Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Getting annoyed at virtue signalling on Facebook local groups

491 replies

Floogal · 28/12/2021 23:13

Ignoring the fussing questions everytime a police helicopter is on patrol or fireworks. Where I live it's usually the same thing. Always along the lines of;

" I've got a lot of old tat but want to donate it to charity"
" I brought the homeless guy on the high street a coffee and had a chat with him"
And, this " how many homeless people are there in town? My (photogenic well dressed) twin daughters want to give out Xmas packages" obviously hoping to appear on the local news or "and finally...' on ITV news. Usually the 'ooooh aren't you wonderful' gushing replies. Gives me the raging arsehole.

OP posts:
CharityDingle · 30/12/2021 08:43

Rolling up on 25 December to hand out bread rolls while taking photos of yourself before swanning off to post about it on Facebook is not helpful. When I see it on Facebook I always want to click the angry face reaction and ask where they plan to be the other 364 days of the year.

@DifferentHair very well said, great post. I just quoted one piece there. I mentioned upthread someone locally who was going to make sandwiches, a day or so before Christmas Eve, but 'couldn't bring them into town teehee, small kids' and so on. And subsequently made a snide comment that the people she apparently offered them to, 'seemed to have plenty'.

The people she offered them to, work, on a voluntary basis all year round helping homeless people with food, clothing and basic necessities. They start gathering stuff together for Christmas, months beforehand, while still providing the everyday support and necessities.

Ugh, she really annoyed me.

Offmyfence · 30/12/2021 08:06

[quote DifferentHair]@Flyingbymypants the problem with this, and so much of the other Facebook posturing, is the complete lack of respect for the privacy or dignity of the person you're saying you are 'helping'.

I absolutely hate it. It's dehumanising IMO.

People in poverty deserve respect and privacy the same as anyone else. They're not in a zoo for people to visit when they need to feel good about themselves.

Also - Having managed charities in my time - PSA- swanning in at Christmas for one day of volunteering is very rarely helpful. By the time you've been given equipment, told where things are, what the rules are, where the loo is- you've wasted otherwise productive time for the organisation and you won't be qualified to do anything critical anyway.

Regular volunteers are the lifeblood, people who come regularly over long periods of time. People who are worth training because that experience stays with the organisation. People who will take time to respect and understand the culture and ethos of the organisation, and the bigger purpose.

Rolling up on 25 December to hand out bread rolls while taking photos of yourself before swanning off to post about it on Facebook is not helpful. When I see it on Facebook I always want to click the angry face reaction and ask where they plan to be the other 364 days of the year. [/quote]
Absolutely!! Well said!

DifferentHair · 30/12/2021 05:18

@Flyingbymypants the problem with this, and so much of the other Facebook posturing, is the complete lack of respect for the privacy or dignity of the person you're saying you are 'helping'.

I absolutely hate it. It's dehumanising IMO.

People in poverty deserve respect and privacy the same as anyone else. They're not in a zoo for people to visit when they need to feel good about themselves.

Also - Having managed charities in my time - PSA- swanning in at Christmas for one day of volunteering is very rarely helpful. By the time you've been given equipment, told where things are, what the rules are, where the loo is- you've wasted otherwise productive time for the organisation and you won't be qualified to do anything critical anyway.

Regular volunteers are the lifeblood, people who come regularly over long periods of time. People who are worth training because that experience stays with the organisation. People who will take time to respect and understand the culture and ethos of the organisation, and the bigger purpose.

Rolling up on 25 December to hand out bread rolls while taking photos of yourself before swanning off to post about it on Facebook is not helpful. When I see it on Facebook I always want to click the angry face reaction and ask where they plan to be the other 364 days of the year.

thaegumathteth · 30/12/2021 01:44

I've just remembered a few years ago someone posted on the school FB group 'does anyone know anything about this (pic of van) because it was parked outside the school at pick up time and a man was in it'

I replied 'yes, it was a dad, picking up his child'

I mean WTAF goes through peoples minds?

Flyingbymypants · 29/12/2021 23:53

Everyone on my local FB goes a bit nuts over the local big issue seller. Endless posts by people claiming to have the latest update on his personal circumstances. ' I spoke to him last week and he said he's had a bad few weeks'. Followed by 'Yes I spoke to him and there's been a problem with his benefit application '. It's like a competition between posters desperate to show they care the most about this poor chap. Just buy the magazine and be done with it.

WeDontTalkAboutBruno · 29/12/2021 23:23

We have two Dave photographers. Unfortunately neither are capable of snapping an image that isn’t out of focus or poorly composed. They announced today they are collaborating to launch a Christmas card next year and did anyone have any advice. I desperately wanted to say “night classes”.

PyongyangKipperbang · 29/12/2021 23:19

Oh and I should say that FB was split between "Good for you, go hun" and "She is a lying spiteful bitch who hated him cheating. You cant rape your wife anway" Hmm

PyongyangKipperbang · 29/12/2021 23:18

we have a local "Dave" the photographer in our village group. I am only still on the group because its handy when random 4 way temporary traffic lights go up with no notice (happens a lot).

I live just outside a town where the seedy arsehole MP lost his job for sexting constituents, his ex wife then got his job and has since proved he raped her. The FB groups went NUTS over that one! (Totally outing where I live!)

For a small market town in the midlands its been an interesting couple of years!

Gumbomambo · 29/12/2021 22:54

We have local filter lady and filter family. All glammed up to the max handing out some really awful crap tat to the local embarrassed “needies”. The glam fam are so filtered that a local wag commented on the picture (first) that they must be a new family as no one in our village looked like these wonder givers. It set the whole tone and Glam fam were furious that they didn’t get the “well done huns”.
Do something nice because you should not to make people think you are better than you are,it’s embarrassing. I work in a DV shelter and we have to be very very careful with this because we absolutely cannot risk any photos of our residents getting onto local FB pages. We provide lists of items on our website that we need and have loads of amazing people who quietly get on with helping and don’t make a song on dance for FB.

LittleRoundRobin · 29/12/2021 20:32

@LittleBearPad

God yes!

“They weren’t rich but they were happy”

Argh! Infant mortality was horrible, women couldn’t vote (most men couldn’t until 1867), there was little social security apart possibly from an old age pension designed to kick in after most people died, no indoor sanitation for most people and limited employment rights along other things!! Grrrr Hmm

That boils my piss too. All these romanticized ideas piss me off... Of pre mid 1900s being so lovely and cosy and romantic, and everybody was so happy and all the families were close and tight knit. This Waltons family bullshit is always peddled out, along with 'It's a wonderful life' and 'Meet me in St Louis.' BIG cosy families, with a lovely snuggly big house!

As you said, for most people , especially the working classes, life was tough, infant mortality was high, disease and famine was rife, hygiene and health & safety was almost non-existent, medical and dental care was very poor, people lived in cold houses, life expectancy was barely middle age for some, and women and girls had shag-all benefits in life. They couldn't vote, many were denied an education, and many were kept in penury.

I remember speaking to a few elderly women when I was in my 20s (1980s) and they were born between 1900 and 1910, and they and their mothers and grandmothers (born 1870s and 1850s) had anything but easy, carefree, happy lives.

They struggled financially, they had no money of their own, no job, no independence, no freedom to speak of, and they knew a number of women who had died in childbirth, and a number of women who had babies out of wedlock, and had the baby taken away from them as soon as the baby popped out.

The few women that did work, did hard, fast, sometimes brutal work, that left them physically exhausted, with bruises and blisters on their body/hands/feet. Many of them looked 10-15 years older than their age by the age of 35-40.

Not in a million fucking years would I want those days back. Covid is shit, and so are the Tories, but I will stay in this time period ta!

Offmyfence · 29/12/2021 18:50

@Whitefire

It's always white vans, isn't it? Because no one has every stolen something with a red/black/blue van

When I become a master criminal, I am going to have a red van, it was fool them because a) it is not white and b) it can be disguised as a postal van. Grin

Hmmm red, I'm going to go for blue, I mean blue could be sky blue, dark blue, navy blue, electric blue, they'd never find me!
Whitefire · 29/12/2021 18:43

It's always white vans, isn't it? Because no one has every stolen something with a red/black/blue van

When I become a master criminal, I am going to have a red van, it was fool them because a) it is not white and b) it can be disguised as a postal van. Grin

LittleBearPad · 29/12/2021 18:19

@Coniferhedge

I’m a member of a few local history pages, where people post photos of the area and how it used to look. As sure as night follows day you get people moaning saying ‘it’s not like the old days’, making thinly veiled racist remarks about immigration and refugees spoiling everything and how it’s always the Council’s fault because they’re all corrupt. On more than one occasion I’ve explained how virtually anyone can put themselves forward to become a councillor should they so wish, and if it’s all bribes, backhanders and stuffed brown envelopes, why don’t they have a go? Get on that gravy train, Malcolm!
God yes!

“They weren’t rich but they were happy”

Argh! Infant mortality was horrible, women couldn’t vote (most men couldn’t until 1867), there was little social security apart possibly from an old age pension designed to kick in after most people died, no indoor sanitation for most people and limited employment rights along other things!! Grrrr

Loveletters123 · 29/12/2021 18:13

@WorraLiberty

😂 made me laugh out loud!

ShaneTheThird · 29/12/2021 18:09

no arrests have been made

Grin
Cookie79 · 29/12/2021 18:07

Does people delighting us with their musical talents on the local FB pages count as virtue signaling?

I used to live in a village that had FB piano lady.

Have clearly gone up in the world as the place we relocated to has FB flute lady.

Coniferhedge · 29/12/2021 17:56

I’m a member of a few local history pages, where people post photos of the area and how it used to look. As sure as night follows day you get people moaning saying ‘it’s not like the old days’, making thinly veiled racist remarks about immigration and refugees spoiling everything and how it’s always the Council’s fault because they’re all corrupt. On more than one occasion I’ve explained how virtually anyone can put themselves forward to become a councillor should they so wish, and if it’s all bribes, backhanders and stuffed brown envelopes, why don’t they have a go? Get on that gravy train, Malcolm!

LittleBearPad · 29/12/2021 17:36

The admin dude said 'take this up with the business itself, at the time, or afterwards, do NOT name and shame on here like this. A business can be seriously damaged with this kind of witch hunt.'

God I’m on some FB groups for a certain handmade homeware designer - the number of complaints about tiny tiny imperfections and questions about what people should do. You don’t like it - send it back!

LittleRoundRobin · 29/12/2021 17:05

@CharityDingle

Yes, there's a very good admin person on a local page, who will not let posters badmouth local businesses like that. A recent thread was closed quick smart, with comments deleted - it could easily have become a witch hunt, just because some person was aggrieved with a business, when by the sound of it, she was the one in the wrong.

Ours is the same. They have deleted a few posts this past few weeks, and deleted/blocked the user, (with a temporary one month ban,) for trying to start a witch hunt against a local cafe or small local pub because their chips were lukewarm when they got their meal, (or their coke was warm!)

The admin dude said 'take this up with the business itself, at the time, or afterwards, do NOT name and shame on here like this. A business can be seriously damaged with this kind of witch hunt.'

I HATE this shit, and cannot stand fucking 'cancel culture!' Hmm

Offmyfence · 29/12/2021 16:57

Yes, there's a very good admin person on a local page, who will not let posters badmouth local businesses like that. A recent thread was closed quick smart, with comments deleted - it could easily have become a witch hunt, just because some person was aggrieved with a business, when by the sound of it, she was the one in the wrong.

The witch that runs our local Facebook group went on at the beginning of the pandemic absolutely slating a local firm for delaying her work. She was vile! She got her arsed handed to her on a plate. She after getting a load of very strong comments deleted the post. She then kept coming back over the next few days, saying I'm sorry .... followed by a but and then the reason why she was right. We then got the I'm a victim act and she took to her bed for three days as she was so upset, She then banned a load of people, so someone then opened up another group, for all the banned members. She decided they were bullying her by doing this and she was informing the police. No arrests have been made.

They moved her work by a couple of weeks because they had to isolate, they hadn't shot her mother. They in the end refused to do the work anyway.

Bumply · 29/12/2021 16:44

We do at least seem to have trained people not to include photo of the whole card they've found - think they left everything visible except the expiry date.

Having lost a card recently I just froze it and reported it as lost asap. I'd worry who had seen it and possibly taken down the details before the 'Good Samaritan' posted.

Someone else posted photos of car keys they'd found "I've left it in the wall at x and y street". She got so much grief from others saying every wannabe car thief was heading to that location to try their luck on all the cars in that vicinity that she had to go back and collect key and hand in to police.

CharityDingle · 29/12/2021 16:18

@cobblers123

A few posters on local sites have been hauled over the coals for posting complaints or telling people not to use or go to specifically named businesses.

It seems people post on FB without directly contacting the offending business/person which many posters thought was very unfair and told them so pointing out they could potentially harm someone's livelihood with just one aggrieved person's whinge.

Yes, there's a very good admin person on a local page, who will not let posters badmouth local businesses like that. A recent thread was closed quick smart, with comments deleted - it could easily have become a witch hunt, just because some person was aggrieved with a business, when by the sound of it, she was the one in the wrong.
XenoBitch · 29/12/2021 16:02

@CerealKiller22

We used to have a rock painting hide/find thing in my old town, a bit like a community treasure hunt. It was a bit of fun for everyone but a few kill joy's were outraged that an adult might enjoy taking part and were occasionally labelled as weird, or strange. One poor person who is known to have MH/SN issues would often be seen walking around the usual rock hiding spots (usually very peaceful places that would really benefit anyone looking for a bit of calm) and the FB patrol were "scared that one's children may come into contact with them" "should they even be outside". It was seriously disgusting behaviour. I don't have FB/SM anymore as it has had such an awful impact on people's behaviour and attitudes. I can't really bare to watch anymore.
There is a rock group for my town too. The admin of the group took it upon herself to paint 100 stones, all with names on. She asked for requests by the members, then left them in one country park. It caused an absolute bunfight. Entitled parents telling their kids that the stone with their name on, that they have not yet found, belongs to them. So many "crying children", abuse at anyone who had found "their" rock and decided to keep it or rehide it elsewhere etc The admin, who spent time and money doing it, was constantly deleting comments. It got ridiculous. For some bizarre reason, she put herself through it again this year, with the exact same result.
LittleRoundRobin · 29/12/2021 15:43

@sweatervest

i am pmsl at this and i LOVE this kind of thread!!

i have NEVER lost a bank card/purse/etc and thought "before i cancel all the cards, let me scroll down facebook to see if anyone has got it".

ffs.

Grin
sweatervest · 29/12/2021 15:41

i am pmsl at this and i LOVE this kind of thread!!

i have NEVER lost a bank card/purse/etc and thought "before i cancel all the cards, let me scroll down facebook to see if anyone has got it".

ffs.