Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gillick competence

85 replies

putthatdown · 28/12/2021 21:24

My DD had a large mole on her neck and we were able to get an appt to have it removed. At the pre-op meeting the dr asked my DD who is 10 what she preferred a general or local pain relief? She then asked me. DD said general as she wanted to go to sleep. I said local and the Dr wrote down General. Has the world gone completely mad. Since when did medics expect a 10yr old to know what pain relief they should have? Since when did my say as a parent become irrelevant. I feel like my role as a parent is being undermined and that the state is now taking responsibility for every area of my childs thinking! Scary times

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
solvendie · 29/12/2021 22:31

Perhaps the doctor was assessing whether she could cope with local rather than giving a choice per se?

Vapeyvapevape · 29/12/2021 22:00

So if you've got such strong views on this the person to talk to was the doctor and ask them what their reasoning was

Exactly, did you just sit there like a lemon , silently seething inside ? All sounds a bit odd .

Porfre · 29/12/2021 21:49

@putthatdown

DD had a local - she wasn't hysterical, writhing in pain or in any way distressed. She was fine. Because our NHS Drs are able to remove moles in their sleep! The mole was on the back of her neck and was unsightly as it was one that had multiple growths on it. I had expected the Dr to listen and to take my view into account. It was the fact that it was a minor op that made me also so concerned that general would be on the table...I dont feel that there has been any public debate around this and I dont agree that children are in a position to make decisions like this. The Dr ignored my wishes - and this I find strange. I also find it strange that so little infornation was given to my DD - it was impossible for her to make a choice when presented with so little information
Ok. So if you've got such strong views on this the person to talk to was the doctor and ask them what their reasoning was.
ChateauxNeufDePoop · 29/12/2021 15:28

@putthatdown

DD had a local - she wasn't hysterical, writhing in pain or in any way distressed. She was fine. Because our NHS Drs are able to remove moles in their sleep! The mole was on the back of her neck and was unsightly as it was one that had multiple growths on it. I had expected the Dr to listen and to take my view into account. It was the fact that it was a minor op that made me also so concerned that general would be on the table...I dont feel that there has been any public debate around this and I dont agree that children are in a position to make decisions like this. The Dr ignored my wishes - and this I find strange. I also find it strange that so little infornation was given to my DD - it was impossible for her to make a choice when presented with so little information
The Dr ignored my wishes

And?

EarthStoodHardAsPrion · 29/12/2021 14:44

@lunar1

My 10 year old is having a surgery soon. His surgeon explained it to him, gave him a choice. He asked a few questions and decided to have a GA.

DH and I weren't asked our opinion. It's his body and his choice. He's a bright child and the doctor took the time to explain.

His medical history isn't his choice, but I damn well will give him every little bit of control he's able to have over his treatments.

This is absolutely fine, because you are fine with it and accepted the doctor had explained the relative risks and you felt your son was capable of making that decision.

Had you disagreed, would you expect the doctor to ask your opinion, then ignore the fact that you disagreed, without explaining why they were doing so?

Had they gone against your wishes, and something went wrong with the anaesthetic, would you be perfectly happy they hadn’t lister explained?

EarthStoodHardAsPrion · 29/12/2021 14:13

@countbackfromten

Really? I agree not all older doctors are mature and competent, so it was something of a generalization. However this is the kind of error that would perhaps be understandable in a young, idealistic doctor with little experience of human nature.

It takes a long time, even for someone with a lot of natural empathy, to learn the art of consultation to the point where you are much less likely to run into trouble for saying the wrong thing and getting yourself in hot water because you didn’t cover your ass well enough. It’s a learning process like any other.

Obviously not all young doctors are bad and not all older doctors are good, but there’s certainly more likelihood of this kind of error early in a doctor’s career.

Scarlettpixie · 29/12/2021 13:48

Why the massive drip feed?

In this case the parent wasn’t over ruled as your DH ‘insisted’ on a local and that was what happened. Presumably you could also insisted or at least discussed the pros and cons at the pre app appointment so your daughter had more information to inform her decision.

What you describe is the opposite of the state taking over your child’s thinking. They were trying to allow your child her OWN thinking which was then overruled by Dad!

I am surprised more info wasn’t given at the pre op appointment but then I would have asked.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/12/2021 13:20

I think this is a case which is significantly different from some others, because it's not a matter of whether the child should have a treatment or not - it's a choice between two options, both of which the doctors are happy with.

lunar1 · 29/12/2021 13:13

My 10 year old is having a surgery soon. His surgeon explained it to him, gave him a choice. He asked a few questions and decided to have a GA.

DH and I weren't asked our opinion. It's his body and his choice. He's a bright child and the doctor took the time to explain.

His medical history isn't his choice, but I damn well will give him every little bit of control he's able to have over his treatments.

countbackfromten · 29/12/2021 12:04

@EarthStoodHardAsPrion how insulting! You have no idea the experience level of any doctor based on how young they look!

EarthStoodHardAsPrion · 29/12/2021 08:36

Was the doctor young?

I find it bizarre that she or he would ask you and your daughter separately, receive different answers, and then randomly go with one, against the wishes of the other (obviously more competent) party. Then it’s even odder to subsequently to change the decision, based on what the other (male) person argued.

I’d expect a competent and mature doctor to instigate further discussion and give more explanation in these circumstances, allowing you as a family to reach a consensus. I would also expect a competent doctor to recommend the much safer option of local anaesthesia, where it is a suitable option (as it obviously was) and only offer general as an option if the family consensus was that the child would be too distressed by being awake through the procedure.

So, OP, you are not unreasonable. The doctor did not handle your daughter’s consultation in a competent way. Had they gone ahead with the GA and there had been adverse consequences, the doctor would have been in a lot of trouble for overruling your perfectly reasonable request for the safer option without very good reason. The uninformed feelings of a ten year old are not good enough grounds for taking the unnecessary risk.

sashh · 29/12/2021 08:24

Glad she has had the procedure OP and that all is well.

I was about to say (before your update) that the form might have been so that there is an anesthetist present as the final decision is made on the day.

TinyLittlePandaSneeze · 29/12/2021 08:24

@XenoBitch

I need an umbrella for the massive drip feed here. So DD has already had the op...
Yeah so she's already had the OP? And had a local?

Wtf

LowlyTheWorm · 29/12/2021 08:22

How is it possible that in the OP it sounds like this just happened but then it transpires that actually the child HAD the procedure and it wasn’t even a GA after all as her dad “insisted” she get a local?
So the Drs DID listen to an adult- just not to you @putthatdown? Did you even try to say at the appt that you would prefer the local for your dd and why? Did YOU explain to your child which was which in order for her to make an informed choice? Was there any point in you child having an opinion as you and her father were going to override it anyway? Great lesson she has learnt about her rights to her own body eh? And about women and girls versus men as well.
👏🏻

TinyLittlePandaSneeze · 29/12/2021 08:13

I find it a bit odd that they didn't explain to you why they were going with the option you said you'd prefer.

Cuck00soup · 29/12/2021 08:06

@Glugglejug

Mate you do realise that is what Gillick competence is, right? The autonomy to make decisions about yourself and your body REGARDLESS of what anyone else might want to push you into?

It is up to you, as the adult, as to whether you can influence your daughter. Most parents are able to do this. If your relationship is so poor with her that she doesn’t listen to you there must be a reason. have you thought about seeking help to improve your parenting?

Gillick competence refers to the ability of a child to consider information and weigh the risks and benefits.

Competence is about far more than bodily autonomy. I remember a hugely distressing situation where an adult patient had to have surgery ordered by a court because her reasons for refusing it didn't demonstrate that she understood the life-limiting consequences of not having the procedure.

The situation in the OP is less drastic and the OPs child absolutely should be involved in the discussion and offered appropriate choices. However, as I said last night few ten year olds would be able to demonstrate Gillick competence to consent to a general anaesthetic.

OrangeShark27 · 29/12/2021 06:50

@TooBigForMyBoots they offered a GA for a child. Yes, what is it you don't understand about the difference between a child and an adult?

Its not about the child chosing, it's about the Dr assessing that child's ability to cope with the procedure under LA. A 2/3 Yr old isn't going to be offered LA for that procedure regardless of how much the parents want it because it's cruel amd not safe.

I don't really understand how you only had a 10 minute appointment but suddenly have had the whole procedure, and no where anyone has actually told you it was a GA

YouCantTourniquetTheTaint · 29/12/2021 02:20

YANBU if the Dr did not explain the difference between a local and general anesthetic, the pros and cons on each, or what the operation entailed, how on earth can a 10yo make an informed decision?

I'm petrified of going to the dentist, so I now need to be completely knocked out for a dentist to do any work. When I went to the hospital to have a consultation, the Dr explained the difference between the local and general anesthetic, so I could make a decision, I'm in my 30's I've never had an operation, so I needed it explained to me, to make the best decision I could. How can a 10yo possibly make that decision without the relevant information.

Kids should have bodily autonomy, absolutely but they need to know the potential ramifications of their decision.

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/12/2021 02:03

They offered a GA for that???Xmas Shock

I know people who've had proper bits cut out without the offer of GA.

ChrimboGateauxCatto · 29/12/2021 01:56

I'm with everyone else on this. They assessed her as competent and allowed her to express a preference.

CuntAmongstThePigeons · 29/12/2021 01:24

You're totally not being unreasonable op. So many people have such a shallow understanding of gillick competency. Its actually more about preserving the ability of a child to carry on their established life than it is about permission over their own body. Gillick competency was established in order to let young girls take the morning after pill essentially because it was accepted a child COULDN'T consent to changing their entire life set up and assuming responsibility for a minor when they themselves where still one. Gillick competency is about preserving children's right to NOT have unprecedented medical procedures not for their right to have it! Hence why we see it referenced so frequently in discussions about children consenting to puberty blockers. They are incapable of consenting to giving up adulthood, eg sexual maturity etc. As they have no understanding of what they're giving up. Only an adult could no what a massive thing it is to compromise their sexual enjoyment/fulfilment. Which is of course what happens when children take puberty blockers. In this instance I think its important you have recognised this issue. Children cannot appropriately comprehend the risks of GA, so how can they possibly consent to it!!!!! Allowing children to choose their own consent is a slippery slope. PIE anyone?

XenoBitch · 29/12/2021 00:17

I need an umbrella for the massive drip feed here.
So DD has already had the op...

Glugglejug · 29/12/2021 00:16

Mate you do realise that is what Gillick competence is, right? The autonomy to make decisions about yourself and your body REGARDLESS of what anyone else might want to push you into?

It is up to you, as the adult, as to whether you can influence your daughter. Most parents are able to do this. If your relationship is so poor with her that she doesn’t listen to you there must be a reason. have you thought about seeking help to improve your parenting?

Ireolu · 28/12/2021 23:23

The doctor made a best interest decision with regards to anaesthesia. For reasons already mentioned relating to operating on a 10 yr olds neck. Several important blood vessels in the neck.

Sirzy · 28/12/2021 23:13

So basically you told your daughter her views on her own body where irrelevant and you and your husband over rode her autonomy. Nice message to send her

Swipe left for the next trending thread