Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Actually offensive Secret Santa Gift?

363 replies

BewilderedPiskie · 29/12/2021 11:55

I have always avoided Secret Santa arrangements where possible due in no small part to threads on here. This year we had some new members to the small team I work in, in a professional environment, who suggested we arrange one amongst ourselves and to avoid looking curmudgeonly I agreed.
I have been gifted an adult colouring book and some felt tips. I must admit I found this disappointing in itself as I never got swept up in this craze and am a little disappointed that one of my colleagues has concluded I am an adult colourer but that's by the by.
My real issue is that it's the 'Go F*ck Yourself I'm Coloring' 50 swear words to color your anger away, adult coloring book. Which should be fine, I like a robust swear and I have a job that can very much cause stress but I finally looked at it properly today and a lot of the words to colour are not swear words per se but really, really unpleasant misogynistic, sexual slurs and terms that I associate with pornography not swearing. I have actually found myself quite offended that someone thought this was an appropriate gift for a fifty year old female colleague in a professional environment. My quandary is whether I should say something to the group or just hide it in the recycling and forget about it? I think I have attached an image so you can see the kind of thing I'm referencing.

Actually offensive Secret Santa Gift?
OP posts:
SpaceshiptoMars · 29/12/2021 22:42

Just wondering if those who so proudly announce themselves to be 'humourless feminists' who won't put up with any nonsense are popular in their workplaces - or percieved as bullies/sneaks?

You know what? If giving someone a public 'gift' that expects them to colour in 'Cum Dumpster', 'Baggy Vag' etc is not bullying, then what is? Where are your boundaries?

foxgoosefinch · 29/12/2021 22:40

@Wreath21

Just wondering if those who so proudly announce themselves to be 'humourless feminists' who won't put up with any nonsense are popular in their workplaces - or percieved as bullies/sneaks? The trouble with throwing a big self-righteous tantrum over what is either minor silliness or a thoughtless mistake can be that when you do encounter real nastiness and seek help, people think that it's just you whining and stirring again...
I’m sure I’m thought of by my older male colleagues as a sneak or a bully (Hmm) because I refused to keep making the tea and taking notes at meetings like their secretary (despite many junior men being present); but then on the other hand they treated me a hell of a lot better and more professionally after I did complain/refuse, so that’s a win in my book.

And I’m a professional woman in my forties, so I have no need to be thought of as the cool simpering girl at work, nor do I care a flying fig about being socially policed by other women trying to put me down by calling me a whiner on the internet. Hope that helps!

Wreath21 · 29/12/2021 22:28

Just wondering if those who so proudly announce themselves to be 'humourless feminists' who won't put up with any nonsense are popular in their workplaces - or percieved as bullies/sneaks? The trouble with throwing a big self-righteous tantrum over what is either minor silliness or a thoughtless mistake can be that when you do encounter real nastiness and seek help, people think that it's just you whining and stirring again...

JacquelineCarlyle · 29/12/2021 21:42

@ANameChangeAgain

But then I’m just a humourless feminist who thinks that women should no longer have to put up with nasty “jokes” at work in order to maintain some kind of social politeness, or to coddle the feelings of spiteful or silly people. No thanks. Absolutely ditto. In my twenties and probably very early thirties I would have faked an awkward laugh at something like this, so as not to be thought of as dull, but now, no way.
I agree with this. I'd speak to HR and leave it to them to deal with however they see fit.
GreenGreenTreesOfHome · 29/12/2021 21:27

@TheGrinchsDog

This is not aimed *@BewilderedPiskie* you in the slightest but there's been a few comments looking down on adult colourers.

I hate it when people look down on or make out like adult colouring is sad, pathetic or because they don't have talent.

I've recently taken it up for stress relief and find it very relaxing. I also do various traditional art hobbies and am not completely without talent, but doing even if I didn't, doing adult colouring wouldn't make me "less than".

People who do this clearly enjoy shitting on other people's enjoyment. It's really nasty behaviour and you should look at why you are so intently hitting out at something harmless that occupies another human being, possibly helps them and is something they enjoy and are proud of.

Have you ever actually seen some of the finished efforts of adult colouring hobbyists? Some people take it to a proper art form! Those who bash it clearly are taking out of their arses to be honest and it says a lot more about them than the colouring in people.

No one should be made to feel shame over a harmless joy in their lives.

Agree with this. ^ WELL SAID! Smile

Me and DH have hobbies and interests that many of our peers don't have, and I'm not gonna lie, we have been mocked too. Just coz DH isn't in to football, golf, fishing, cycling, and has more 'unconventional' hobbies,' he has been royally mocked at work on and off over the years (always by men.) AND by his mates. Not all but some.

Same with me, I have a few 'unconventional' hobbies, and like you, I like colouring. This will blow the haterz minds, my latest project in adult colouring is colouring in a FROZEN book. The book is aimed at 5 to 12 y.o girls. IDGAF. I enjoy it.

I also have a little fairy garden with little 'elf' houses (in the shape of toadstools,) and a few 4-5" high dragon ornaments, and a few little old cottages and castles (like 6" high) in the garden... A few people who have seen it (a couple of neighbours, extended family, and work colleagues,) have seen fit to mock and deride and ask me if I was 5. Or just stifle a giggle, and say 'fairy garden? Really?'

I also have a big soft unicorn toy that DH bought me 20 years ago that I keep on the bottom of the bed, and have a calendar on the wall of my favourite actor. DH has one of Star Wars. We have been mocked and derided by quite a few people for this. When DH got me a beanie cat for Valentines a few years ago, a work colleague said to me 'what the fuck? You are woman in your 40s.

I have NO idea why people have to be such cunts. Neither me OR my DH have ever mocked or derided or critisized what others do. My DD reckons it's because people mock and berate what they don't understand. But I don't buy that. I think some people are just cunts.

@BewilderedPiskie

I am with @StarryNightSky26 and a few others though regarding this book, I don't think I would complain as I doubt the buyer meant any harm - they probably just bought it thinking it was cheeky, and didn't realise how awful it was. YANBU to be annoyed though.

Butchyrestingface · 29/12/2021 21:25

@TheGrinchsDog Not colouring, but I've just ordered a bunch of scratch art from Amazon after discovering the joys this Xmas. Xmas Grin

Intend to hole up for the next week or so with the holy tryptic of jigsaws, scratch art and lego.

Haterz can hate.

Notgettingbetter · 29/12/2021 21:24

@TheGrinchsDog

This is not aimed *@BewilderedPiskie* you in the slightest but there's been a few comments looking down on adult colourers.

I hate it when people look down on or make out like adult colouring is sad, pathetic or because they don't have talent.

I've recently taken it up for stress relief and find it very relaxing. I also do various traditional art hobbies and am not completely without talent, but doing even if I didn't, doing adult colouring wouldn't make me "less than".

People who do this clearly enjoy shitting on other people's enjoyment. It's really nasty behaviour and you should look at why you are so intently hitting out at something harmless that occupies another human being, possibly helps them and is something they enjoy and are proud of.

Have you ever actually seen some of the finished efforts of adult colouring hobbyists? Some people take it to a proper art form! Those who bash it clearly are taking out of their arses to be honest and it says a lot more about them than the colouring in people.

No one should be made to feel shame over a harmless joy in their lives.

Absolutely! Thank you for saying this! I love colouring. I have some incredibly beautiful colouring books created by very talented artists.
BigBadBoom · 29/12/2021 21:14

I'd be willing to bet that whomever bought it just thought it was full of standard swearing, rather than stuff like that. The title doesn't give that impression! I've seen that book before, and without flicking through that's certainly what I thought.

SpaceshiptoMars · 29/12/2021 21:09

No one should be made to feel shame over a harmless joy in their lives.

I'm with you on the flowers and birds etc. I might feel shame colouring in (most of) the phrases in that booklet!

TheGrinchsDog · 29/12/2021 20:55

This is not aimed @BewilderedPiskie you in the slightest but there's been a few comments looking down on adult colourers.

I hate it when people look down on or make out like adult colouring is sad, pathetic or because they don't have talent.

I've recently taken it up for stress relief and find it very relaxing. I also do various traditional art hobbies and am not completely without talent, but doing even if I didn't, doing adult colouring wouldn't make me "less than".

People who do this clearly enjoy shitting on other people's enjoyment. It's really nasty behaviour and you should look at why you are so intently hitting out at something harmless that occupies another human being, possibly helps them and is something they enjoy and are proud of.

Have you ever actually seen some of the finished efforts of adult colouring hobbyists? Some people take it to a proper art form! Those who bash it clearly are taking out of their arses to be honest and it says a lot more about them than the colouring in people.

No one should be made to feel shame over a harmless joy in their lives.

shiningcuckoo · 29/12/2021 20:54

I think it's a rushed present from someone who was trying to be funny. I'd let it lie. In the spirit of ss awfulness, I got a crocheted doily that looks like a cats arse. What was my colleague thinking? I have largely shrugged it off but some people at my work would be so upset by this.

humdingle · 29/12/2021 20:44

I'm surprised at the number of people saying they'd escalate it. And also slightly worried that I didn't read the joke book I gifted cover to cover before our secret Santa.

Franticbutterfly · 29/12/2021 20:30

Disgusting. Recycle it.

Wreath21 · 29/12/2021 19:21

Because Secret Santas do very often cause trouble. If it's not people gifting offensive or potentially offensive items (in a workplace where there isn't a shared and enjoyable culture of pisstaking) it's people sulking and flouncing because they put So Much Effort into a carefully chosen present and got a pack of pound shop toiletries themselves.

My workplace did one and as far as I know, nobody has felt hurt or insulted - my gift was some scented candles which will be useful as I have a rather farty teenager. But then there aren't very many of us...

again2020 · 29/12/2021 19:17

I agree with PP who said leave it in a communal space.

I'd be very confused by this gift. As if anyone thinks that's a decent, even passable gift for a work secret Santa! Very inappropriate.
My colleague got given a cliff Richard calendar and it was consider risque 🤣😂
I very much doubt it was personal. Maybe given by someone young who doesn't have much experience in secret santas?
Recycle.
Don't report to HR, it's unlikely to work out how you would like.
Opt out of the secret santa next year.

Wreath21 · 29/12/2021 19:17

There's quite a scale between doing nothing at all despite finding the book offensive, and raising a formal complaint. Again, the most important thing is the OP's assessment of her workmates and her judgement as to whether this is more likely to have been silly, thoughtless and lazy (as some PP said, a person thinking 'sweary colouring book for a colleague who swears, less than £5, that will do')and a person thinking 'let's send a really offensive gift to OP because she's a bitch who needs putting in her place'.
If OP has her doubts about a specific colleague who has form for pushing limits and claiming it's banter then perhaps a word with HR might be in order. If not, then a few comments to other colleagues she knows well - or to whoever organised it - that her Secret Santa gift was a bit much and maybe doing the thing at all is not a good idea might be more effective.

ddl1 · 29/12/2021 19:00

Adult colouring suggests that the person doing it has not enough of an artistic gift to actually design and draw and outline themselves to "colour in" or can't be bothered. It also suggests they have a lot of time on their hands to produce something unoriginal.

Well, most people don't have that sort of artistic gift! Unless the job is something related to art and design, it wouldn't even occur to me to worry about that.

It's something many people do to relax, and at least it's more creative than many of the things (usually involving screens in some way) that we do to relax.

I'm not even into adult colouring books, but some of the condemnations sound so snooty.

I am, however, happy to be snooty about this particular colouring book: it sounds absolutely vile!

Mamamia344 · 29/12/2021 18:53

@notanothertakeaway

OP, in your shoes, I'm not sure I'd go to HR, but I would speak to the SS organiser and ask them to tell the giver that you found the gift offensive and inappropriate
Yup. The more I think about it, the more unacceptable I think it is. One for HR.
karmakameleon · 29/12/2021 18:49

I quite like the suggestion of putting it in a communal area, then everyone else can see how horrible it is.

Quite a few people have made this suggestion and although I’m sure the OP doesn’t intend to go down this path, it’s worth pointing out that this could mean the OP has an HR complaint directed against her. Anyone who saw this in the workplace could reasonably claim to be offended by it.

I’m another who would have put up with this when I was younger and more junior, and very likely would have colluded as no one wants to stick their head above the parapet. But I’m older now and have senior management responsibilities. Part of my role is to uphold the values and culture of my organisation. I’d not be doing my job if I turned a blind eye.

ChristmasRobins · 29/12/2021 18:46

@roolz If you’re not commenting on the words, what are you commenting on? Just calling it a “crappy book” and a “shitty Amazon gift” is minimising how wildly inappropriate and offensive it is.

roolz · 29/12/2021 18:41

@ChristmasRobins

It is a book of swear words. Lots of swear words are yucky things or sex related

The issue with “cum dumpster” is not that it’s a “yucky thing”. It’s grossly offensive, not far off giving a black person a colouring book containing the n word.

I didn't comment on the word itself. Of course it's the internet so people will pick apart anything you say. My point is it's kind of obscure as a swear, it's two words for a start

To be clear, it's a crappy book, hence why they're scrimping for words like cum dumpster. Someone said it's like £3.50. It's a shitty Amazon gift someone made to get a bit of money

(Yes it's definitely misogynistic to use it as an insult, that's obvious, don't think many people are said otherwise)

monotonousmum · 29/12/2021 18:38

@Bambooshoot
That's not what I said though. I'm just saying I doubt they even realise what was in it, and not to take it as a personal insult.

Nothing about santa having his own problems. It's a shit gift, without a doubt.

I quite like the suggestion of putting it in a communal area, then everyone else can see how horrible it is. But I wouldn't assume that the giver was trying to insult the OP.

MsTSwift · 29/12/2021 18:36

Complain!

MsTSwift · 29/12/2021 18:36

*Miss World

  • Vonokain to HR not her
MsTSwift · 29/12/2021 18:35

If women hadn’t “made a big deal” of how we were treated over the years we would still be treated as chattel and not had the vote or equal pay 🙄 and Benny Hill and Miss Works would still be on mainstream tv . You realise we had to fight for evertthing we’ve got now?

Fuck this I would go and complain to her and demand action. Dh would too. But we are bolshy 40 somethings I fear my twenty something self would have simpered and done nothing (whilst feeling degraded and got at)