Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Getting annoyed at virtue signalling on Facebook local groups

491 replies

Floogal · 28/12/2021 23:13

Ignoring the fussing questions everytime a police helicopter is on patrol or fireworks. Where I live it's usually the same thing. Always along the lines of;

" I've got a lot of old tat but want to donate it to charity"
" I brought the homeless guy on the high street a coffee and had a chat with him"
And, this " how many homeless people are there in town? My (photogenic well dressed) twin daughters want to give out Xmas packages" obviously hoping to appear on the local news or "and finally...' on ITV news. Usually the 'ooooh aren't you wonderful' gushing replies. Gives me the raging arsehole.

OP posts:
CherryRipe1 · 31/12/2021 00:04

@DillonPanthersTexas

We just leave ours outside in our yard near the wall and it invariably goes

Straight away or after a few days? Weeks?

It really looks shit when walking down the street and you see junk on the pavement outside someone's house.

Pretty much straight away mostly, often at night but some stuff takes a couple of days. Yep, I live in a shitty, crappy area where flytipping abounds and is often moaned about on our Nextdoor.
Inexpertjuggler · 31/12/2021 00:04

Totally agree about the virtue signalling. And I’m convinced there are people who prowl every post, everywhere, to see if they can post ‘ give it to the homeless’, ‘what about the homeless’ For everything everyone is doing or has. That way, THEY get the likes and congratulated, and they’ve had to do, er, zero. Genius really. I’m in some cookery groups on FB, and I see it on there…’ I've got some Bramley apples and the usual baking ingredients - what’s your best crumble recipe?’ Brings forth random’ give it to the homeless’ comments’. ND- I’m mind-boggled at posts such as ‘ Hi all, just joined. I’m linda, I’m 52, and live with my husband graham who is 53, at 64 New road, with our children Neil, Jake and Sarah, and our dog Sandy’… PASSWORD OVERLOAD

bossybloss · 31/12/2021 00:02

@Notinhampshirenow

Yes. 1000 x yes. I send cards every year as I’ve not got a huge family and love sending good wishes. The old ‘will be donating to charity’ post is pants. A) I believe it when I see the receipt and b) the whole thing just tells me you think cards are a hassle and cant be bothered. Actually if I was I was running a charity I would set up a website where you could send a virtual Christmas card in return for the donation……
I think the Salvation Army do this ..e cards in return for a donation. X
BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 30/12/2021 23:38

My two local FB groups (I'm on the edge of both of them) are about 90% planning applications and land sales. There's a bit of a building boom going on here. The rest is usually missing cats or dogs. What I wouldn't give for the excitement of an unknown man in a white van. Grin

Gorse · 30/12/2021 23:26

I replied to someone on our Nextdoor site, oh, about 12.15am. The next morning she told me off for posting after midnight! Didn't I know how scared it made her feel, what with her being a pensioner and being disabled, AND living on her own? How cruel I was?
Have to say, I knew nothing about this fragile woman before, nor did I think the very bland topic exercising the forumistas was threatening or scary in any wayConfused

StarfishDish · 30/12/2021 23:07

@AsYouWishButtercup Is a good deed even a good deed unless you post it on social media? Grin

AsYouWishButtercup · 30/12/2021 22:51

(He didn’t post on social media BTW because he’s not an attention seeking twat)

AsYouWishButtercup · 30/12/2021 22:51

My OH once helped a family at a petrol station who were on their way to a funeral, but they weren’t local and couldn’t find the crematorium- it was starting in 15 mins. It was miles away and too complicated to explain directions so he drove there with them following him and ensured they got there in the nick of time!

I told him it didn’t count unless he posted it on social media GrinGrin

JackTheHack · 30/12/2021 22:50

I bet if I said 'Tony the homeless man who lives on a bench' other people on here would know who was talking about from a certain Facebook group. He's very dividing Smile

Mum090521 · 30/12/2021 22:47

We had a post this week about someone's recycling box blowing over in the wind. Apparently the entire council are incompetent because of this. Approximately 5000 people work for the council here and this person has just put their name to offending every single last one of them. We're not allowed to reply, so yes, we do hold a grudge you utter tosser.

cannockcandy · 30/12/2021 22:41

These posts boil my pee too! Cannot fathom why you can't do something kind for someone without posting about it on Facebook or other social media. During the first lockdown there was a lot of kindness in my small town, luckily only around 30% of the posts about these things were done by the givers with the other 70% being done by the receiver which is how it should be. I personally did quite a few good deeds purely to make people smile. That's what good deeds should be about, not clout.

StarfishDish · 30/12/2021 22:40

@AsYouWishButtercup I don't actually live there but I like the page as I visit friends who do. Is there a post on there at the minute about somebody losing a scrabble piece? Grin

QueenoftheFarts · 30/12/2021 22:36

Right now on my community FB page, someone's sisters cat has been run over, and the driver didn't stop. Does anyone know anything about it, or did anyone see it.

Now I love cats so much, I really do. My life isn't complete without a cat to serve and obey... BUT...

  1. The person who hit it probably never knew they hit it... its a cat, not a stag.
  2. The person who hit it isn't going to come forward
  3. There is no law requiring a person to stop after hitting a cat. Its shitty if you knowingly drove on... but it's not against the law..

There has now been a collective outpouring of grief and sympathy on the comment... for a cat no one knew....

AsYouWishButtercup · 30/12/2021 22:31

@Redglitter

Not in local fb pages but it drives me nuts some of the posts on the Police appeals.i work for the police & obviously very often an appeal is only part of the story but folk seem to think we have an obligation to tell every aspect of an enquiry to the armchair detectives

I have to sit on my hands when a missing person appeal has comments like 'there's cctv in the area has that been checked' 'has find my phone been tried' Cheers Sherlock. Damn it wed never have thought of checking for cctv if you hadn't suggested it 🙄

And don't get me started on people or dogs who go missing in Glasgow & you get Shared Newcastle on the post when there's nothing to suggest the person has ever been to Newcastle in their life & its probably not very likely a dog will turn up 200 miles from home

It drives me nuts too when people share missing persons posts not from the police. There’s good reasons not to do this and I always politely point out that they should only get shared from the police and get called all sorts 🙄
BlueBell50 · 30/12/2021 22:30

Our FB group is dominated by praise for someone who appears to be the local vigilante. He patrols the streets each night reporting on the potential crimes he has prevented and the old folk he has assisted at 3am, all accompanied by photos of street signs to prove where he has been. It’s really disturbing but he gets plenty of “well done mate, you’re a hero”.

AsYouWishButtercup · 30/12/2021 22:29

@StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli

One of the reasons I deleted Face ache.

A couple of years ago a 'friend' gushed with pride all over Faceache that her 3yo DD wanted to donate all of her Christmas present money to charity, about £200 in total that were a collection of gifts from friends and family. The money was donated and the obligatory photos everywhere.

It just felt, off...I'm not really sure why, it seemed a bit exploitative of their child, and giving away something that was meant for her. £200 is a lot of money for a few likes and gushy replies, but I guess when the money wasn't yours in the first place...🤷‍♀️

A school mum once took a photo of her 5yo DD giving her birthday money to a homeless man - about £90 IIRC. I thought “Great, that will score him a decent amount of heroin” (which is what I’d buy if I had to sleep rough). They live in cloud cuckoo land if they think they are helping
Redglitter · 30/12/2021 22:25

Not in local fb pages but it drives me nuts some of the posts on the Police appeals.i work for the police & obviously very often an appeal is only part of the story but folk seem to think we have an obligation to tell every aspect of an enquiry to the armchair detectives

I have to sit on my hands when a missing person appeal has comments like 'there's cctv in the area has that been checked' 'has find my phone been tried' Cheers Sherlock. Damn it wed never have thought of checking for cctv if you hadn't suggested it 🙄

And don't get me started on people or dogs who go missing in Glasgow & you get Shared Newcastle on the post when there's nothing to suggest the person has ever been to Newcastle in their life & its probably not very likely a dog will turn up 200 miles from home

Spidey66 · 30/12/2021 22:16

About a year ago, a woman posted on ND worried as her son (Early 20s) hadn't been seen or heard from for a couple of days and this was out of character.

A few days later, she posted again. I can't remember the exact wording, but people could stop keeping an eye out, they'd had a visit from the police, it was bad news, but search was off. While she didn't say it directly, the message was clear. His body was found and it was either murder or more likely from what she said suicide. Peopkevwere obviously shocked and offering condolences. Then someone said "but what happened?" Obviously wanting all the gory details, I gave her short shrift (in a polite way in case mum was reading) that it was clear what had happened and it was too sensitive and painful for the family to tell us everything.

AsYouWishButtercup · 30/12/2021 22:16

@StarfishDish

'Anybody know any women and childrens hostels? I have clothes and I'd rather they go there than in the bin. x'

Though my favourite one was a woman posting to say she NEEDED a pram. Lots of people offered prams but she refused them all as she WANTED a specific pram!

I think you live in my city

I saw the first post and thought “I know exactly where the women’s hostel is but the point of it not being public is to protect the women and children.”

There was also one asking how much longer the local panto is on for. Fucking Google it!!

BackInBlackAgain · 30/12/2021 22:16

A couple of years ago there was a big Facebook rant about giving food to a homeless man.

A couple and their young daughters (about 8 years old) gave a homeless man some food and a Christmas present, and the daughters were trying to have their pictures taken doing this, the homeless man who is a well known alcoholic went mad and stomped on the food, threw the present away and swore at the kids.

They put all this on Facebook and it was a mix of “poor huns, you were only being nice” and “ you were only doing it for Facebook likes and maybe he didn’t want his picture taken”

He shouldn’t have swore at the kids but he had been plastered all over Facebook twice before with people giving him food and photographing it for the likes.

Never saw him on Facebook again after that.

CodenameEgg · 30/12/2021 22:13

@Kinneddar

Best one recently someone posted a warning how they'd woken up and heard footsteps outside. They checked their Ring doorbell and it shows a guy walking up to their front door turning round and running back down the drive.

The poster said he was with another dodgy looking character in a white van who drove slowly down the street then drove off when the 2nd guy got in the van. Clearly up to no.good and scared off by the Ring doorbell

Cue about a dozen posts:

OMG hun so scary
So.glad your doorbell scared them off

Then cane the OMG they were in our street about 0400
Phone the police

Then finally the voice of reason posts 'it was the milkman'

Bloody idiots didn't think the carton of milk in his hand was a clue 🙄 Worked all the dafties into a frenzy

They reported the Milkman on ours as a potential burglar. The funny part was someone said they had seen the milkman at the time and thought that he 'must have seen the dodgy character'. It didn't occur to them that the milkman was the person they had seen, their paranoia was too much for that.

In a similar story Ring footage was posted of a woman walking to the door then walking away at 7am. She was in every group by 10am as dodgy and warning people to watch out for her.
When the poor cow got home from work at 4pm and saw herself plastered all over FB she had to post and explain she was a carer going to a new client and had got the wrong address.

Madness.

TreborBore · 30/12/2021 22:10

[quote DifferentHair]@Flyingbymypants the problem with this, and so much of the other Facebook posturing, is the complete lack of respect for the privacy or dignity of the person you're saying you are 'helping'.

I absolutely hate it. It's dehumanising IMO.

People in poverty deserve respect and privacy the same as anyone else. They're not in a zoo for people to visit when they need to feel good about themselves.

Also - Having managed charities in my time - PSA- swanning in at Christmas for one day of volunteering is very rarely helpful. By the time you've been given equipment, told where things are, what the rules are, where the loo is- you've wasted otherwise productive time for the organisation and you won't be qualified to do anything critical anyway.

Regular volunteers are the lifeblood, people who come regularly over long periods of time. People who are worth training because that experience stays with the organisation. People who will take time to respect and understand the culture and ethos of the organisation, and the bigger purpose.

Rolling up on 25 December to hand out bread rolls while taking photos of yourself before swanning off to post about it on Facebook is not helpful. When I see it on Facebook I always want to click the angry face reaction and ask where they plan to be the other 364 days of the year. [/quote]
This. Most people in real life are caring and reasonable, social media is good for reuniting lost cats, keys...

Then there is a vocal minority who virtue signal with no real empathy for others who get shitty with homeless shelter staff when they are politely told that their services are not required on Christmas day. Their regular volunteers and staff will have spent time planning Christmas at the shelter, they've worked out the quantities, put in appeals for what specific things they need in good time, collected the food, worked out the rotas. How they manage to keep their cool with such people I have no idea.

The homeless shelter near me also had CF food businesses who don't help at any other time of year trying to dump their leftover cooked food on them last thing on Christmas eve. The coordinator said that they won't take food that has been on a buffet table in a warm room for hours, and that unsolicited donations will probably get wasted. But there seems to be an attitude that shelters should take this crap that no one else would eat to make the food donors feel better and that rough sleepers should be grateful.

Spidey66 · 30/12/2021 22:05

@PearlyShamps

A "friend" of mine on Facebook, posted pictures of herself with a homeless man she had delivered a food parcel to - he was holding a tin of tomato soup in each hand and had a slightly bewildered look on his face whilst she had a broad smile. I didn't think "isn't that kind if her?"... all I thought was "how on Earth will he open those tins; heat the soup; serve it & eat it??"
Oh god this reminds me of an ex colleague of my husband, who while on holiday in NY had a picture taken giving a few cents to a homeless man. I was cringing inside.
Kinneddar · 30/12/2021 22:04

Best one recently someone posted a warning how they'd woken up and heard footsteps outside. They checked their Ring doorbell and it shows a guy walking up to their front door turning round and running back down the drive.

The poster said he was with another dodgy looking character in a white van who drove slowly down the street then drove off when the 2nd guy got in the van. Clearly up to no.good and scared off by the Ring doorbell

Cue about a dozen posts:

OMG hun so scary
So.glad your doorbell scared them off

Then cane the OMG they were in our street about 0400
Phone the police

Then finally the voice of reason posts 'it was the milkman'

Bloody idiots didn't think the carton of milk in his hand was a clue 🙄 Worked all the dafties into a frenzy

StarfishDish · 30/12/2021 22:03

'Anybody know any women and childrens hostels? I have clothes and I'd rather they go there than in the bin. x'

Though my favourite one was a woman posting to say she NEEDED a pram. Lots of people offered prams but she refused them all as she WANTED a specific pram!

Swipe left for the next trending thread