Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should be able to afford 2 kids?

160 replies

bookofthewitch · 29/12/2021 05:42

H and I both work as teachers. Me currently part time after DD born 18mo ago.

We have always done everything 'sensibly', have reasonably cheap for the area mortgage and various other unavoidable payments for bills etc. Old phones on cheap contracts.

No childminder option near us and I would have chosen nursery anyway, however this is very expensive so me working only leaves us 200 a month better off. It is what it is.

How the hell are we struggling so much each month to stay out of overdrafts when we've both always done everything ' right'?

AIBU to think that as professionals who have both always worked since teens, never even had credit cards or extravagant purchases, we should be able to afford one more child instead of panicking that it'll tip us into debt or just mean we have to worry about money and bills forever? We haven't had a holiday since 2017, have one cheap car that we own outright, I never buy new clothes and wear cheap make up, we are vegetarian so try to shop as cheaply as poss... it's infuriating!

I feel like my mother's and even my late 40s sister's generations never had to worry about this and could happily have as many kids as they want. Both were SAHM for a few years too! I could never as even that 200 a month makes a difference to us.

Any advice also welcome!

OP posts:
CottonSock · 29/12/2021 10:28

Part of the reason we have a 3 year age gap

2reefsin30knots · 29/12/2021 10:26

@ThanksItHasPockets I agree for primary and I certainly found that already being SLT and very experienced in a difficult-to-recruit niche made it much easier for me when DS came along. When he was ks1 age I worked 0.9 and finished at 2.30pm each day so I could do pick up. I couldn’t have done that as a CT.

However, in 13-18 our observation is that the Head just doesn’t get school holidays anymore. It’s bad enough at DH level, but at least there is the expectation that you will be out of contact some of the time. Not so for the Head. My DH may look at that again once DS has left home.

LowlandLucky · 29/12/2021 10:09

bookofthewitch As a parent of the 80s i could afford to have as many children as i liked because i stayed at home, so no childcare costs. Life was very different back then, i could go a week without opening my purse now people constantly spend. We paid our t.v licence annually and our phone bill came in every quarter. Now it we have many more bills,take my DSD she and her husband have contract phones that cost £40 a month each, Sky, Netflix, Disneyplus , Amazon prime and Boadband , they spend more on communication and viewing a month than i do on food in a quarter. DSD is not unusual many household spend such amounts every month on the samething. So many families can't seem to go a day without nipping into a shop for a "top up shop" . Lunch or a coffee on the way to work and takeaways all add up, these are things we rarely did, now it is the norm. Back then we '"treated" ourselves once in a blue moon now treats are an everyday occurrence.
Back then the world demanded equality for women and the right for them to work because seemingly being at home with your children was the worst thing in the world, well women went to work children went into daycare and these new problems began. Once a couple were both working they could bid a bit more on a house they wanted, those that were selling houses thought this was a great idea and asked a higher price and the problem just got bigger and bigger until we got to this. Today most couples are struggling to pay rent/mortgage and childcare and most Mum's are doing 2 jobs, one outside the home and the majority of household tasks. Progress is not always wonderful.

canary1 · 29/12/2021 10:08

I agree with you OP- it shouldn’t be this hard. A professional couple like yourselves a generation or two ago would be living an easier life than you describe.

ThanksItHasPockets · 29/12/2021 10:07

@2reefsin30knots

I agree with *@Phineyj* that at least one of you needs to be career orientated if you want to make a decent living as teachers. My DH has stopped at Deputy (for now) as being a Head would be too detrimental to family life. However, up until this job we have moved every 3-4 years or so for him to take good promotions. For this job, we looked for the best possible lifestyle package (good family house without rent, hefty discount on school fees 3-18).

That said, we only have one DC through choice. We could manage two, but we wouldn’t be able to give them as many opportunities or as much support with things like university later on.

I imagine it's different for primary but DH and I have found that he has never had so much flexibility in his schedule since he became a headteacher a few years ago. HTs rarely teach, or at least very little, and he has control of his schedule in a way that I never have up to the level of AHT.

I do agree with the teacher pp who say that you need to start thinking a bit more strategically. Are you both on UPS? If not and if you are eligible you need to start preparing an application for next year. One of you needs to get yourself on a promotion track. You need to consider increasing your hours to full-time in advance of your next maternity leave to ensure that you maximise your maternity pay. Or, of course, you can begin to consider your family complete with one child. Many people make this very valid choice.

Porcupineintherough · 29/12/2021 10:05

Well what happened in my mum's generation was typically that the woman didnt work until the kids were all at school, kids walking themselves to school at 5 (so no prob with mum getting to work on time), and latch key kids to save on childcare costs. You could try that I guess.

Or wait til your eldest is 3 or 4 and more free childcare starts kicking in.

Martha8 · 29/12/2021 10:01

@GrendelsGrandma

Yanbu, it's ludicrous. I think a large part of the rise in anxiety is this financial kneecapping where you limp from student loan to just about managing to buy a house in your 30s then having a window of about 4 years to sprog before the fertility window closes, during which time you're supposed to somehow make progress at work in order for any of it to be affordable.

We should be demanding free/cheap childcare provided by the state imho.

However, I do think you have rose tinted specs about the realities of life in former generations, plenty of families lived in two rooms with no heating, kids slept tip to toe in a shared bed, struggled to buy shoes etc. As a schoolteacher you would have been sacked on marriage and expected to spend the rest of your life peeling potatoes and doing laundry without a washing machine.

I think part of the problem is the mass of boomers, funding and policies are skewed to them and politicians are not doing much to woo younger voters who want family friendly policies.

Lumping everyone together born between 1946 and 1964 and calling them "boomers" is absolutely stupid.
JennetHumfrye · 29/12/2021 10:00

Yanbu OP. This is exactly what had swayed the decision that we won't have any more children. We have DS who is 4 and up until he finished nursery, we really struggled financially. I just can't face going through the nursery fees again.

As things stand now, we can afford to take DS on holidays and make sure we can afford to run a home comfortably. Another child would definitely be unaffordable for us, as much as I really want one.

converseandjeans · 29/12/2021 09:58

We're both teachers & DH had retrained and was NQT when DD was born & it was extremely tight for the first 5 or so years (the free funding wasn't really there for childcare). I was PT but my school used to get me in for say 4 days for 0.5 so that meant childcare spread over the week.

We ended up with small gap of 18 months too - I only had 4 months off with DD then 6 months off with DS.

So what we did to manage was

  • short maternity leaves
  • childminder instead of nursery
  • camping holidays/YHA
  • never going out for food/drink & take picnics on days out
  • old cars
  • small budget for birthday & Christmas
  • ask for useful things as gifts like PJs (they now like this sort of thing)
  • have passes to things so you can have free days out once you have the pass

We have survived and things are better now they're older. Ours never ask for much. We're not poor compared to many & they know this. We just can't afford holidays abroad or meals out.

Phineyj · 29/12/2021 09:55

Term time deals leave you no time to work though - marking hundreds of pieces of coursework in the evening if your DC gets up at dawn is no picnic! Ask me how I know Hmm

2reefsin30knots · 29/12/2021 09:54

I agree with @Phineyj that at least one of you needs to be career orientated if you want to make a decent living as teachers. My DH has stopped at Deputy (for now) as being a Head would be too detrimental to family life. However, up until this job we have moved every 3-4 years or so for him to take good promotions. For this job, we looked for the best possible lifestyle package (good family house without rent, hefty discount on school fees 3-18).

That said, we only have one DC through choice. We could manage two, but we wouldn’t be able to give them as many opportunities or as much support with things like university later on.

Phineyj · 29/12/2021 09:53

Another thing to consider - I've worked various contracts since I had DC (0.5 up to FT) but have never done all full days. For many years now I've done 0.6 over 4 days. This helps the school out as it means I can teach a whole A level subject and it helps with wrap around childcare as I can arrive 'late' one day and leave 'early' on a couple of others (compared to FT colleagues - I don't get paid for those times).

So worth thinking ahead to primary years as they're more fiddly than nursery.

DH has also worked flexibly - he doesn't leave it all.to me.

maddening · 29/12/2021 09:29

If.ypu are a teacher.also you can often get tern time only deals at nurseries, which save the childcare being spent in thr holidays

maddening · 29/12/2021 09:28

Time your second so you go on mat leave the September before your dc goes go Primary school, so you save a year in childcare being on mat leave and take a year so you return as dc1 goes to school and remain with 1 set of childcare bills?

Phineyj · 29/12/2021 09:20

Hi OP, I am also a teacher. It sounds like you live fairly frugally. Your only option therefore is for one or both of you to earn more after childcare, if you'd benefit from more coming in. You say maybe you should make a 5 year plan. Yes, definitely! I made a 10 year plan when I entered teaching and had a DC in a short space of time. I looked up all the pay scales and salaries and realised that I would greatly benefit from stopping working in the home counties (on main scale) and instead working in inner London and getting onto UPS. So that's what I did, but gradually over 10 years and with a couple of job moves. Much easier to negotiate a raise when they want to get you, than to do it in post.

The good thing about teaching is the info on salaries is quite transparent.

Others have mentioned working overseas and in the independent sector, and in boarding, which are all worth considering.

I also freelance sometimes - exam marking and resource writing, plus I have a niche extra responsibility in school. But mainly it's been changing job strategically that's helped, and planning ahead. And reading the pay policy!

If you are paying for full time nursery, use the days that nursery's open but your school(s) aren't to get ahead on work, research new jobs and look for extra paid work.

I had another career before teaching. A lot of teachers don't really think strategically so if you can, it'll help a lot.

mdh2020 · 29/12/2021 09:18

Having children has always been a difficult choice. When ours were small we couldn’t afford holidays and we couldn’t always afford to get our old banger fixed and sometimes it was off the road. I made most of our clothes and the others came from charity shops. All baby equipment was secondhand. At one stage my DH had a Saturday job so I hardly ever saw him and I used to do childminding for friends. However none of these sob stories will make life any easier for you. I’m afraid teachers’ pay was never appropriate for the work they do. to add to your woes, the papers this morning are saying that families need to find £1200 this year to cover the rise in energy and tax bills.

yikesanotherbooboo · 29/12/2021 09:17

Childcare has always been expensive; quite rightly in some ways but housing costs are the killer.Most people are relying on two incomes for that whereas when my DC were young we could live off DH's salary albeit, being very frugal with living costs . When I went back to work after 2 DC in close succession my salary covered childcare and I expected that.It gets easier . One thing I would say is that DC don't need things, holidays, clubs etc. That is a very recent concept, they are happy being loved and particularly in those first few years any extras can be waited for without any harm.

FreeFrenchHens · 29/12/2021 09:16

@WulyJmpr

My son is 3, full time at nursery. As the 30 free hours is only school term time 38 weeks of the year it is effectively only a 33% reduction in cost. I was hoping it would be more like a 50% drop :(
It does seem to be so variable in how it's applied. We saved a lot more than that. I think we were lucky to have a nursery that calculated it generously and was flexible on hours, so we could save a few hours by picking DC up earlier some days etc.
Indecisivelurcher · 29/12/2021 09:15

Mine are 4 & 7 and it is easier now they're both in school. The 30 free hours was such a help. Just a word of caution though if you're thinking that when they're at school, you'll up your hours. It might not be so straightforward. Mine want to come home after school, not go to after school club. They're tired. So I knock off at 3pm every day to pick up.

If you want two children and can get through the early childcare stage then I think you'll manage. You've got most of the 'stuff' already. Just think about timing for the 30hrs to kick in.

SarahBellam · 29/12/2021 09:15

You can afford to have two children, but you need to think long term rather than short term. The cost of childcare is crippling now, but that eases significantly once they turn 3 and by the time both are at school you are only paying for wrap around care if needed. As they get older childcare costs reduce further and by the time they are at secondary school they are very small. In your shoes I would go for planned debt now and do a bit of juggling. If you are off on maternity leave with a second, that will significantly reduce childcare costs for the first as you can do much of the childcare. What I would say, is keep your career - you will both progress and perhaps take on leadership roles with more money and that will ease things further. Many parents would agree that it can be a fairly hairy few years but you will get through it, and it is worth it.

LakieLady · 29/12/2021 09:15

Would you consider a child minder instead of a nursery, OP?

When my friend worked out that going back to work would make her £50pw worse off, she found a lovely child minder and it was a hell of a lot cheaper.

She then realised that if she dropped her hours and worked only 3 days pw, she'd be below the threshold for repaying her student loan and everything became a lot more viable. She went back to f/t hours when she got the 30 hours free childcare.

Frazzled2207 · 29/12/2021 09:13

I sympathise op it is hard. I have a salary similar to a teacher’s.

I have lots of friends who waited 4/5 years before having their second for childcare cost reasons. In my opinion it just prolongs the agony. We had two 21 months apart and they were in nursery for a while which was staggering then I got made redundant which in hindsight was a good thing. I pretty much gave up work for 4 years but was self employed with a low income. Financially it was tough but practically it worked. Now however they are 6 and 8 I’ve gone back to working almost ft and don’t pay for much childcare these days.

As teachers you won’t need much childcare in the hols especially as they get older which will will be a significant help.

Having two close in age makes it easier on a lot of levels and is not double the cost. They share clothes, toys and a room. They also entertain each other. Granted I’m lucky that they are the same gender and get on.

mizu · 29/12/2021 09:10

It's hard, isn't it. I had two DDs fairly close together and when they were both in nursery ( and this was a while ago, they are 17 and nearly 16 now) I was part time teaching in FE (still am) and pretty much my entire 0.5 salary of around £10,000 was on nursery fees.

My DH's salary wasn't very high at this point too and we were always in overdraft. It was tough and we struggled a lot financially.

Thing is, my job is like gold dust around here and there was no way I was able to leave and then find the same job again. And I wanted to work too.

Gets much easier when they get to 3 years old.

Agree that as school teachers, you shouldn't have to feel you are struggling, ridiculous!

ThanksItHasPockets · 29/12/2021 09:10

@ArthurTudor

Where are all these term time only nurseries? There aren't any where I live. Only state pre schools which run 9 to 3, which is no use to teachers.

My youngest child is in a 51 weeks a year nursery despite me being a teacher as I can't find a term time only nursery with long enough hours during term time.

My children have term-time places with childminders now but my eldest initially went to nursery, and we looked at lots before making ohr choice. None of them advertised term-time places but all were prepared to offer them if you asked. This included some of the bigger groups like Asquith / Bright Horizons / Busy Bees as well as small, independent businesses.
LakieLady · 29/12/2021 09:09

@Beachbabe1

Yet people on benefits and not working can pop them out one after the other!
I wondered how long it would be before the first benefit basher popped up. That was pretty quick considering the thread was started very early in the morning.

We should start betting on the timing for posts like this.