Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gillick competence

85 replies

putthatdown · 28/12/2021 21:24

My DD had a large mole on her neck and we were able to get an appt to have it removed. At the pre-op meeting the dr asked my DD who is 10 what she preferred a general or local pain relief? She then asked me. DD said general as she wanted to go to sleep. I said local and the Dr wrote down General. Has the world gone completely mad. Since when did medics expect a 10yr old to know what pain relief they should have? Since when did my say as a parent become irrelevant. I feel like my role as a parent is being undermined and that the state is now taking responsibility for every area of my childs thinking! Scary times

OP posts:
shouldistop · 28/12/2021 21:59

@snapsieplopp

Would you want to be awake whilst having a large mole removed from your neck?

It's a fairly routine procedure & everyone I know has had it under local.

You know more than one person who's had a large mole removed from their neck? Were any of them children who would rather be asleep for it?
snapsieplopp · 28/12/2021 21:58

My brother did but I guess it was different when we were kids as I doubt a choice was given.

XenoBitch · 28/12/2021 21:57

@snapsieplopp

Would you want to be awake whilst having a large mole removed from your neck?

It's a fairly routine procedure & everyone I know has had it under local.

Would you expect a child to remain calm and still when having a mole removed? The doctor will be holding a scalpel to this girl's neck. A GA is probably safer all round.
ShinyHappyPoster · 28/12/2021 21:57

A lot of 10-yr-olds wouldn't understand the possible implications or potential complications of a GA. It would need quite an extensive conversation for a doctor to explain them in an age-appropriate way that wouldn't potentially terrify the DC.
And that's part of the problem because sometimes medical risks are frightening and if a doctor tries to soft-soap them, how can the DC possibly be deemed Gillick competent?
Then there's the issue that we now have DCs being deemed Gillick competent regarding procedure that can and do have lifelong implications. Whilst, in the justice system (around sentencing) it's been accepted that the brain isn't fully developed in under-25-yr-olds which impacts their risk-taking and decision-making.

Porfre · 28/12/2021 21:56

Having an LA really hurts.

I've had operations under LA and it took a lot not to freak out.

The needle is sharp and it really stings when the LA goes in. And they put it in and out around the area being operated on. And it really hurts every time they do this for the first few minutes until the LA starts working. It's really painful and in the neck area youd have to be really still.

Then they'd cut the area and you'd feel them cutting it. It doesnt hurt once the LA works but feels dull. But you can still feel the sensation of the scalpel. It's horrible and really difficult to stay calm I would have thought especially in the neck area.

The surgeon probably thought she wouldn't cope with an LA so made the decision themselves.

countbackfromten · 28/12/2021 21:55

And I can imagine it was a surgeon you were seeing and not an anaesthetist. We do some procedures under GA that we would do for adults under local anaesthesia, we use sedation for some procedures and ultimately the final decision and discussion is with us on the mode of anaesthesia. We are the specialists in that.

Do I involve children in my discussions tailored to their age and other factors? Of course!

snapsieplopp · 28/12/2021 21:54

I had a few stitches & wasn't offered any anaesthetic as a child, now that was painful!

countbackfromten · 28/12/2021 21:53

We have very clear guidance from the GMC about looking after children www.gmc-uk.org/-/media/documents/gmc-guidance-for-doctors---0-18-years---english-20200211_pdf-48903188.pdf

This line is key - “When treating children and young people, doctors must also consider parents and others close to them; but their patient must be the doctor’s first concern.“

It sounds as if the doctor was involving your daughter in the consultation exactly as they should. And I agree with @Oinkypig, it about ensuring the child’s voice is heard!

snapsieplopp · 28/12/2021 21:52

Would you want to be awake whilst having a large mole removed from your neck?

It's a fairly routine procedure & everyone I know has had it under local.

Antsgomarching · 28/12/2021 21:50

If the doctor explained in detail to your DD about what those options would entail I would expect a ten year old to understand. I would let my DD at ten choose as long as I was confident she understood what her options were. At that age I probably would have chose general just to see what it was like but I’m sure your DD has more sensible reasons.

shouldistop · 28/12/2021 21:49

Would you want to be awake whilst having a large mole removed from your neck?

ShaneTheThird · 28/12/2021 21:49

This is a very weird thread.

One the one hand yes even children are able to have a say in their own medical treatment.

On the other why on earth would they even offer GA for a quick routine procedure when GA has such serious complications?!

CallMeNutribullet · 28/12/2021 21:47

How do you know what the Dr wrote down?

Oinkypig · 28/12/2021 21:46

It’s not even particularly about Gillick Competence it is about involving the patient in the treatment plan. For adults and children even if they don’t have competence/capacity they can still have their voice heard and contribute.

I would imagine the surgeon was at the brink of just offering your child GA but because she seemed sensible and able to communicate her wishes he involved her, and then quite correctly listened to her views.

She sounds very sensible I would struggle having a mole removed from my neck under local!

Divebar2021 · 28/12/2021 21:44

I thought NICE guidelines for childrens decision making was 13 - (assumption that 13 is competent unless there is evidence to the contrary.) Overrall it’s down to the Dr to be satisfied about her competence to consent though not the parent. What I’m curious about is why you elected for local when your DD had made their decision around that. Did you have a conversation with her or just try to overrule her ?

Porfre · 28/12/2021 21:44

I understand your worried.

But I'm not sure how you expect them to operate on a kid that might be kicking and screaming. Unless shes comfortable with the idea- which by her answer seems not. They aren't going to be able to operate.

The other option would be to wait til shes older if the surgery can wait. She might be able to handle the procedure better and get it done while awake.

Noisyprat · 28/12/2021 21:43

Thank you @ShinyHappyPoster I came on to say this however you put it much better than I could have. I find it very worrying how often this is now used on younger and younger children, I also find it worrying how many parent son her see it normal and the child is asked and the parent ignored.

cariadlet · 28/12/2021 21:40

The state isn't taking responsibility for your child's thinking; the dr was taking your child's own wishes into account.

My only concern would be whether the pros and cons of local and general anaesthetic were properly explained at a level which a ten year old could understand.

CoffeeRunner · 28/12/2021 21:37

The Dr will have felt general more appropriate so chose to agree with DD. He wouldn't have offered a general otherwise.

Had DD requested local & you general I imagine he may have sided with you.

ShinyHappyPoster · 28/12/2021 21:36

YANBU Gillick competence is being used to allow under-age DCs to make decisions without their parent's consent and without any time taken to assess whether they are 'competent'.

It's quite worrying especially when viewed alongside other legal pushes to enable DCs to have treatment underage, to be assisted to have different identities that are kept secret from their parents and the resurgence of campaigns around paedophilia. There is a concerted push for very young DCs to be given bodily autonomy at the same time as there are powerful lobbies campaigning for DCs to be given life-altering medication and surgeries; and for them to be deemed able to consent to inappropriate relationships with adults. The medical profession really needs to look again at its safeguarding.

Gladioli23 · 28/12/2021 21:36

Why wouldn't a ten year old know they wanted to be asleep for a minor operation?

Ten year olds seem perfectly old enough to be able to make a decision like that, and they're the one that has to keep their shit together if they're awake while the procedure occurs.

It would take basically all my self control as an adult to not freak out at someone conducting an operation on me would I was awake: why would you expect a child to be able to?

snapsieplopp · 28/12/2021 21:34

I'm surprised the choice was given tbh

Chimley · 28/12/2021 21:33

Why would a doctor overrule your DD's wishes if she has a clear and reasonable reason for her choice?

My DD9 refused to let a doctor lift up her t-shirt to look at her chest. Whilst it hindered diagnosis I also respected her right to say no. I explained why afterwards and next time she said yes because she understood why. Perhaps you could talk to and listen to your DD rather than assuming you know better than her? And feel free to throw legal precedents around but ultimately your DD will resent you overruling her without listening to her.

AliceW89 · 28/12/2021 21:33

There isn’t enough information in this story. If an explanation of both options was given and your DD was allowed time to weigh up the pros and cons and make a decision, then YABU. If it was literally ‘do you want a general or a local’, then she may still be competent to make her own decision, but I’d question the basis of which she made it.

user1471517900 · 28/12/2021 21:31

The state is responsible for your child's thinking because they.......

..... asked your child what they wanted......