Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to think this is not legally binding or enforceable?

88 replies

ConcernedFriend17 · 28/12/2021 22:07

Keen to hear from legally qualified Mumsnetters as I'm pretty worried about my friend. She's early forties and has been with her partner for four years. She's always lived beyond her means and a consequence of that is that she's never bought her own house or had any savings, in spite of having a good, secure job.

Her partner is financially secure and they have lived together in his house for the last three years. Recently she's been excitedly telling everyone that they're buying a new house together. I thought this was great; financial security for her, her own home etc. However she confided in me that she won't be on the mortgage or the deeds, but her partner will draw up a contract to pay her a certain amount of money if they split up.

This sounds really strange to me. And can it really be legally binding or enforceable? I know that she'll put her heart and soul into this house; she loves her partner but it's a rocky relationship. I'm just worried that she'll invest her time, money and love into somewhere and then she'll have absolutely zero to show for it, if they split.

AIBU in thinking this could be a financial disaster for her?

OP posts:
Unreasonabubble · 29/12/2021 00:16

@How2Help - I would hope that the people I consider to be my friends and whom I consider to be their friend that we would all speak without forked tongue.

I would rather be blunt with a girlfriend (in the nicest possible way) and point out my concerns and what she has to look out for.

As I said previously, I cannot believe some women actually fall hook line and stinker for this still. Sad

Nowayoutonlydown · 29/12/2021 00:00

She would be better putting her own money into her own house, just as you've said repeatedly, however the thing that's getting in the way of that is her own habits isn't it?

I'll assume that not only does she not have any savings, but also has a fair amount of debt which will be stopping her.

Here's the thing, you'll be thinking she's taken advantage of, but anything other than her name being nowhere near the deeds actually leaves her (financially sound) partner in a very vulnerable position.

TBH there ard all sorts of legal contracts that can be written up which will his investment- and he should absolutely use everything he can.

Have you considered that this may be the only way that her partner can have a relationship with her given that she refuses to act responsibly with money?

What would you think if it was your partner?

If she is on his deeds, and she has debt, the house that he has worked for is at risk if she defaults on them.

You are letting the way you feel about her cloud your view, she is not on the deeds because she can't get on the deeds by her own merits. Not only is it best for him, this may mark out the most stable chance she has occurred somewhere to live. If she lives above her means and has no savings its only a matter of time before things come crumbling down financially for her.

How2Help · 28/12/2021 23:56

Wow! Still cannot believe that women in this day and age are believing that they will be okay if a couple split when they are not married, not on the mortgage and have no way of showing how they have contributed towards the cost of the house and therefore deserve a share.

Mind boggles...

And yet when a friend realises this and tries to point this out some posters say it is none of her business.

Unreasonabubble · 28/12/2021 23:47

Wow! Still cannot believe that women in this day and age are believing that they will be okay if a couple split when they are not married, not on the mortgage and have no way of showing how they have contributed towards the cost of the house and therefore deserve a share.

Mind boggles...

DespairingHomeowner · 28/12/2021 23:41

@ConcernedFriend17

It's a little bit my "business" if she talks to me about it . . . but I agree with you, he's buying a house, and she's lucky that she gets to live there.

I just wish she'd buy her own place, however small, rather than relying on her partner for financial security.

Talk to her about building up her own financial security through savings

She is lucky that he is in a position to buy a house they will both live in (if it were me, I’d expect rent or other contribution)

She should really try to not buy furniture etc if not her house. Tricky though: I’m a homeowner on my own, I’d be angry if a boyfriend expected to profit from savings I sacrificed to make over the last 20 years

It’s tricky when people meet in mid life onwards or have different positions.. your friend should talk to partner & also seek legal advice- getting a contract checked would only be a few hundred pounds so worth it for both parties given a home is usually our biggest asset

ConcernedFriend17 · 28/12/2021 23:39

Yes, @How2Help - thank you. I'm worried that my friend will believe her partner will look after her financially and (because she's certainly not a freeloader) she'll buy lots of lovely things for what she believes to be their home, instead of paying a fair "rent" but ALSO saving or making some provision for her own future.

OP posts:
Itsalmostanaccessory · 28/12/2021 23:38

She is not paying for the house. They dont have kids for her to use an excuse to not work and contribute financially. She can piss right off if she thinks she should get half the house if they split. If he is willing to offer a financial settlement in the event of a split then that is plenty.

Maybe she should just grow up and stop living beyond her means. She is blood lucky she'll have a lovely home to live in without contributing to it. Z

JeffThePilot · 28/12/2021 23:38

@ConcernedFriend17

No, *@JeffThePilot* - I'm suggesting she should be using her own money to secure her own financial future.
But after she pays him reasonable living expenses, she can still save. She’s never chosen to do that before, though. I suppose if it comes to it, she’ll have to move back into her own accommodation as presumably she had somewhere to live before she met him. She is deluded if she thinks she’ll have an interest in the house, though, so you might want to advise her to get her own legal advice to spell this out.
Mummylovesmonkeys · 28/12/2021 23:37

When my DH and I got together I was a financial mess. Owed money right left and centre. DH has always been financially responsible - owned his own house (I was in a council flat, and owed rent - I was on part time minimum wage)

He gave me the chance to retrain in a job I love. For a short time he was unemployed (not his fault) and I was earning, but he soon found a job.

When we bought our current house we came to an agreement and sorted our wills accordingly - I have one daughter, he has 2. All assets in the marriage would be split 3 ways, with the surviving partner having rights to the house until their demise. Works for us.

As we near retirement we will be reassessing of course - DH has a much bigger pension than me / I have received a small inheritance, and are mortgage free, but on the whole we trust each other to carry out the others wishes (I wouldn't dream of 'stiffing' my lovely stepdaughters.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/12/2021 23:35

I'm not saying she deserves a share of the house. I think he's doing the right thing in protecting his assets. I'm just worried about possible naïveté on the part of my friend, and a potential reliance on something that won't come to fruition should they split

All you can do is suggest she gets legal advice - if she won't then she won't but you'll have done your best

I'm surprised you said she could "save for a place of her own" though, since the the fact she's "always lived beyond her means" would surely make that unlikely?
Frankly it sounds as if she's seeing £££ signs because he's got money, but that's her choice to make and while I'd be supportive with practical advice I certainly wouldn't house her if it all goes wrong

ConcernedFriend17 · 28/12/2021 23:34

No, @JeffThePilot - I'm suggesting she should be using her own money to secure her own financial future.

OP posts:
How2Help · 28/12/2021 23:32

I think I understand your concern. It isn’t that you think she should ‘get’ anything, but that being potentially deluded by how protected she is, that she will fail to make other provisions.

I can understand that concern and think it is your concern as a friend. You aren’t asking for her to get a contract that does protect her, but to understand the reality of how protected she is.

Is that it?

JeffThePilot · 28/12/2021 23:31

Are you suggesting she should be living rent free and either squirrelling away or frittering her own money?

tara66 · 28/12/2021 23:02

As they are not married her claim to any part of the house might be weaker than should they marry.

ConcernedFriend17 · 28/12/2021 23:01

I'm not sure, @ChiefStockingStuffer - he doesn't have any children so I think his next-of-kin would be his mum.

@Shedmistress she plans to buy things for the house (furniture and decor-type stuff) as her contribution, as a kind of rent, so I'm not sure she'll have much left every month after that to save. And if they split up, I'm not entirely sure he'd let her retrieve furniture etc. Sad

Hey ho. There's not much I can do if the worst happens, other than just be there for her with a spare room, if needs be. I really hope it doesn't come to that and they live happily ever after!

OP posts:
ChiefStockingStuffer · 28/12/2021 22:53

What happens if he dies?

Will she be homeless?

CheshireKitten123 · 28/12/2021 22:52

If the boot was on the other foot and it was a woman inviting a financially irresponsible guy to live with her, there would be a hoard of Mumsnetters urging her not to do it, to protect her assets, to not get involved with a waster etc.etc.

But you're feeling sorry for your friend ?? Shock

Shedmistress · 28/12/2021 22:52

perhaps advise her to put the money she would have paid in rent away, so she isn't left homeless if the relationship ends.

ConcernedFriend17 · 28/12/2021 22:50

I don't think she should have a claim on his house, @ElectraBlue - I think she'd be better putting her own money into her own house, or saving some cash every month rather than buying furniture and furnishings for someone else's (she'll see this as paying rent which is fair, but I think it would be better for her to achieve financial independence).

That's what I'm afraid of, @Nat6999 - I wasn't sure if a contract like this would be binding.

OP posts:
Doesntfeellikexmas · 28/12/2021 22:47

@ConcernedFriend17

No, *@Doesntfeellikexmas*, I'm worried that someone I love like a sister could be turfed out onto the street due to a lack of sound financial planning. My friend isn't a freeloader; she'll contribute by buying nice furnishings and making the place beautiful. But she'd be much better off putting her money into a savings account or into her own place.

I'd like to be clear that I'm not getting hugely involved - I've advised my friend to get her own solicitor, whether she does or not is up to her and I won't push the point. I'm simply asking a question on an anonymous forum because I'm worried and have a gut feeling that what she thinks will happen isn't what will actually happen. But I could be wrong - maybe reality will meet her expectation.

But she won't save or ever buy a place of her own because she lives beyond her means.

And shock horror.....she will buy items for the house she lives in. She will decorate the house she lives in. She can take the items with her, if they split. Decorating will be a fraction of he actually living costs.

You don't get money, if you rent a place and then have to leave.

I would always advocate getting independent financial advice

However, it really seems like you think she should be making a profit off this.

Living with him, she will have more spare money so could absolutely save or buy a place of her own. So she has a back up plan. She can do that because she isn't putting anything in or paying towards it.

CheshireKitten123 · 28/12/2021 22:47

Concerned,
"I'm worried that someone I love like a sister could be turfed out onto the street due to a lack of sound financial planning."

Your friend doesn't, through choice, have a track record of sound financial planning up to now and is unlikely to change no matter how much you worry. Hmm

Nat6999 · 28/12/2021 22:43

My ex signed an agreement that if we split up he would move out of the house which was in my sole name. When we separated wasn't worth the paper it was written on.

ElectraBlue · 28/12/2021 22:42

So she is not paying towards the deposit or the mortgage and they are not married.

Why would you expect her to have any claim on this house?

ConcernedFriend17 · 28/12/2021 22:36

No, @Doesntfeellikexmas, I'm worried that someone I love like a sister could be turfed out onto the street due to a lack of sound financial planning. My friend isn't a freeloader; she'll contribute by buying nice furnishings and making the place beautiful. But she'd be much better off putting her money into a savings account or into her own place.

I'd like to be clear that I'm not getting hugely involved - I've advised my friend to get her own solicitor, whether she does or not is up to her and I won't push the point. I'm simply asking a question on an anonymous forum because I'm worried and have a gut feeling that what she thinks will happen isn't what will actually happen. But I could be wrong - maybe reality will meet her expectation.

OP posts:
CheshireKitten123 · 28/12/2021 22:31

Concerned,
"Again - I'm not saying she deserves a share of the house. I think he's doing the right thing in protecting his assets. I'm just worried about possible naïveté on the part of my friend, and a potential reliance on something that won't come to fruition should they split."

This makes no sense.

First of all you say "I'm not saying she deserves a share of the house"
and then you say "and a potential reliance on something that won't come to fruition should they split." So what do you think should "come to fruition."?

Apparently he's said he's going to give her money if they split so what could possibly go wrong? Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread