Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Science podcasts now ‘gender neutral’ about pregnancy

156 replies

WinterNeverChristmas · 28/12/2021 22:42

Listening to the ‘Brains On!’ Podcast about innies versus outies and other pregnancy related facts. Really excited that there was a new (to us), interesting podcast on science for our DC. However, quickly the podcast is all about how a placenta grows within a ‘pregnant person’ etc etc. That phrase was mentioned no less than 20 times. No mention of the fact that it’s actually a woman who has a child. Nope we are pregnant people now. It’s science.

OP posts:
Cherryblossoms85 · 29/12/2021 13:18

I don't know. Thing is I saw a really vitriolic thread bout the trans man who was having a baby and didn't want to be referred to as a mother. I think he's a bit misguided, in that mother doesn't have to negate his male identity, it just has etymological roots in mammary glands. It seemed mean to slag him off quite so much and whatever really if he wants to be a pregnant man. But of course every time this happens, every organisation on the planet runs scared of the 1 in 10000 that don't want to be a pregnant woman or expectant mother and then the other 9999 of us can't be that either. That's what pisses me off.

GoatsAndBarley · 29/12/2021 13:17

What would you call a man who has a womb?

I just asked my 12 year old. Thank goodness, despite all the madness, he immediately knew the correct answer.

It's woman. In case you didn't know.

Or an intersex person who has both reproductive organs?

Extremely rare. Not necessary to remove words that describes the vast majority for this.

Do you really not see how ‘people’ is the easiest way to include everyone?

Don't you see how this language excludes rather than includes?

bordermidgebite · 29/12/2021 13:16

@xfgdhfgnhkk007

And anti matter ?

bordermidgebite · 29/12/2021 13:15

The female ones often can

sst1234 · 29/12/2021 13:15

@worriedaboutfitness

Okay, I’ll bite.

What would you call a man who has a womb? Or an intersex person who has both reproductive organs? Do you really not see how ‘people’ is the easiest way to include everyone?

Do intersex people give birth?
GoatsAndBarley · 29/12/2021 13:12

If it is about pregnancy, why would somebody unable to get pregnant be interested in it? If somebody has no womb, it wouldn't be of relevance to them

That's weird. Are you not interested in any biological facts if they are not directly relevant to your own body then?

GoatsAndBarley · 29/12/2021 13:11

It seems to require a reliance on parents teaching their children that only females get pregnant, so that 'educators'' can then score their woke points.

WonderfulYou · 29/12/2021 13:08

If it is about pregnancy, why would somebody unable to get pregnant be interested in it? If somebody has no womb, it wouldn't be of relevance to them.

Just because you can’t get pregnant or don’t want to get pregnant doesn’t mean you shouldn’t learn about it.
It’s a science podcast so it will go through a range of science subjects.

xfgdhfgnhkk007 · 29/12/2021 13:07

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

Lifeform, *@GrumpyPanda*? Although that excludes inorganic substances. Tricky!

😱

"Things". I win Grin
Whatwouldscullydo · 29/12/2021 12:43

I will have to listen to it myself (apart from this issue it does sound good) however I read that some women are offended when talking about how all women have wombs

Hasn't most of this discussion involving all women have wombs etc come about becuase of the attempts to remove the word woman as a biological fact. So people ate forced to keep going with lists if characteristics until we find one that cant be appropriated or " used against" inter women like those who have had hysterectomies etc

Or taking the whole not all women have a womb but all who have a womb are women etc out of context.

The real actual.insult however is this constant nonsense we are exposed to where just because some women don't have a uterus that means male people can also be included in the word woman because they are now exactly the same Hmm

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 29/12/2021 12:40

@WonderfulYou

I will have to listen to it myself (apart from this issue it does sound good) however I read that some women are offended when talking about how all women have wombs, give birth etc as obviously not all women have wombs. Just like not all pregnant women are mothers - so I would be more leaning towards they’re not wanting to offend biological women rather than trans-women.

Regardless I think it’s ridiculous and I’m saddened that a Science podcast wouldn’t just stick to facts.
It’s up to the person listening to understand that everything isn’t always back and white.

If it is about pregnancy, why would somebody unable to get pregnant be interested in it? If somebody has no womb, it wouldn't be of relevance to them.
WonderfulYou · 29/12/2021 12:38

I couldn't. Firstly 'female' refers to a female of any animal species. We deserve a word to distinguish female humans just as much as dogs and cows too.

This is ridiculous.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/12/2021 12:35

@worriedaboutfitness

What's the downside of saying woman instead of person in the instance given by the OP?

That the very low number of trans men who are planning to get pregnant would feel 'not included'?

We cannot change language and make it less clear and less accurate just to cater to potential hurt feelings of a very, very small minority of people.

My trans friends wouldn't be offended by 'pregnant woman' being used instead of 'pregnant person' because they are sensible, reasonable and know that language is important - it matters. Even more so when something medical is being discussed.

I have yet to hear the phrases 'people with a prostate' or 'penis havers' campaigned for which is a reflection of the underlying misogyny within the TRA community. It's clear they believe that natal women should pipe down and #bekind at the expense of clarity or safety. That natal women should consider and cater to the feelings of trans women at all times, while trans women shouldn't ever have to prioritise the feelings of women over their own.

WonderfulYou · 29/12/2021 12:34

I will have to listen to it myself (apart from this issue it does sound good) however I read that some women are offended when talking about how all women have wombs, give birth etc as obviously not all women have wombs. Just like not all pregnant women are mothers - so I would be more leaning towards they’re not wanting to offend biological women rather than trans-women.

Regardless I think it’s ridiculous and I’m saddened that a Science podcast wouldn’t just stick to facts.
It’s up to the person listening to understand that everything isn’t always back and white.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 29/12/2021 12:20

@worriedaboutfitness

A trans man with a womb then (I feel like you all know exactly what I mean when I say that)- they exist whether you agree with it or not.
I would say that if he was taking the drugs in order to be male, his womb (what an old-fashioned word that is to be sure, really quite biblical!) would be unlikely to be fertile so the question of pregnancy would be unlikely to arise.

Worth having a look at even so open a source as Wikipedia, where you will find this:

"Pregnancy is possible for transgender men who retain a functioning vagina, ovaries, and a uterus" -- good start

but then

"Testosterone therapy affects fertility, but many trans men who have become pregnant were able to do so within six months of stopping testosterone" (the others took longer without it, not stated but obvious from the context)

Also

"Exposing a fetus to high levels of exogenous testosterone is teratogenic."

So let's hope that he does stop taking the testosterone and doesn't risk disabling his baby. You know, like not taking thalidomide when you are pregnant is a good idea.

bordermidgebite · 29/12/2021 12:16

endofbluenight

I appreciate your view but I am more interested if the TRA /stonewall/ and general "people terminology "
community would accept it

endofbluenight · 29/12/2021 12:09

@Janesmom

YABU - just don’t listen and leave those of us who aren’t TERFs to get on with our lives without your misery and bile
Are you able to articulate a reasoned response to any of the concerns that have been raised?
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 29/12/2021 12:07

@Janesmom

YABU - just don’t listen and leave those of us who aren’t TERFs to get on with our lives without your misery and bile
Best report all the bile you see, @Janesmom. MNHQ will remove it. Perhaps you could help the rest of us by explaining where the bile is in wanting to be referred to as women and female in contexts where that actually matters, e.g. pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding, menstruation, menopause, women's health issues, women's sport, single-sex services and spaces?
endofbluenight · 29/12/2021 12:06

@bordermidgebite

I could also accept the use of female
I couldn't. Firstly 'female' refers to a female of any animal species. We deserve a word to distinguish female humans just as much as dogs and cows too.

Secondly, using words like 'female' (or people who menstruate etc) is not inclusive in (what should be) the real meaning of inclusive, in that it is a word that fewer people will understand. Using language like this can exclude or impede certain women (and men) , such as who are not proficient in english (may have it as as second language) or who have learning disabilities. Using simple and well understood language is particularly important in health communication.

NeedsCharging · 29/12/2021 12:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ for repeating deleted message. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Janesmom · 29/12/2021 12:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

LadyGAgain · 29/12/2021 12:01

@worriedaboutfitness

A trans man with a womb then (I feel like you all know exactly what I mean when I say that)- they exist whether you agree with it or not.
Is a biologically born man. Who you identify as is up to you. That's gender identify. And most people respect that. In terms of science which being pregnant directly relates to, biologically born WOMEN have babies. It's a bloody fact.
SpudleyLass · 29/12/2021 12:00

We all know there is only one sex that can become pregnant. No male human can, or ever will, become pregnant.

We call that sex, in humans, women.

Given how taxing pregnancy is on the FEMALE body, I don't want particularly want to hear from actual men on the issue or give them a seat at the table.

FrippEnos · 29/12/2021 12:00

@worriedaboutfitness

A trans man with a womb then (I feel like you all know exactly what I mean when I say that)- they exist whether you agree with it or not.
You answered your own question there.

A man does not have a womb a transman does.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 29/12/2021 11:59

What would you call a man who has a womb?

Imaginary

Swipe left for the next trending thread