Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Science podcasts now ‘gender neutral’ about pregnancy

156 replies

WinterNeverChristmas · 28/12/2021 22:42

Listening to the ‘Brains On!’ Podcast about innies versus outies and other pregnancy related facts. Really excited that there was a new (to us), interesting podcast on science for our DC. However, quickly the podcast is all about how a placenta grows within a ‘pregnant person’ etc etc. That phrase was mentioned no less than 20 times. No mention of the fact that it’s actually a woman who has a child. Nope we are pregnant people now. It’s science.

OP posts:
ForestLake · 29/12/2021 15:32

@Whatsnewpussyhat

No man has ever been pregnant.

If any of the minuscule number of females who want to say they are men or anything other than a woman, decide to use their FEMALE organs to produce a baby, (funny how this doesn't 'trigger' them isn't it. Just the word woman) they can simply ask their own midwife and other medical professionals involved to call them whatever they want and stop demanding that 50% of the population pretend THEIR sex based reality no longer matters or exists.

By getting pregnant they know damn well what sex they are. So why should the rest of us pretend they are somehow special or different to any other woman who has a baby?

This.

No one can change sex.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/12/2021 15:23

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]**@hugr

I didn't learn about periods at school before I had mine. We had 1 3 day education on it which I was ill for. My mum taught me about periods and people who have them.

And what about girls who have families who don't talk openly about these things?

Girls who don't have a mum, only a dad and no wider family, so nobody older female they trust to ask? If that dad has archaic views and is too embarrassed to do the right thing and be as open about periods as a mum would be?

Those girls NEED to be taught outside of the home and they need correct and clear language in order to understand important things about their own bodies. [/quote]
What about these girls @hugr?

YouSetTheTone · 29/12/2021 15:22

Posters on this thread are demonstrating just how many women there are who have internalised misogyny. It’s really depressing.

You know those mental health support groups for men - Shed Groups?
Why does no one go after those, saying how exclusionary and transphobic they are? Women, on the whole, understand why men like these services/ groups etc. Most will say (quite rightly!) ‘totally fine and appropriate that men have these spaces.’ But most of those very same women will attack women who want their own groups/ services etc and even wanting to use the correct word to describe our sex. Why?

Woman = adult human female. Why aren’t we allowed to own this?

NeedsCharging · 29/12/2021 15:22

It's not the same as BLM.

Both women and black people are disadvantaged groups. As a black woman I fall in to both disadvantaged groups. I find it odd that you wouldn't want to take away "black" from me but you are happy to remove the word woman from me? Why?

hugr · 29/12/2021 15:19

@NeedsCharging

Yeah

And there we have it.
hugr is happy to disadvantage women and girls only. The misogyny is strong in you clearly.

I just don't see the point in arguing with someone who is being so obtuse.

It's not the same as BLM. If we were talking about NAMALT and "but men are disadvantaged too" then I'd agree with you. But it's unrelated.

But there you go, you don't think women are people so...

NeedsCharging · 29/12/2021 15:17

People who have periods

I didnt have my period until I was 15 but my mum discussed it with me when I was about 11. She never discussed it with my brother and at aged 11 we were both people who didn't have periods so why didn't she talk to him about what he should expect when his period started?

Whatwouldscullydo · 29/12/2021 15:17

Yes. What class of people have oeriods.

How do the teachers know who to give the free samples. What people need them and why?.is there a name.for this group of people?

Franca123 · 29/12/2021 15:17

Do we just tell kids that they may get a period or they may not. If a boy starts bleeding from his cock at around 13 we assume it's a period and don't bother investigating. I just love how bonkers it all is.

Whatwouldscullydo · 29/12/2021 15:16

The samaritans was set up because a teenage girl killed herself after starting her periods because she didn't know what was happening.

hugr · 29/12/2021 15:16

@Whatwouldscullydo

And identify those people how?
You really have to know how my mum knew I was going to have periods?
Whatwouldscullydo · 29/12/2021 15:14

And identify those people how?

hugr · 29/12/2021 15:13

@Whatwouldscullydo

How did she know you needed to know?

Is there a particular group of people who need to know?

People who have periods
almondcaramelcoconut · 29/12/2021 15:13

It's pandering nonsense to placate a tiny number of people and the much, much larger number of people who feel offended on their behalf. Offended by the actual scientific reality that "people who are pregnant" and "people who have a womb" are women. It's bizarre that so many think we should play along and pretend otherwise.

Franca123 · 29/12/2021 15:13

Lol. Always love to see gender woo 'people' crumble under the slightest questioning. Never gets old.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/12/2021 15:13

@hugr

I didn't learn about periods at school before I had mine. We had 1 3 day education on it which I was ill for. My mum taught me about periods and people who have them.

And what about girls who have families who don't talk openly about these things?

Girls who don't have a mum, only a dad and no wider family, so nobody older female they trust to ask? If that dad has archaic views and is too embarrassed to do the right thing and be as open about periods as a mum would be?

Those girls NEED to be taught outside of the home and they need correct and clear language in order to understand important things about their own bodies.

Whatwouldscullydo · 29/12/2021 15:12

How did she know you needed to know?

Is there a particular group of people who need to know?

NeedsCharging · 29/12/2021 15:11

Yeah

And there we have it.
hugr is happy to disadvantage women and girls only. The misogyny is strong in you clearly.

YouSetTheTone · 29/12/2021 15:11

@hugr

Language matters, and cloaking 'pregnant women' in 'pregnant people' obfuscates matters. As I said before - it does not benefit women.

If you're so insistent that trans men are women, then it does benefit women.

I think it’s arguable that ‘pregnant people’ even benefits a transman who is pregnant. A transman is undoubtedly very aware of the dichotomy between their sex and their gender identity. They know they’re only pregnant because they’re a woman. A transman will benefit from clear language around the medical needs or biological facts of women because they too are women.

Do you seriously think that using a term that might benefit the proportionately extremely rare instances of pregnant transmen over a term that benefits over 50% of the population is sensible or fair? Confused

hugr · 29/12/2021 15:10

@Whatwouldscullydo

hug

How would you go about teaching children what happens to their bodies as they get older?

If a girl has not started menstruating by the age of 16 that girl would need to see a dr.

If she were however brought up just thinking some people have periods some don't.. some.people get pregnant some don't. How would this girl be alerted to the fact she actually is one of those people?

Someone has to tell her right? I mean either you believe everyone is just people amd nothing happens to anyone I'm particular due to any specific characteristics and think any negative consequence is just unfortunate and not something that could be predicted.

Or you know full well what affects what sex amd are just cashing in on someone else doing the dirty work.for you.

Which is it?

The bbc recently published an article on people with prostate cancer. 1 in 12 people get it apparently. So is that one in.6 men (.as.presumably 12 people was 6 men and 6 women) or its in fact 1 in 24 people because they asked 12 men and 12 women no?

When deciding how to allocate resources amd research 1 in six vs 1 in 12 vs 1 in 24 would show different urgencies and need.

So do you think the BBC knew which 12 people to ask?

I didn't learn about periods at school before I had mine. We had 1 3 day education on it which I was ill for. My mum taught me about periods and people who have them.
Starcup · 29/12/2021 15:10

@Linguini

Health websites are full of advice for "why am I not falling pregnant?"

The top common causes are
Being over 35
Having PCOS
Being too overweight
Being too underweight

I'm seeing a future where we need to explicitly explain
"Having a penis can be a reason why you're not falling pregnant" IN ALL SERIOUSNESS!!

The scary this is, this is exactly the kind of rubbish that will be needed to be in leaflets in the future.

We’re currently in the process of creating a generation full of kids that actually will believe that sex is a social construct and you can chose what sex you want to be on any given day.

It’s the epitome of terrifying

hugr · 29/12/2021 15:09

@NeedsCharging

Because I don't want to?

Oh OK but you are happy for the word woman to be replaced by the word people? Why is it ok for 1 disadvantaged group but not another in your eyes?

Yeah
Whatwouldscullydo · 29/12/2021 15:09

hug

How would you go about teaching children what happens to their bodies as they get older?

If a girl has not started menstruating by the age of 16 that girl would need to see a dr.

If she were however brought up just thinking some people have periods some don't.. some.people get pregnant some don't. How would this girl be alerted to the fact she actually is one of those people?

Someone has to tell her right? I mean either you believe everyone is just people amd nothing happens to anyone I'm particular due to any specific characteristics and think any negative consequence is just unfortunate and not something that could be predicted.

Or you know full well what affects what sex amd are just cashing in on someone else doing the dirty work.for you.

Which is it?

The bbc recently published an article on people with prostate cancer. 1 in 12 people get it apparently. So is that one in.6 men (.as.presumably 12 people was 6 men and 6 women) or its in fact 1 in 24 people because they asked 12 men and 12 women no?

When deciding how to allocate resources amd research 1 in six vs 1 in 12 vs 1 in 24 would show different urgencies and need.

So do you think the BBC knew which 12 people to ask?

NeedsCharging · 29/12/2021 15:05

Because I don't want to?

Oh OK but you are happy for the word woman to be replaced by the word people? Why is it ok for 1 disadvantaged group but not another in your eyes?

NeedsCharging · 29/12/2021 15:04

So you're saying you can't give an example?

I gave examples in my previous post. Of how changing women to people directly impacts and disadvantages women and girls.

hugr · 29/12/2021 15:03

@NeedsCharging

And no I wouldn't answer with all lives matter. Sorry that I took more than 2 minutes to answer your question. Some of us have more important things to do.

Why wouldn't? I mean black people are just people just as women are people like you say. So what's stopping you from saying that?

Because I don't want to?
Swipe left for the next trending thread