Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to think this is not legally binding or enforceable?

88 replies

ConcernedFriend17 · 28/12/2021 22:07

Keen to hear from legally qualified Mumsnetters as I'm pretty worried about my friend. She's early forties and has been with her partner for four years. She's always lived beyond her means and a consequence of that is that she's never bought her own house or had any savings, in spite of having a good, secure job.

Her partner is financially secure and they have lived together in his house for the last three years. Recently she's been excitedly telling everyone that they're buying a new house together. I thought this was great; financial security for her, her own home etc. However she confided in me that she won't be on the mortgage or the deeds, but her partner will draw up a contract to pay her a certain amount of money if they split up.

This sounds really strange to me. And can it really be legally binding or enforceable? I know that she'll put her heart and soul into this house; she loves her partner but it's a rocky relationship. I'm just worried that she'll invest her time, money and love into somewhere and then she'll have absolutely zero to show for it, if they split.

AIBU in thinking this could be a financial disaster for her?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Redact · 29/12/2021 14:32

@CheshireKitten123 agree completely with your post. I think her partner has done the right thing in protecting his money and investment. If it was role reversal and the spendthrift partner who is happy to put their heart and soul but not their cash into the house was male would replies be so supportive of him getting a financial settlement off his female partner while investing none of his capital.

roseblosssom · 29/12/2021 14:19

Can't comment on the legalities but if your friend were smart about things she could set herself up with a backup plan. She can cut back on the expensive furnishings and get saving. Then buy herself a flat or house that she can rent out and then move to if the relationship goes wrong.

If she did this and the boyfriend effectively helped her onto the property ladder it would be wrong, in my opinion, for her to expect anything from the boyfriends house besides any personal belongings.

TeacupDrama · 29/12/2021 12:30

if you split you can take away what is yours ie what you have paid for; if you buy a chair / tv / computer/ coffee maker you can take then chair /tv/ computer/ coffee maker ( maybe best to keep reciepts) , if the furniture is all joint purchases you would have a share of furniture but not the house the furniture is in

inheritancetrack · 29/12/2021 12:26

Op why can't your friend put her salary into a savings account. Surely they will have a lot of furnishings from the current house and the sum not huge? If she's living there rent free she will,have money to save. You don't spend £600 every month on home furnishing

If she lived on her own she would be paying for everything and not saving. I suspect though (on previous form) she will just spend, spend, spend.

inheritancetrack · 29/12/2021 12:23

@Nat6999

My ex signed an agreement that if we split up he would move out of the house which was in my sole name. When we separated wasn't worth the paper it was written on.
Presumably you were married? If so then no, it wouldn't be worth the paper it's written in. A marriage is totally different to a relationship
GettingItOutThere · 29/12/2021 12:20

he is very sensible!

she needs to have savings, buy her own house or invest wisely!

I would not want her on my mortgage either

inheritancetrack · 29/12/2021 12:20

Of course the contract they both sign and is drawn up by a solicitor is valid. Does she seriously expect to be on the deeds at 50% having not paid the deposit and a small percentage of the mortgage? If her partner did this he would lose a huge amount to someone who is known to be poor with money. This is England? I think Scotland may be different.

BarbaraofSeville · 29/12/2021 12:14

This will only be a financial disaster for her if she makes it one. It's all on her.

She could use the opportunity of living rent free to save and invest a good portion of the income from her well paid job to build a nest egg to provide financial security, retirement income and to buy a property should she need one.

She could also buy a property to rent out if she wants to be 'in property' so she doesn't get left behind by any rise in the market.

If she doesn't take this opportunity and spends all her money on whatever non essentials she likes, then it's a problem of her own doing.

HTH1 · 29/12/2021 12:00

The answer is likely yes IF she goes to a solicitor and gets it done properly (highly likely the answer is no otherwise). The issue they would likely have is that it sounds like she is not putting in any money i.e. consideration.

Like PPs though, I would query why she deserves a share of a property to which she is not contributing (unless she marries DP).

You can’t do much about this as people do what they want to do and tend not to listen to unsolicited advice. If you can get her to become more frugal and look after her future (e.g. Dave Ramsey is a great place to start), you would be a great friend to her.

Bluntness100 · 29/12/2021 11:52

This makes no sense op, you keep jumping all over the place.

You say she will buy lots of things for whay she believes to be her home. It will be her home, she will live there. Jist like it would be her home if she was in rented accommodation.

She’s not buying into it so can’t claim the property. If you feel she shouldn’t buy furniture for her home, then tell her.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/12/2021 11:27

Being financially irresponsible is a choice, being a freeloader is a choice, they’re both things she has actively chosen. If she has to move out and rent somewhere thats on her, no one else, she is an adult after all

Exactly - but she's clearly seen an opportunity with someone who's got a house and money and is now trying to make it into something it's not ("our house" and all the rest)

When she's "always lived beyond her means", the insistence that she'll save for her own place makes no sense to me, and neither does the idea she'll get a payout from what OP's openly described as a "rocky" relationship

Few men are that stupid, so perhaps she'd be better enjoying her good deal while it lasts and start taking some responsibility for herself

Thirtytimesround · 29/12/2021 11:10

The short answer is we can’t tell you if the contract will be enforceable/calid when the contract hasn’t even been written yet. It depends what it says!!

She needs legal advice if she’s planning to invest any money into the house. Sounds like financial advisor would be useful too, her bank can arrange that.

It would be much simpler / better for her if they just got married but presumably he doesn’t want to 🤷‍♀️

Questions I’d suggest she think about

  • Does she have a pension?
  • what happens to the house if he dies OR becomes mentally incapable?
  • Why does she think they are buying it ‘together’? If she isn’t investing money and her name isn’t on the deeds then I don’t see how this is anything other than his house.

Also worth remembering that whatever the legal position is, the legal position doesn’t actually matter much unless she has time/money/energy to take him to court.

Strongly recommend she avoid the situation where his name is on the house and he pays the mortgage but she pays the bills / food expenses etc. Men often suggest this arrangement because they know they’ll make a return on their investment but money on bills is money gone.

DisforDarkChocolate · 29/12/2021 10:49

She needs legal advice but if I was him I'd be going something similar.

worriedaboutfitness · 29/12/2021 10:47

OP, I am your friend- my finances are a mess from years of overspending, and I currently live with my partner in their property which they own. I do pay half of the mortgage payments to them each month (it’s not clear from your OP if your friend will be doing this?) but to me it’s basically “rent” rather than actual mortgage contributions.

My partner and I have a document drawn up similar to what you’ve described, that says if we split I get back the money I’ve paid them and am entitled to nothing more- so essentially I can’t go after my partner saying I contributed to the mortgage for x years.

It’s not ideal and I’d love to be able to be on the mortgage properly, but until I get my finances straight (am working on it) it’s not an option. I consider myself incredibly lucky to be in this situation with the person I love- if I was your pal I’d be thanking my lucky stars too!

As a side note it means my partner and I can’t really get married as I would end up better off for no reason really and suddenly have a stake in their home- which is unfair as it’s my past mistakes that mean I’m not as financially secure. That’s the worst part for me, but is what it is.

paddingtonbearsmarmalade · 29/12/2021 10:40

My partner owns our house and pays the mortgage; I pay the utilities & we split food. For a long time I was the higher earner but as the asset is his there’s no question of me paying more (except of course in an emergency or he suddenly lost his job - we had this as a back up option when lockdown hit). I pay small amounts towards “finishing” rooms or if I’d want something more expensive than he’d pay eg I bought the lovely bathroom mirror and split the cost of paint, but he paid for the refurbishment. If bills continue to go up significantly we’ll review and he’ll give me some money towards bills so that our expenditure is even.

However I also use this to hammer my savings to save towards a deposit of my own. This is my safety net if we split. I am very sensible with money and live within my means, and we talk about finances so neither of us is taking advantage of the other. I also know exactly which furniture I paid for or was given and what would therefore be coming with me!

This is a very long winded way of saying that these set ups can work, but you should both be going in with your eyes wide open & ensuring that you are both protecting your own interests as well as building your partnership. And your friend needs to be careful about what she pays for in terms of things that would be difficult to remove.

ElsieMc · 29/12/2021 10:39

When we married I provided the deposit for our first home as I had lived at home and had savings, not a huge amount but enough. DH progressed to a good job in time. There was no way he would not have been on the mortgage as we were a partnership, legal and otherwise.

I think your friend is getting a bit carried away and burying her head in the sand. If she is anything like my dd1, she will focus on spending on furniture and decorations to the house which is not hers. She had been stupid with money since she left school and is now mid thirties.
Huge extravagant gifts at Christmas but cannot pay bills. That said, her partner is correct to protect his own assets and this is because he knows she is reckless with money.

There will be things you do not know. My colleague was married but not on her own home mortgage. This was because the lender would not allow someone with so many CCJ's on the mortgage. They did split and she kept the house but I believe only because he did not want it and moved on with someone else. I suspect this is the main reason, but cannot know with certainty.

If she has always been reckless with money, then I think that is who she is. You cannot help here, it is down to her.

Doesntfeellikexmas · 29/12/2021 10:33

[quote mobear]@Doesntfeellikexmas She is losing the opportunity to make an informed choice about her finances if she thinks she’s entitled to something that she isn’t.[/quote]
She is getting the opportunity. She can go get her own legal advice. She is choosing not to.

mobear · 29/12/2021 10:31

@Doesntfeellikexmas She is losing the opportunity to make an informed choice about her finances if she thinks she’s entitled to something that she isn’t.

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 29/12/2021 10:26

I've asked her to engage her own solicitor but she says she's quite good with legal documents and will be able to sort it out herself.

That's an incredibly silly approach, especially when dealing with land. I'm no expert, but I suspect a simple contract won't do it - she probably needs a formal deed, and it certainly needs to be registered against the title to the property. She must get legal advice, not doing so would be a ridiculous false economy.

BornIn78 · 29/12/2021 10:23

Even if he refuses a financial settlement if they split, and whatever he promised is not legally enforceable, she’s still getting a good deal.

BornIn78 · 29/12/2021 10:20

She is paying nothing towards the deposit or mortgage.

She will be paying no rent.

Her contribution might be buying some furniture and maybe paying for a bit of decorating. Well there’s only so much furniture you can buy and decorating to be done.

And if they split, he’s going to give her a lump sum of money?

Your friend should bite his hand off. She sounds like a financial disaster and she’s getting a great deal.

GabriellaMontez · 29/12/2021 10:19

She could find herself paying all utilities, decorating, new boiler, gardener for 10 years.

This could be OK.

But if she mistakenly believes she would receive a sum of money should they split. I suspect she'd want a rethink.

He is rightly protecting himself.

Its good of you @ConcernedFriend17 to try and encourage her to seek legal advice. It sounds like she generally isn't coping very well.

CheshireKitten123 · 29/12/2021 10:15

Simon;

"Being financially irresponsible is a choice, being a freeloader is a choice, they’re both things she has actively chosen. If she has to move out and rent somewhere thats on her, no one else, she is an adult after all."

Exactly this. ^

This is what many of us have been saying for the last 3 pages Hmm

Simonjt · 29/12/2021 10:12

How much shopping for furniture can she do that means she is spending the equivalent of rent every single month?

Being financially irresponsible is a choice, being a freeloader is a choice, they’re both things she has actively chosen. If she has to move out and rent somewhere thats on her, no one else, she is an adult after all.

CheshireKitten123 · 29/12/2021 10:05

@mobear

I think OP is concerned because her friend may rely on something that is unenforceable and therefore be even less likely to plan for her financial future if she thinks she will be provided for (to whatever extent they’ve agreed). I don’t think it is unreasonable to be concerned for this reason.
It's possible to be concerned but that won't stop anyone making poor choices.

I can remember two females I knew years ago who repeatedly got entangled in destructive relationships with married/attached men. Then, when it all went t*ts up (as it always did) they went into 'victim mode' crying "how could he do this to me?!"

I suggested to one of them that she might like to choose men who were free. Her reply "They pick me I don't pick them" ( ! ) I suggested she might like to say "No" and she never spoke to me again.

OP, you are only getting one side of the story.

Your friend is a grown women who is responsible for her own choices.
Accept a) that she isn't going to change
b) you can't be responsible for her poor choices.

You need to step back and stop giving her head space - she's not your problem Hmm