is a carrier, your DH's carrier status will be revealed to him, as he will be an obligate carrier. With this scenario it is unlikely that a child aged 12 will be able to be tested without some genetic counselling. I would ask for a referral to your local clinical genetics department ( each nhs region has one) for the whole family to receive expert advice. This is not a situation that a gp should be expected to handle, they should refer you.
(I am a genetics professional)

Zilla1 · 29/12/2021 20:13

HNRTT though have seen you seem to be on top of this. It seems clear your DS and DSD are a priority to you and it is a shame that their other parent is unwilling to do the action that could give certainty for three younger people, whether down to some health 'anxiety', anxiety about family members' historical causes of death or some other reason.

Good luck.

greenlynx · 29/12/2021 20:12

Sorry meant in my post that my DH was surprised that I’ve asked

greenlynx · 29/12/2021 20:08

I can’t get my head around some comments: oh how can you talk about this at Xmas dinner or his body his choice or you are undermining your DH by making his medical appointments. It’s nonsense! If there was a chance, tiny chance, that I or DH could go through testing or procedure instead of our DD we would jump to it. And before anyone would comment I did ask him about it before posting, he was surprised that you asked. Do we like medical procedures ? Of course not. But we do love our daughter.

By the way I think it’s normal family conversation at the dinner table about family issues when everyone got together. And I do all appointments in our family and can make a comment like OP did.

TomsPrisonConsultant · 29/12/2021 19:32

@ancientgran yes sorry, I didn't mean it is essential to have a first degree relative as like you say there are circumstances where other factors make people eligible but the bar is surprisingly high. I thought the criteria where wrong/too high and I'm very glad I did or I'd still be in the dark.

HarrysChild · 29/12/2021 19:24

Yes sorry what i meant was I assumed it was a blood test as in a simple yes or no test, i hadn’t realised it takes months to come back and how complex it is - but yes, for the patient of course it is a blood test

ancientgran · 29/12/2021 19:24

@TomsPrisonConsultant

I think the distinction is what it possible (ie anyone can be tested for BRCA faults, but with no other info it's a long search!) vs who is eligible e.g. the NHS sets a very high bar, you need to have a very significant family history (eg first degree relatives), and in those circumstances they want the relevant blood test info to make the testing as straightforward as possible.
I didn't have a first degree relative with a diagnosis but I did have alot of cousins/aunts plus grandmother with confirmed diagnosis, although GM's diagnosis was long after her death.
ancientgran · 29/12/2021 19:20

@HarrysChild

That’s what happened to me OP, and I couldn’t get BRCA testing as no living relatives or recently deceased ones whose histology they could access. I was shocked as I had assumed a blood test too but it was considerably more complex 😔
For the person having the test it is just a blood test though. The complications of other samples doesn't make the test any harder to have, they just take some blood, you wait for the result.
TomsPrisonConsultant · 29/12/2021 19:19

Sorry that was another post to @HarrysChild

TomsPrisonConsultant · 29/12/2021 19:18

I think the distinction is what it possible (ie anyone can be tested for BRCA faults, but with no other info it's a long search!) vs who is eligible e.g. the NHS sets a very high bar, you need to have a very significant family history (eg first degree relatives), and in those circumstances they want the relevant blood test info to make the testing as straightforward as possible.

ancientgran · 29/12/2021 19:17

@HarrysChild

I am sure you may know this OP so sorry if covering known ground - but with BRCA testing it’s not as simple as a blood test in many cases. You need to ask your GP to refer you to your regional Clinical Genetics department, not Breast Clinic. They will often need samples from other relatives with the gene, so that they can look for the specific mutation, before they are able to offer BRCA testing. Sometimes without other confirmed histology from relatives with the relevant cancer they cannot test (this happened to me). I see you are going private so that might change things, but most NHS Clinical Genetics departments have a really high bar for testing, as they are constantly swamped with requests. Hope you get somewhere, it’s a minefield.
Yes, it wasn't clear in the early replies that they don't even know if there is a BRCA connection. In my family they had samples going back to the 60s as my grandmothers samples were still available, then aunts and cousins.

Unlike someone who posted earlier my genetics specialist won't give results by letter or phone, he feels if it is positive he should be there for support/advice so everyone goes back for results. For me it was a bus journey, train journey and then another bus to get to the hospital.

HiJenny35 · 29/12/2021 19:14

Poor dh, please. Can you imagine if a mother was refusing a medical procedure knowing her 12 year old child with special needs was going to have to go through it because she wouldn't. I fail to see how anyone can say he's anything but completely selfish. Yes his body his choice but when you have children at least you should be willing to go through a level of pain so they don't have to. He wasn't so phobic when it was an issue that was making him uncomfortable. Yes his choice, 100% but also your choice of how you see him after that choice as I could never forgive, respect or want to be with a man who would make his special needs son go through the procedure with the fear and lack of understanding the child will go through so that he didn't have to and its come from his family line so at the end of the day he has a level of responsibility. Absolutely selfish, should be ashamed of himself.

BigYellowHat · 29/12/2021 19:13

It’s his body. He doesn’t have to have the procedure if he doesn’t want to. If you were a man complaining about your wife refusing to have a procedure then you’d have been ripped a new one by now. Anyone who wants to know just has to have the test 🤷‍♀️

TomsPrisonConsultant · 29/12/2021 19:13

@HarrysChild as I understand it, having a sample is preferable (then they know where to look for the genetic fault) but not a necessity. I didn't have one myself, I'm the first person in my family known to have a BRCA mutation.

HarrysChild · 29/12/2021 19:10

OP this may be of interest to you, i picked GOSH purely as I used to work there once and could easily find the link, but their genetics testing is for adults and children not just children. It also says there that to get BRCA testing you normally need an affected living relative. This rules out a lot of people I think 😔
media.gosh.nhs.uk/documents/Cancer_genetics_clinic.pdf

liveforsummer · 29/12/2021 19:10

[quote questionandanswer]@liveforsummer he kept saying he would do it when he had time. We
that he would. In the meanwhile we all behaved as if they all had the condition. The girls are getting fed up with waiting now and wanted him to get on with a consultation about the matter, hence bringing it up while we were discussing family medical issues.[/quote]
The daughter is an adult though and has had a reaction so surely she needs to take that on herself and get tested? And as I said you boom every other thing for him but was leaving this til he had time. Confused why it was different, just book the appointment like you do and have for every other issue over the years as you say he is not capable of doing so himself anyway

Antiqueanniesmagiclanternshow · 29/12/2021 19:06

Jesus, Christmas sounds like a proper party in your house!
Your poor dh!

HarrysChild · 29/12/2021 19:03

That’s what happened to me OP, and I couldn’t get BRCA testing as no living relatives or recently deceased ones whose histology they could access. I was shocked as I had assumed a blood test too but it was considerably more complex 😔

questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 19:03

@liveforsummer he kept saying he would do it when he had time. We
that he would. In the meanwhile we all behaved as if they all had the condition. The girls are getting fed up with waiting now and wanted him to get on with a consultation about the matter, hence bringing it up while we were discussing family medical issues.

OP posts:
questionandanswer · 29/12/2021 19:01

@HarrysChild I will have to find out who the GP wants to refer to here (Ireland). I will speak to her next week.

There can be no samples from any other relatives as there are none living, apart from his sister, who he does not speak to and will never speak to, and who has not had cancer (I did make sure that she was told, through back channels in the family, about my findings in the family tree though. She has two daughters).

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 29/12/2021 19:00

The adult dd who has already had a reaction to GA and is a dr. Why has she not had a test?? This has been over 2 years in the know and despite you organising all dh's appointments for everything else youv e not done this for this situation that you stress is important for ds but it's all been brought up during Xmas dinner?! I can see why he was taken aback

HarrysChild · 29/12/2021 18:54

I am sure you may know this OP so sorry if covering known ground - but with BRCA testing it’s not as simple as a blood test in many cases. You need to ask your GP to refer you to your regional Clinical Genetics department, not Breast Clinic. They will often need samples from other relatives with the gene, so that they can look for the specific mutation, before they are able to offer BRCA testing. Sometimes without other confirmed histology from relatives with the relevant cancer they cannot test (this happened to me). I see you are going private so that might change things, but most NHS Clinical Genetics departments have a really high bar for testing, as they are constantly swamped with requests. Hope you get somewhere, it’s a minefield.