Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should be able to afford 2 kids?

160 replies

bookofthewitch · 29/12/2021 05:42

H and I both work as teachers. Me currently part time after DD born 18mo ago.

We have always done everything 'sensibly', have reasonably cheap for the area mortgage and various other unavoidable payments for bills etc. Old phones on cheap contracts.

No childminder option near us and I would have chosen nursery anyway, however this is very expensive so me working only leaves us 200 a month better off. It is what it is.

How the hell are we struggling so much each month to stay out of overdrafts when we've both always done everything ' right'?

AIBU to think that as professionals who have both always worked since teens, never even had credit cards or extravagant purchases, we should be able to afford one more child instead of panicking that it'll tip us into debt or just mean we have to worry about money and bills forever? We haven't had a holiday since 2017, have one cheap car that we own outright, I never buy new clothes and wear cheap make up, we are vegetarian so try to shop as cheaply as poss... it's infuriating!

I feel like my mother's and even my late 40s sister's generations never had to worry about this and could happily have as many kids as they want. Both were SAHM for a few years too! I could never as even that 200 a month makes a difference to us.

Any advice also welcome!

OP posts:
forcedfun · 29/12/2021 08:20

I would try and draw up a battle plan, to maximise what you can both earn with as little childcare as possible
For instance, teachers I know do things like

  • tutoring (evenings/holidays /weekends)
  • exam marking.
  • working at holiday camps in the holidays

Most people I know (whatever their profession) find ways to work around each other while children are young so that they can keep nursery costs down and salaries up.

Dizzyhedgehog · 29/12/2021 08:18

DH and I are also both teachers. We moved abroad. So much easier. Childcare is much, much cheaper, child benefit is higher, we have more paid child sick days we can take and we earn more in general.
So, going through IVF at the moment. If we had twins, it wouldn't be a problem in terms of finances. We'd even be able to put all three through private school without having too much of an issue.
It was much more of a struggle with one in the UK. What helped was that DS's nursery was run by teachers. We had good term-time only contracts and were both able to go part time (0.8) to have him in nursery 3 days a week.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 29/12/2021 08:17

I know you say you have a cheap mortgage "for the area" but is that £500 or £1,300? It makes a big difference.

Our mortgage is about £750 a month and we'd struggle to afford number 2 even if we wanted one.

2reefsin30knots · 29/12/2021 08:16

@bookofthewitch could one of you work in a boarding school that has staff housing? They are not as easy to come by as they used to be, but they are still around.

DH and I are both teachers (maybe 15 years older than you by the sounds of it). We are both senior now so on reasonable salaries. However, DH has almost always worked in boarding schools and that is what has made the biggest difference to our financial position. We do have our own house too which we rent out.

venusmay · 29/12/2021 08:14

I hear you. I think costs are going up too, petrol, gas, electricity and food. It's really expensive to live and then childcare has always been expensive. I think now my dcs are older I spend a lot on activities .

Bitofachinwag · 29/12/2021 08:12

I think your definition of "giving my children a decent life" is probably different to previous generations ' definition!

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 29/12/2021 08:12

I could have written your post when DC1 was the same age as your DC.
In the end, I adopted the "investment mindset" and surrendered to the fact that we would need to take on some debt for a few years in order to afford nursery fees for a second child, as well as a year of maternity leave. It felt counterintuitive as we had never owed a penny between us apart from a sensibly modest mortgage.

We arranged a 6 month mortgage holiday while I was still working and pregnant, and saved this money to cover costs while I was on maternity leave. We had been making overpayments on our mortgage, and our lender allowed us to use our pot of overpayments to pay the monthly mortgage payments while I was on maternity leave.
DC1 stayed at nursery for the bare minimum hours while I was on maternity leave in order to stay with their friendship group for a year before starting Reception and participate in the transition to school process. This was supposed to be the "free hours for 3 year olds" but our nursery's charging structure meant there was still a fee paying element, so we had to take this on as debt; we were a few hundred short each month. We gritted our teeth and put it on a low interest card for a year. It wasn't ideal and once I went back to work we were in a pickle as we were not quite breaking even when DC1 started Reception and DC2 started nursery and had to attend for enough hours to enable us to go to work. It took us until DC2 started Reception to clear the "nursery card", and it had been such a pain to keep switching deals (3 times in all). Possibly not the best way to do it, but it got the job done.
Both DP and I worked extra periodically in fields unrelated to our professional roles throughout this time in order to top up funds for things like Christmas (without being outing, think skills aquired prior to current careers such as book keeping or hair dressing etc which could be done "out of hours", although as a teacher, you'll appreciate how mad that is as we're always working!). A bit irritating sorting out tax and insurance for small additional income streams, but a necessary temporary solution for us.
Good luck, OP. Work out a 5 year plan, borrow if necessary, and all being well, and with no unforeseen expenses or adverse life events, you should be out of the woods soon after DC2 starts school.

Ohdoleavemealone · 29/12/2021 08:09

Timing is every thing here. Our second arrived the year before our eldest started school. So whilst I was on Maternity, we just used the free hours and then he went to school and we just had to pay the fees for our youngest. I was part time until she started school.

Darbs76 · 29/12/2021 08:08

It’s difficult when you’re paying childcare costs but it’s not forever. Mine are 13 & 17 now so childcare is all but a distant memory. We spent a fortune on it though. Best thing to do is write down all income & outgoings and sort out how much you should have spare, then stick to your budget. I move £450 a month into Tesco bank which I use for my shopping, and move the money for any later DD’s / bills to another account and move across as bills come out. I save £250 a month for Christmas, birthday and car tax / MOT / tyres etc. if I didn’t do all above I’d just fritter it away. Also forgot to say I move x amount into savings on payday, not just what’s left or as above be very little going into that

bonetiredwithtwins · 29/12/2021 08:06

Childminders are half the cost of nursery in my area - we couldn't afford our twins otherwise. The twins and an older child in before/after school the cost is around £2k a month on a "bad" month

Use term time only contracts with childcare (but if you are teachers maybe you already are)

Work full time

When we knew we were having twins we took out a £25k 10 year loan - this will be used to pay for childcare until 30 hours kicked in and the repayments are only £300 per month

1 car

No holidays

TinyLittlePandaSneeze · 29/12/2021 08:04

@Beachbabe1

Yet people on benefits and not working can pop them out one after the other!
The biology of having children is not linked to money or benefits or anything like that.

And no one "pops" out a child.

Figgygal · 29/12/2021 08:04

Ive no clue how people do it
We have a 4 year gap with our two and second has just started school in September its been a long 10 years and despite earning more now than ever still feel like have no money (bloody mortgage)

rrhuth · 29/12/2021 08:03

Plus derailing every discussion about working people with the same repetitive comments about benefits is really boring.

The op has raised an interesting and relevant topic that applies to lots of people I think, and one that is going to apply to more of us through the next year or so.

girlmom21 · 29/12/2021 08:02

If you want another child and you're currently struggling to afford the cost of living you need to earn more or quit work completely and live even more modestly on one salary. That's the simplicity of it.

We'll have two in full time nursery in a few months (can't get older ones 30 hours until September) but we'll both be working full time. Yes the days are long but it makes better financial and long term career sense.

Lastdaysofdecember · 29/12/2021 07:59

@Beachbabe1

Yet people on benefits and not working can pop them out one after the other!
No, they can’t. Benefits are capped at two children and have been for nearly five years.
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 29/12/2021 07:58

Quite simply I had to get a pay rise between my first and second to survive, (not an option for everyone) and it’s still so hard!
I also don’t buy the idea that kids get cheaper after the preschool child care years/ school have endless holidays and run 9-3- you still have a childcare bill, plus more expensive holidays, uniform to buy etc- perhaps OP you are realising you may only afford 1 child.

rrhuth · 29/12/2021 07:57

It warned that in April the introduction of tax changes, with a new price cap on energy bills, will cost families £1,200 overnight.

From today's article here: www.theguardian.com/money/2021/dec/29/uk-households-warned-of-year-of-the-squeeze-as-cost-of-living-soars

ThirdElephant · 29/12/2021 07:55

We went for a nanny, OP. Worked out cheaper once we had two kids.

rrhuth · 29/12/2021 07:54

@Beachbabe1

Yet people on benefits and not working can pop them out one after the other!
Oh do give over Biscuit
rrhuth · 29/12/2021 07:54

How the hell are we struggling so much each month to stay out of overdrafts when we've both always done everything ' right'?

This is a question so many people are asking now. Many people who work at the lower end of the earning scale are in poverty FFS! Teachers and nurses can not afford to buy homes.

The system is broken - a society is dysfunctional if regular jobs do not allow for regular lives. Cost of living is going to worsen and many of us are in for a shitty time.

@bookofthewitch I sympathise Brew but have no answers other than cut outgoings or increase incomings!

Beachbabe1 · 29/12/2021 07:51

Yet people on benefits and not working can pop them out one after the other!

DeepaBeesKit · 29/12/2021 07:50

So I’m not sure it’s quite as bleak as the OP paints.

I'm not either. Dsis and dbil have two kids, they teach and teaching wages cover more than childcare so OP would always be better off working full time, for one. Teachers can save a lot by choosing a nursery offering term time only - especially common from age 3. I suspect OP hasnt realised with 30 hours and a term time place at 3 her childcare bill will be peanuts.

DeepaBeesKit · 29/12/2021 07:47

How most people manage it:

  • save before starting on kids. If you can manage now bringing in only 200 a month after childcare, you could have saved easily a grand a month before having kids.
  • work full time. The huge childcare bill doesnt last forever then when they are at school your career hasnt suffered and you suddenly have plenty of money.
  • have one parent quit a 9-5 but work evenings/weekends/nights to reduce childcare costs
  • rely heavily on family childcare
  • have one SAHP and depend on benefit top ups
  • wait to have children until earnings are higher
Lastdaysofdecember · 29/12/2021 07:47

However, it is still ridiculous that 2 working professionals living modestly cannot afford a second child

Well, this does depend on a myriad of factors. I’m assuming UPS3. I’m on UPS3, and that’s £2,376 take home pay. The OP is part time so I’ll halve that and round up to £1200. So rounding the DHs salary and halving the OPs leaves us with £3,550.

Let’s say DC is in nursery for three days and this will vary according to where they live but my nursery charges £55 a day so I’ll use that as my baseline. So let’s call that £700 a month - less 20% - that’s 640 but I’m rounding up not down, so £650.

That leaves £2900 - that’s to pay the mortgage and bills which can’t be THAT much, given old phones, own car outright, etc.

OP and her DH may not be on UPS3 of course but even M1 (lowest pay scale) is £25,717. I’m not sure what that is after tax and pension contributions and I do see that would be tight but then it goes up.

So I’m not sure it’s quite as bleak as the OP paints. If they do have a joint income of around £3500 a month then I do think they could afford a second child.

AutumnAnn · 29/12/2021 07:42

Can you change your work hours to save some childcare costs?
Me and my partner both work, but around each other so one of us is always home with the kids and we have no childcare costs, he will work 4 days a week, i will work 1 or 2 days a week in between his days off.