Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to think this is not legally binding or enforceable?

88 replies

ConcernedFriend17 · 28/12/2021 22:07

Keen to hear from legally qualified Mumsnetters as I'm pretty worried about my friend. She's early forties and has been with her partner for four years. She's always lived beyond her means and a consequence of that is that she's never bought her own house or had any savings, in spite of having a good, secure job.

Her partner is financially secure and they have lived together in his house for the last three years. Recently she's been excitedly telling everyone that they're buying a new house together. I thought this was great; financial security for her, her own home etc. However she confided in me that she won't be on the mortgage or the deeds, but her partner will draw up a contract to pay her a certain amount of money if they split up.

This sounds really strange to me. And can it really be legally binding or enforceable? I know that she'll put her heart and soul into this house; she loves her partner but it's a rocky relationship. I'm just worried that she'll invest her time, money and love into somewhere and then she'll have absolutely zero to show for it, if they split.

AIBU in thinking this could be a financial disaster for her?

OP posts:
ChristmasRobins · 29/12/2021 10:02

Your friend needs proper legal advice of her own. There's a lot more to consider here than whether the contract is enforceable.

Frazzled2207 · 29/12/2021 10:02

@Justcallmebebes

You can have a Cohabiting/Partner Agreement drawn up by a solicitor that is legally binding. It's becoming more common
Yes this. I don’t think it’s 100% bombproof but most courts would uphold it.
GabriellaMontez · 29/12/2021 10:00

It became your business when she confided in you.

I totally understand your concerns. Some here seem to have wilfully misunderstood them.

If he is drawing up an 'agreement' but neither of them are seeing a solicitor, it's likely she's being misled into thinking she has some financial protection. She may be plan/save accordingly for the next 10 years based on this. Thats worrying and I'd urge her to seek legal advice over the contract he writes.

Alittlepotofrosie · 29/12/2021 09:59

It would be worse for the man if they break up and this feckless woman walks away with half of everything he's worked for. He's protecting himself as he should.

Doesntfeellikexmas · 29/12/2021 09:57

@mobear

I think OP is concerned because her friend may rely on something that is unenforceable and therefore be even less likely to plan for her financial future if she thinks she will be provided for (to whatever extent they’ve agreed). I don’t think it is unreasonable to be concerned for this reason.
If its not enforceable, the friend leave with what she brought. Nothing.

Or some furniture. Or she could take responsibility for herself and manage her money better and set up her own back up plan. Like a grown up.

The friend is putting herself in a situation and claims to understand all the implications.

However, she is not losing anything. And she, if they split, she will be left with nothing as she has put nothing in.

mobear · 29/12/2021 09:49

I think OP is concerned because her friend may rely on something that is unenforceable and therefore be even less likely to plan for her financial future if she thinks she will be provided for (to whatever extent they’ve agreed). I don’t think it is unreasonable to be concerned for this reason.

PinkWednesdays · 29/12/2021 09:23

only so much decorating

PinkWednesdays · 29/12/2021 09:21

I’m confused - you’re worried she’d be left with nothing if they split and she was kicked out from a home that she doesn’t own, doesn’t contribute financially to and her only contribution is decorating the home.

Surely the money she has spent decorating the home (and even then, there’s only decoration she can do) would be going on rent anyway if she wasn’t with him, so she would be in no worse position?

The onus is on her to protect herself by being better with money, not expecting a payout if they split.

CheshireKitten123 · 29/12/2021 09:20

@ConcernedFriend17

No, *@JeffThePilot* - I'm suggesting she should be using her own money to secure her own financial future.
Agreed, she should but she hasn't shown any inclination to do that up to now, so why do you think she will change?

And now she has some -mug- person who is happy to bankroll her frivolous lifestyle there isn't any incentive for her to financially plan ahead. Hmm

HiJenny35 · 29/12/2021 03:16

He's paying for the house so it should be his. She lives above her means so wouldn't be able to get a mortgage anyway. If she moved out she'd have to move into rented so wouldn't be able to save and would be spending the same as she's spending on furnishings, at least this way she can take the furnishings with her if they seperat. I'm relaly not sure what you want to achieve, she can't achieve financial independence as she lives above her means, her choice is with him and pay for furniture on her own and pay rent. Either way she isn't saving for her future.

ajs8 · 29/12/2021 03:06

@ConcernedFriend17

She's not paying anything towards the deposit, and as her partner is wealthy, the mortgage is probably more than she can afford to pay her fair share of.

By the way - I'm not saying she deserves a share of the house; I just think she's deluding herself in talking about "their" house. I don't think this "contract" of giving her a financial settlement if they split us actually legally valid, and I think she'll end up with nothing after potentially investing years into making a home Sad

So she has no claim on anything with no deposit. She’s put absolutely nothing into the house, but her partner has said he will give her some money if they split, despite her putting no money in??? You are either deluded or this is a reverse!! Biscuit
mjkrta · 29/12/2021 02:08

as a friend you shouldnt be interferring,you have said they have a rocky relationshp so why would he make such a commitment?as her friend if things dont work out for HER.then say i told you so...and pour her a glass of wine

mobear · 29/12/2021 01:46

It’s unlikely to be enforceable but may assist if she decides to take him to court later (but there’s no guarantee, and she’d then have to spend money on lawyers also). She should obtain proper legal advice now.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 29/12/2021 01:34

Honestly my advice would be to tell this guy to stay well away from your friend. She sounds like she’ll be a financial drain on him.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 29/12/2021 01:15

I don't think she will spend as much on furniture as she would have on rent - especially over a longer time period. She can save the extra. That way if they split, she will have savings and can go back into renting - she won't have lost out at all.

sst1234 · 29/12/2021 00:55

[quote Unreasonabubble]@JeffThePilot - But what happens if the poor soul lives with this man for say, another 10 years. He turfs her out. She has nowhere to go. She cannot afford to rent as she has lived with him and lived off his money all these years. What is she supposed to do? She has given him the best 10 years of his life by the way.[/quote]
She’s not a poor soul. She’s an irresponsible soul, by the sounds of it. As for what she’s supposed to do? Buy her own place, maybe.

Unreasonabubble · 29/12/2021 00:53

@JeffThePilot - It is alright, I am pulling your plonker. Just needed your reaction to reinforce what women should not do. 😇

Wtfdoipick · 29/12/2021 00:51

[quote Unreasonabubble]@JeffThePilot - But what happens if the poor soul lives with this man for say, another 10 years. He turfs her out. She has nowhere to go. She cannot afford to rent as she has lived with him and lived off his money all these years. What is she supposed to do? She has given him the best 10 years of his life by the way.[/quote]
He's providing her with a roof for free for those 10 years. If she can't manage to save in that time that's on her not him

JeffThePilot · 29/12/2021 00:50

[quote Unreasonabubble]@JeffThePilot - But what happens if the poor soul lives with this man for say, another 10 years. He turfs her out. She has nowhere to go. She cannot afford to rent as she has lived with him and lived off his money all these years. What is she supposed to do? She has given him the best 10 years of his life by the way.[/quote]
She works. She pays her way, as we all have to. And if she isn’t paying rent, she will be able to save up a large chunk if she so chooses.

These poor cocklodgers and fannylodgers, imagine suddenly not being able to live off someone else’s money any more…

Honestly. Got to be a joke.

Unreasonabubble · 29/12/2021 00:47

@JeffThePilot - But what happens if the poor soul lives with this man for say, another 10 years. He turfs her out. She has nowhere to go. She cannot afford to rent as she has lived with him and lived off his money all these years. What is she supposed to do? She has given him the best 10 years of his life by the way.

sst1234 · 29/12/2021 00:44

OP, it sounds like your friend is getting a good deal here. If the guy was your friend, you’d probably be telling him to protect himself from her irresponsible ways.

JeffThePilot · 29/12/2021 00:35

[quote Unreasonabubble]@How2Help - I would hope that the people I consider to be my friends and whom I consider to be their friend that we would all speak without forked tongue.

I would rather be blunt with a girlfriend (in the nicest possible way) and point out my concerns and what she has to look out for.

As I said previously, I cannot believe some women actually fall hook line and stinker for this still. Sad[/quote]
She isn’t really falling for anything though, she’s not being duped. Naive, but not duped. She isn’t paying towards the house so of course she won’t have a share in it and doesn’t deserve one either, would you hand over a chunk of your house to a financially irresponsible partner who hadn’t co-purchased it or meaningfully contributed other than to buy some furniture?

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 29/12/2021 00:35

Does she have a shopping habit? Is buying furniture and decorations for the house about making the house a home or is it about her spending. In fact since he already has a house do they even need this furniture.

gogohm · 29/12/2021 00:23

We have a legal agreement, it is possible. I'll own half eventually (waiting on my house sale, delayed until kids finish university for ease) until then I have right to reside until my death

GoGoGretaDoll · 29/12/2021 00:20

I think legal advice wouldn't be a bad shout in that hearing a professional third party spell out exactly what would happen in the event of a split might give her a bit of a wake-up call.

Of course she should be paying rent, but if he's prepared to let her live rent-free than she'd be MAD not to save. Could she give money to you to save for her?

Swipe left for the next trending thread