Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gillick competence

85 replies

putthatdown · 28/12/2021 21:24

My DD had a large mole on her neck and we were able to get an appt to have it removed. At the pre-op meeting the dr asked my DD who is 10 what she preferred a general or local pain relief? She then asked me. DD said general as she wanted to go to sleep. I said local and the Dr wrote down General. Has the world gone completely mad. Since when did medics expect a 10yr old to know what pain relief they should have? Since when did my say as a parent become irrelevant. I feel like my role as a parent is being undermined and that the state is now taking responsibility for every area of my childs thinking! Scary times

OP posts:
putthatdown · 28/12/2021 22:59

DD had a local - she wasn't hysterical, writhing in pain or in any way distressed. She was fine. Because our NHS Drs are able to remove moles in their sleep! The mole was on the back of her neck and was unsightly as it was one that had multiple growths on it. I had expected the Dr to listen and to take my view into account. It was the fact that it was a minor op that made me also so concerned that general would be on the table...I dont feel that there has been any public debate around this and I dont agree that children are in a position to make decisions like this. The Dr ignored my wishes - and this I find strange. I also find it strange that so little infornation was given to my DD - it was impossible for her to make a choice when presented with so little information

OP posts:
LuaDipa · 28/12/2021 22:45

@putthatdown

yep and the dangers of going under a general far outweigh the advantage of a local. Recovery time being one of them. Anyway DD ended up having a local - as DH insisted and she was absolutely fine. For those that feel 10 is a good age to take such a decision how low would you go? 2/3yrs of age? The thing I hate is that it completely negates the fact that these are children. DD shouldnt have to make these decisions - theres enough crap when you're an adult without forcing it on a child. And what if it goes badly would DD then have the live with the emotional aftermath of knowing she had chosen a general?? Mad, mad mad!
Huge difference between age 10 and age 2/3. Most 10 year olds can have a procedure explained to them and understand what is happening. It’s not mad to involve a child in decisions involving her care, it’s sensible and proper. You may be well meaning, but you and your dh have just shown your dd that her thoughts and opinions don’t matter a jot to you. That will have a far greater emotional aftermath than anything else.
Hotpinkangel19 · 28/12/2021 22:45

@putthatdown

yep and the dangers of going under a general far outweigh the advantage of a local. Recovery time being one of them. Anyway DD ended up having a local - as DH insisted and she was absolutely fine. For those that feel 10 is a good age to take such a decision how low would you go? 2/3yrs of age? The thing I hate is that it completely negates the fact that these are children. DD shouldnt have to make these decisions - theres enough crap when you're an adult without forcing it on a child. And what if it goes badly would DD then have the live with the emotional aftermath of knowing she had chosen a general?? Mad, mad mad!
Don't be so silly - you can't compare the understanding of a 2-3 year old to a 10 year old. I think 10 is a age that some input is acceptable.
Ponoka7 · 28/12/2021 22:44

@putthatdown, I think that you have an exaggerated view of the dangers of GA in healthy children. As for how low in age, my GD has had a say in her pain relief and relaxants at 7. She has opted for sedation. Children are given the minimum possible and generally shake it off quickly.

Ionlydomassiveones · 28/12/2021 22:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Chloemol · 28/12/2021 22:36

It’s not you having the operation is it? It’s your child

She wants a GA because she doesn’t want to be awake, and having to keep still. It’s probably less scary for her

ErrolTheDragon · 28/12/2021 22:33

Local anaesthetic is uncomfortable and the procedure is quite anxiety inducing.

There's a good reason for that - local anaesthetic contains Adrenalin (I think it helps keep the anaesthetic itself local). This was explained to me before a mole removal - I was feeling calm enough in my head but my body wasn't! DH had to have lots of locals for a tooth filling the other week (he's resistant to them) and came out absolutely hyper.

So I'm inclined to think a surgeon wouldn't want to use a local on kid's neck unless the child was really up for it.

putthatdown · 28/12/2021 22:33

no explanation

OP posts:
Hellocatshome · 28/12/2021 22:32

Also 10 is an age where the child is old enough to know what a local anaesthetic entails. It will be multiple injections to the area and will be uncomfortable

If it were explained. I dont think my 11 year old knows what a local anaesthetic actually entails having never had one.

putthatdown · 28/12/2021 22:32

yep and the dangers of going under a general far outweigh the advantage of a local. Recovery time being one of them. Anyway DD ended up having a local - as DH insisted and she was absolutely fine. For those that feel 10 is a good age to take such a decision how low would you go? 2/3yrs of age? The thing I hate is that it completely negates the fact that these are children. DD shouldnt have to make these decisions - theres enough crap when you're an adult without forcing it on a child. And what if it goes badly would DD then have the live with the emotional aftermath of knowing she had chosen a general?? Mad, mad mad!

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 28/12/2021 22:31

"On the other why on earth would they even offer GA for a quick routine procedure when GA has such serious complications?!"

Because without the child's cooperation, consent etc, it won't go ahead at all. The child will be traumatised, possibly put off for good and an appointment will be wasted. My GD has had to have procedures done. At 7 she wanted sedation. They tried without it and there was no way that they could go ahead with it. They will only restrain to an extent. Serious complications in healthy children is very rare.

OrangeShark27 · 28/12/2021 22:29

But they must have told you it was general not just written it down otherwise your going to turn up for your general having eaten breakfast thinking it was a 10 minute LA job

OrangeShark27 · 28/12/2021 22:28

Also 10 is an age where the child is old enough to know what a local anaesthetic entails. It will be multiple injections to the area and will be uncomfortable

If they go into the procedure confident they can do it, they be fine. If they go in scared thinking they can't they probably won't get through the procedure. The best way at 10 to gauge if a child is capable of local is to ask them.

10 is probably the lower limit of a child where you even consider local for this, and only if the child is capable and complaint.

putthatdown · 28/12/2021 22:27

No explanation was given. Unfortunately NHS is very busy and the Dr had 10mins to check the mole, explain that it would be removed and then asked about pain relief.

OP posts:
OrangeShark27 · 28/12/2021 22:19

How many times have you tried to cut a large mole out from a hysterical child's neck? If a child isn't able to cope with the procedure it's simply not safe.

That's quite a big procedure for a 10 year old. Some may manage it, but many won't. Local anaesthetic is uncomfortable and the procedure is quite anxiety inducing. At 10 your Dd is old enough to know if she can manage a local.

The question is does a parent have the right to force a child through local anaesthetic they don't want? Sometimes you have to be firm with parents, I have been in situations where parents refuse general while their child is becoming increasingly more distressed, and you have to say no, this child isn't able to cope with a local, you don't want to traumatise them.

I highly doubt the surgeon went GA or LA and then just wrote down Ga. There must have been discussions and some form of consent. They must have actually informed you it was under GA

Cuck00soup · 28/12/2021 22:11

This isn't quite right. Gillick competence would require the child to weigh up the risks and benefits of having the procedure under general anaesthetic, something most 10 year olds would not have the maturity to do.

On the other hand the 10 year old can express a preference.

Consent for GA would require someone with parental responsibility or a court order unless it was a medical emergency.

snapsieplopp · 28/12/2021 22:07

Why on earth would you put your 10 year old through an operation that is for cosmetic reasons

It may not be cosmetic, they can be cancerous or uncomfortable eg catching on things

Sirzy · 28/12/2021 22:06

@olympicsrock

Why on earth would you put your 10 year old through an operation that is for cosmetic reasons . When you believe she is competent to make up her own mind about her body , then take her back to talk about getting it removed. You can’t have it both ways.
Mole removal isn’t always for cosmetic reasons. Mine wasn’t.
Sirzy · 28/12/2021 22:05

A calmly sleeping child is much safer to operate on than an awake panicking child.

I get your concerns but have you stopped and asked her why she prefers that option? I had a mole removal she 10, in the long run it was done with another operation I had to have a GA for but no way would have managed it wihj a local

olympicsrock · 28/12/2021 22:05

Why on earth would you put your 10 year old through an operation that is for cosmetic reasons . When you believe she is competent to make up her own mind about her body , then take her back to talk about getting it removed. You can’t have it both ways.

BewareTheRedNosedDragon · 28/12/2021 22:02

@ShaneTheThird

This is a very weird thread.

One the one hand yes even children are able to have a say in their own medical treatment.

On the other why on earth would they even offer GA for a quick routine procedure when GA has such serious complications?!

My ds had an ingrowing toenail minor procedure recently and was offered GA if he wanted it. They appear to be offered to children where they wouldn't be to adults because children find surgery much more difficult presumably. I'm amazed that anyone is surprised that it was offered.
LadyMonicaBaddingham · 28/12/2021 22:02

I suspect that the GA was offered because the procedure involves the neck - jugular vein/risk if patient panics/ability to see exactly what is going on.

Your daughter should be able to feel supported in her decision, not questioned.

snapsieplopp · 28/12/2021 22:01

& other relatives, we are a very moley family & a big one!

megletthesecond · 28/12/2021 22:00

I had a mole on my chest removed under local. It was horrible smelling the burning.
GA all the way, for everything here. I want the medical team to crack on without me stressing.

snapsieplopp · 28/12/2021 22:00

My brother & my mum actually