Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Actually offensive Secret Santa Gift?

363 replies

BewilderedPiskie · 29/12/2021 11:55

I have always avoided Secret Santa arrangements where possible due in no small part to threads on here. This year we had some new members to the small team I work in, in a professional environment, who suggested we arrange one amongst ourselves and to avoid looking curmudgeonly I agreed.
I have been gifted an adult colouring book and some felt tips. I must admit I found this disappointing in itself as I never got swept up in this craze and am a little disappointed that one of my colleagues has concluded I am an adult colourer but that's by the by.
My real issue is that it's the 'Go F*ck Yourself I'm Coloring' 50 swear words to color your anger away, adult coloring book. Which should be fine, I like a robust swear and I have a job that can very much cause stress but I finally looked at it properly today and a lot of the words to colour are not swear words per se but really, really unpleasant misogynistic, sexual slurs and terms that I associate with pornography not swearing. I have actually found myself quite offended that someone thought this was an appropriate gift for a fifty year old female colleague in a professional environment. My quandary is whether I should say something to the group or just hide it in the recycling and forget about it? I think I have attached an image so you can see the kind of thing I'm referencing.

Actually offensive Secret Santa Gift?
OP posts:
JustUseTheDoorSanta · 30/12/2021 08:23

Set up an office swear bucket
If that isn't agreed to by the team then the only appropriate response to the bucket will be "fuck off".

MsTSwift · 30/12/2021 08:08

Just watch Colin in Black and White on Netflix. Watch it. One of the things that upsets the character and brings him down are the constant micro aggressions he gets for being black. This is the same.

mathanxiety · 30/12/2021 04:09

There has been quite a bit of consideration of the application of 'zero tolerance' policies doing rather more harm than good.

@Wreath21
It has been observed that it is important to crack down hard and consistently on what is called 'quality of life' problems. In the case I mentioned, erasing graffiti means no gang tagging, and sends a message to gangs that gang activity is not tolerated. Give gangs an inch and they will take a mile. Same goes for men inclined to dominate a workplace and create a hostile environment for women, gay people, etc.

The misogynistic 'banter' that so many women (and gay people) have to put up with because it's considered low level - and therefore completely acceptable, something they should be willing to put up with in exchange for the privilege of being let out to work - is a form of turf marking in exactly the way gangs tagging turf is. It's one group of people (men) making it plain that the office is run on their terms in order to make sure another group of people knows its place.

I live in a well run, very racially and economically diverse municipality where property taxes pay for excellent public schools which provide a vast range of support services for struggling students (academic, social-emotional, support for students who are parents/creche in the school, a discipline policy aimed at eliminating detentions and suspensions) along with great public recreational facilities, libraries, and outreach and youth programmes run by police, park district, and the public health department.

An integrated and consensus driven approach to issues is not only possible, it's the only way to ensure results. The result in the case of the place where I live is solid, community-wide support for police and policing, for school administrations, and willingness to shoulder the tax burden that makes it all possible.

There is an 11pm curfew for under 18s. Parks are off limits after 10pm. I can take a walk outdoors any time, day or night, in my neighbourhood. I could leave children's toys out on my front lawn (which had no fence or wall around it as in many American municipalities) all night when my DCs were young. I often leave my back door unlocked at night.

This is a very nice place for children to grow up and form their opinions of the world and their place in it. It's a high trust society with a high degree of trust in the institutions that keep it ticking over, thanks to zero tolerance and the other elements that go hand in hand with it.

NoNotMeNoSiree · 30/12/2021 03:54

How is it woke if a man likes colouring Confused Grin
Or do you think men should only drink beer and hammer some dry wall Grin
You know, MAN stuff

mathanxiety · 30/12/2021 03:41

Really, @UniversalAunt?

A colouring book for a man. How woke.

UniversalAunt · 30/12/2021 03:37

Hmmm @BewilderedPiskie, is that image of the front cover? As seen on the shop shelf?

UniversalAunt · 30/12/2021 03:30

‘ Would the person (man or woman) who gave this piece of garbage have given it to a man?’

Yes.

UniversalAunt · 30/12/2021 03:25

If you were a person who never swore in the office, & made it clear that you find swearing distasteful, then maybe you could take the item as a dig.

But you do say that you like ‘ robust swear’ & that your workplace can be stressful, so I assume that you do swear at work. Likely your Secret Santa looked no further than the front of the book & thought that’ll do OP, she likes a good swear.

For some a robust swear goes a lot further than you (or I) would be comfortable with & that book caters for a broad market.

Chalk this episode up to experience: you could just bin the item.

Maybe turn this round? Set up an office swear bucket, colour in a few acceptable phrases & stick them round the bucket with a swear tariff, proceeds go to charity. Anyone suggests putting up one of the worst phrases in the book - & they won’t as it is a professional workplace - but if they do, tell them exactly why. Then you are in a position to say someth8ng.

As long as the worst swearing/derogatory/misogynistic terms are not used in the office, then keep this light & turn it round.

Flickflak · 30/12/2021 02:50

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

StrangerThanSpring · 30/12/2021 02:01

@UnRavellingFast

If ‘cum dumpster’ was given to a male gay colleague anonymously, how would people view it?
I'm not sure what your point is but absolutely no one should be referred to as a cum dumpster. It's disgusting.

I would have no issue with passing this on to HR and telling them you didn't appreciate it. This kind of shit gets played off as office banter all the time. It's not ok and I can't believe all the people making excuses for the bastard who gave it to her.

Geppili · 30/12/2021 01:40

HR

Pantsomime · 30/12/2021 01:07

Take it to HR a but don’t leave it with them and ask what you should do

Snorkmaidenn · 30/12/2021 01:06

Sorry, sent wrong faces

Snorkmaidenn · 30/12/2021 01:04

GrinGrin

UnRavellingFast · 30/12/2021 00:51

If ‘cum dumpster’ was given to a male gay colleague anonymously, how would people view it?

Wreath21 · 30/12/2021 00:21

There has been quite a bit of consideration of the application of 'zero tolerance' policies doing rather more harm than good. When it's a matter of policing neighbourhoods, it often leads to discrimination and police officers taking it upon themselves to respond with disproportionate aggression to minor crimes. When it's imposed in schools it leads to children whose 'unacceptable' behaviour is a cry for help being punished instead of supported.
It also leads to a lot of bullying, meddling and snitching, when people who enjoy power over others decide to appoint themselves authorities on what is acceptable behaviour, going far beyond what others, even those on the recieving end of minor rudenesses, consider necessary.

mathanxiety · 30/12/2021 00:17

Telling women not to 'overthink' this is a form of gaslighting.

mathanxiety · 30/12/2021 00:11

The trouble with throwing a big self-righteous tantrum over what is either minor silliness or a thoughtless mistake can be that when you do encounter real nastiness and seek help, people think that it's just you whining and stirring again...

@Wreath21
It is all 'real nastiness'.

And finding it offensive and reporting it isn't 'throwing a self righteous tantrum'. It's speaking up for your right to a workplace that is not a hostile environment.

Here's an earth shattering concept - report everything and the big stuff won't happen.

Women don't have to put up with bullshit - any bullshit - in their workplaces.

I live in a nice suburb of an American city where there is zero tolerance for graffiti. Residents can call to report graffiti if they see it and the Streets and San Dept sends a graffiti removal team out. Small potatoes, you may say, but the lack of graffiti sends a message as loud and clear as graffiti does. There is very little crime related to gangs here. So called 'low level' harassment and hostile signalling in a workplace is the same as gangs marking turf. You let them get away with the small encroachments and they are soon well entrenched, with women worried about repercussions for standing up for their rights.

OhYesIKnowWhatYouMean · 29/12/2021 23:22

HR.

Totally offensive and constitutes harassment. If it was intentionally offensive then the person needs to be dealt with, if it was unintentional then the person needs to be made aware of why it was inappropriate.

Twillow · 29/12/2021 23:21

@CommanderBurnham

Bin it.

Why oh why don't people just buy bland generic gifts at Christmas???

Because hand cream/soap sets are also offensive! Secret Santa is awful.
Hugoslavia · 29/12/2021 23:13

I:d be tempted to colour them in and then stick them to the offending colleagues monitor!

HunterGatherer · 29/12/2021 23:11

I think whoever gave you that was trying to embarrass you in front of the team and probably had a snigger with their mates beforehand too.
I work in a professional setting and was horrified one year when a lovely dignified older lady on our team was given a copy of the karma sutra and a vibrating cock ring. WTF. Some people are beyond awful. Our team is all female as well.

OVienna · 29/12/2021 23:02

@SpaceshiptoMars

Just wondering if those who so proudly announce themselves to be 'humourless feminists' who won't put up with any nonsense are popular in their workplaces - or percieved as bullies/sneaks?

You know what? If giving someone a public 'gift' that expects them to colour in 'Cum Dumpster', 'Baggy Vag' etc is not bullying, then what is? Where are your boundaries?

X1000

C8H10N4O2 · 29/12/2021 22:58

@Wreath21

Just wondering if those who so proudly announce themselves to be 'humourless feminists' who won't put up with any nonsense are popular in their workplaces - or percieved as bullies/sneaks? The trouble with throwing a big self-righteous tantrum over what is either minor silliness or a thoughtless mistake can be that when you do encounter real nastiness and seek help, people think that it's just you whining and stirring again...
I'm a humourless feminist if being a "good sport" requires nodding, smiling and turning a blind eye to bigoted crap and bullying.

Like fox I never made the tea, took the notes "because it made sense" or tolerated "banter" aka bigoted crap about women and minorities. I also remember who made "jokes" when i was on the way up and who was supportive.

I am the boss now of a large practice. I have a wait list for all my teams, especially from said young women and minorities.

foxgoosefinch · 29/12/2021 22:45

(Oh and @Wreath21 I’ve also made it my business during my career to make sure go speak up every time over the sexist treatment of female colleagues (especially younger female colleagues) in the workplace, including making sure employers adhere to legal standards on equality law and best employment practice. But I should imagine you prefer to call other women whiners instead of sticking up for all our rights at work - so I’m very glad you aren’t at my workplace.)