Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Guardian is a joke re: JK Rowling?

367 replies

Firesidefox · 28/12/2021 16:19

So, the Guardian was running a 'person of the year' poll, and I voted for JK Rowling for her bravery in standing up to the extremist wing of the trans lobby.

I went to have a look to see when the results were out, and they've deactivated the poll! According to Twitter, it's because JK Rowling was the out and out winner.

If this is the case, this is PATHETIC.

OP posts:
PolytheneRam · 29/12/2021 11:56

JK Rowling is the joke as far as I'm concerned.

MmeSosostris · 29/12/2021 11:52

Apologies for errors - I’ve still so much frustration and hurt from what went on. I feel like we were pushed out of our community (home/church/jobs) because we weren’t right wing enough for New Labour.

MmeSosostris · 29/12/2021 11:49

I would say that a lot of the very real problems during that time were not properly acknowledged by many of the services tasked to deal with them (antidepressants rather than counselling for mh/substandard housing/teachers leaving due to demands) and now we are noticing them. I’m from a migrant family and watched as the floor under people moved away- they could sense it but couldn’t (imv) quite articulate what was tho them bewildering and frightening (esp the elderly). It was that space that became hijacked by the media who then said that is what’s happening and pushed the immigrants narrative. Combining that with the underlying narrative of anti immigration that floated around in many of those old W/c areas and I think many people were saying what they thought they should be saying to the left, wo all of a sudden completely changed their narrative on education and immigration.

I remember graduating and returning to my inner London home borough and being shocked that those who were right wing were in the traditionally left of centre jobs like teaching. I think this was the real point of alarm for many as the whole tone of community conversation changed. To deny this is to really ignore what happened in different pockets of old, W/c communities who for generations had been shunted into following certain dogmas (which many took with a pitch of salt) and then had those same dogmas turned on them. That’s what I heard with Mrs Duffy. I would also add that at that time, I was working in a profession and there really was a disgusting dismissal of so much that had functioned at a local even. There was a frenzy of breaking up old systems, communities and bonds but the very things that were attacked were the very things that sit outside of the social state framework - church groups/mothers spaces, etc. Some people were able to shift themselves to a comfortable position which left many others very vulnerable to attack - and they were primarily the W/c who’d always been told the rules to follow (as opposed to decision makers creating the rules/culture). I also think the numbers properly add up on paper because so many of the tragedies of that time were undocumented or written off as mental health issues.

I, as my family were Labour voters. W/c aspirational, own home, went to university- very much the identity they were pushing but I cannot turn my eyes away from the undercurrent of harm that was caused by not listening to people on crime and resources unevenly shared out.

@JohnHuffam1812 please read my post. The only hope for the PLP now is for them to acknowledge this properly and be honest about the parts they wilfully ignored.

1dayatatime · 29/12/2021 11:02

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@Waitwhat23

Her complaint, in a nutshell, was that she has to pay taxes whilst "these eastern European immigrants" come over here and claim things she is being told she cant claim.

His would you engage with that concern? You have to pay tax, and you vant get benefits if you dont qualify and immigrants coming over dont just get handed benefits.

She was a bigot.[/quote]
Please stop making stuff up, what you posted is not only factually incorrect but done so to unreasonably support your own belief.

The exact quote from Gillian Duffy in her April 2010 televised discussion with Gordon Brown was:

"You can't say anything about the immigrants because you're saying that you're … but all these eastern European what are coming in, where are they flocking from"

No reference to immigrants unfairly claiming benefits etc etc.

The Oxford definition of a bigot is:

"obstinate or unreasonable attachment to a belief, opinion"

That definition looks a lot like your post.

slashlover · 29/12/2021 11:02

I agree OP, they obviously closed this one because according to Twitter "sitting in my house" was winning. PATHETIC!

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/20/tell-us-what-were-you-doing-on-15-may-2020

endofbluenight · 29/12/2021 10:40

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

I can't remember the ins and outs of what the woman said, but I do remember very clearly that Labour under Blair and Brown, with their enormous majorities, ignored the concerns of ordinary voters about immigration from the EU. They could and should have had a frank discussion with their voters about why they agreed to put no limits at all on immigration from the EU and what they thought the benefits would be. They could have reassured them that they would make sure school places, housing, NHS etc would have capacity to deal with all these new UK residents. Instead of which they shut all discussion down and labelled all the concerned people as bigots. People's concerns, founded or unfounded, didn't go away and we see the end result in the Brexit referendum.
Absolutely this.

EU Immigration impacted different communities in different ways, and it is not surprising that communities under pressure had concerns. Even my polish neighbour who got a job as a TA in a school in a deprived area said she was appalled at the number of Polish children in the class who could not speak English and which impeded the ability of the teacher to teach the class.

People had real concerns which were not about being racist but about being communities under pressure. If people had felt listened to and engaged with then maybe we would not have go to the Brexit situation.

Unfortunately, after Brexit, instead of starting to listen the ' you are a RACIST' mantra just intensified.

endofbluenight · 29/12/2021 10:29

@Berlinkreuzberg

Which mp is that *@whachatalkinaboutwillis* ?
That was one of the things that undid Gordon Brown.
ChateauMargaux · 29/12/2021 10:23

American teenage youtube star Ranboo also received a huge number of nominations on twitter.. (but I can't find it now..) .. this was not a real poll.

Wombat43 · 29/12/2021 10:23

Just been listening to Times Radio. They kept wondering why J. K Rowling wasn't included in the Harry Potter reunion. I couldn't decide if they were clueless or swerving the obvious cancel culture threat to the show.

SerendipityJane · 29/12/2021 10:20

Probably time to reflect that the Daily Mail was an an enthusiastic supporter of the Nazis, and Adolf Hitler personally. Headlines like "Hurrah for the blackshirts!!!" and all that.

PLus ca change ....

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/12/2021 01:53

Yeah she will. She'll voice another opinion: probably a left wing, feminist, imperfect one, and the Mail will run 27 derogatory and possibly illegal stories about her everyday. Women will think badly of her and denounce her.

You just have to look at what happened to other women who stood up for women.

Look

nolongersurprised · 29/12/2021 01:38

And that's why she'll be forgotten in this

Not by women, she won’t

Smokeahontas · 29/12/2021 01:24

@HermioneWeasley

What do they think will happen if they say she’s won the vote?
Owen Jones will have the mother of all tantrums. Sorry, birthing parent of all tantrums.
TooBigForMyBoots · 29/12/2021 01:22

No she won't. The Times, the Mail, the Sun, Piers Morgan, Donald Trump etc. will claim it as their victory.

JKR will be a side note. She spoke out with intelligence, knowledge and sensitivity. She was brilliant. But she is not a man in power/with influence, that's why she faced so much hate. And that's why she'll be forgotten in this.

sst1234 · 29/12/2021 01:01

JKR will be celebrated and vindicated in years to come. When the militant trans lobby is proved to be what it is - misogynistic to it’s core. She did what the powerful should do - speak facts. Rather than pander to the fashionable view of he day.

nolongersurprised · 29/12/2021 00:57

I bet JK Rowling wishes she’d kept her views to herself

I doubt it, given the massive outpouring of positive correspondence she said she’d received.

And what views? People can’t change sex, that’s not a “view”

NoNotMeNoSiree · 29/12/2021 00:46

@TooBigForMyBoots

TBF, none of the UK newspapers are fans of diversity. The Times, Sun and Mail havent changed much from their misogynist, right wing past either.Xmas Hmm

Indeed I think they've all become worse since media moved online. Bit by bit they've retreated into echo chambers that encourage division, not discussion or knowledge.Xmas Sad

Agree with this!
TooBigForMyBoots · 29/12/2021 00:44

TBF, none of the UK newspapers are fans of diversity. The Times, Sun and Mail havent changed much from their misogynist, right wing past either.Xmas Hmm

Indeed I think they've all become worse since media moved online. Bit by bit they've retreated into echo chambers that encourage division, not discussion or knowledge.Xmas Sad

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/12/2021 00:41

TBF, none of the UK newspapers are fans of diversity. The Times, Sun and Mail havent changed much from their misogynist, right wing past either.Xmas Hmm

Indeed I think they've all become worse since media moved online. Bit by bit they've retreated into echo chambers that encourage division, not discussion or knowledge.

Firesidefox · 28/12/2021 23:19

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

Happy to accept I was mistaken when I thought I was voting in a poll. I went onto The Guardian website and answered a question there which said something like 'Who's your Person of the Year?' and then a section on the lines of 'What are your reasons?' From the wording of everything I saw, I assumed they would publish the names of the most popular candidates and some of the reasons people mentioned. But now I know that's not a poll, that's just a bit of vox pop. Okaaaaaaaaaay...........
Yeah me too @Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g
OP posts:
NoNotMeNoSiree · 28/12/2021 22:11

the real issue with this thread is it demonstrates how fast fake news spreads and how people latch on to stories that support their views without any proper research or fact checking to validate them
Agree this
It's the reason I always ask for sources on here when people say stuff as fact, or quote figures seemingly out of thin air again with no context or anything.
Some just expect you to believe and not question anything.

Wineandroses3 · 28/12/2021 22:07

The Guardian- does not surprise me one bit.

Porfre · 28/12/2021 22:06

@yellowtwo

I bet JK Rowling wishes she’d kept her views to herself. not likely given she is still speaking up about these issues.
Exactly she did backtrack once and say she'd accidentally liked a tweet or something. But in the end she had to stand up for what she felt was right no matter what the backlash was.

She had the chance to back out but she didnt.

yellowtwo · 28/12/2021 22:00

I bet JK Rowling wishes she’d kept her views to herself. not likely given she is still speaking up about these issues.

Clavinova · 28/12/2021 21:58

JohnHuffam1812
Keep it up, you're amusing

No - I'm going to watch a film.

Again from 2020

So, it's OK for Labour MPs to call voters 'racist' after Brexit? Or perhaps Lisa Nandy is talking nonsense again? She's not in Keir Starmer's Shadow Cabinet is she? Oh dear - she is.