Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Actually offensive Secret Santa Gift?

363 replies

BewilderedPiskie · 29/12/2021 11:55

I have always avoided Secret Santa arrangements where possible due in no small part to threads on here. This year we had some new members to the small team I work in, in a professional environment, who suggested we arrange one amongst ourselves and to avoid looking curmudgeonly I agreed.
I have been gifted an adult colouring book and some felt tips. I must admit I found this disappointing in itself as I never got swept up in this craze and am a little disappointed that one of my colleagues has concluded I am an adult colourer but that's by the by.
My real issue is that it's the 'Go F*ck Yourself I'm Coloring' 50 swear words to color your anger away, adult coloring book. Which should be fine, I like a robust swear and I have a job that can very much cause stress but I finally looked at it properly today and a lot of the words to colour are not swear words per se but really, really unpleasant misogynistic, sexual slurs and terms that I associate with pornography not swearing. I have actually found myself quite offended that someone thought this was an appropriate gift for a fifty year old female colleague in a professional environment. My quandary is whether I should say something to the group or just hide it in the recycling and forget about it? I think I have attached an image so you can see the kind of thing I'm referencing.

Actually offensive Secret Santa Gift?
OP posts:
WanderleyWagon · 30/12/2021 15:24

I'm going to go against the grain and say that this is something that would merit followup. This is so grossly inappropriate for the workplace and so sickly misogynistic that I couldn't let it stand.

BUT, I would assume the person who got it didn't check it carefully enough; I wouldn't go straight to assuming malice/sexual harassment. And I don't think I'd raise it right now. I'd either wait a few weeks and then raise it with my manager in a 'let's do things differently for Christmas 2022' way, or I'd wait until the autumn and raise it then, when people are starting to gear up for Christmas.

Depends what kind of management/team structure you have, but if there's a suitable meeting I'd bring an image or two of the worst images (cum dumpster!!! wtaf Angry) and say look, this is clearly an accident but I got given this for the Secret Santa and this is just gross and shows appalling judgement and how do we avoid this ever happening again.

tbh I'd also work out what company made it and write to complain/ name and shame them on social media. I love the idea of adult colouring books but this shit is not on.

CastleCrasher · 30/12/2021 15:18

A very good friend bought me a colouring book from this range a few years ago. She was mortified when she later saw the content. She literally went on to Amazon, saw a sweary colouring book and bought it. She didn't look inside and tbf, it was probably about February before I did either. Unless you've got reason to think otherwise I'd chalk this up to laziness, nothing more

UnRavellingFast · 30/12/2021 15:18

@StrangerThanSpring my point was that taking things out of context, switching them around, can make us realise how offensive something is. This kind of thing is what happens to women all the time and I believe we need to keep aware so we can challenge and therefore change things.

karmakameleon · 30/12/2021 15:16

@Wreath21

Hmm. In terms of office Cartmans, imagine that you work with one or more trans/non-binary people. You get on well with these people but someone else in the office (who is neither trans nor non-binary) discovers you are a Mumsnet user and decides that you are transphobic and are making the workplace unsafe for your colleagues...

Again, OP is not unreasonable to dislike this 'gift'. She might well be unreasonable to snitch to HR and make it a bigger issue than it is.

Has someone actually accused you of transphobia at work simply because you are a mumsnet user? Because if this has actually happened, that would be unpleasant and create a hostile working environment. But whether it’s true or weird made up whataboutery, it had nothing to do with the OP Hmm
ChristmasRobins · 30/12/2021 14:54

PMSL that someone has managed to use this thread to have a completely irrelevant dig at some trans people. Good grief.

ravenmum · 30/12/2021 14:46

She might well be unreasonable to snitch to HR and make it a bigger issue than it is
OP gets to decide how big an issue it is. Not you.

ravenmum · 30/12/2021 14:45

OP has been given this thing herself, and she is offended by it. Why bring up the unrelated topic of people who imagine someone else taking offence when it has nothing to do with them?

foxgoosefinch · 30/12/2021 14:40

I’m no fan of the daft pronouns/nb stuff either, Wreath, but being given an anonymous gift of “cum dumpster” is not quite in the same ballpark. I don’t think women should accept outright misogyny in the workplace as “humorous” just because someone else might manufacture offence for another reason.

Imagine if you told a colleague to ignore racist material they’d been given, just in case someone else in the office used it as an excuse to get offended about their pronouns?

Wreath21 · 30/12/2021 14:32

Hmm. In terms of office Cartmans, imagine that you work with one or more trans/non-binary people. You get on well with these people but someone else in the office (who is neither trans nor non-binary) discovers you are a Mumsnet user and decides that you are transphobic and are making the workplace unsafe for your colleagues...

Again, OP is not unreasonable to dislike this 'gift'. She might well be unreasonable to snitch to HR and make it a bigger issue than it is.

zingally · 30/12/2021 14:29

That's pretty gross. But I'd be inclined to give the benefit of the doubt that the purchaser just thought it was a funny title, and didn't look through the actual contents too closely.

I'd just put it in the recycling and forget about it.

Years ago, a "friend" got me a book of sexual positions - with actual photographs of a couple "doing it" - for Christmas! I was 17, never even kissed a guy, and was mortified! No way could I take that home to my parents! I ended up detouring home via the big recycling bins at my local supermarket, and chucking it in there.

HailAdrian · 30/12/2021 13:45

There's no way I'd buy that for a colleague I barely know Confused

Cherrysoup · 30/12/2021 12:47

Next year when it’s raised, you could say no given the frankly crude and thoughtless present you were given last time. Very cringe.

foxgoosefinch · 30/12/2021 11:59

Some of you have clearly never had to work with an absolute Cartman: someone constantly policing the behaviour of others despite being on the same level of them, snitching to HR about what they 'witnessed' even when neither participant in an exchange of banter was at all upset, taking offence on the behalf of hypothetical people, all to draw attention to themselves.

This thread isn’t even remotely about that. This is about a woman who has been sent a rather vile piece of misogyny as a “joke” - it’s nothing to do with whatever your own experiences of “Cartman” have been.

karmakameleon · 30/12/2021 11:51

If someone did that, it would be an obvious, targeted attack. Unless OP knows different (that there is an existing culture of petty bullying in this workplace) there is still a good chance that this book was bought by someone who wasn't putting much thought or effort into the gift choice and meant no harm.

If this was an error (unlikely given that approximately half the book’s pages are misogynist or sexual insults and it is clear that is the case from the back cover) the outcome would probably just be a reminder to the team about professional conduct and to think carefully about secret Santa gifts in the future, and maybe a warning about possible repercussions.

Some of you have clearly never had to work with an absolute Cartman: someone constantly policing the behaviour of others despite being on the same level of them, snitching to HR about what they 'witnessed' even when neither participant in an exchange of banter was at all upset, taking offence on the behalf of hypothetical people, all to draw attention to themselves.

This isn’t about a random person drawing attention to themselves by reporting an incident that doesn’t concern them. This is about an individual who is offended (reasonably so) by an inappropriate gift she received.

Wreath21 · 30/12/2021 11:38

@karmakameleon

Overzealous self-appointed workplace morality guardians tend to create a toxic atmosphere, too.

Sure. So it’s the people saying that they don’t like this shit that are the problem. Not the ones bringing it into the office. When are women allowed to complain? What if some one coloured in the ‘cum dumpster’ page and stuck it to her computer? Should she pretend to find that funny too?

If someone did that, it would be an obvious, targeted attack. Unless OP knows different (that there is an existing culture of petty bullying in this workplace) there is still a good chance that this book was bought by someone who wasn't putting much thought or effort into the gift choice and meant no harm. Some of you have clearly never had to work with an absolute Cartman: someone constantly policing the behaviour of others despite being on the same level of them, snitching to HR about what they 'witnessed' even when neither participant in an exchange of banter was at all upset, taking offence on the behalf of hypothetical people, all to draw attention to themselves.
karmakameleon · 30/12/2021 10:16

Overzealous self-appointed workplace morality guardians tend to create a toxic atmosphere, too.

Sure. So it’s the people saying that they don’t like this shit that are the problem. Not the ones bringing it into the office. When are women allowed to complain? What if some one coloured in the ‘cum dumpster’ page and stuck it to her computer? Should she pretend to find that funny too?

C8H10N4O2 · 30/12/2021 10:08

@UnRavellingFast

If ‘cum dumpster’ was given to a male gay colleague anonymously, how would people view it?
Why is this even relevant?

It was given to an older woman. Women are overwhelmingly the targets if this kind of "fun". Can we not talk about harassment of women ever without thinking about "the menz"?

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 30/12/2021 09:58

It was obviously given in the spirit of a bit of fun, no matter how many perl clutchers are here on MN.

Wasn't that the (unsuccessful) defence offered in the Employment Tribunal by the woman who said that she pulled down her colleague's hijab for fun?

A supermarket worker who was sacked for pulling down a colleague's hijab has lost an unfair dismissal case after claiming she was just 'having a laugh'.

Natalie McGonigle who worked for Morrisons pulled down her Muslim colleague's hijab without her consent on 'two separate occasions' in acts which were deemed 'disrespectful' towards the colleague's religion.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10349741/Supermarket-team-leader-loses-unfair-dismissal-case.html

Wreath21 · 30/12/2021 09:50

@mathanxiety

There has been quite a bit of consideration of the application of 'zero tolerance' policies doing rather more harm than good.

@Wreath21
It has been observed that it is important to crack down hard and consistently on what is called 'quality of life' problems. In the case I mentioned, erasing graffiti means no gang tagging, and sends a message to gangs that gang activity is not tolerated. Give gangs an inch and they will take a mile. Same goes for men inclined to dominate a workplace and create a hostile environment for women, gay people, etc.

The misogynistic 'banter' that so many women (and gay people) have to put up with because it's considered low level - and therefore completely acceptable, something they should be willing to put up with in exchange for the privilege of being let out to work - is a form of turf marking in exactly the way gangs tagging turf is. It's one group of people (men) making it plain that the office is run on their terms in order to make sure another group of people knows its place.

I live in a well run, very racially and economically diverse municipality where property taxes pay for excellent public schools which provide a vast range of support services for struggling students (academic, social-emotional, support for students who are parents/creche in the school, a discipline policy aimed at eliminating detentions and suspensions) along with great public recreational facilities, libraries, and outreach and youth programmes run by police, park district, and the public health department.

An integrated and consensus driven approach to issues is not only possible, it's the only way to ensure results. The result in the case of the place where I live is solid, community-wide support for police and policing, for school administrations, and willingness to shoulder the tax burden that makes it all possible.

There is an 11pm curfew for under 18s. Parks are off limits after 10pm. I can take a walk outdoors any time, day or night, in my neighbourhood. I could leave children's toys out on my front lawn (which had no fence or wall around it as in many American municipalities) all night when my DCs were young. I often leave my back door unlocked at night.

This is a very nice place for children to grow up and form their opinions of the world and their place in it. It's a high trust society with a high degree of trust in the institutions that keep it ticking over, thanks to zero tolerance and the other elements that go hand in hand with it.

You live in a wealthy, middle-class neighbourhood. Probably full of smug gits who think that the problems in poor neighbourhoods are due to poor people making bad choices, being lazy and feral etc. Smug gits are generally able to believe that the police are there to protect, rather than to control them. I don't find your argument convincing at all. Overzealous self-appointed workplace morality guardians tend to create a toxic atmosphere, too.
TheGrinchsDog · 30/12/2021 09:32

@GreenGreenTreesOfHome I have NO idea why people have to be such cunts. Neither me OR my DH have ever mocked or derided or critisized what others do. My DD reckons it's because people mock and berate what they don't understand. But I don't buy that. I think some people are just cunts.

I honestly think it's jealousy. Not in the school bully way of oh they're just so jea-lous! Ner ner!

I mean I think they are jealous of someones unabashed enjoyment of something that traditionally isn't considered 'right' for their age/sex/whatever. I remember a girl at school when we were about 11-12, I asked what kind of cartoons she liked and she gave me Confused face and was like I don't watch cartoons all snooty ha ha! I was Confused back at her and thought she's lying because she thinks she'll look silly for liking cartoons... her loss ha ha!

Some people don't grow past that need to fit in I think and feel that to be a proper adult you must never really enjoy something a they consider childish.

It's their loss! They could be having those joys like the rest of us, it's not childish at all it's cutting their noses off to spite their face and fit in with the cool crowd for fear of Othering themselves. A bit sad really when you think about it. It made me a bit cross there though.

I'm glad there are so many sharing their little joys! I'm happy for you even if the joy suckers aren't Wink

Sorry for hijacking @BewilderedPiskie

TheGrinchsDog · 30/12/2021 09:23

@SpaceshiptoMars

No one should be made to feel shame over a harmless joy in their lives.

I'm with you on the flowers and birds etc. I might feel shame colouring in (most of) the phrases in that booklet!

Oh sorry I agreed earlier that the phrases in the book the OP has are really disgusting!

It was more people shitting on the colouring in bit in particular I was meaning ha ha!

karmakameleon · 30/12/2021 08:56

It was obviously given in the spirit of a bit of fun

How is this obvious? How do we know it wasn’t given out of malice and in an attempt to humiliate the recipient?

You found it funny. The OP did not and she’s entitled to say something if only so that there is no repeat next year.

Dottybackorcid · 30/12/2021 08:54

@Brieandcamembert

Gosh, it would make me wonder who I worked with if someone finds colouring in swear words funny. That is low intelligence to find that sort of thing appealing or funny.
Actually Albert Einstein attributed his brilliant mind to having a child-like sense of humour. I also wonder about people who I work with who claim to be better and more intelligent than the rest of us because they lack the ability to see humour in other things and look down on others as though they are some thing special 🥱.
Brieandcamembert · 30/12/2021 08:36

Gosh, it would make me wonder who I worked with if someone finds colouring in swear words funny. That is low intelligence to find that sort of thing appealing or funny.

Dottybackorcid · 30/12/2021 08:31

Well I work in an professional environment and got the very same book last year 🧑‍🎄. I personally found it funny and gave it my DH.

It was obviously given in the spirit of a bit of fun, no matter how many perl clutchers are here on MN.

As for all the people saying go to HR I'd suggest take that huge stick out of your arse. There is no better way to exclude yourself from your team and gaming a grudge down this path, especially if the OP swears alot anyway. Just recycle and forget if you don't like it.