Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should be able to afford 2 kids?

160 replies

bookofthewitch · 29/12/2021 05:42

H and I both work as teachers. Me currently part time after DD born 18mo ago.

We have always done everything 'sensibly', have reasonably cheap for the area mortgage and various other unavoidable payments for bills etc. Old phones on cheap contracts.

No childminder option near us and I would have chosen nursery anyway, however this is very expensive so me working only leaves us 200 a month better off. It is what it is.

How the hell are we struggling so much each month to stay out of overdrafts when we've both always done everything ' right'?

AIBU to think that as professionals who have both always worked since teens, never even had credit cards or extravagant purchases, we should be able to afford one more child instead of panicking that it'll tip us into debt or just mean we have to worry about money and bills forever? We haven't had a holiday since 2017, have one cheap car that we own outright, I never buy new clothes and wear cheap make up, we are vegetarian so try to shop as cheaply as poss... it's infuriating!

I feel like my mother's and even my late 40s sister's generations never had to worry about this and could happily have as many kids as they want. Both were SAHM for a few years too! I could never as even that 200 a month makes a difference to us.

Any advice also welcome!

OP posts:
Neurodiversitydoctor · 29/12/2021 07:39

I should have said we are now finaicially comfortable and able to support our children through University it is worth it, just keep going.

TheUsualChaos · 29/12/2021 07:38

How much is your mortgage compared to your income? As on two good salaries with just one DC in childcare that does seem quick tight money wise especially when you describe you aren't big spenders on other things.
Are you both newish teachers? Therefore incomes projected to go up steadily over next few years? In which case things will improve hugely once DC in school.
I agree though, affording a basic standard of living when you need to pay for 3 Plus days childcare is week is very hard unless you have above average income. This is the main reason why we had to wait to try for DC2, then DC1 was at school by the time I finished mat leave so only ever had one in child care at a time.

ManicPixie · 29/12/2021 07:38

them, dare

God this forum needs an edit function…

ManicPixie · 29/12/2021 07:37

Childcare in this country is broken. Society wants everyone to work but it also wants to financially cripple then to do so if they date have kids.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 29/12/2021 07:35

It's tough I guess I am your sisters age. In 2007 with 2 under 5, as a ft hospital doctor (registrar) I had £500 pm left after childcare and travel. That was with working anti-social hours night's, weekends etc.

Pysgodywibliwobli · 29/12/2021 07:31

I agree with pp - previous generations had it hard and made sacrifices.
However, it is still ridiculous that 2 working professionals living modestly cannot afford a second child. Something is wrong in our society.

Practically - I had second child when first turned 2. That meant I took the year off on mat leave ( so no childcare cost) and then when she restarted nursery we had 30 funded hours ( I worked pt) therefore only paying for child 2. That was the most cost effective way around nursery fees for us.

LakieLady · 29/12/2021 07:26

@Agadorsparticus

It's why we have a 4 year gap between mine. DC2 was born 2 days after DC1 started reception.
That's impeccable timing, @Agadorsparticus! I'm awestruck.

Childcare is hugely expensive, and imo should be subsidised from general taxation. But then I'm in favour of a high tax, good public services economy on the Scandinavian model, which will never happen here.

Wotsitsits · 29/12/2021 07:22
  1. The 30 free hours aren't free they are spread over the year so in practise it's effectively a % discount on the full time cost. Since your DC is part time this will be pro rata down, you will still pay but not as much.
  1. What is your monthly income and outgoings? No one can advise you without the detail. Are you putting away 000s in savings each month? Do you have savings? Start using them....!!

I have a few friends who moan about money and found out two of the couples have 15k and 50k in savings respectively. I lost all sympathy.

As pp have said, the big cost is the early years childcare. Budget accordingly. You will get through it. So what if you end up living frugally or with credit card debt or a personal loan. You can pay that back. You can't magic a DC out of thin air and have them not cost money.

You are better off staying in work because long term you protect your earning capability. If you stop it will be harder to start again and you will be more vulnerable as a family and as an individual should the worst happen.

Arrow03 · 29/12/2021 07:20

Do remember to factor in to your calculations that 30 hours free childcare isn't actually 30 hours of free childcare, especially at a nursery Round here a lot of nurseries only let you claim funded hours 9am-12pm and 1pm-4pm and you have to pay quite a lot of money for the hours outside of these times. It definitely took me by surprise!

StarfishDish · 29/12/2021 07:18

@bookofthewitch We're exactly the same. After the bills and essentials are paid for, we're left with £120 a month. Gas and electric are going up by £50 a month and nursery have announced they're raising fees too which will be an extra £50 a month.

Christmas was a 'second hand' Christmas for our daughter this year. She's only 10 months old so didn't need a lot. We cut right back on gifts for other people too. If people insisted on buying us a gift, we asked for vouchers to a restaurant so we could enjoy a meal out which is what we got.

We aren't entitled to funding until our daughter is three but we're focusing on when that happens, everything we'll be able to do Smile

Lastdaysofdecember · 29/12/2021 07:17

I don’t know how old you are, but if you’re in your thirties I think your mums generation was probably the last one who lived in the way you described, and I’m not sure that was always a good thing.

Nurseries weren’t as well regulated, childminders tended to be casual arrangements, and house prices weren’t as expensive.

Working on the assumption you’re both UPS3 do you earn around 65 between you?

You do get 30 free hours when your eldest is three so timing it so you have this gap between children is probably best? People do like to reminisce but I think the reality is for most people money is tight with pre school children.

Fairyliz · 29/12/2021 07:16

My grandma had her children in the 1930’s and sometimes didn’t eat so that her children could.
My mum had her children in the 60’s and worked evenings and we didn’t have central heating.
I had my children in the 90’s and DH worked Monday to Friday and I worked Saturday and Sunday and some evenings so no childcare costs.
Where have you got the idea that previous generations had it easier?

yoyo1234 · 29/12/2021 07:13

You say you work part time and that brings in £200/mth, what if you increase to full time?

Joystir59 · 29/12/2021 07:10

Why would you consider another if it will mean financial hardship for your current family? Just stick to one, be able to provide well for her. You ought to be thinking about enriching her life with family holidays. What if she wants to pursue a skill or talent that requires funds?

onedayoranother · 29/12/2021 07:09

After my second I calculated I would be paying to work. Luckily my husband was a high earner (managing partner in a City law firm), so we could afford for me to give up work. But even on his high salary after five years we could not have afforded to buy our house again - we bought from two teachers and I eventually sold to a banker. I have no idea who could afford that house now. We also only went abroad every other year and had second hand cars. You make sacrifices in your choices in order to afford what you prioritise. I don't know how my kids will manage it - neither have picked particularly well paying occupations.

Hothammock · 29/12/2021 07:09

Pre school is just the most expensive phase and it is really tough. As others have said, if you don't have any free support from friends or family you might be best to space out your second child for when your first is in full time school. Remember also that the first year of school can be a bit stop start - some schools take ages to phase them in the first term, some run breakfast clubs and after school clubs but others don't. You might find it helpful to get a local childminder lined up for your first who will also be able to take your second at a younger age. This could make it simpler for you to coordinate pick ups and drop offs when you return to work and make it possible to return full time.
We had to accept using more childcare for our second than we did for our first. Taking the full maternity leave helps too although there is little pay for much of it of course!

Ponoka7 · 29/12/2021 07:03

Previous generations lived without a minimum wage and regulated childcare, which is why so many women were SAHMs. How far do you think 50p an hour went? (80's). I can remember my friend who worked in care earning 67p an hour. You are spending your money on something, housing, heating etc. I grew up in the 60/70's and when posters on here talk about ice on the inside of their bedroom window, they aren't exaggerating. People gathered in one room because you could only heat one room.
You don't want another child until you can give them a 'good life' what defines a good life? Did previous generations have that? It's a matter of waiting and using the free hours.

TinyLittlePandaSneeze · 29/12/2021 07:03

Ah saw you'd looked at that. Just remember that half the childcare cost should come from your partners salary too (or some people split proportionate to income) so that might help how you view your job.

TinyLittlePandaSneeze · 29/12/2021 06:58

Would it be better for you to go full time once you youngest gets some funded hours? It's tricky to do the maths!

PlugUgly1980 · 29/12/2021 06:55

Our are 6 and 7 now, the years when they were both in nursery full time (from 1 until they started school) crippled us...our nursery bill was double our mortgage repayments at one point until the funding kicked in. I remember my BIL helpfully saying when we announced we were expecting our second that we should increase our childcare voucher contributions at work to cover the extra nursery costs...completely clueless as we were already max'd out at that point! We had £20 each a month left from our salaries after all bills paid each month, if we were lucky. But it gets so much better when they start school. My childcare bill is only £46 a week for 2 in after school club 3 nights a week. Coupled with DH and I both having worked our way up and being promoted during the last few years, we're in a much better financial position. We're still careful with money and by no means extravagant, but we don't worry and make significant over payments on our mortgage for instance. Continuing to work full time also meant we have been able to keep making contributions to our pensions which is an investment for the longer term.

Eileen101 · 29/12/2021 06:54

But as a pp has said - definitely try and look at it as investment. I see my working as being a positive influence on my children, as well as contributing to my pension, keeping my professional certification, CPD, experience etc.

Eileen101 · 29/12/2021 06:52

Yanbu, it's hard in the early years..
We also have 2 professional salaries, mine is 4 days, DH 5 days. We have 2 in nursery for 3 days per week - one with a funded place (that we top up about £250 per month, one without a funded place. Even paying through the tax free childcare scheme, we pay £850 per month.

Childcare is so expensive. It was only when we had a child in nursery that I truly understood why people say that they can't afford to work.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 29/12/2021 06:42

I sympathise. My youngest is 10 now, but the 2 years we had 2 in nursery for 3 days a week, cost us about my salary per month. Also no holidays. Very fortunately, my car comes with my job. We were able to switch to an interest only mortgage for a short time, and have overpaid repayments since youngest dc started school to compensate.

Look at childcare costs as an Investment in your financial/professional future, rather than a daily overhead to be paid out of income. If you stay in work, over the long term, your salary should only go up, and your childcare costs should only go down. Could you get a loan to help with childcare for now? I realise this this very trite

MaverickSnoopy · 29/12/2021 06:42

I think really the trick is to have them very close together and not work or to wait until the first is at school and spread the cost that way.

We have 3 children - 3, 5, 10. Nursery for the first while we both worked full time. Then I went part time with our second and found a part time job (term time 3 days a week) and paid a Childminder. Then when we had our third I became a Childminder myself (part time). I dont make a huge amount but it's more than I would make working full time employed after childcare (even with 2 children). We found that it wasn't just money, but time that we lost the more children we had. I don't mean in the obvious way - things like illness and time off work when you don't have a support network. Fine if you are lucky and no one gets ill but we have someone ill a couple of times a month. Really very hard and I know others with no support network who say the same.

bookofthewitch · 29/12/2021 06:26

@Overthebow

It’s expensive for a few years but at 3 you get the free childcare hours. Maybe plan a second child for that time? Would you be better off working full time?

Also are you claiming the tax free childcare? That has made quite a big difference to my childcare affordability.

We are claiming the tax free childcare now which has helped a lot. I would definitely not want a second until she's 3 and gets her free hours, but we work such long days that that would only cover 3 days so it wouldn't really be worth me going back full time although would massively ease the pressure.

Like above posters, we also have no practical family support, financially or with childcare, so I'm very aware that we need to be able to make it work long term.

That sounds hopeful though that it improves once they're at school. Maybe we just need a 5-year plan or similar, would be helpful if we knew what would happen with energy prices etc as I am very anxious about this.

OP posts: